Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Please Step Away From the Fear
Recently did my fine and ever-loving and yet slightly overworried parents, still married and flirty and sort of amazing after something like 147 years together -- and no, I have no idea how the hell they did it, so don't even ask -- forward on a terrifying hunk of email to me, full of sound and fury and unchecked socioeconomic gloom, signifying nothing.
It was an email, I quickly surmised, that had bounced around their group of retired, largely Republican friends and then commented on and fretted over a bit too much, all about what the hell is happening to the world, how dramatically things have changed, what can or cannot be done about it and, more than anything else, how they feel fearful for their kids -- which, for the purposes of this column, we'll call, me.
It was an email, simply put, about the end of the world. More specifically, the end of the American empire, of the United States as global economic superpower, primarily due to various and sundry "horrific" factors having to do with the threadbare American workforce, the staggering loss of manufacturing and factory jobs in this country, the spiraling debt, the shocking erosion of our industrial base, and so on.
"Facts About The De-industrialization Of America That Will Blow Your Mind" screamed the email's headline, instantly indicating its mad desire to be not the slightest bit tactful or reasonable. The piece then went on to list all manner of "horrifying" data about America's post-industrial implosion, from the mundane (a single Ford factory closing due to "globalization") to spurious forecasts about China, "rotting war zones" like Detroit, and how America's number one export is now, quite literally, garbage.
On it went, item after item, all context-free and gleefully myopic in its abject fearmongering and its intent to scare the unsuspecting reader out of his stock portfolio and into investing in gold bars. Unfortunately, I haven't the space here to list the most garish examples -- there are just so many -- but if you're so inclined, remove your pants, pray to Shiva, and click.
A quick Google side trip revealed the column's origins: a frighteningly Christian lad named Michael Snyder, shameless slinger of endless "shocking" doomsday scenarios via a site called "The Economic Collapse Blog," packed like a Jesus-clad fallout bunker with screeching headlines like "20 signs a horrific global food crisis is coming," "65 ways everything you now own is systematically being taken away from you" and "Armageddon for homeowners." So, you know, fun times at Michael's house.
Nothing new here, really. After all, Christian panic mongers like Snyder (and Glenn Beck, and the Tea Party, and the Tories, and nervous cavemen) have been trafficking in similar flagellation for eons. But thanks to the Net, the spiteful imp at the center of his list -- which is to say, fear -Ð now has far more fluid access to the brainstems of the unwary and the retired.
Now, right about here is where I would normally spin off and casually defy Snyder's Rapture-ready silliness, maybe something about how it goes without saying that for every overblown gloomsday factoid he spits forth, there is always, always a counterforce, an irrefutable sign of positive amazement, something to make you gasp and feel just a twinge, a glimmer of newfound hope for our perpetually doomed species.
But then, serendipity happened. Just after I sent my parents my "beware of viral email fundamentalist Christian fatalism spittle" speech, I stumbled across yet another new study that essentially reaffirms something you already suspected.
The study said: The brains of liberals and conservatives are wired differently. We respond to stimuli differently, process information differently, view the world through lenses unique to our political viewpoint. I know, shocking.
But then, the upshot: "Liberals have more gray matter in a part of the brain associated with understanding complexity, while the conservative brain is bigger in the section related to processing fear."
And then, "It's conceivable that individuals with a larger ACC [anterior cingulate cortex] have a higher capacity to tolerate uncertainty and conflicts, allowing them to accept more liberal views."
I realize you are not the slightest bit surprised by this. I realize, furthermore, it's a slightly specious generalization. After all, I know plenty of liberals who are quite terrified of the slightest bump in the karmic night. And I know a few conservatives -- not many, but some -- who have tremendous joie de vivre and see the world as a big mud puddle to be splashed around and loved well. They still don't want to fund the arts, help the poor or support universal single payer health care, however. Silly people.
But the fundamental truth remains. Fear equals conservatism (and vice-versa), which naturally leads to isolationism, protectionism, paranoia, religious dogma, surveillance cameras and wiretapping and Dick Cheney and guys like Snyder who write junk like "The Economic Collapse Blog" and aren't instantly stuck by lightning for being loudmouth heretics who traffic in the basest energy known to man, without shame.
And here are my otherwise fantastic and usually savvy parents, lured in by this overamped Christian, feeling increasingly powerless against the onslaught of his unfiltered "facts," the imp of fear driving them headlong into excess worry and despair. My father explained the emotional toll that such context-free information has on his group of friends, thusly:
"None of us work any longer, so there is no chance to rebuild -- we feel frustrated and helpless because there is nothing we can do (itals mine). Age does make you more conservative. I can well remember when our own world kept us so busy we did not have time to worry so much. Now we have time -- all of us, meaning our friends, are concerned about our kids and how you will survive."
This struck me as heart wrenching as it was revelatory. "Of course, there are a thousand things you can do," I thought. "Of course, while some anxiety is to be expected, most is just, well, poisonous." But then I recognized the conservative brain aswim in its element, overworking the fear synapse, seeing only frustration and the lack of power to return to some perceived previous glory, instead of engaging the more liberal mindset: seeking ways to invent a wildly new future.
This is what I told my fine folks: It's never too late. There are a million things you can do, are doing, right now, to improve the world. The products you buy, the foods you eat, the stores you patronize, the news sources you value, the politicos you vote for, the love you make, the information you choose to share, the stories you believe in -- every single choice, from coffee cup to charity donation, joke retold to tender human touch -- these are what make all the difference.
These are, cumulatively and collectively, what really make a great society. The jobs, the factories, the economics? These do not exist in a vacuum, independent of the daily churn. You don't have to be part of the active workforce to make an enormous difference.
But the very best and most important thing we can do to change the world? The single finest way to make your mind, your body, your nation healthier and stronger across the board? Do not buy into the fear. Defy the imp. And ignore flaming scrunchballs like Michael Snyder. I'm quite sure it's what Jesus would have wanted.


25 Comments so far
Show AllYes, but Mark, there are a huge number of liberals and pseudo-liberals right here at CD that could write there own 'Economic Collapse Blogs.' Fear is kinda universal, especially when one knows a little bit too much, but not enough to have a complete understanding. And we all know some kind of trouble is just around the corner.
Let's all hope you're correct, Mark.
On the national news last night (for the benefit of those of you who don't watch TV on principle) it was reported that recent polls indicate that a large percentage of then U.S. populace now believes the economy is NOT improving. The congenital optimism that the people of this land always are prone to is breaking down due to the inroads that nasty old reality is making. The economy, susceptible always to the power of mass suggestion, will probably now get worse as its deteriorating condition becomes more widely perceived. This "self fulfilling prophesy" is one more factor pulling things in the direction of downturn. People here are losing faith, and positive thinking alone can't reverse this.
I am one of those who do not watch TV (not on principle, but because if I did, I would have no time to read - the choice is easy). But I am one of those who are not conviced that the economy is improving. My wife and I run a small retail business in Indiana. We make some of the things we sell (yarn, from the sheep we raise) but buy most of it from distributors who import the yarns from Europe, SA and Japan.
A few years ago when we called in an order, the distributor would ship it (if it was in stock) in a week to ten days. For the last several months, the goods have been going out on the day we call, or the following day. In other words, the distributors do not have the backlogs they used to have. That means that small businesses such as ours are not ordering as much as they used to.
That tells me that people are not buying as much as they used to, which means that they do not believe the economy is improving. You don't have to be an economist to figure out what is happening.
And, also, fewer people are learning to knit and cochet these days, and those that do are working longer hours and have much less time for such activity.
The frighteningly addictive G-whatever smartphones are robbing people of quiet time for home craft hobbies too.
Years ago, I concluded that all of those "Top 10 Things You Must Know/Do/Have/Be" are BS. I still think that way! I always want to reply "what if there's only 9? Or, perhaps 11?"......
The film biz in nyc is off the charts due to tax breaks for movie producers. Any unemployed out there who need a little "extra" work, jump right in to the circus! Bread provided at the craft service table....
I hate these pieces too, Mark, it's fear mongering, wanting you to buy gold and silver, a newsletter, or something another. But, I wouldn't be so cavalier as to discount all of your parents concerns. I think over time, you'll temper your dismissal of their opinions and life experiences. On the other hand, I'm always in awe of how MSM liberals live and maintain their own special blissful state of mind. I honestly mean that. It must be a wonderful thing. But I get this type of email from older liberals as well, so I'm assuming you'll grow out of it.
Sorry, Mark. The Christian is probably closer to the truth than you are on this. Read Tom Engelhardt's piece on yesterday's CD about the collapsing empire. Depression and anxiety are normal at time like these - with massive unemployment and ever-increasing wealth differentials, and public services being relentlessly cut.
Since America has been so rich, there is a long way to fall, and I doubt many of us will starve to death or freeze. So that's the good thing. I guess keep working for a revolution and hope for the best.
This was not about who is less wrong (closer to the truth) but how we respond to impending doom--do we let fear determine our path (fight/flight), or do we try to solve the problem. Are we Tooter Turtle (Help, Mr. Wizard!) or Mr Peabody?
"There are a million things you can do, are doing, right now, to improve the world. The products you buy, the foods you eat, the stores you patronize, the news sources you value, the politicos you vote for..."
Yup... consume your way to a better world; buy a Prius and drive it at every opportumity, eat expensive stuff from "Whole Foods", dine at Organic Annie's Whole Earth Cafe, read the "Utne Reader" or "Mother Jones", vote for Nancy Pelosi (not Cindy Sheehan) or other such Democrat.
Spoken like a true San Francisco Kalifornian rich gay yuppie...
Having a bad day? Not enough sleep?
Prozac hasn't kicked in?
"Spoken like a true San Francisco Kalifornian rich gay yuppie..."
If I didn't know better, I would think you were a tea bagger, homophobic redneck.
No, I'm not defending Nancy Pelosi, or even the author, relative to the quote.
Yup, Mark Morford is a bit of a yuppie whiner.I remember in particular a piece he had in the Chronicle about the evil done to him when some no-goodniks trashed his newly restored pet ride.His parents' blog is indistinguishable in substance from similar rants by the aleged "Left" on CD: Everything's going to hell,and there's nothing you can do about it. Still, I manage to get out of bed every morning and put one foot in front of the other. Like Antonio Machado says "Traveler, there is no road/ you make the road by walking." Pick your battles and forget the rest.
Idiot.
..and be excellent to each other!
I wish I could live without fear of impending economic collapse, but I have to face facts.
I work two jobs: a day job for the benefits and to supplement the income from my two classes-per-semester adjunct college instructor gig. I haven't received a raise at my day job for 5 years. My state income taxes went up by a record 66% this year, which means I bring home a substantially smaller paycheck (not that it was ever huge) than I did last year. And now those "benefits" I mentioned are being replaced by a new "money saving" package that will necessitate either paying significantly more for local health care or making a 180 mile round trip to see a doctor. The value of my home is probably much less than what I paid for it six years ago (although we wisely stayed within our means when we bought it). There is no real sign that a "recovery"--for anyone other than banksters and other megarich--is in the offing. And thanks to peak oil and commodity speculation, we probably get to see $5 gasoline this summer.
I have no idea how to stretch my paycheck(s) to make it work. I do not have the time or energy to work a third job. I want to get more involved than I already am in local issues, but that too requires time and energy. I watch daily as working folks like me get squeezed more and more while the megarich who brought us to this state give themselves outrageous bonuses and "our" politicians do nothing but strike poses (at best).
I'm not afraid, Mark. Frankly, I am terrified.
I don't think Mark is asking us to be Little Mary Sunshine--be afraid, be VERY afraid. Bad,bad stuff is happening, and if you grok karma, you know what's ahead. You make decisions everyday,Rev, that reflect your very real situtation. You haven't thrown up your hands (yet) and said "Save me, Big Brother!!" You're looking for solutions.
I sometimes have panic attacks myself about the uncertainty of the future, but so far I haven't had to choose between survival and my soul.
>but so far I haven't had to choose between survival and my soul.<
..Pity! let us know when you get there and have joined the rest of us! Here in hell/america!
But hey I took my chance and lost, now with a broken back and miniute to miniute pain, you do what you must, and try not to hate the world too much. You gotta eat!
>^^<
"You don't have to be part of the active workforce to make an enormous difference."
Spoken like someone with (1) a decently-paying, full-time job with benefits or (2) a trust fund.
I accept the premise that it is a mistake to equate working with success, happiness, or "making a difference." It is hard to make a difference, though, when you are having trouble making ends meet. Something to do with a hierarchy of needs...
Actually, that article, and the associated commentary, are quite interesting. Thanks for the inadvertent link, Mark.
Mark,
Probably anyone responding is a big fan...in love with your imaginative flights of fancy. I am.
But, honestly, playing Dr. Pangloss to our tired,poor, hungry masses of Candides isn't going to cut it. Look around. We're not afraid because we might not be able to afford a Prius. We're afraid because we might not be able to afford a loaf of bread.
Still, I love you.... Where did you get that fabulous mind? Oh yeah, your parents donated the materials and sent the co-mingled stuff out into the world. The result was clearly spectacular. Maybe their DNA knows a thing or two too.
This piece seems a bit glib and I think the study of conservative and liberal brains seems kind of simplistic. It may be that liberal thinking creates a certain type of brain not as wired for fear.
I think the important message is that fear is not a good motivation. We are having a breakdown of US society as it has been. Especially consumer society for reasons having to do with increased green consciousness and, even more so, economic reality. It is the conservatives whose world is really falling apart.The past experts are grasping to their dying ways and Wall Street can't break its gambling addiction or for that matter its coke and prostitution addictions. Idiots like Paul Ryan, who hasn't gotten past his adolescent Ayn Rand fantasy of unappreciated superiority, are trying to destroy democracy in favor of a rigid hierarchy that will enforce their undeserved place in the world.
He railed that Obama had "got down to the partisan mosh pit level." This puke
who would starve children and impoverish people who worked hard all their lives and paid into Social Security regularly. Ryan's ilk don't pay payroll tax on most of their money and for the rest they have loopholes. They deserve their wealth, they are so brilliant they created it. The US has been propagandized out of remembering that workers create wealth for Capital. It is very convenient for them not to remember this. So they refuse to see reality, dismiss science if it is inconvenient, wreak havoc with ever more ghastly ways to dredge oil out of the earth or reanimate the nuclear nightmare which is always there waiting to go off since we have no solution to nuclear waste. There are horrors to be feared and most of them are manmade though nature just following her own laws has always presented challenging conditions.
Actually some rational fear would be a good thing. For example of drilling deep under the ocean or the Frankenstein creepy sicknesses of radiation that nuclear power and weapons inflict or of a rapidly heating earth or of jumping into war after war. A little rational fear and precaution taking would really be in order here. Instead we get the bogey man of the moment whether it be Osama bin Laden or Iraq's weapons of mass destruction (that's rich from a country with a military budget larger that the rest of the world's combined, socialist healthcare and death panels or currently the DEFICIT ...shiver shiver tremble in fear.
Where we need some hope is believing in ourselves. Taking heart from Wisconsin that we can unite for democracy. We still have that in common as citizens. Say no to delusional dominance disorder. It is the disease of the owning class. But it could be terminal for us all if we don't call it out and start to laugh at it a lot more. Satire and ridicule are effective weapons against these petty tyrants. And a pretty good antidote to fear.
Naw, Al Qaeda aint the problem, the peoblem is we done ticked off so much of the world what with all our bombing, expolding pesticide factories. and just throwing our weight around all over everybodys day, We will have "terrorists" coming out of every manhole and oriface before too much longer passes.. but know this... We deserve it!.
For not controlling our government/dog and leting it roam around shitting on eerybodys lawn for so long!
>^^<