EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- One American Who Isn't For Sale
- Edward Snowden: Saving Us from the United Stasi of America
- Major Loss to Organic Farmers as Court Rules in Favor of Monsanto
- The Judicial Lynching of Bradley Manning
- Remembering Satyajit Ray’s Hirok Rajar Deshe: On Edward Snowden, Resistance and Inverted Totalitarianism
Popular content
Today's Top News
Obamacare: Why I'm Voting 'Yes'
The following are the prepared remarks offered by US Rep. Kucinich today regarding his plans for the upcoming health care vote:
Each generation has had to take up the question of how to provide for the health of the people of our nation. And each generation has grappled with difficult questions of how to meet the needs of our people. I believe health care is a civil right. Each time as a nation we have reached to expand our basic rights, we have witnessed a slow and painful unfolding of a democratic pageant of striving, of resistance, of breakthroughs, of opposition, of unrelenting efforts and of eventual triumph.
I have spent my life struggling for the rights of working class people and for health care. I grew up understanding first hand what it meant for families who did not get access to needed care. I lived in 21 different places by the time I was 17, including in a couple of cars. I understand the connection between poverty and poor health care, the deeper meaning of what Native Americans have called "hole in the body, hole in the spirit". I struggled with Crohn's disease much of my adult life, to discover sixteen years ago a near-cure in alternative medicine and following a plant-based diet. I have learned with difficulty the benefits of taking charge personally of my own health care. On those few occasions when I have needed it, I have had access to the best allopathic practitioners. As a result I have received the blessings of vitality and high energy. Health and health care is personal for each one of us. As a former surgical technician I know that there are many people who dedicate their lives to helping others improve theirs. I also know their struggles with an insufficient health care system.
There are some who believe that health care is a privilege based on ability to pay. This is the model President Obama is dealing with, attempting to open up health care to another 30 million people, within the context of the for-profit insurance system. There are others who believe that health care is a basic right and ought to be provided through a not-for-profit plan. This is what I have tirelessly advocated.
I have carried the banner of national health care in two presidential campaigns, in party platform meetings, and as co-author of HR676, Medicare for All. I have worked to expand the health care debate beyond the current for-profit system, to include a public option and an amendment to free the states to pursue single payer. The first version of the health care bill, while badly flawed, contained provisions which I believed made the bill worth supporting in committee. The provisions were taken out of the bill after it passed committee.
I joined with the Progressive Caucus saying that I would not support the bill unless it had a strong public option and unless it protected the right of people to pursue single payer at a state level. It did not. I kept my pledge and voted against the bill. I have continued to oppose it while trying to get the provisions back into the bill. Some have speculated I may be in a position of casting the deciding vote. The President's visit to my district on Monday underscored the urgency of this moment.
I have taken this fight farther than many in Congress cared to carry it because I know what my constituents experience on a daily basis. Come to my district in Cleveland and you will understand.
The people of Ohio's 10th district have been hard hit by an economy where wealth has accelerated upwards through plant closings, massive unemployment, small business failings, lack of access to credit, foreclosures and the high cost of health care and limited access to care. I take my responsibilities to the people of my district personally. The focus of my district office is constituent service, which more often then not involves social work to help people survive economic perils. It also involves intervening with insurance companies.
In the past week it has become clear that the vote on the final health care bill will be very close. I take this vote with the utmost seriousness. I am quite aware of the historic fight that has lasted the better part of the last century to bring America in line with other modern democracies in providing single payer health care. I have seen the political pressure and the financial pressure being asserted to prevent a minimal recognition of this right, even within the context of a system dominated by private insurance companies.
I know I have to make a decision, not on the bill as I would like to see it, but the bill as it is. My criticisms of the legislation have been well reported. I do not retract them. I incorporate them in this statement. They still stand as legitimate and cautionary. I still have doubts about the bill. I do not think it is a first step toward anything I have supported in the past. This is not the bill I wanted to support, even as I continue efforts until the last minute to modify the bill.
However after careful discussions with the President Obama, Speaker Pelosi, Elizabeth my wife and close friends, I have decided to cast a vote in favor of the legislation. If my vote is to be counted, let it now count for passage of the bill, hopefully in the direction of comprehensive health care reform. We must include coverage for those excluded from this bill. We must free the states. We must have control over private insurance companies and the cost their very existence imposes on American families. We must strive to provide a significant place for alternative and complementary medicine, religious health science practice, and the personal responsibility aspects of health care which include diet, nutrition, and exercise.
The health care debate has been severely hampered by fear, myths, and by hyper-partisanship. The President clearly does not advocate socialism or a government takeover of health care. The fear that this legislation has engendered has deep roots, not in foreign ideology but in a lack of confidence, a timidity, mistrust and fear which post 911 America has been unable to shake.
This fear has so infected our politics, our economics and our international relations that as a nation we are losing sight of the expanded vision, the electrifying potential we caught a glimpse of with the election of Barack Obama. The transformational potential of his presidency, and of ourselves, can still be courageously summoned in ways that will reconnect America to our hopes for expanded opportunities for jobs, housing, education, peace, and yes, health care.
I want to thank those who have supported me personally and politically as I have struggled with this decision. I ask for your continued support in our ongoing efforts to bring about meaningful change. As this bill passes I will renew my efforts to help those state organizations which are aimed at stirring a single payer movement which eliminates the predatory role of private insurers who make money not providing health care. I have taken a detour through supporting this bill, but I know the destination I will continue to lead, for as long as it takes, whatever it takes to an America where health care will be firmly established as a civil right.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...




417 Comments so far
Show AllI understand why you sold out Dennis. No one wants to be Wellstoned. Good luck trying to get re-elected though.
Obama's Health care bill a real shot in the arm for the Fascist Death Care industry.
Well said, & true. We're witnessing the death of the D party. It has been "Wallstreeted", & now the people will get serious about "Wellstoning" wallstreet (& their R and D parties, too).
ACTION ITEM FOR ALL OF YOU:
As soon as Obama signs this toxic legislation, e-mail or phone your state attorney general's office and encourage them to join the lawsuit that several state attorney generals promised to pursue against the Obama Regime for their criminal giveaways to Nebraska, Louisiana and others in exchange for support for Obama's corporate welfare program disguised as health care reform.
Also, contact your US Congressional Rep. and two US Senators and remind them why you won't be voting for them in the next election.
I can think of several inside the Beltway whose name I'd like to see in the following blank space....."The Honorable_______ was Wellstoned yesterday!"
Yeah sadly the first thought that came to my mind too when I heard about this flip flop in favor of the criminal insurance cartel sellout was "did Kucinich receive a threat?"
It had to be a tall kool-aid or a threat.
I'm a big fan of Dennis, but this reminds me too much of the way he always caves, every election season, and ends up supporting the Dims' candidate, come what may.
The Snowbombya propaganda machine is so well organized that it gave Dennis a speech to deliver as he caved in.
Oh, noooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!
what he didn't say:
"the dlc said i'd never see another dollar for re-election and I would see a primary challenger - sorry people - but I need MY job and health insurance more than you need heath care - so sorry to throw you under the bus! it's nothing personal - it's just business. I will continue to stand up for the little guy as long as there's no adverse consequences to it"
dennis kucinich
I'm betting you're 100% right. The old "live to fight another day" canard. All this does is blunt any momentum towards the substantive change Mr. Kucinich is working for. Everyone can say they took care of healthcare and get it off the table, never to be talked about again. Obama gets to claim a victory and everyone dances as the money rolls in for the next election.
It sure was a lovely show though.
The "...another day" ruse is over. We are in completely different times. We won't get out of this YEAR without serious, dramatic, and traumatic changes world-wide.The interalpha group of financiers is bankrupt, (& they'll take their wallstreet "capos" with them). This is the heart & soul of the POWER of the imperial global oligarchy. They got nothing left but their monetarist "bullshittery", & fascist police state bullying.They frankly feel there's too many "peasants" in the world anyway, & a dark-age "culling" is needed (a piss-poor healthcare system is the easiest way to "cull the herd"). They'll fail at this. But it will be UGLY (mainly for THEM).
I don't have the stomach to read this. All I can say is that I shall never support DK again for anything. I know I am only one person but I'd guess that there are thousands out here just like me. He was the last D that I had any respect for, now there are none.
Peggy, you have plenty of company so don't feel left out. I can never forget RichM constantly reminding us of Kucinich's tendency to stay in the party and cave in every time and he discussed it yesterday in a reply to a Kucinich supporter. I don't think RichM will be happy with DK once he reads this article and I will not blame him for calling Kucinich a Democratic Party apologist should he respond to this article.
"I don't have the stomach to read this." -- peggyforpeace
Like you, Peggy, I don't have the stomach for it, either!
I voted for Nader in 96,00,04 and 08. Looks like I will be voting for Nader again in 2012.
We hope Ralph will run! Or is he too good for this country??
VERY sad. Dennis was the one Congressperson we thought we could count on.
Yep I hope this gives Dim party apologists and coffee party advocates a pause and gets them out out on the street march 20th to protest the war as opposed to servilely at the feet of concentrated wealth and power begging for a little crumb more.
The Kucinich cave in won't give the "Dim party apologists and coffee party advocates a pause" because they think that Obama's health care bill is GOOD.
Hell... they still think Obama is a great 'progressive'. They say, "I mean, how could this wonderful man lie to us. He is so pragmatic and intelligent. His speeches are just fabulous... and... Haven't you read his books!! He was a community organizer. Plus, I was watching Jon Stewart, Olberman, and Maddow the other day and even THEY are for this health care reform. I mean, it's on MSNBC, so it has to be true. Also, this bill might not be perfect but it's a great step in the right direction!"
Every single time the Democrats fail to keep their word, crafty new 'rationalizations' and 'justifications' about why they could not do this or that sprout up everywhere, and spread like a wild fire on a windy day with the help of their media pundits/whores. And every single time these democrat supporters buy into their 'rationalizations' and 'justifications'.
When I tell these loyal democrat supporters why this health care reform bill is horrible I usually get labeled as being too idealistic, sometimes a conspiracy nut, or even a Republican. Why? Because they get their news from corporations. The message that I am trying to spread differs so greatly from the corporately crafted message that it must make more logical sense for them to question me over the neatly packaged message on the TV. They reply, "I mean, why would the news lie to us? We live in a democracy, and there is no reason for these people to lie to us." I then try to tell them why the corporate news is misleading and whose interests the corporate media really serves... but by this point in the conversation the glazed over look in their eyes tell me that they are already thinking about getting home to watch Lost, or something like that.
I would never have thought that seeing the 'light' and embracing the wonderful truths that lie beyond the corporately crafted message would be such a lonely place to be! But, alas... I feel better each day by reading the wonderful comments here on CD because I know that I am not alone anymore.
Markpaddles:
I feel the exact same. Thanks for posting your well-worded message.
Fishmael.
This is why I don't hang out with many progressives. They love to eat their own. Preferably, drawn and quartered.
Lousy partiers, too!
The problem with people like Kucinich and Sanders are that as progressives, they make no room for error. When Sanders withdrew his fight for single payer, the same kind of outrage we are seeing against Kucinich ensued. Kucinich's opposition to this bill all along and without a public option is now in question now that he flipped by choosing to vote yes. I don't think that the people here would be showing their anger at Kucinich if he had simply voted no. I myself don't understand why this vote was so special that he had to vote yes of all things. I reviewed this bill that he plans on voting yes on and even the public option were put back in and the anti-abortion gag on coverage was removed I wouldn't support this bill. Some say that this bill is the road to single payer but I went through it and found out that it was a giant leap away from single payer. Worse, this bill would destroy any chances of single payer or any meaningful type of universal health care from ever seeing the light of day in this country if it should pass. Kucinich knows this but here is what I think throws everyone here off about him. By voting yes for this bill, he damages his reputation of being in support of single payer since the bill is against single payer. I hope I could help you on this one. Please let me know.
P.S.: I can't say I was always progressive myself but caving in to the wrong side can seriously damage a person's credibility faster than expected.
"P.S.: I can't say I was always progressive myself but caving in to the wrong side can seriously damage a person's credibility faster than expected."
Be careful, Stanley - you may find yourself "caving" sooner than you'd like to believe and will be savagely accosted by your "friends" for having the temerity to think for yourself and make a tough, though imperfect choice. Such is the reality in these rarified confines of blog-dom where talk is cheap and action non-existent.
Thanks for the advice Ted. Now that I have just witnessed Kucinich's latest move to copy Obama's art of bullying his own party members of Congress, I feel like taking back what little sympathy I had of DK. Read this and tell me what you think of Kucinich now. I for one cannot believe he is bleeding his own progressive credentials faster than yesterday's shocking switch.
http://tpmdc.talkingpointsmemo.com
/2010/03
/from-progressive-holdout-to-whipping-health-care
----how-dennis-kucinich-is-helping-dems.php
I read it.
Are you upset that DK is trying to get votes for the bill, or that he's acting like the House Whip? Maybe he knows something we don't.
If Kucinich is wrong about this bill, then he's wrong about this bill. I don't equate that with being a sellout to progressives. Hell, the more I converse with progressives, the more I'm sure I don't even know that that term means.
Ted, I am glad you asked that question and will be happy to answer. I am upset at both his trying to get votes for the bill and volunteering as the House Whip to abuse power to pass a bad bill. There are plenty of other Democrats who could have done either or both of those actions but for him to go out on a limb and volunteer his service towards drumming up support to pass a totally regressive bill completely destroys all of his progressive credentials given what I know about his past political record. I have not forgotten the years Kucinich tirelessly argued for taking profit out of health care but here he is totally contradicting himself by supporting a bill that will guarantee more profits for the big insurance companies because most of us will be required to pay more taxes and buy insurance from the very same insurance companies who can do anything they want with our coverage. As a crook would once say, "Who needs to steal when the government steals for me !". I cannot speak for everyone here but I think that when they say that Kucinich is a sellout, they are rightfully angry and hurt that he has abandoned the core progressive values on health care he stood for all along up until March 17, 2010. I don't even know what to say watching Kucinich bleeding his credentials like mad. Sometimes progressives can sound like conservatives but the way I see Kucinich falling apart, it is like a motor cycle driver driving at too high speeds and then getting seriously injured when just a slip on the road causes his motorcycle to crash. I don't know what to trust him on anymore. I understand what you mean on whether progressives can really define themselves well and they can be similar to conservatives who aren't really conservative in a good sense.
P.S.: I don't want to go insane. On another post, I went angry and jealous comparing Kucinich's luxury in terms of family and health care coverage to mine. This health care crisis brings back painful memories of the loss of my wife and I can never forgive the doctors or the insurance companies for making that possible.
He may be falling apart, Stanley, or he may be making a tactical move. Time will tell.
As I've said, I am torn about this whole thing. I don't think anyone has a good sense of what this bill will do. Knowing the (corporate) world as I think I do, I can well imagine that it helps corporations. However, I believe it will also help some Americans. I am loath to pit the perfect against the good, as that usually yields nothing.
I'm sorry about the loss of your wife. My father's life was also cut short by the medical "industry."
That does it ! This is the move that is starting to force me into believing that maybe they were right. As long as they stay in the Democratic Party like Kucinich or caucus with them as "independents" just like Sanders, the same old caving in like this. Dennis, what happened to your sense of courage and conviction? You had no reason to vote yes on this bill. Voting against this bill was the real road to single payer health care while voting yes keeps it further out of reach. I know some people lost trust in you for caving in every presidential election but this cave-in further damages your credibility. I am ashamed of you Dennis but thanks for adding in your efforts to hasten my departure from the Democratic Party.
Anyone can be bought. I'm surprised Dennis was so cheap.
Congratulations to the Democratic party, one step closer to destruction from corruption.
Dennis, I admire you - what you have gone through in your life and what you have always tried to do for the American people.
This bill is far from Health Care reform and I know what a hard decision it is for you to vote 'yes' on it. I know because I'm struggling with it myself. I know it is not anywhere near what this country needs - but maybe, just maybe, it is a start.
I ask that you continue to fight for what is needed for this county - that is universal health care for all our citizens - medicare for all.
I also ask that you try and add a clause in the bill that will allow any citizen to buy into medicare prior to their reaching age 65. Also, could you 'sneak' in the public option??
Thanks again for all your fights for the American people.
What are you talking about? This bill is a sham and I can prove it. Please read my earlier review of this bill. My comment can be found under article
http://www.commondreams.org/view/2010/03/09-13
I don't feel like repeating my long review again and again but I will refer to it for anyone who still foolishly thinks that this scam is better than nothing !
Whatever good efforts DK tried in the past, he has completely crushed his own reputation and shattered our trust for this last vestige of hope. I don't even know if he was serious about his earlier fights. Maybe my loving niece was right. DK should have been an independent and not the "caucus with Democrats/Republicans" brand like some "independents" in the Senate !
Maybe DK could read my long review and reconsider his caving in but I'm already doubting he'll even try.
"Maybe my loving niece was right. DK should have been an independent and not the "caucus with Democrats/Republicans" brand like some "independents" in the Senate !"
You're starting to sound more and more like your loving niece...Stanley.
"....but maybe, just maybe, it is a start."
No, it isn't a start, it's a dead end ... and Kucinich knows it. Kucinich's job now is to pull you along with his weak logic. His role is to keep progressives in their pen.
Do you know the U.S currently pays 17% of our GDP and leaves 1 in 6 not covered scwell and Canada pays something 9% of their GDP for health insurance and has total coverage and a long life expectancy and more just total coverage of everyone?
http://www.counterpunch.org/lindorff03102010.html
This will mean Americans will pay even more of the GDP towards health care including forcing the young and healthy to buy crappy coverage with high co-pays from the criminal health insurance cartel that has ruined American health care in the first place.
Kucinich's cave leaves ironically Ron Paul as the most courageous Congress-critter left and I say that as a direct action lefty. Compare Kucnich's cave to Paul's blistering words about the war very recently:
http://original.antiwar.com/paul/2010/03/15/supporting-the-war-instead-of-the-troops/
One out of every four American children is on food stamps. If working people are forced to pay for insurance, maybe we can get it up to one in three children on food stamps. Then we can all starve to death and solve the problem for the corporate government and the oligarchy.
-"I have taken this fight farther than many in Congress cared to carry it "
-"I still have doubts about the bill. I do not think it is a first step toward anything I have supported in the past."
-"However after careful discussions with the President Obama, Speaker Pelosi, Elizabeth my wife and close friends, I have decided to cast a vote in favor of the legislation. "
Makes perfect sense to me, Dennis, you took the fight further, then dropped it...
You still have doubts, and you don't think the bill is a step towards anything you said you supported...
But, after talking with Pelosi and Obama, you will vote for it!!! makes sense to me!!!
I especially like the line:
"attempting to open up health care to another 30 million people, within the context of the for-profit insurance system."
That is an interesting way of saying you will force 30 million people to buy tax-payer subsidized junk insurance that they can't now afford, with its ballooning co-pays and deductables, further entrenching the powerful insurance lobby.
We now have a clear view of the "transformational potential" of the Obama presidency.
I'm very disappointed.
Dear Representative Kucinich,
I am not angry.
It's all water under the bridge.
You are on the other side and the bridge is in decay.
All I've lost is a little hope.
You have lost much more.
"You have lost much more."
Ahhh, but what has he gained? Remember, we're the little people. Our job is to beg for crumbs. Dennis will be just fine.
Some have the smart plan to beg Kucinich to make this horrible bill just a little more palatable. "Without Dem-Dennis, what would we do!" they cry.
This bill should be flushed down the toilet. If Kucinich wants to eat the sh** rather than flush it, it's his choice but watching him do it ain't going to be pretty. It makes my stomach turn.
p.s.
I was wrong about that bridge. In the time since I wrote the above, the bridge has totally collapsed.
I guess that since you have access to big jets now, something requiring constant maintenance on your part, like a bridge, is of less importance.
Well, I better get going. There's no reason to waste any more time.
Birdbrain Alley
So well said. Bump.
Dennis, how bad were the threats? Tell us why you compromised your values like all the other whores in congress. I hope you have a nice cushy job lined up in the health care insurance industry, because you are now in your last term, and those guys owe you bigtime. What are you getting, a half mil a year for life? Asshole.
The fascist party has two branches, and nothing good should be expected from either one of them.
Are we there yet?
http://www.wsws.org/
http://socialistworker.org/
http://www.gp.org/index.php
http://www.greenparty.org/index.php
http://www.greens.org/na.html
"Are we there yet?"
I thought we were there decades ago and as always, just when I'm quite sure of it, along comes a charismatic, or courageous, or "progressive" Democrat to save the duopoly. When will we ever learn? I'd say around the 12th of Never.
"Whenever we compromised, we lost." -- The Arch Druid, David Brower
Dennis,
In the end, the bill still is a corporate giveaway. Despite the pressure from Obama and Pelosi, it would be far better for you to hold your ground and vote against this bill. That would be the right thing to do, and clearly state your reasons for doing so to your constituents. While it is tough witnessing what is taking place in your district, the bill still is a bad one. Vote against it.
Another one bites the dust. I was really hoping he would actually tell us why he is voting for it, whether it is things in the bill that make life a little better, or Obomba said he'd be toast...whatever. After the NYT article that MM sent out about mid-Michigan and Flint, I fear our only recourse here is to find a governor who will fight for single-payer state-wide legislation. ???
I am sad and disheartened for the moment. I had such high hopes for DK. I am afraid his dreams have been wish washed into oblivion.
MM, we need you now, out front, everywhere...tour your ass off and speak to crowds everywhere. Your last letter has the makings of the next great wave of worker/poor/middle class/anti-corpoRAT angst. We need you for the revolution. Your voice speaks wisest. Dennis gave up. We know you won't. The time is here, the time is now. You're going to have to take whatever you can get cause we are all so damn poor now. Do donations at the door. Just please please help us with your fabulous wit and wisdom. How about a bus tour, just stop in every town and make the wave start. You're our last hope Obi-wan.
Okay, this really hurts, but at the same time I have tired of the insulting, intimidating, bullying "now or never" White House rhetoric. This bill isn't the end of the line; this one vote isn't the end of the line. It is the beginning of little in the way of alleviating suffering and heartache and not the end of our pursuit of Medicare for All.
We have learned something valuable: we won't get there by electing Democrats. In other words, this struggle may be more historic than our president and the Democratic Party intended. For those still addicted, wait until this bill passes and they finally see what this bill does and doesn't do.
Vowing not to vote for Democrats is a good start, but making sure we have an alternative on the ballot is an even better start. Any volunteers?
Actually, if this bill dies out, there will be an autopsy as to why it deserved to fail. The Democrats may lose either way but by killing this bill, the road to single payer is restored rather than taken away.