Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Israeli Soldiers Say Army Rabbis Framed Gaza as Religious War
JERUSALEM -- Rabbis affiliated with the Israeli army urged troops heading into Gaza to reclaim what they said was God-given land and "get rid of the gentiles" - effectively turning the 22-day Israeli intervention into a religious war, according to the testimony of a soldier who fought in Gaza.
Soldier says rabbis pushed "religious war" in Gaza. An Israeli soldier gestures atop a mobile artillery unit as the sun sets over the central Gaza Strip in this January 5, 2009 photo.
(REUTERS/Gil Cohen Magen) Literature passed out to soldiers by the army's rabbinate "had a clear message - we are the people of Israel, we came by a miracle to the land of Israel, God returned us to the land, now we need to struggle to get rid of the gentiles that are interfering with our conquest of the land," the soldier told a forum of Gaza veterans in mid-February, just weeks after the conflict ended.
A transcript of the testimony given at an Israeli military academy at the Oranim college on Feb. 13 was obtained on Friday by McClatchy and also published in Haaretz, one of Israel's leading dailies. The soldier, identified as "Ram," a pseudonym to protect his identity, gave a scathing description of the atmosphere as the Israeli army went to war.
"The general atmosphere among people I spoke to was . . . the lives of Palestinians are . . . let's say far, far less important from the lives of our soldiers," Ram said. The religious literature gave "the feeling of almost a religious mission," he said.
Jonathan Peled, the Israeli Embassy spokesman in Washington, said that Israel "absolutely" had no intention of expelling Palestinians from Gaza and has no territorial or other claims there. While he hadn't seen the religious literature mentioned by the soldier, he said the Israeli army "is a secular army and is not run by any religious institution but by army commanders answering to the democratically elected government of the State of Israel."
Brig. Gen. Avichai Mendelblit, the Israeli army's chief prosecutor, on Thursday announced the first criminal investigation into the killing of Palestinian civilians during Israel's military incursion. He issued the order after the Haaretz and Maariv newspapers published an account from the Oranim forum of how an Israeli sharpshooter killed a Palestinian woman and her two children when they inadvertently took a wrong turn after being released from detention in their own home.
There are growing questions about the Israeli Defense Force's commitment to prosecute war crimes and burgeoning criticism of the operation itself. According to Haaretz, the army first learned on Feb. 23 of the Oranim forum allegations and obtained a full transcript on March 5. The army told McClatchy on Thursday it had received the transcript that day, but on Friday a representative said it had received the document "a few days ago."
The Israeli Embassy in Washington said the army "holds itself to the highest moral and ethical standards, and as such is investigating the claims with the diligence one would expect in order to determine their accuracy, should further action be required."
Some 1,400 Palestinians were killed during the operation, more than half of them civilians, according to Palestinian human rights groups.
Danny Zamir, the head of the Yitzhak Rabin military academy, which organized the soldiers' the forum, said the Gaza operation was "an unusual military action in the IDF's history which established new, unknown, norm in the IDF's ethical code."
The testimonies indicated that the army, despite repeated claims that it was protecting civilian lives, was not instructing its troops to that effect.
One soldier, identified only as "Aviv," said he was bothered by open fire orders given to his unit for an operation that was later canceled.
"We were supposed to go in with an armored vehicle called an Ahzarit, break into the door and start to shoot inside and simply go up floor by floor. . . . I call this murder . . . to go up floor by floor and every person that we see we were to shoot," he said. "Aviv" served as a squad leader with the Givati unit in the Gaza neighborhood of Zeitoun.
"At first I said to myself how is this logical? Higher authorities said this was permissible because everyone left in the area and in the city of Gaza is condemned, is a terrorist, because they didn't run away."
When the orders were changed, Aviv said that another soldier protested: "Everyone in there is a terrorist, that's known." His comrades joined in, "We need to kill every person found there; everyone in Gaza is a terrorist."
Another soldier, indentified as "Gilad," said his battalion commander made clear that the army was going to use its overwhelming firepower as its protection in entering densely populated Gaza City.
"He made clear to everyone that one of the most important lessons and one of the big differences with the Second Lebanon War (in 2006) is the way in which we, the army . . . went in with a lot of fire. The surprise wouldn't be the time, or the way or the place, nothing but a lot of firepower. The goal actually was to protect solders' lives with firepower."
McClatchy reported that scores of Palestinians were treated at Gaza hospitals for burns that may have come from shells containing white phosphorus, which is illegal to use in heavily populated areas. The issue came up only briefly at the Oranim conference, when a sergeant in the paratroops, identified as Yossi, said, "There was a lot of use of white phosphorous."
Sarit Michaeli of the Israeli human rights group B'Tselem thinks that the public release of the testimony helped spur the investigation. "There have been many cases where we have asked the advocate general to look into cases, and they drag their feet until it gets into the media."
Michaeli said the testimonies showed the need for an independent investigation into Israel's action in Gaza, "The army and (State Attorney Menahem) Mazuz has claimed all along that the internal investigations and debriefings are the correct way. This clearly demonstrates that the soldiers didn't reveal what they did or that they didn't consider it a problem," Michaeli told McClatchy.
Churgin is a McClatchy special correspondent.



51 Comments so far
Show AllA religious war they say now? From the smell you might have thought it was a barbecue.
There is no "secular" Israeli government. A nation created for the purposes of securing the mythology of a religious group isn't defending itself. They are killing others to perpetuate their fantasy. The people they kill are no more real to them than so many chickens. In Israel people are Jews and non-people are not really worthy of consideration.
In a few minutes an Israeli propoganda officer will be here to tell you that this was all a mistake and that Israel had to defend itself from rocket attacks that kill fewer people than Israeli auto accidents by killing Palestinian children. He doesn't really think those children in Gaza were dead people so the comments will be a little off.
Just watch.
I can believe it! The Israeli's went to a lot of effort to turn it into a religious war! There is nothing like religion to get people fired up to a bloody slaughter of innocents who are being portrayed as heathens not fit to live among the religious. Who imagine they are defending something God gave them centuries ago. That they are superior to everyone else in this world because they are 'God's Chosen People'. Until Jews and Christian's both get over the ignorance in the bible. The myth that God gave these people the land centuries ago. There is going to be strife in the region. The Israeli's are going to see it as their duty to rid their land of all non-Jews. The Jews are just as bigoted and racist as any Moslem's thought about being. The best thing that could happen to this planet is to ban all religion. It's the root of all evil in this world.
Religious extremism is always dangerous regardless of what religion they are practicing. When you add the sickness of "nationalism" to it-it becomes twice as dangerous. Israel is a profoundly dangerous country.
And people still call Israel a democracy....It is nothing but a vile, racist, apartheid theocracy. Worse than any Islamic theocracy.
I recently watched a documentary on the Nazi/Russian fighting during WW 2. Soilders on both sides were told to go house to house, floor to floor, and shoot anything that lived. Nice to see Israeli leaders in tune with Stalin and Hitler (US leaders also for that matter).
True Jews Are Anti-Zionist And Support Justice For The Palestinian People
"Who are the true Jews?"
"Always siding with the slave, never with the slave-master."
"What makes the Palestinian a slave?"
"Having his/her homeland occupied by another people."
"And what turns the Jewish settler into a slave-master?"
"Being the occupier."
"What's the answer?"
"Jewish colonizer and colonized Palestinian sit down together for the purpose of figuring things out."
"Based on?"
"One equals one."
"Anything else?"
"Yes we can."
Good for you, yours truly.
Yes, we could. If every problem in the world were stripped down to its simplest, most basic essentials as you did with your Q&As, and every government and all the people were truly sincere about the well-being of their nation's diverse peoples and the world's peoples, and developed and carried out policies and actions for the collective well-being, we would have a lovely world.
It's so simple really. When ego-centric thinking and behavior evolves into spiritual maturity, all is possible.
Hold that thought. /cm
Jews are a minority in every country in which they live (except Israel) and they have frequently experienced persecution throughout history.
Until Israel is safe, the Jewish People will never be safe.
A peaceful co-existence, based on the two-state plan, is the only solution.
When Jews were a minority in other countries individual Jews were imperiled but Judaism was safe. If all the Jews return to Israel and are rewarded for the sins of the IDF there will be no Judaism, no Israel and no Jews.
The economy that supports Israel in the US is collapsing and the overwhelming numbers of Arabs on Israel's borders are going to need a distraction when THEIR, oil based economies collapse.
Egypt, has a vast excess of young men and a shortage of food. Afghanistan and Iraq have demonstrated that the weapons systems that the IDF uses can be defeated by determined ground troops willing to take losses. Do the math.
300 million young arabs, 20 million aging Israelis. The 20 million in Israel are absolutely dependent upon food shipments for survival. World grain stocks are declining and grain shipments aren't as secure as they used to be.
Israel is a trap.
"The general atmosphere among people I spoke to was . . . the lives of Palestinians are . . . let's say far, far less important from the lives of our soldiers,"
**or rather less important than the lives of jews.
Its just human supremacy.
I cant really blame them too harshly since the concept of thinking you are better than others isnt condemned--even by some CD posters. They want to have their cake and eat it too.
Humans who eat meat or hunt, or say they have a right to go into national parks and shoot bears if they get threatened, they are just like these zionists.
They think they have a divine right to oppress others.
Whether its bears, chickens, gentiles, the poor, etc.
There are people who are anti-racism who hate gays. There are gays who are racist. Humans arent very consistent about these things.
And then some will say the trouble isnt human nature but religion. And yet who created religion? Secularism is a religious belief system according to academic philosophy. China is secular and its also a supremacist society.
If you want to fight zionism, fight the idea that one group of humans is better than other living beings.
If you just say: "we are all humans" then you arent fighting the myth that someone is superior, you are just adding a few more members to the snob club.
Bring America Back !!!!.....Okay Webber, then what you aptly describe is the legendary:.....'survival of the fittest'.....a nation and society which-- with
its mad advance to killing apparatus, has digressed and regressed itself to
a pitiful animal level--be we human or mammal animals.
The Governmnet of Israel is suffering an extreme backlash over its invasion of Gaza, even from the United States of America where they could once count on overwhelming support.
The eyes of the world are finally opening to the reality of what the Government of Israel has become.
They sent out their minions in droves to monitor boards such as these and to try and turn the debate into one of Israel as victim so as to stem the outrage but failed in that regard.
These latest reports of atrocities will be "investigated " and there will certainly be punishment meted out but all of that will simply be for the purpose of "catapulting the propaganda"
The underlying motive for this is not because the Government of Israel wants to be a "Moral state" and one concerned with the principles of human rights. It is because they want to be PERCEIVED as such so that they can continue to count on the support of the United States of America and other such countries as they steal the lands of the peoples of Palestine.
While they might send a soldier or two to prison, or censure a commander, the underlying POLICIES will not change. They will continue to kidnap palestinains at will. They will continue extra-judicial assassinations. They will continue to expand settlements on the West bank. They will continue to push down olive trees and steal palestinian water. They will continue to pursue policies of expansionism.
They will provoke more wars, go through this entire process again, and then once more try to regain support for their actions by more "sober reflection of the actions of our soldiers" with the press fed every detail and Government officials loudly proclaiming they will investigate every wrongdoing.
In order to show his submission to Yahweh, Abraham was willing to sacrifice his own son. The Government of Israel will have no problem sacrificing a few of her soldiers to show their own submission to Zionism and "Ersatz Israel"
Kudos to the New York Times for extensively covering the testimonies of the Israeli soldiers.
Now, if the MSM TV news broadcasts would provide the same coverage...
Oh well, hope springs eternal.
Bring America Back !!!!...The evidence that Gaza was and is another intentional Israeli Genocide is overwhelming !!!! I echo the posts of 'horrified' and greatbear215 below.
**prior to the attack, the US Army Corps of Engineers set up a mock Gaza city on Israel lands and provided training to the IDF on the best ways to attack the people of Gaza. Much blood then is on the hands of US Army personnel, and we must pinpoint the specific names of the military, quasi-military, and contractors who participated in the Attack==religious or not ! We must identify all these exact names, from the troops on the ground to the commanders at the 5-sided puzzle palace at the Pentagon. Hopefully one of us Progs will have the time to file a freedom of info act request, including the amount of US Taxpayer monies invested in planning, executing, and covering-up GAZA !
**300 to 400 of the Palestinian dead are innocent, defenseless children !!!!
**At least two other headliners in today's CD are documenting Israeli soldier admissions and testimonies they intentionally fired upon Gaza civilians.
**Culpability most surely extends to then President Bush in FAILING to demand that the IDF stop its Gaza attacks, it's starvation campaigns, food blockades,and medical boat ship interventions. Most assuredly, another War Crime from the Bush war mongers.
**Even more culpable, then President = elect Obama failed as well to demand a cease fire and withdrawal by Israel. Just the opposite, He made an inoccuous statement that if his daughters were in the line of fire from Palestinian rockets, that He would do the SAME THING as Israel. This gave the IDF even more impetus to continue shedding Gazan blood !!!
**Therefore, even before becoming President, as a US Senator, Obama shares
guilt for Gaza !! Those 300 to 400 innocent dead kids were also someone's daughters, sons, cousins, grandchildren and friends.
**Just as magically and mysteriously, the IDF withdrew from Gaza on the exact day of the Inauguration--Jan 20 ! So, the Obama inaugural balls danced on the graves of 1500 dead Gazans, thousands more injured and homeless and displaced !
Not even one ounce of regret from either the departing criminal Bush cabal, or the incoming Obama team.
**Now the Obama Administration throws more US millions to the rebuilding of the Gaza Strip==again without so much as an apology for being part and parcel of the attacks themselves !!!! What insolent, inhumane arrogance this is, and is a disgrace which will haunt our Leaders, past and present.
**It becomes easier and easier to condone Genocides, since it is exactly what the US has been doing in it's pre-emptive invasion of a defenseless Iraq, for the past 7 years. At some point even we American Sheeple must rise up in protest of our Nation's role as war criminals and war mongers. !
The genocidal mass murder and maiming of men, women and children is "Religious?"
I think it's time for the world to ban that fabricated Book of cruelty and avarice.
I can sure understand the Roman and Aryan points of view now.
Distortions of ancient texts say more about those who distort them than the intent of the texts. Try reading the bible in tandem with say... the Tao te Ching.
An example of distortion is the Doctrine of Discovery
http://ili.nativeweb.org/sdrm_art.html
The tribal storm and war god, Yahweh, commanded the little wandering tribes to go forth and take the towns and settlements of those who lived upon the land that He coveted. Over and over, He told them to kill all the people, animals, tear down the cities and leave nothing intact. On at least one occasion, when the Israelites had kept the choice animals to sacrifice to Yahweh, He chastised His people most severely for not following his orders.
Most gods have matured over the years and become more benign, but apparently the ancient god of war and storm has stayed the same, demanding ruthless slaughter in His name and cursing those who worship life and peace.
.
...Kiryat Arba Chief Rabbi Dov Lior delivered a fiery and overtly political speech, calling for Israeli sovereignty over the whole of the Land of Israel and criticizing what he described as weak-minded IDF strategies in the face of Israel's enemies.
Citing the Torah, Lior noted that "200,000 Israelites and 10,000 Judahites fought Amalek. Why are the Judahites counted separately from the others? Because the Israelite army pitied Amalek. Today this is called being humanitarian."
He added, "Only the tribe of Judah did not pity Amalek, and destroyed it... The sons of Torah are taught not to pity their enemies."
Lior expressed hope that a growing number of IDF strategists coming from the national-religious camp would have an influence on future military campaigns.
"We need ethics from the Torah, not the Christian world, which teaches to turn the other cheek. This hypocrisy is against human nature," Lior said.
Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat also saluted the soon-to-be soldiers, saying the IDF was an army of "city-dwellers and villagers, secular and religious, left- and right-wing."
A religious band provided high-spirited music, and the youths danced along....
(By YAAKOV LAPPIN ..haaretz)....
The US doesn't have the money for more war. Ours or anyone elses.
For our leaders to think otherwise is bad for the world but to have no one to run against them due to a lack of money, absents of media support and ignorance of voters...in that order...marks the end of our experiment with democracy.
If you are smart you will lay low and become self reliant within or near a small township or village that has water.
Good luck to everyone...
Israel has nuke weapons
Deepa
This is another example of how religion and God are (mis)used for the legitimation of the selfish-interests of the ruling classes.
Violence, both coercive and systemic, reigns in the world. This is institutionalized in modern social structures. The myth of redemptive violence undergirds popular culture, civil religion, nationalism and foreign policy. It lies at the root of the system of domination that has characterized human existence. A theology that affirms the salvific power of violence results in denigration of people, who are not part of the “God's chosen community”, permitting discrimination and violence. This reality is reflected in the violent history of religions that is steeped in blood, sacrifice and scapegoating. The brutal facts of the history of religions pose stark questions about the intertwining of religion and violence.
In any religious world there are atleast two streams and these streams have their own respective understanding of their God and religion. The socio-political stream which consisted of ruling and upper classes used their God and religion to sanction and legitimize their genocidal violence and expansionistic policies. A section of theologians, who are dependent for their sustenance on the ruling classes, are involved mainly to promote interests of ruling classes. Thus the large part of theological discourse supported the point of view of ruling classes and defended their genocidal violence.
Imperial and colonial powers (collaboration between Roman, Spanish, British, American empires and the Institutional Christian church) have used religion to support their volence, plunder and occupation of others' lands. Palestine, Iraq, Afghanistan, Congo... are some of the examples.
It is time to STOP giving $3 billion in military aid to Israel each year (see Analysis: U.S. weapons used in Gaza http://ncronline.org/node/3104), especially when the IDF is using U.S. F-16 fighter-bombers, U.S. white phosphorous shells and bombs, U.S. attack helicopters, and U.S. M-16 rifles to murder and oppress Palestinian civilians in illegally occupied Gaza and the West Bank (see UN Chief Annan Calls on Israel to End 'Illegal Occupation' http://www.commondreams.org/headlines02/0312-08.htm), in clear violation of U.S. law. Section 4 of the (U.S.) Arms Export Control Act requires that military items transferred to foreign governments by the United States be used solely for internal security and legitimate self-defense.
Why is Israel such an exception to this law? Claims of "self-defense" in retaliation for Hamas' terrorist rockets are belied by the disproportionate number of civilians, especially children, killed during Israel's Gaza onslaught, and by Israel's criminal use of indiscriminate weapons of mass destruction, such as white phosphorous, cluster bombs, Dense Inert Metal Explosives (DIME), and flechettes (see Unconventional Weapons against The People of Gaza: Interview of Dr. Mads Gilbert http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=11636 and Israeli army used flechettes against Gaza civilians http://www.amnesty.org/en/news-and-updates/news/israeli-army-used-flechettes-against-gaza-civilians-20090127).
Two wrongs never make a right, but brutal and disproportionate retaliation against civilians, which was termed the war crime of "Collective Punishment" by the post-World War II Nuremberg Tribunals, will lead to more brutal reprisals as the insane cycle of violent revenge spins madly out of control.
If any other ally used U.S. military aid to kill and oppress civilians in illegally occupied land, there would be a loud outcry in Congress and the U.S. media with strong demands that such misused aid immediately cease.
We in the U.S. share some of the blame for the horrific injuries Israeli forces inflicted on Gazan civilians because many of these terrible weapons were developed here (see Mystery weapons allegedly used in Gaza developed at military bases in Va., Fla. http://www.southernstudies.org/2009/01/cancer-on-a-dime-mystery-weapons-allegedly-used-in-gaza-developed-at-military-bases-in-va-fla.html).
So it is time to end military aid to Israel, which has the sixth most powerful military on earth and, certainly, the most powerful in the Middle East, even without its approximately 200 nuclear weapons.
Unless and until the U.S. treats Palestinians as we treat Israelis, as full human beings deserving of all the human rights everyone is entitled to under the U.N.'s Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and unless and until BOTH Israelis and Palestinians respect each other as human beings, accept each other's sovereign states, and renounce violence against each other, there will never be a just peace. We must lead the way by ending the double standard of treatment of Israel and Palestine.
The US once helped Israel. Now Israel has become so powerful that it is a de facto 51st state of the US and can demand what ever it wants and the Israelis who are in our government - Congress & Senate give it to them. Until we are governed by non-Israelis, this will continue.
Israel the 51st state? I don't think so.
A state has only *two* Senators in Congress.
Ed: "It is time to STOP giving $3 billion in military aid to Israel each year ..."
From my readings, Ed, I believe the figure is 30 billion dollars per year. Either way, it's too much for a prosperous 1/2 nation receiving money from the Rothschild's and other similar financiers, plus the AIPAC-tainted U.S. government.
peace, /cm
If Gaza is a giant outdoor prison, the State of Israel has become an asylum.
How can there ever be peace with religious fanatics, bigots, and racists dominating one side, while continuously accusing the other side of anti Semitic extremism?
One begets the other. And so long as Israel enjoys lockstep support from Jewish "liberals" in the United States, with the Lobby fronting for the fanatics, and our politicians fall over backwards not to appear soft on "Israel’s right to exist," there is very little hope.
When the Lobby accuses a politician, anyone, of anti Semiticism or of being a "self hating Jew" we must not cower and hide and plead for mercy. We must spit these disgusting slanders back in their unscrupulous faces.
Meerscheimer and Walt, Jimmy Carter and a few others have led the way. Now Israel appears to have begun to strangle on its own extremism. Hopefully there will soon be a day when attesting that Palestinians have rights too will not set off a fierce firestorm of fanaticism squelching all criticism Then the United States can finally do what it has to do.
How on earth can anyone blame the Palestinians for "Anti-Semitism"? The Palestinians are more Semite than the Israelis , most of whom came from Europe and Russia.
As capitalism goes the way of the dinosaur, Americans will grow too broke to finance wars of aggression complete with war crimes in support of an apartheid state. --Peace!
Every Inquisition has its auto-da-fé.
· Yr Obd't Servant
"The testimonies indicated that the army, despite repeated claims that it was protecting civilian lives, was not instructing its troops to that effect."
Anyone who has proclaimed violence his method inexorably must choose lying as his principle.
~Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Once victims, now executioners...
But, at Durban, the US will be boycotting the international conference on racism, because as everyone knows, to even bring up the idea that Israel may be be committing atrocities based on race is horrible antisemitism.
---USAn---
"IDF is a secular army and is not run by any religious institution but by army commanders answering to the democratically elected government of the State of Israel".....which is a self discribed "Jewish State"...therfore thier army is by definition not secular.
while I dont believe in God, still, I DO hope there is a special hell for these people.
"The only means of strengthening one's intellect is to make up one's mind about nothing, to let the mind be a thoroughfare for all thoughts." - John Keats
'Gott mit uns' should sound familiar to especially Jews who know their history. The rest of the animal kingdom has now sense of history, as far as we know, but this kind of behaviour really takes the biscuit!! If I were a Jew, I might consider renouncing my faith if I had any. After this, pointing fingers at the Germans for their past is something that's become impossible, you can be a Jew and a Nazi at the same time now. It's like Animal Farm; at the end pigs and human looked the same to the rest of the animals.
Gaza And The Warsaw Ghetto
same place
different time
while the world stood by
genocide
live
If the IDF is the most moral army in the world, it doesn't say much about all the others, does it?
And it claims to be secular too yet I've seen many photographs of IDF thugs praying before they go into battle! Funny thing that! And they have army rabbis too for the secular army!
The world is a strange place!
www.dangerouscreation.com
"If Gaza is a giant outdoor prison, the State of Israel has become an asylum."
Soon, it will become the world's largest panic room!
"Cee Miracles March 21st, 2009 9:37 pm
Ed: "It is time to STOP giving $3 billion in military aid to Israel each year ..."
From my readings, Ed, I believe the figure is 30 billion dollars per year. Either way, it's too much for a prosperous 1/2 nation receiving money from the Rothschild's and other similar financiers, plus the AIPAC-tainted U.S. government."
THAT IS INVALID in two ways.
*) It's $3bn a year, $30bn for the next ten years, but this is only the funding for military spending, of which of course around 70-75% has to be spent buying from the U.S. MIC, which is one of the wrongs about this, because the U.S. MIC has to be put in its damn grave; but what's also wrong about this is that in referring to only this $3bn a year, people help to hide the total $9bn a year of U.S. [taxpayer] dollars going to funding the extremely criminal state, not country, but state of Israel! The whole damn amount, the whole $9bn a year, needs to be terminated; not only the $3bn for military spending, weaponising, ... and mass murders and destruction!
*) It's not the Rothschilds' and AIPAC'atised U.S. govt that fund the government of the [state] of Israel; it's U.S. taxpayers' dollars that are [stolen] and criminal mis-allocated that are funding the wholly criminal government of the [state] of Israel. The Rothschilds' don't fund it; they partake in the theft of the U.S. taxpayers' dollars and in order to profit from this stolen money.
Oh, and AIPAC does NOT control the U.S. government, regardless if apparences cause some people to believe that the opposite is true. The real controllers of the U.S. government are much more powerful than AIPAC!
M I K E
Yes, I agree that AIPAC is hardly the controller of American Govt.
A better way to perceive this is looking at the many controls on a Stereo Hi Fi system, and realizing that adjusting the LEFT / RIGHT balance has little to do with the frequency response nor volume ( of gov't ).
We may consider the multitudinous influences and variable controls of gov't more likened to that of the Space Shuttle than a mere stereo. The fuel mix must be just right for lift-off, while the air breathable environment is crucial for survival for more than a few minutes.
In a similar analogy, all the organs of our body were challenged to figure out who was the most powerful and rightful big BOSS, and while the brain, muscles, stomach, liver, and heart had many solid arguments in their favor -- it was the lowly anus who showed who really rules -- by just stopping work for a short time.
The Assholes have us, and we need relief.
Namaste
Obama has promised $30 billion in military aid to Israel over the next 10 years, so that's where the average of $3 billion per year comes from.
Our corporate war profiteers, otherwise known as the Military-Academic-Industrial-Media (MAIM) Complex, "needs" these wars and conflicts to survive. "If it bleeds, it leads" applies to more than each evening's newscast. Congress depends on kickbacks ("campaign contributions") from this complex in our money-corrupted corporate political system to get elected and re-elected. So the circle is closed, and we, the citizen-taxpayers, are mostly left out. True democracy here would be a nice dream, if it weren't for current campaign funding and corporate personhood. Change those two giant obstacles to democracy and you will have REAL change, not Obama's 'appearance of change'.
Quoting from the article:
One soldier, identified only as "Aviv," said he was bothered by open fire orders given to his unit for an operation that was later canceled.
"We were supposed to go in with an armored vehicle called an Ahzarit, break into the door and start to shoot inside and simply go up floor by floor. . . . I call this murder . . . to go up floor by floor and every person that we see we were to shoot," he said. "Aviv" served as a squad leader with the Givati unit in the Gaza neighborhood of Zeitoun.
"At first I said to myself how is this logical? Higher authorities said this was permissible because everyone left in the area and in the city of Gaza is condemned, is a terrorist, because they didn't run away."
END QUOTE
I thank these IDF soldiers for speaking out, but what's quoted above from the soldier going by the pseudo-name of Aviv shows that he needs to understand that the IDF had NO legal or moral right to be in Gaza to begin with, not even if the orders given to them had been ethical [if] invasion of Gaza was legally and morally justified, which it was NOT. The soldiers need to understand that it is NOT Hamas or Palestinians in general who are the aggressors, but that they instead are only trying to defend themselves, their country, lives, and right to exist in their country that is right to exist. The soldiers need to understand that it is Israel that is and has always been the aggressor and extremely criminal about it, or in its ways. And once the soldiers finally wake up to this reality, which is the true reality, then they need to understand that they must DISSENT against [all] orders given by the Israeli government for carrying out operations against Palestinians anywhere in Palestine as well as anywhere else that there are Palestinians. The soldiers need to understand that they are always carrying out totally criminal orders even when these don't appear criminal; because, again, Israel is [always] aggressor in this, and regardless of whether the orders appear ethical or not! The orders appearing strongly ethical are criminal; they are always about aggression, [war of aggression], supreme international crime!
I feel sad for the soldiers who are demonstrating soundness in important ways, but still not fully enough. Fully, is what's needed! LET NO MAN DICTATE YOUR ACTIONS! It is [you], each one of us, who must consider suggestions and orders, weigh them carefully but while making sure to be adequately informed, first, and then decide if the suggestions or orders for actions to carry out are acceptable, or not. And when we are not adequately informed, then make damn sure to tell the persons giving out orders that you can't provide a 'yes' or 'no' response until making yourself adequately informed, in order to be able to make a [responsible] decision.
LET NO MAN DICTATE YOUR ACTIONS; ACTIONS THAT YOU ARE TO CARRY OUT! Learn to DISSENT and to tell asshole dictators to go jump off of cliffs, or ... whatever alternative expression comes to your mind, as long as it's not one that is about blind obedience; as if you're no more intelligent than a dog trained to attack when given orders to do so. The dog will obey without thought, but we [must] apply real and critical thinking, and based on real and sane [conscience].
Anyway, the following are two related videos, one that's specifically related, while the other is indirectly related to the recent testimonies of the IDF soldiers.
"'Cold-blooded murder' of Gaza man's daughters - 20 Mar 09" (3:13), AlJazeeraEnglish, Mar 20 2009
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7W06iJ8q3c
"Israeli soldiers say killing of civilians 'allowed' - 19 March 09" (3:32), AlJazeeraEnglish, Mar 19 2009
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZGITh9HPJ7g
Again, I THANK the IDF soldiers who have been speaking out, so of course including the group Breaking the Silence.
Having just done a search of Youtube to see if I'd find any current enough videos there about Breaking The Silence, I found the following one and it's directly related to the article of this CD page.
"Israel's Army Rabbi Gave Out Hate Leaflet to Troops" (1:28), theGlobalReport, Feb 4 2009
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b19vVFqfCXU
BIBLE
B asic
I nstructions
B efore
L eaving
E arth,
Simple & Loving Instructions they are too,
The 2nd Commandment is,
Love Thy Neighbor As Thyself, Love Thy Neighbor As Thyself,
It is not Murder Thy Neighbor And Steal His Land.
No no, I checked.
Yikes! I think I'm a gentile.
The IDF have learned a lot in the Waffen SS
None of this will go anywhere. How is this any different from the Bush White House self-investigating? Israel will sacrifice a few soldiers to satisfy the public-and it will still be business as usual in Gaza. This is exactly what Israel does every time-and it's it's always been business as usual afterward. What's needed is an independent intenational inquiry into Gaza. Gotta be independent-and it's gotta be international, as well. Only way to really accomplish anything.
Yes, we are ALL "Gentiles", who aren't Jewish, and they hate us all, even as they whine about "anti-semitism" when anyone criticizes them. THEN, they are a Race and a Religion; the rest of the time , when it suits their deceptions, they are "secular".
This unholy RACIST war they are perpetrating on the Palestinians is based on nothing so much as pure GREED. Their "God-given Superiority" as a big steaming pile of BS, and they demonstrate it every day!
This report just in, no doubt showing their "Secular side" and their obvious love of fashion and bragging rights:
"Dead babies, mothers weeping on their childrens' graves, a gun aimed at a child and bombed-out mosques - these are a few examples of the images Israel Defense Forces soldiers design these days to print on shirts they order to mark the end of training, or of field duty."
"The slogans accompanying the drawings are not exactly anemic either: A T-shirt for infantry snipers bears the inscription "Better use Durex," (a brand of condom) next to a picture of a dead Palestinian baby, with his weeping mother and a teddy bear beside him. A sharpshooter's T-shirt from the Givati Brigade's Shaked battalion shows a pregnant Palestinian woman with a bull's-eye superimposed on her belly, with the slogan, in English, "1 shot, 2 kills."
"There is a perception that the Palestinian is not a person, a human being entitled to basic rights, and therefore anything may be done to him."
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1072466.html
Why did they let them back in, in the first place? After being dispersed among the Europeans for the last two thousand years, their blood lines have probably been so diluted that you have to wonder if there is any real "Jewish" blood left in these people?
Perpetuating the "myth" of "God", is only beneficial to those who do so, if that "God" makes a "choice" of who will be the "chosen" ones of that "God".
This was not known among the Native People of the Americas if it ever had been was long forgotten, and was introduced by the European Christians most likely as a justification for the destruction of countless cultures and tribes and as many as 500 million individuals.
Things haven't changed much, and one would think that the Jews now known as the "Israelis" would have learned something from the "holocaust" they often use now as a justification for the illegal occupation of Palestine, and the same terrible actions against those people, that was visited upon the Jews just slightly over sixty years ago. But then when you are the "chosen ones", you've got "God on your side" and you can do what you damn well please-----if you have the money of course.
Which brings me to the point of this posting.
Taking into consideration all of the atrocities committed by human beings against other human beings, in the name of that "God",i.e. Yahweh, Jehovah, Allah, Jesus, etc--- in the past two thousand years alone---I am convinced that that "entity known as God" DOES NOT EXIST. But if I am wrong, I would never give my allegiance, prayers, propitiation---or "money" to such a cruel and thoughtless being that would allow so much innocent blood to be spilled in "his
name". Personally, I would worry about a "God" that needed so much help from all of these "lowly humans"----especially with m-o-n-e-y.
In the distant future, if human kind will allow itself to evolve into the beings that they are capable of; beings that have developed technology that allows them to leave their own planet, cure diseases, and so much more--they will look back in dismay at their ancestors who were simply barbarians with high technology who wasted their potential.
If that happens the USA will no doubt stand out as the primary negative example.
After their own history of genocide, in the name of "God" and "manifest destiny"
being the leaders in the development of so much of that technology, they were not only tragically foolish enough to forget their own crimes against humanity,
they "financed" the Jews in THEIR crimes against humanity.
Hey folks, your tax dollars at work for you and "God"-----
Good Luck America, you really need it.
N A T I V E _ S O N
Thank you for the wise words.
Many will react w/o understanding that there is ( underneath ) a tremendous appreciation and reverence for nature and ALL life, and that this is spirituality w/o religion ( as thought of by most Westerners ).
The biggest problem for Western Civilization ( such a good idea, per Gandhi ) is the 5000 year history of patriarchy married to 500 year tradition started with Descartes -- who undercut all connection and intrinsic sovereign appreciation of spirituality -- in preference to thinking and building up of technological and scientific edifices.
Please do not take this as a 100% indictment of all religions, through and through -- just the majority of each and for each institution's every interaction with actual people. When people were illiterate the iconic churches were a "replacement" for long abandoned verbal traditions of spirituality ( some survived the burnings ) -- too often force fed. Also too often w/o acknowledgement of the individual's natural divinity -- in fact going too far with "Original Sin' and mandated use of priests and churches to connect with one's higher power ( source of all that SI )
As we discussed on another thread, CHOICE is the key to morality, but that is tightly coupled to perception, which is founded upon metaphysical assumption of reality ( like imaginary religious allegories )
Namaste
How can the US claim to protect freedom and promote peace when they fund the destruction of a country by another and then pay to reconstruct.
To add insult to this injury, this money is all included in the pathetic foreign aid budget which still doesn't meet the promises the US government made.
Imagine how many lives in developing countries could be saved with $3 bn per year. But I guess this doesn't go into the pockets of rich Americans, so isn't the kind of foreign aid the US govt supports.
Gods don't kill people, people with gods kill people.
Bomb Thy Neighbor As Thyself
Blessed are the Merciless, for they Shall Inherit the Earth,
Blessed are the IDF, Chosen by God,
To Kill Thy Brother,
Rape They Sister,
To Do Unto Others,
As You Would Have Them
Do Unto You.