EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Rise Up or Die
- Rallying Cry: Citizens Worldwide to Unite in 'March Against Monsanto'
- A 'Nonviolent Army of Love' Rises in North Carolina to Face Down Rightwing's Assault on Progress
- The Latest Lie: IRS Targeted Conservatives
- Genetically Modified Democracy: Monsanto and Congress Move to Stomp on Your Rights
Popular content
Today's Top News
The Original Anti-War Mother's Day
In 1870 - 140 years ago - the disastrous human consequences of the American Civil War were becoming increasingly apparent, especially to the mothers of sons and the wives of husbands who had watched as these men proudly and patriotically marched off to "glorious" war a decade earlier.
Some of these women had probably (and regretfully) participated in the pre-war flag-waving fervor that war planners and profiteers cunningly elicit from the poor and working classes who will be doing the dirty work.
Everything changed, however, when the killing and maiming started and the permanent war wounded struggled back home with desperate needs for medical and mental health care.
Julia Ward Howe was a life-long abolitionist and therefore probably a reluctant supporter of the Union Army's anti-slavery rationale for going to war against the pro-slavery Confederate South.
A compassionate and well-educated middle child of an upper-class family, Howe was also a poet who, in the early days of the Civil War, wrote "The Battle Hymn of the Republic" using many biblically-based lyrics.
Though she later became a pacifist and a famous antiwar activist, her fervent anti-slavery attitudes inspired her to write that still famous song; and she did it in one sitting, in the pre-dawn darkness of Nov. 18, 1861.
Originally, Howe had thought of her song as an abolitionist anthem. However, because of some militant-sounding lyrics and the eminently marchable tune, the song soon was adopted by the Union Army as its most inspiring war song.
At the time, the Civil War also had not yet degenerated into the wholesale mutual mass slaughter made possible by the advances in weaponry that were destined to make obsolete the cavalry, the bayonet and the sword.
Grim Images
In part because of the relatively uncensored battlefield journalism of the time and the grim images of dead soldiers made possible by the invention of the camera, it didn't take too long for peace-loving, justice-oriented activists to recognize that war was the equivalent of hell on earth.
By the time the Civil War ended in 1865, 600,000 American soldiers were dead, with no accurate count of the likely much larger number of soldiers wounded, disabled or missing in action.
Women saw their sons and husbands returning home broken in body and spirit - definitely not as heroes, as had been the pre-war hope - and the minds of Howe and other women were changed about the lie that war is glorious.
The families of the returning Civil War veterans, both North and South, also discovered that many of the soldiers who had no visible scars were emotionally disabled, a problem that actually grew worse after they were home and out of "harm's way."
The healing effect of time didn't work like it was supposed to with these psychologically wounded veterans. The so-called "unwounded ones" often suffered melancholy, had nightmares, couldn't function in society and turned suicidal, homicidal and/or anti-social.
Many of the most infamous train and bank robbers and serial killers of the late 1800s got their start as Civil War soldiers, most famously the members of the James gang.
Because of normal society's inability to deal with massive numbers of war-traumatized veterans, the first "veterans homes" were constructed for the long-term care of the tens of thousands of invalided ex-soldiers who otherwise might have died homeless, hungry and helpless.
Many of these unfortunates were diagnosed as having "Soldiers' Heart," also known in the Civil War era as "Nostalgia," a commonly incurable malady better known today as "Combat-Induced PTSD" (posttraumatic stress disorder).
The horrors of the Civil War even changed those the conflict made famous. Speaking to a graduating class of military cadets years later, Union General William Tecumseh Sherman uttered his famous truth about the nature of warfare as part of a rebuke to the era's "chicken-hawks," people who call for war without having experienced it.
"I confess without shame that I am tired and sick of war," Sherman said. "Its glory is all moonshine. It is only those who have neither heard the shrieks and groans of the wounded, who cry aloud for more blood, more vengeance, more desolation. War is Hell."
By 1870, Julia Ward Howe had been deeply affected both by the ongoing agonies of Civil War veterans and the carnage occurring overseas in the Franco-Prussian War. Though very short, that war resulted in almost 100,000 killed in action plus another 100,000 lethally wounded or sickened.
The First Mother's Day
So, as a humanist who cared about suffering people - as well as a feminist and a suffragette who advocated social justice - Howe penned her "Mother's Day Proclamation" in 1870 as an appeal to mothers to spare their sons and the sons of others from the depredations of war.
The Mother's Day Proclamation was partly a lament for the useless deaths and partly a call to action to stop future wars. The call was directed, not to men, many of whom may have felt proud for their "service," but to women, who often have proved more thoughtful and humane about issues of human suffering.
Then, on June 2, 1872, in New York City, Julia Ward Howe held the first "Mother's Day" as an anti-war observance, a practice Howe continued in Boston for the next decade before it died out.
The modern Mother's Day, with its apolitical message, emerged in the early Twentieth Century, with Howe's original intent largely erased from the mainstream consciousness. Howe's vision of an antiwar mother's call to action was watered-down into an annual expression of sentimentality.
Like most other holidays (including religious ones), Mother's Day in capitalist America has been transformed into just another expectation of gift-buying and gift-giving.
What was originally a call to mobilize outraged mothers to keep their sons and husbands from going off half-cocked to kill and die for some corporate war profiteer or other, became just another opportunity to market non-essential consumer goods.
Note in Howe's proclamation below how strongly she felt that wives and mothers should never have to be put in the position of comforting or applauding their soldier-husbands or soldier-sons when they come home from war "reeking of carnage."
In her view, the prevention of such "reeking" was so much simpler than the attempt to reverse the consequences of the "carnage" of war.
Howe also felt that mothers should never allow war-making institutions to make killers out of their sons whom they had raised to be ethical, humane people with love for humankind.
One must wonder, too, what Howe meant when she referred to "irrelevant agencies." One can only assume that the same American military, governmental, corporate and bureaucratic agencies that have been messing things up in Iraq, Afghanistan, New Orleans, the Gulf of Mexico and all over the world were also operating in the last half of the 1800s.
Wall Street and the military/industrial/congressional/media complex - the entities that dominate U.S. policymaking today - were probably in operation then, too, though surely with less exorbitant salaries, bonuses, contracts and cost overruns.
Given the ongoing horrors of war, perhaps it's finally time for people of good will to recall Julia Ward Howe's peacemaking vision on this Mother's Day, 2010.
Julia Ward Howe's Mother's Day Proclamation of 1870:
"Arise then, women of this day! Arise, all women who have hearts, whether your baptism be that of water or tears!
"Say firmly: 'We will not have great questions decided by irrelevant agencies.
Our husbands shall not come to us, reeking with carnage, for caresses and applause.
Our sons shall not be taken from us to unlearn all that we have taught them of charity, mercy and patience.
We women of one country will be too tender of those of another to allow our sons to be trained to injure theirs.'
"From the bosom of the devastated earth, a voice goes up with our own. It says, 'Disarm, disarm!'
The sword of murder is not the balance of justice. Blood does not wipe out dishonor, nor does violence indicate possession.
As men have often forsaken the plow and the anvil at the summons of war, let women now leave all that may be left of home for a great and earnest day of counsel.
Let them meet first, as women, to bewail and commemorate the dead. Let them solemnly take counsel with each other as to the means whereby the great human family can live in peace, each bearing after his own time the sacred impress, not of Caesar but of God.
"In the name of womanhood and of humanity, I earnestly ask that a general congress of women without limit of nationality may be appointed and held at some place deemed most convenient and at the earliest period consistent with its objects, to promote the alliance of the different nationalities, the amicable settlement of international questions, the great and general interests of peace."
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

9 Comments so far
Show AllMOTHERS DAY
2006
Move up your feet, wiggle your hands about, utter words of endearment to the one who birthed you into life!
How many ways are there to say that love and honor and respect, that is earned, at every turn of this life where ever we may be.
This is not just for the mothers that enter or affect my particular life; This goes to mothers across the world, for what a lonely and empty place it would be without them.
How many mothers go out gather food for a family and clean and I mean clean whatever needs cleaning from tots, to teens to grand-tots and grand-teens for any foreseeable future in calm or strife.
That is just manual labor.big,but not all of what a mother is. Let me see; chief cook and bottle washer: Doctor of heart, mind and body and best friend of those who would see.
Mothers can see into every corner of the human existence and yet some, through choice,cercumstance or any reason choose to start and not finish.Tis difficuly,judge not for remember that woman was taken from Adam’s rib and not his head or feet to show her equality to the him. Remember that God counts every tear of a woman’s life and isn’t a mother a woman? Treasure your gem.
Make your day a treasure and all future ones too
With Love to all, Sandy and Tony
Thank you for posting this. I fall far short of being a radical pacifist, and as a feminist, I bristle at defining women as wives and mothers. On the other hand, that the cause of my youth, women's liberation, has led to "lady cops and mothers in combat" does not give me cause for celebration. I am deeply suspicious of all sorts of "humanitarian interventions" that make use of armed force. At the very least, we must all advocate for the abolition of nuclear weapons and unmanned drones.
Code Pink Women for Peace Shut Down Military Weapons Exhibit on the National Mall
(photos here: http://dc.indymedia.org/newswire/display/149213/index.php)
BY ETHAN GENAUER
May 8, 2010
Washington, DC
In advance of an announced Mother's Day protest by Code Pink women for peace, the U.S. Army shut down their annual weapons exhibit, closing it to public access while the women marched around the weapons and sang for peace, all in view of Congress.
This Mother’s Day weekend, the U.S. Armed Forces is hosting its annual weapons exhibit on the Washington Mall, encouraging parents to bring their children to play with the weapons.
CODEPINK women, bringing the energy from their peace festival with comedian Roseanne Barr at John Marshall Place Park, marched at 3:45 pm on Saturday, May 8 to the military fair, calling for a celebration of life and peace, not weapons and warfare.
A group of over 40 women peace activists, and several dozen more children and male allies, arrived at the military weapons exhibit to find it already shut down and fenced off from public access, in anticipation of their protest.
This was greeted as a small victory, and the women proceeded to protest for almost one hour -- in the face of heavy police surveillance and intimidation -- around the perimeter of the displays of tanks and other military vehicles framing Congress.
The women handed out “Arms are for hugging” stickers around the Military Arms Exhibit. They carried their 150-foot banner created out of 6,000 knitted squares, knitted by women around the world, that takes an excerpt from the original 1870 Mothers Day Proclamation, "We will not raise our children to kill another mother's child."
The women also sang peace songs, in the process resisting numerous police warnings that they were not allowed to sing without a permit, in order to counter the official celebration of war and violence with a message of hope and joy.
“It saddens us that every year the military holds a war machine exhibit on Mother's Day. This is a slap in the face to all peace-loving mothers around the world who work to shield their children from the tragic effects of war,” says CODEPINK Cofounder Medea Benjamin.
“It violates the original intent of Mother's Day, which was a call for peace, a call to disarm and build a world without violence.”
"they were not allowed to sing without a permit"
hopefully their protest permit was in ordnung.
Disenchantment with the Civil War began soon after the war did. There were in fact two wars going on, as it were, at right angles to each other: the political war (North versus South) and the class war (rich versus poor). The fact that the North was technically the offended party (after the attack on Fort Sumter) kept war enthusiasm going a few months longer in the North than in the South, but during the second year of the war people on both sides were saying "Rich man's war, poor man's fight". Refusal to serve, and desertion, became chronic on both sides. The South lost partly because it collapsed under the class war sooner.
"Wall Street and the military/industrial/congressional/media complex - the entities that dominate U.S. policymaking today - were probably in operation then, too, though surely with less exorbitant salaries, bonuses, contracts and cost overruns." Probably, but they were already bad enough then. Lincoln said that he was fighting a two-front war -- with the rebels before him and the bankers behind him -- and of these the bankers were the more dangerous. War profiteering was ubiquitous and shameless. The word "shoddy" was originally the name of a kind of cloth, from which a company made army uniforms that fell apart after a few days in the field.
This is documented in "A People's History of the Civil War", by David Williams, a book which I found most interesting and informative.
"The call was directed, not to men, many of whom may have felt proud for their "service", but to women, who often have proved more thoughtful and humane about issues of human suffering."
Obviously, Julia Ward Howe and Mr. Kohls have never met, Hilary Clinton, Sarah Palin, Jane Harman, Michele Bachman, Diane Feinstein, Virginia Fox or Ann Coultier.
Amazing what money and politics will do to a person!
Maggie Thatcher, Golda Meir, Indira Ghandi, The Queen of Hearts . . .
gnken
Thank you Dr. Kohl for a fine article. I would love to send it to every media outlet the world over. Im sad to see that so few comments are posted at the end of this fine article.
I watched people in the late 60's graduate high school to Vietnam. I graduated in 1974 and went into the Service. I saw many returning veterans and the issues that were experiencing with PTSD. I never was in combat but I know enough that it is not fun or glorious. Today as a ham radio operator when Im communicating with others around the country and tell them where i got my communications background I get this reply of "Thank you for your service" I remain with just a mild "Thank you" but I feel this is some kind of current remark very much like "Support the Troops", seeing faded Yellow Ribbons on cars. I find this to be what Naomi Wolf calls "False Patriotism". Most media services would never put this article in there papers and it should be. Thank you.