Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Gaza War Report Was Stalled by Palestinian Authority on US Request
Papers reveal PA held up Goldstone report from UN security council and suggest Abbas was warned of 2008 invasion
Palestinian Authority leaders co-operated with US officials in a bid to postpone the reference of the Goldstone report into war crimes in Gaza to the UN security council, leaked papers reveal. The PA, who have denied they made the decision under US pressure, later reversed their decision.
The postponement of the report into Israel's 2008 assault on Gaza triggered heavy criticism of the PA leadership, at one time threatening Abbas's position. But at a meeting on 21 October 2009, three weeks after the Goldstone scandal erupted, US national security adviser Jim Jones told the Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat: "Thank you for what you did a couple of weeks ago [on Goldstone]; it was very courageous".
On the day the reference of the report was delayed, US officials presented Palestinian negotiators with a "non paper" [a proposal that is off the record in diplomatic terms] committing the PA to "help promote a positive atmosphere conducive to negotiations ... [and] refrain from pursuing or supporting any initiative directly or indirectly in international legal forums that would undermine that atmosphere".
Erekat's response was to tell Mitchell: "On going to the UN we will always co-ordinate with you."
The papers also reveal new evidence of contact between Mahmoud Abbas, also known as Abu Mazen, the Palestinian president, and Amos Gilad, a senior Israeli defence ministry official and senior negotiator, before the the launch of Israel's assault in late 2008. It remains unclear whether he had advance warning of the impending assault, which he has always denied.
Contacted by Gilad before the war, "Abu Mazen replied that he will not go to Gaza on an Israeli tank," the Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat told the US envoy George Mitchell in October 2009.
Any evidence that PA leaders co-operated with Israel in the attack on the Hamas-controlled territory, which left 1,400 Palestinians dead, would be highly controversial and fuel anger at the western-backed Ramallah-based leadership, especially by its bitter rival, Hamas.
Earlier this week, Gilad publicly and flatly denied the collusion claim. "No concrete warning concerning an offensive was given to the Palestinian Authority," he told Israel Radio.
"I didn't say anything to President Abbas that I hadn't said to the entire world: that we could not tolerate the resumption of rocket fire and other terrorist attacks against our territory."
Abbas issued a forceful denial late last year when US diplomatic cables released by Wikileaks were quoted as reporting that in June 2009 Israel's defence minister, Ehud Barak, told a US congressional delegation that Israel "had consulted with Egypt and Fatah prior to Operation Cast Lead, asking if they were willing to assume control of Gaza once Israel defeated Hamas." Barak continued: "Not surprisingly...Israel received negative answers from both."
Erekat said at the time:"Nobody consulted with us, and that is the truth. Israel doesn't consult before going to war."
The Palestine Papers also record how Gilad and Tzipi Livni, then Israeli foreign minister, had spoken to Palestinian negotiators of the likelihood of a fullscale confrontation over Gaza. "We are on a collision course with Hamas," Gilad warned them. "You need to be prepared.. Sooner or later they [Hamas] will be taken care of."

20 Comments so far
Show AllAre PA figureheads on the US payroll?
Actually the whole PA is openly on the US payroll. The PA couldn't function without US support. The US govt is not at all the sole source, but US financial support to the PA is critical. It's removal would result in a crisis if not a complete collapse of the PA.
Hamas is an indirect recipient of US aid and may actually have had help early on from the IDF as a way to split the Palestinians away from the PLO, Fatah and the PA. Worked brilliantly too.
The game here is deep and very ugly. Palestinians are the designated losers; their job is to supply the bodies and the footage of anguished mothers wailing over their children's bodies and bull-dozed homes. While the corrupt, violent hacks in Gaza,and East and West Jerusalem preen and pose, the real game is to perpetuate the slaughter indefinitely. It serves the purposes of the "leadership" on all sides and in the US.
As always, the US does a tad more than "support" corruption and human right abuses not only in Palestine but everywhere else in the world:
CIA working with Palestinian security agents
US agency co-operating with Palestinian counterparts who allegedly torture Hamas supporters in West Bank
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/dec/17/cia-palestinian-security-agents
Remember, too, that the PA was defeated in a fair election recognized by the U.N. as legitimate. The U.S. refused to recognize the winners and openly supported the losers (the P.A.) in both armed resistance and then by governmental and financial support. If the U.S. has stayed out of it, it is likely that the Palestinians would have a nation by now. But, then, Israel wouldn't have an excuse to kill people and keep the nation on a war footing or a reason for the U.S. to keep giving them enough money to actually pave their inhabited areas two dollars deep. Remember, they have universal health care and we pay for it!
Whistleblowers must be feeling empowered by the exposure of so much double-dealing, and we can all hope this stream of disclosures will eventually grab the attention of the mass media and maybe energize the masses themselves. Keep them coming.
I read yesterday that a CIA agent was involved in the leak of the papers but I can't put my hands on the article right now as I can't remember where I read it (maybe Ha'aretz or The Guardian).
I will never forget the expression on the face of Barack Obama,when he got publicly ridiculed by Netanyahu on his visit to the US of A last year.What a sad scene to watch.It clearly showed,who runs the White House and the American foreign policy.Israel lets the Americans do the barking,but the biting they do themselves.I see the world as a humongous chess board with two opponents.On the one side is socialism and on the other capitalism.It`s a struggle of civilization against barbarism,or love against fear if you will.Capitalism took a lot of pieces with brute force from the opponent,but the opponent had the best strategy and is now in the end-game in the strongest position..Intelligence always wins from ignorance.
yup, the battle line is between the global capitalist class and the people of the world.
Obama deserved to get ridiculed by Netanyahu. Had he not capitulated to Netanyahu and begun parroting AIPAC's lines the minute he took office, he might not be in this situation. I have no sympathy for Obama...he brought his presumed overall predicament on himself.
No, intelligence doesn't always win. Brute force usually wins outright.
The US is the genocidal monster here.
Koreans, vietnamese, indonesians, laotians, indians, chinese, phillipiinos, hawaiians, latin amerncans, central americans, native north americans, and africans will confirm your statement.
Hamas are the democratically elected leadership of the Palistinians. Fatah are US Stooges
Maybe it should be " U.S. out of Israel AND Palestine now!"
Why is it a "crisis" if the PA "collapses"??? Perhaps
groups that truly represent the views of Pallestinians
would be recognized as sovereign,independent entities.
Independent of the US and of Israel. Of course, the US/
Israeli's would have to give up on the "demand" that
the government of Palestine recognize Israel AS A
JEWISH STATE!!! I will be waiting for Israel to recognize
this sovereign Palestinian State as a good faith partner,
welcome them to the UN, submit to recommendations of
"the Goldstone Report", dismantle "Fortress Israel"
under the random supervision and monitoring of the
[UN] IAEA in the MidEast Nuclear Free Zone. And if the
media would report the details of "The Stuttgart Declaration"
it might help in movement. See: "The Stuttgart Declaration-
An Analysis" by Lawrence Davidson (http://www.tothepointanalysis.com).
So, the Palestine Papers had to make that startling revelation since the fact that Abbas actually condemned the Goldstone Report didn't give it away, right? Sheesh! None is so blind as those who don't want to see.
The Palestinians should take Abbas and the rest of his cronies and hand deliver them to Hamas. A bigger traitor dog has never existed in Palestine. The bastard is utterly despicable and revolting.