Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Open Season on Gaza Activists in Egypt
In late November of last year, I was haphazardly invited to watch a documentary film screening in the posh Cairo suburb of Ma'adi. Exhausted from the workday, I begrudgingly agreed to take the hour-long trip to some obscure coffee shop to join a friend in what I figured would be an exercise in futility. After all, the film was titled "This Palestinian Life," and therefore concerned a topic so horribly sensationalized that I tend to avoid documentaries on the subject altogether. Surprisingly enough, though, this short twenty-minute film presented a quite lucid yet unexaggerated account of non-violent resistance by everyday Palestinians. Indeed, this short film did the unthinkable by humanizing those embroiled in this contentious and hotly debated conflict.
I had to excuse myself immediately after the film had ended - and before the question-and-answer session - but later learned that this brave filmmaker, a German-Egyptian dual citizen named Philip Rizk, had spent two years living and working in Gaza. Yet his social conscience wasn't limited to this cause alone: in his next film he hoped to focus on Egypt, using personal interviews to humanize the struggles of working-class Egyptians and their frustrations when faced with a dire lack of upward mobility. Clearly, Philip fit the profile of the avant garde artist.
On February 6th, I was shocked to learn that the brilliant filmmaker I had met in Ma'adi three months ago was arbitrarily arrested by Egyptian state security, corralled into an unlicensed Suzuki microbus, and herded off to an undisclosed location, in what amounts to a bona fide state-administered kidnapping. His crime? Organizing and participating in a non-violent demonstration in support of the people of Gaza. He, along with fourteen other activists, had marched from Cairo to the neighboring governorate of Qalyubiyya draped in Palestinian flags. Photographs from the protest show Philip holding a sign reading, "Al-Kayl qad tafah, iftahu ma'bar Rafah!" which loosely translates as, "Enough is Enough! Open the Rafah border crossing!" Egypt's refusal to open this crossing contributes to the dire shortage of medical supplies and other humanitarian necessities in Gaza, which in the eyes of Philip and other activists makes Egypt complicit in the deaths of hundreds of Palestinians. Yet the Egyptian government keeps the border closed, both to keep US military aid flowing and to avoid "insurrectionary spillover" - in other words, armed Palestinians organizing in Egypt.
Thankfully the international community quickly responded, and under the pressure of daily protests at the American University in Cairo and elsewhere, the Egyptian regime acquiesced and released him early Wednesday morning. Still, the fact remains that Philip was arbitrarily abducted, with no right to due process whatever, simply for demonstrating non-violent support for Gaza.
For any seasoned commentator on Egyptian politics, this incident wouldn't seem particularly unique at first glance. After all, the infamous Emergency Law, a draconian measure in place for over a quarter-century now, prohibits assembly of more than four persons at any given venue. But there's more to Philip's case than meets the eye.
Expatriates in Egypt, myself included, have conditioned themselves to believe that their foreign citizenship immunizes them from harassment by the otherwise insidious Egyptian security apparatus. The putative laxity of the Egyptian authorities towards foreigners can quickly translate into foreign journalists and activists exercising more latitude than the average Egyptian when engaging in political activity. Philip's abduction is unique because, as a dual citizen, he is technically accountable to Egyptian law, yet ostensibly can expect to be shielded from the worst excesses of Egyptian police brutality by his German citizenship. Clearly this wasn't the outcome.
Egyptian security's grandiose kidnapping of an utterly benign protestor in the obscure governornate of Qalyubia seems to indicate that the Egyptian regime is in no mood to tolerate criticism of its policy towards Gaza and the Rafah border - whether by Egyptians or foreigners. Indeed, on Monday Egyptian authorities arrested a second blogger sympathetic to Palestinians, one Diaeddin Gad, whose whereabouts are as of this writing stillunknown. It seems that the Egyptian government is set on making an example of Philip, and any other activist who dares to challenge its position on Gaza.
On February 4th, two days before his abduction, Philip made the following post on his blog, tabulagaza.blogspot.com, titled "Rafah to Close":
Word on the street is that Egypt is closing Rafah crossing to all journalists and doctors entering or exiting Gaza on Friday
Does this mean more bloodbaths to come?
That remains to be seen, but based on Philip's case, anyone with an axe to grind with the Egyptian government's position on Gaza stands to suffer a similar fate. On Wednesday, the same day Philip was released, Egyptian police arrested 30 truck drivers carrying food and supplies toward Rafah, and the next day Egyptian authorities arrested two Muslim Brotherhood members attempting to transfer 2,200 tons of food and medical aid into Gaza. Clearly these arrests aren't arbitrary. Barring a stern condemnation from the Obama administration at the horrible internal abuses committed by its so-called ally in the Middle East - who annually receives a $1.7 billion aid package from the US - there is no telling how many more peaceful pro-Palestinian dissidents Egyptian state security will round up in the coming weeks and months.



16 Comments so far
Show AllThe BBC should change its name to the Holocaust Memorial Corporation.
Does a day or week go by without another story that isnt really big news, like Frank's guardian turns 100, or nazi doctor Heim died in 1992.
I suspect we will be seeing ones like Oscar Schindler's third cousin twice removed likes Israel
or Joseph Goebbel's neighbor alleged to have said hello to him one morning-Simon Weisenthal center seeks extradition
Or just call it Israel's British channel.
There are 51 OIC members, with state-controlled TV, whose coverage is surely more to your taste.
The hostile government-to-government relations between Egypt and Gaza reflect their at-odds politics.
Joe Hopeless,
Is Izak your jewish name? Quite strange that you pop up when Joe Hopeless disappeared.
I can't hear you. I've been watching Jew-killing bunnies on Al Manar, then I switched to "Horseman Without a Horse" on TV Damascus, and after that I read, "How The Jews Use The Blood Of Gentile Children In Matzoh" in the Saudi newspapers. You were saying something about "respect" and "people of the book," I believe.
Did you get tired from being called Hopeless Joe?
You're probably thinking of "Shoeless Joe Hardy."
Sioux Rose
So long as the super-powers sell weapons and bribe "lesser" nations through trade deals and aid, WAR will go without much question, and its casualties be seen as the "cost" of "doing business."
My only hope is that out of the current fiscal calamity that's rolling like a slow motion tidal wave around the world, a lack of funding FOR war, developing new weapons, or finding cause to trade them occurs. One would hope that when enough citizens go hungry and homeless a shift in these ghastly priorities will arise.
This is totally disgusting. Obama could quickly change situations such as this with a wave of the hand. The question is: Will he?
clovis, hi.
Egypt is a match away from immolation. A combustion of outrage by the people that would burn Mubarak and his police/torturer/kidnappers to ashes is close.
This will result in the now silent mass of Egyptians to become empowered. To support their brothers in Palestine.
To help consolidate the Islamic resistance to Israel and Western oppression.
Pakistani ISI elements, Hezbollah, Hamas, the Taliban, al-Queda. All would see this as a victory and feel new strength with a new ally of huge influence.
Do you want this?
azjoe.
Pan
Egypt helps Israel as long as the Americans keep shoveling Billions and Billions to them both.... a new American economic miracle kept going and FUELED by the SUFFERING of an abandoned people.
What is the Egypptian government can do if the only super power in the world
is supporting Israel 100%. The economic situation for most of the Egyptians
is depressing and Egypt is in dire need for every penny in trade or tourism
or economic aid. Yes, the situation of the Palestinian people in Gaza is tragic
and the Israeli criminality is glaring but Egypt cannot afford a confrontation
with the United States.
So, please give the Egyptian governmnent a break and try to understand its
position.
This report makes clear that Egypt loves Israel and America, and it hates Arabs.
Can this be seen as anything but wonderful news?
After all, in the case of the first two, what's not to love? And in the case of the latter, what's not to hate?
All Egypt has yet to do is renounce its Arabism, then its obsequious surrender will be complete. I'm waiting with baited breath.
"commoner3 February 15th, 2009 6:15 pm
What is the Egypptian government can do if the only super power in the world is supporting Israel 100%."
The Egyptian govt could refuse to make itself complicit in the supreme international crimes of those two other govts.
commoner3:
"The economic situation for most of the Egyptians is depressing and Egypt is in dire need for every penny in trade or tourism
or economic aid."
That is NO excuse at all. Egypt, the govt, is [complicit] in the extreme crimes of the U.S. and Israel against Palestinians!
commoner3:
"Yes, the situation of the Palestinian people in Gaza is tragic
and the Israeli criminality is glaring but Egypt cannot afford a confrontation with the United States."
Too bad. The Egyptian govt doesn't have a choice other than choosing to be either complicit, hence criminal, in the supreme international crimes of the U.S. and Israel against Palestinians, or to not be complicit. These are the only two options to choose from; there are no others, and hiding heads in sand isn't an option, either.
commoner3:
"So, please give the Egyptian governmnent a break and try to understand its position."
Infantile minds like the one commoner3 just demonstrated should give the world a break from such infanility coming from someone who I suppose is of adult age!
That's being polite to someone who just demonstrated that he or she is also complicit along with Egypt in the crimes ... as per above.
Mike,
You are probably sitting comforatably now in your house whether in Britain or USA thousands of miles away from Egypt pontificating and lecturing and feeling
"morally superior". Did you visit Egypt recently? Who do you think you are to judge a situation you are really ignorant "about the real dimensions of it".??!!
The real test is that you take your ass to to Gaza and do something. Talking and writing is cheap.
The politics of the Middle East as all international politics is very murky and
things are not what they seem to be. If the only super power in the world wants
something to happen then that something will happen unless someone has special
advantage then he can oppose. Good decisions are based on realities and feasibilities and not on emotions or idealism.
You do not try saving someone from drowning if yourself your nose is barely above the water surface.
And finally please do not call someone infantile because everyone has a big collection of very profane and obscene words that he might throw at you. Please
learn to express your opinion without calling names. OK!!
The following is a short video, 2:07.
"UK police seize Gaza aid vans", by AlJazeera.net, Feb 14 2009
http://www.uruknet.info/?p=m51800
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zFBFggzMbrY
People who are truly concerned for Palestinians in Gaza or the occupied territories should or will enjoy this video. It's one to certainly not miss.
The article's short, so I'll quote it all.
QUOTE:
British police have seized three vans that were to form part of a 100 vehicle aid convoy headed for Gaza.
Lancashire police said on Saturday that the seizure was made as part of an anti-terror raid in the northwest of England.
The convoy had been organised by the pro-Palestinian organisation Viva Palestina and left central London on Saturday, the group's website said.
It said the vehicles, which include a fire engine and ambulances, were carrying clothes, blankets and children's toys.
It said volunteers planned to drive 8,000km through France, Spain, Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya and Egypt where they had hoped to cross the border at Rafah into Gaza on March 2.
Lancashire police said the cargo from the three seized vehicles was being "thoroughly checked by search officers who are working as quickly as they can to ensure that the parcels can be released and continue on to their destination".
Lancashire police said they were searching five houses in the town of Burnley on Saturday after arresting nine men under anti-terrorism laws on a motorway near Preston on Friday.
Six of the men have been released and the remaining three are still in custody. Police can hold them without charge until Sunday night.
END QUOTE.
Never mind, my mistake.