Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
John 'Nuke Bailout' Bryson Must NOT Be Secretary of Energy
Among the names on the apparent short list for Barack Obama's all-important choice as Secretary of Energy is that of John Bryson, former head of Southern California Edison.
As the embodiment of greenwashed corporate piracy and radioactive public bailouts, Bryson's appointment would send a terrible message.
Bryson is now being hyped as "an advocate of hybrid cars." No doubt he is reinventing his image. On a personal basis, he may be the finest of individuals.
But John Bryson will forever epitomize the bailout of the nuke power industry and the horrific catastrophe of electric utility deregulation, including the contrived energy crisis that cost Californians tens of billions of dollars and allowed them to be robbed by the disgraced Enron.
Early in his career, Bryson helped found the Natural Resources Defense Council. Under Jerry Brown he headed the California Public Utilities Commission, where he played a role in the installation of some 17,000 windmills. He also sold his soul -- and much of California's -- to the nuke power industry.
When Bryson left the CPUC to head the huge Southern California Edison utility company, many heralded the switch as an eco-triumph. But in the early 1990s, California's green community proposed a pioneer renewable construction project that would have provided the state with some 600 megawatts of Solartopian power free from fossil and nuclear fuels.
Bryson attacked, falsely charging that the power was unnecessary and expensive. In defense of the state's four reactors, all sited near earthquake faults, he used Edison's huge legal and political resources to kill the proposed renewable energy bank.
With all those windmills and solar panels safely buried, Bryson drafted AB1890, the catastrophic deregulation law that opened the door for Enron.
AB1890 allowed SoCalEd and Pacific Gas & Electric to recoup billions in nuke construction cost overruns. Rushed through the legislature under intense pressure from Bryson's lobbyists, the bill overrode years of citizen opposition and forced ratepayers to eat the utilities' radioactive mistakes.
AB1890's chief public advocate became a Bryson disciple named Ralph Cavanagh, who unfailing flouted his "green" credentials during radio debates (a few of them with me).
Cavanagh and SoCalEd paved the way for corporate piracy on a gargantuan scale. They argued that the state's expensive, uncompetitive reactors could not stand in the market place. Their billions in "stranded costs" must therefore be absorbed by the ratepayers to pave the way for "true competition" that would somehow "lower rates."
Bryson then sat back and watched as Enron selectively withheld power and gamed the de-regulated grid, driving thousands of businesses into bankruptcy and soaking the state's ratepayers for tens of billions of dollars.
AB1890 passed with Republican Pete Wilson in the governor's mansion. But the crisis broke on Democrat Gray Davis. A close Bryson associate, Davis failed to stand up to SoCalEd and Enron's price gouging. Public outrage opened the door to the recall that led to Arnold Schwarzenegger becoming governor.
Bryson's seminal pro-nuclear, anti-ratepayer role at SoCalEd stands as a monument to the power of greenwashing. From California the craze to deregulate electric utilities spread to two dozen states. In many of them, the idea of a marketplace in electricity was merely a cover used to scam billions in cost overruns at uncompetitive nuke plants. (In Ohio alone, the take exceeded $9 billion) These "stranded costs" then disappeared from utility balance sheets, giving the illusion that their bloated, dangerous and inefficient reactors were somehow paying for themselves.
Some of the same utilities that argued then for these stranded cost handouts on the grounds that their nuke plants could not compete are now demanding loan guarantees to build still more reactors on the grounds that they are somehow "cheap."
However much he may wish to greenwash his image, John Bryson has never come clean about what he did to delay renewables and bankrupt ratepayers.
Long gone from Southern California Edison, Bryson's ascent to head the DOE would send a disastrous signal to those who are genuinely committed to a post fossil/nuclear future. It would say that somehow an extremely powerful executive who took very destructive steps to delay the green revolution and support nuke power is now the one to lead us to Solartopia.
There are other candidates to head the DOE who have long histories of genuine support for the renewables revolution on which the future of this country so thoroughly depends.
In an age where green-powered self-sufficiency is an absolute necessity, John Bryson is unfit to be Secretary of Energy.
- Posted in



14 Comments so far
Show AllSo was Bryson a dupe, a co-conspirator, or did the wise guys at Enron simply find a loophole he unintentionally helped create to turn California utilities into cash cows? Is it really fair to say he delayed renewable projects, or is it a stretch? Is he better man for having been snookered along with the NRDC? Lets hope Obama gets to the bottom of this before any nomination.
Don't be shocked if there is a nuclear element (no pun intended) to the Obama administration's energy plans. Both new plants and research on new generation reactors.
Sioux Rose
HARVEY: Thank you for educating CD readers on the background check of such persons. I know of NO media that would otherwise expose the resumes of these individuals. Advocates of crash (military) and burn (nuclear) definitely are having their hey day and at what a cost to the rest of humanity!
But Wind, Solar and Hydro power do not produce depleted uranium to poison the world's Muslem population.
Writing as a quite reluctant long time customer of So. Cal. Edison, there is no way in Hell I would ever consider the douche bag who "led" it being financially raped by the cowboys from Enron. That Bryson also kept San Onofre and other nuclear dinosaurs online is even worse.
www.wunderman-comics.com
My diito to SIOUXROSE's comment.
We are indebted to HARVEY, and others like him to expose the real lives of theses supposed "pillars" of society.
What a hoot that conspiratorial ( rethuglican de-reg illusionary privatization ) payoffs ( which actually increased the cost of energy ) of billions in "stranded costs" now make the nuking America look so much more "promising". Yeech
Namaste
I think (and hope) Obama is smart enough not to fall for the greatest, most expensive and most dangerous of energy boondogles, nukes.
For some reason, everytime I hear the name "Enron", I can't help but wonder if Ken Lay has really passed-on to the next world. A closed casket makes me wonder about those kinds-of-things.
Has anyone kept track of his wife's travels since his unfortunate departure?
This sentence caught my eye -- it could indicate a very large group of anti-Bryson people who'd be willing to give this potential appt. loads of bad publicity: "Bryson then sat back and watched as Enron selectively withheld power and gamed the de-regulated grid, driving thousands of businesses into bankruptcy and soaking the state's ratepayers for tens of billions of dollars..." Imagine if your business was one of the bankruptcy victims!
I thought I was up to speed regarding nukes, but I'd never heard of Bryson. Good thing we have Harvey to keep us informed.
I also think we should all take a minute to send a short e-mail to that site Obama has for comments, pointing out that Secretary of Energy is going to be one of the most CRUCIAL jobs in the cabinet.
Bryson also has a history of ripping off Third World nations, specifically Indonesia. A person with that history in the US Cabinet can only worsen our relations with the Muslim world.
Obama shouldn't consider ANYONE with a corporate utility background, let alone a former CEO. Southern California Edison rates are among the highest in the nation thanks to poor management and the bad legislation it fostered. If this guy was a champion of nuke power, we all need to be concerned. I hope this is just a trial balloon that Obama's sending up.
http://freesolaradvice.blogspot.com
I agree that nuclear energy shouldn't be our main focus in our pursuit to get off oil. But it should be part of energy portfolio that includes solar power, bio-fuels, natural gas, clean coal, wind power, and hydro-power. We shouldn't put all our eggs in one basket. The problem of climate change is so vast that will require a variety of solutions.
Anyone who voted for Obama who has an inkling of the serious dangers of nuclear power and weapons better get on it about John Bryson. Sad that so many remain seriously ignorant about the uranium mining impact on just the Navajo peoples. Over 1000 uranium mines existed to fuel the cold war status. Only 500 hundred have been covered. Now the Dine (Navajo) are being pushed to allow uranium mining again, not to mention the continuous problems with Peabody Coal mining operations. See this link for one story about cancer and the uranium tailings on the rez:
http://www.global-sisterhood-network.org/content/view/1448/76/
It is a similar situation on the Spokane reservation where i went with friends to witness the abandoned uranium tailings piles and also spoke with Spokane Indian people who had relatives living around the area die of cancer along with their neighbors. Thank you Newmont Mining Corp.
The neglect in even cleaning up the messes left on reservations from Northern Saskatchewan to North Dakota, Spokane, Arizona and New Mexico is so typical of the US policy of slow motion genocide and the NIMBY syndrome of privileged Americans. How many pro nukers want a mine in their community?
I notice Obama has not included any traditional Native Americans in his circle. The only Indigenous voices allowed must do the white man's dance to even have a chance, just like he has. It is a pathetic excuse for equality.
frontlinemom@yahoo.com
Ralph Nader for Secretary of Energy!!!!!!!!!!!!