Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Gaza, Then and Now
Year before last, I was sitting in the living room of my childhood home sharing a cup of morning coffee with my mother and musing over the holidays. We laughed over kitschy Christmas gifts from well-meaning relatives before deciding to turn on the news for five minutes on the brink of another vacation day. Those five minutes would turn out to be one of those times like 9/11-when you never forget exactly where you were when you found out. "Oh no," gasped my mother, tears welling up immediately in her eyes. "Gaza Explodes..." scrolled across the bottom of the screen, and plumes of smoke hung on the living room wall in high definition.
Violence in the Middle East was hardly a surprise. I was living near the West Bank city of Ramallah in 2006, where I began to understand the intricacies of life under occupation-checkpoints, settlement expansion, and raids. That summer, Hamas and Hezbollah abducted three Israeli soldiers, and the Israeli military unleashed a series of attacks that devastated parts of Gaza and Lebanon. I remember sitting on my roof with neighbors sipping local Palestinian beer from a nearby Christian village, and watching macabre lights fill the sky night after night. A former European soldier taught me how to identify the various weapons: a cluster bomb branches out horizontally before hitting its target, while thermobarics fall hard and fast, demolishing entire structures. The warplanes were low, lit up by the moon as they traveled north to Lebanon and south to Gaza. My neighbor finished the last sip of his beer one night and whispered, "It's like fucking Space Invaders up here."
But operation Cast Lead put previous attacks to shame. For more than three weeks, the Israeli military assault was the most violent action against the occupied territories since the 1967 war. And for the past two years, I have been breathing in Gaza from the outside, sustained by a few precious journeys into the coastal territory known by many as the world's largest open-air prison.
During the war, I spent hours on the phone with people inside Gaza-from the comfort of my eclectic office and heated apartment. Colleagues and friends filled me in from their cell phones while they stood on dangerous street corners watching bombs flatten buildings. We would almost always lose our connection and when I called back, they would apologize for the interruption and describe the scene in detail. One day, a Palestinian man working for the United Nations cried helplessly when white phosphorus danced through the sky like firecrackers. Or like Space Invaders.
Israel stopped attacking the Gaza Strip two days before the U.S. presidential inauguration. Many speculate that the Israeli withdrawal was a trade-off with the President-elect for his silence during the military operation. I stood shoulder to shoulder with hundreds of thousands of people in front of my country's capitol building on what felt then like the first day of a new millennium, Obama's charismatic voice crackling through the freezing air as he took the oath. Hope had taken the nation by storm, Bush was on a helicopter bound for Texas, and the streets of Gaza were silent. Razed, I would soon witness just weeks later, but silent.
Getting into Gaza right after the war was nothing short of a miracle. I entered with a delegation through Rafah on the Egyptian side. We passed by Palestinians who had no chance of crossing the gate, and I knew that it was they who should have been granted passage, not me. Bombs fell on the tunnels near the buffer zone, but somehow, being in Gaza made me feel incredibly safe. And the resilience of the people crept to a place deep inside me. It hasn't left since.
The Gaza Strip is full of astonishing stories and the people there go to lengths to get them out. Being a visitor in that context is a privilege that comes with considerable responsibility. From speaking with families who lost loved ones to tank fire to spending time with children that trembled from the affects of PTSD, there was consistent desire to be heard. "Now you have seen this with your own eyes," they would say, "so you need to let people outside know what is happening to us here."
The second I left, I immediately started planning another trip. And then another. Within a year of the war, I had been back three times. Gaza is the kind of place that melts stereotypes. Let down by the Israelis, the Egyptians, the Americans, and the Palestinian Authority, Gazans continue to organize despite oppressive circumstances. They have burned garbage to fuel cars, built homes from mud, and crushed rubble to pave roads. Women from local community organizations bank seeds in their kitchen sinks and plant gardens in the most unlikely urban settings.
Today, the siege on Gaza continues with no end in sight. The United Nations has reported that at least 500 truckloads of wheat sit idle on the Israeli side of the Karni conveyor belt that has acted as a lifeline to a million and a half people. Even though these provisions are critical to survival, Palestinians living in the seaside enclave long for much more than access to food aid, but for freedom of movement, food sovereignty, and self-determination.
And now, military violence against Gaza has escalated again. One contact wrote that F16s had bombed several times over the past week, drones buzzing overhead as he sent out the message. Some Palestinians feel that another wide-reaching attack looms. It remains unclear exactly what awaits the people of Gaza two years after the war. What is certain is that we must keep their voices in the debate, and listen when they say enough is enough-especially when so many of us are intrinsically linked to their struggle.



13 Comments so far
Show AllAs for the Israeli ethnic cleansing apologists that are popping up again on CD, rather than take the bait and respond to a professional troller, I'll once again post the following and then make my comments on the article separately:
Apologists use tools such as Megaphone Desktop (www.giyus.org) to alert themselves when articles about Israel's destructive policies appear on the internet so they can use tactics like those below to try to win public or opinion, divert attention from the article or simply clog the comment thread by picking discussion thread fights.
Apologists' tactics in regards to the US/Israel policy of ethnic cleansing of Palestinians (they will also attack this list, but nevertheless use the tactics of the list):
1 – Avoid talking about the substance of the article, the occupation, the ethnic cleansing and the illegal acts: land confiscation, house demolitions and evictions, burning and razing of Palestinian farmland, illegal land annexations, specific apartheid policies in the West Bank, shooting and arrests of non-violent demonstrators on occupied land, restriction of movement, land and sea blockade, restrictions of imports of medicine, food, school supplies and building materials, illegal shooting of Gazan farmers and fishermen...
2 – Attack the messenger (CD poster or whoever criticizes the US/Israel's ethnic cleansing)
3 – If the critic is a Jew, call the Jew anti-semetic or a self-hating Jew
4 – Make it sound like Israel is the victim although Israel is the aggressor and occupier.
5 – Point to other injustices in the world to deflect attention of Israel's illegal acts.
6 – State that Jews and Palestinians have a long history of conflict therefore the situation is unresolvable (ignoring Israel's illegal occupation) in order to maintain status quo and further Israel's expansion of illegal settlements
7 – Claim Israel has biblical rights to Palestinian land (thus God supports the ethnic cleansing)
8 – Claim the occupied territory was either no man's land or another countries land to justify Israel's illegal confiscation of the land and the people on it.
9 - Try to make the ridiculous argument that Palestinians are a threat to Israel or have the capacity to destroy Israel, which they don't and will never have due to Israel's massive military with over 1200 Air Force aircraft, 18 Navy ships, 14,000 Army land based weapons, laser guided bombs and missles, illegally used cluster and phosphorus bombs, and nuclear weapons (and this list is conservative).
10 – Make illegitimate arguments or use inaccurate/misleading facts to justify Israel's illegal occupation and ethnic cleansing policy that it is impossible to respond to them all because every time you try, another illegitimate argument is made. (The Bush administration was a master of this in the buildup to the Iraq war. It seemed every week, another piece of unsupported evidence was made to support attacking Iraq. And every time you challenged one illegitimate argument, the arguer (usually a Fox News viewer) would abandon that argument and jump to the next illegitimate argument and this would continue to the point of exhaustion.)
11 – Switch between tactics 1-10 above in your non-stop argument whenever one of the tactics runs out of steam.
12 – In regards to blogging, create discussion fights and go off topic (article is rarely discussed).
13 – In regards to blogging, apologist is either ignorant or feigns ignorance and attempts to attack the credibility of the comment by asking for a link to the source (effort to waste time of blogger when information is readily available on the internet and the apologist doesn't provide support for his own misinformation). If you don't respond, e.g., because you don't monitor the site all day, apologist discounts your argument, and if you respond, the apologist changes the subject, makes a new attack, or ignores the response.
Good article by Salena.
Salena: "Many speculate that the Israeli withdrawal was a trade-off with the President-elect for his silence during the military operation"
Response: When asked during the attack about Israel's attack on Gaza, President-elect Obama cowardly said he couldn't comment because Bush was still in office (who was obviously a lame duck with no more interest in governing).
The timing of Israel's recent escalation of activity in Gaza may be no coincidence. It may on this 2nd anniversary of the Gaza attack just to terrorize the population of Gaza.
Past time to wrap up the the un-country of "Israel". De-certify it and boot it from the United Nations.
There is no room for criminal agencies the like of that entity on this planet.
Support Democracy in the middle east.
Boycott Divest and Sanction, "Israel".
Sophie Scholl-The Final Days
Is an Israeli Jewish sense of victimization perpetuating the conflict with Palestinians?
---
The sweeping support for Operation Cast Lead confirmed the main diagnosis that arises from the study, conducted by Daniel Bar-Tal, one of the world's leading political psychologists, and Rafi Nets-Zehngut, a doctoral student: Israeli Jews' consciousness is characterized by a sense of victimization, a siege mentality, blind patriotism, belligerence, self-righteousness, dehumanization of the Palestinians and insensitivity to their suffering.
---
http://www.c-r-t.org/content/newsarticles/IsraeliJewishvictimization.pdf
---
Meanwhile, elderly Palestinian women on a tour of the Holocaust Museum are called "whores" by a group of teenagers, girls of African descent are beaten up by marauding racist gangs, and the ramshackle houses of Sudanese migrants are set on fire.
http://www.jpost.com/NationalNews/Article.aspx?id=200469
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KUXSFsJV084
Interesting, M156.
If you have not read her articles previously, writer Sara Robinson used William O. Paxton's description of the five-stage development of fascism in various countries throughout the 19th Century to study American civilization.
We seem to have passed through two stages: resentment at perceived injustices, low-income, usually rural, and - in America - white and Christian "brown shirts" who are capable of violence; folks like Timothy McVeigh, the abortion doctor killers and the Unabomber.
Movements like the KuKluxKlan and homegrown militias are born, and late in Stage 2 or in Stage 3, actual political parties are formed. Members of the conservative elite (senators and representatives, political figures like Palin and Bachmann, "journalists" like Beck and Limbaugh, and leaders from the Christian Right) all spout inflammatory nonsense that is designed to rile people who don't see through their lies. They seem to care not that some of the people they inflame are, like McVeigh, capable of violence, or that formerly civil discourse seems to have been replaced by downright meanness.
After this year's election, it could very well get worse. Stage 4, perhaps.
Personally, I thought William Paxton dropped the ball a bit when he wrote 'Anatomy of Fascism'—in contrast to his ground-breaking research into the Vichy regime and it's collaboration with the Nazis-as it seemed too concrete in sticking to particular circumstances of the rise of Nazis to power in Germany in an era that is frankly too far removed from our own to be a source of insight into how the "low grade fever" of Fascism (Level 1, which per Paxton is a constant albeit dormant factor of political life in most capitalist/modern societies) can bloom into the full-blooded variety. Unfortunately, he couldn't tease out the abstractions that underlie the Nazi/Fascist phenomenon from the particulars of the twin cases of Germany and Italy after WWI.
This is a problem which, imho, Umberto Eco wasn't able to deal with well either—which is why his characteristics of that type of setup seem rather dated—but, while some of the symptoms are no longer as relevant, the general outline of the political disease of Fascism which he sketched, borrowing a concept from Wittgenstein, still remains comprehensible to most folks:
---
...the fascist game can be played in many forms, and the name of the game does not change. The notion of fascism is not unlike Wittgenstein's notion of a game. A game can be either competitive or not, it can require some special skill or none, it can or cannot involve money. Games are different activities that display only some "family resemblance," as Wittgenstein put it...Ur-Fascism is still around us, sometimes in plainclothes. It would be so much easier for us if there appeared on the world scene somebody saying, "I want to reopen Auschwitz, I want the Blackshirts to parade again in the Italian squares." Life is not that simple. Ur-Fascism can come back under the most innocent of disguises.
http://www.themodernword.com/eco/eco_blackshirt.html
---
Ian Kershaw's metaphor for explaining how the unimaginable could befall European Jews under the Nazis is probably more applicable to Palestinians under Israeli rule:
"...the road to Auschwitz was built by hate, but paved with indifference".
Anyone who spends time in Tel Aviv and notices the profound indifference, though not necessarily hate—although there's no shortage of Liebermans and hilltop settlers peddling that too—among the vast majority of it's cosmopolitan denizens, toward the Palestinians a few miles away—behind 30 foot concrete barriers—can only find the experience chilling in light of Kershaw's findings:
http://www.amazon.com/Popular-Opinion-Political-Dissent-Third/dp/0199251118
Bear in mind, however, bernice, that the Ku Klux Klan has a long history of not only being anti-black and anti-Semitic, but being anti-Roman Catholic as well. Many, if not most of these white, Christian "brownshirts" fail to realize that, since they've got no sense of history. Stage 4 could well escalate into murder!
"Israeli Jews' consciousness is characterized by a sense of victimization, a siege mentality, blind patriotism, belligerence, self-righteousness, dehumanization of the Palestinians and insensitivity to their suffering."
--------
Except for the "sense of victimization," wasn't what you described also characteristic of the Germans under Hitler?
I don't know if you've seen the movie about Sophie Scholl and the White Rose, but the investigator cited his sense of victimhood arising from French rule over parts of Germany after WWI to justify his own Nazi convictions:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XM5A4ETW_Io
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Why_did_France_occupy_the_Ruhr_in_1923
This time, we are the "good Germans," and we can't pretend we weren't fully aware of what was happening.
Israel uses U.S. tax dollars to finance their crimes against humanity. Meanwhile, U.S. citizens go hungry, homeless, jobless, and without access to medical care.
One of the best websites for following what is really happening in Israel/Palestine is mondoweiss.net, which covers the news from a Jewish perspective.
Very sad article, representative of the Palestinian condition under Israel occupation. The opening paragraph reminded me of a conversation I had not too long ago with a Palestinian friend. Oddly, we drifted to Lebanon not Gaza. And he told me, almost verbatim the same story: how their family would sit around the TV and his mom would weep over the victims in Lebanon. How sad! The same thing is being done to them, still - and unlike their victimizers - their hearts turn to others they perceive as having equal or more suffering than their own. The resilience, kindness and humanity of the Palestinians albeit all their misery and suffering should be a beacon to guide the people's of the world and inspire them to find solutions towards peace.