Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
IMF: Stop Funding Honduras
By giving millions of dollars to Honduras, the IMF is supporting an illegitimate coup government the world doesn't recognise
The IMF is undergoing an unprecedented expansion of its access to resources, possibly reaching a trillion dollars. This week the EU committed $175bn, $67bn more than even the $108bn that Washington agreed to fork over after a tense stand-off between the US Congress and the Obama administration earlier this summer.
The Fund and its advocates argue that the IMF has changed. The IMF is "back in a new guise", says the Economist. This time, we are told, it's really going to act as a multilateral organisation that looks out for the countries and people of the world, and not just for Washington, Wall Street or European banks.
But it's looking more and more like the same old IMF on steroids. Last week the IMF disbursed $150m to the de facto government of Honduras, and it plans to disburse another $13.8m on 9 September. The de facto government has no legitimacy in the world. It took power on 28 June in a military coup, in which the elected President Manuel Zelaya was taken from his home at gunpoint and flown out of the country.
The Organisation of American States suspended Honduras until democracy is restored, and the UN also called for the "immediate and unconditional return" of the elected president.
No country in the world recognises the coup government of Honduras. From the western hemisphere and the EU, only the US retains an ambassador there. The World Bank paused lending to Honduras two days after the coup, and the Inter-American Development Bank did the same the next day. More recently the Central American Bank of Economic Integration suspended credit to Honduras. The EU has suspended over $90m in aid as well, and is considering further sanctions.
But the IMF has gone ahead and dumped a large amount of money on Honduras - the equivalent would be more than $160bn in the US - as though everything is OK there.
This is in keeping with US policy, which is not surprising since the US has been - since the IMF's creation in 1944 - the Fund's principal overseer. Washington made a symbolic gesture earlier this year by cutting off about $18.5m to Honduras, and the state department announced on Thursday that it is terminating other assistance.
But more than two months after the Honduran military overthrew the elected president of Honduras, the US government has yet to determine that a military coup has actually occurred. This is because such a determination would require, under the US Foreign Appropriations Act, a complete cutoff of aid.
One of the largest sources of US aid is the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC), a government entity whose board is chaired by Hillary Clinton, the US secretary of state.
Interestingly, there were two military coups in the last year in countries that were receiving MCC money: Madagascar and Mauritania. In both of those cases MCC aid was suspended within three days of the coup.
The IMF's decision to give money to the Honduran government is reminiscent of its reaction to the 2002 coup that temporarily overthrew President Hugo Chávez of Venezuela. Just a few hours after that coup, the IMF's spokesperson announced: "We stand ready to assist the new administration in whatever manner they find suitable."
This immediate pledge of support by the IMF to a military-installed government was at the time unprecedented. Given the resources and power of the IMF, it was an important source of international legitimacy for the coup government. Members of the US Congress later wrote to the IMF to inquire how this happened. How did the IMF decide so quickly to support this illegitimate government?
The Fund responded that no decision was made, that this was just an off-the-cuff remark by its spokesperson. But this seems very unlikely, and in the video on the IMF's website, the spokesperson appears to be reading from a prepared statement when talking about money for the coup government.
In the Honduran case, the IMF would likely say that the current funds are part of a $250bn package in which all member countries are receiving a share proportional to their IMF quota, regardless of governance. This is true, but it doesn't resolve the question as to whom the funds should be disbursed to, in the case of a non-recognised, illegitimate government that has seized power by force. The Fund could very easily postpone disbursing this money until some kind of determination could be made, rather than simply acting as though there were no question about the legitimacy of the coup government.
Interestingly, the IMF had no problem cutting off funds under its standby arrangement with the democratically elected government of President Zelaya in November of last year, when the Fund did not agree with his economic policies.
We're still a long way from a reformed IMF.


19 Comments so far
Show AllThe only way to reform the IMF is to abolish it. It's nothing more than the official functionary for the world's banking powers.
q
Well said!!!!
Amen.
Touche!
The IMF's funding--which was supposedly denied as happening by the IMF office in Tegucigalpa on Wednesday--WHICH IS IT FOLKS?!--is just another way for the US to continue supporting the coup while they make a State Department show of calling it a coup and CUTTING funding.
Note the verb CUT, not the verb CANCEL.
They agreed to give 70 million in humanitarian aid to help line Michelletti's pockets. Or perhaps as severance pay when he signs Plan Arias.
Ya know something funny? When aid was cut off to the Palestinian authority several years ago progs were screaming countries providing aid had not right to cut it off.
How does anyone NOT have the right to cut off aid? Think about what you just said.
Perhaps you confuse "aid" with "gift."
Aid mostly includes funds for which some deal or another has been cut. Stopping it means backing out on a deal.
The US committed a travesty cutting off aid to Palestine because of the confluence of two things:
1. It crawfished out of an agreement.
2. It did so to punish the Palestinian electorate for voting against the perceived self-interest of the US government.
The situation is very different in Honduras. The electorate had elected Zelaya. Because he did things not against Honduran law, but against the perceived self-interest of elements in the US government and corporate elite, some bigtime Washington lobbyists and Honduran elites funded and executed a coup.
The objection is not that the US should withhold funds if betrayed, but that they should not withhold funds to betray the popular will.
this is all a pile of poo. honduras threw out a blossoming dictator because he was breaking constitutional law and is a croonie of chavez.
there was no coup.
now the US is going dumpster diving to restore him. meanwhile...out of 6 million people here...2/3 of them are living well below poverty level.
and a cut or termination of aide is the response? bad move.
i am an american living here. ALL tourism has stopped. what jobs these people had in that sector have evaporated. things are looking very very sad for this country. i am ashamed to be an american.
Well, if it makes you feel any better, I'm sure lots of Americans are also ashamed that you're an American. I know I am.
The insistent chorus that there was no coup has pretty well shouted itself hoarse, and still has only convinced itself.
I think it's down to you and Lanny Davis at this point, so hang in there!
· Yr Obd't Servant
"I stopped hiring any gringos 15 years ago even to teach English--those on-the-run jokers were trying to take jobs away from local Mexicans who were suffering yet another major economic crisis"
That sounds like racism!!! (LOL) Just kidding. You do your country proud by hiring its citizens before a foreigner. Your own citizens need every job they can get, especially after NAFTA. Why is it so hard for people to understand a countries first duty is to its own citizens?
I wanted to use "Dumpster Diving" myself....but I guess I'll have to pass since you have the copyright......
When I typed in Casaverde's comment into Altavista's Babelfish feature this is what I got back:
"I was golden living here exploiting the natives by virtue of my greenback domination. It isn't enough for me that the Honduran currency exchange has been manipulated downward by the IMF and USAID and all those moneylaundering ops CIA and others in the prior corporatist Honduran administrations.This duly elected Zelaya guy had the nerve to follow through on the mandates to get a bit back of his and the other peones own, no, he threatened to impose conditions on my residency here, including surcharges on any currency exchanges including the HOLY DOLLAR. GOD forbid do you know what that is going to do to all the Enronning I've used to sock away the bucks before I came down here to enjoy my nationalized healthcare entitlement as a permanent resident?
And those ugly rumors that people from all over the world are boycotting the Main Man's coup, shunning the oligarchs and supporting the 99.999% of Honduras's population, well the real reason Tourism has stopped is because they don't want to dodge the bullets, aimed at peaceful protesters on their way to the radio station, that the US trained school of assassins graduates are being forced to fire because students and shopkeepers and farmers keep using ugly words like "justice" and "restoration of rights" and other dangerous, dangerous words."
Capitalist Republic -- Can it compete with social democracy?
In just six years Venezuela has reduced poverty by 30%, reduced inflation from 14.7% down to 7.3% and created a national healthcare system that is free to all. And surely not because Hugo Chávez is the dictator of it, as the majority pushed him into it. For when the CIA tried to kill Chávez in the coup of 2002, it was the outraged millions that stormed the palace who saved his skin and restored him to office.
And in Honduras President Zelaya was on a fast track to do the same thing and the rich were none to happy.
Whereas our Republic, even with half the wealth on earth, is doing all it can to keep 25% of us in total poverty. And doing its best to block any regulation that would reduce profits in their capitalist medical industry.
For in 1776 when the farmers in New Jersey were about to form a social democracy, a group of slave owners decided to create a fake democracy, a capitalist Republic that would give all capitalists the unregulated freedom to compete for excessive wealth. The reverse of equality and the total destruction of democracy.
Thanks Mark. Otherwise we never would have known.
Going back even farther, how about the military takeovers in Argentina and Chile that resulted in so many desparecidos?
Those lovely governments received IMF moneys, which are always loaned at high rates of interest and, guess what?-- when the coup governments themselves have incurred great debt and are themselves thrown out, the new, often democratic governments are still responsible for the debts of their predecessors! Screwed once, screwed, twice........