Iraq: What We Leave As We Withdraw
Not long after the statue of Saddam fell in Firdos Square, several
CODEPINK women and I returned to Iraq. We'd first visited in February
during the time Bush proclaimed, "The game is over" and announced his
plans for "shock and awe." We'd learned then how much Iraqis loved
Americans and did not want our disrupting their country; they asked us
to let them deal with Saddam because the change had to come from within
or it could be a disaster. We fell in love with Iraq and felt totally
safe there, taking cabs in the wee hours of the morning, walking at 2
a.m. on the Tigress and driving to many parts of the country.
Returning a few months later, however, we found the country
devastated. Bustling markets were empty, the streets were those of a
ghost town. Electricity was rare if at all and gas lines were miles
long. U.S. soldiers in Humvees sped down the streets with an
embarrassing arrogance. Jerry Bremer had just arrived and had issued
100 edicts that infuriated every Iraqi. The story on the street was
that it only took Saddam a month to get the country back in shape after
the Gulf War, thus, impatience and anger toward the U.S. were growing.
Over and over, we heard from Iraqis, "We had one Saddam and now we have
hundreds."
"In six years they have destroyed Iraq," her eyes teared as she
began to tell me what she found. She used the image of a pen trying to
balance on the tip of her finger to describe Iraq now: balancing but
very unstable. Since she was there last it is a bit safer. Women who
had been in exile and hiding for four years were starting to reemerge.
But more than 70 percent of the women are not sending their daughters
to school. I asked her about the women from the Bremer reception, 20
women have been killed and most others are gone.
When I asked about Baghdad, she asked which one. "There are two
distinct Baghdads, the red one and the green one," she said. "And they
do not relate. On the red side, they call the Americans the 'friendly
other side'.
The Embassy/Green Zone is another city within a city, now
one-fourth of Baghdad, she explained. It was built for 5,000 employees
and already people are having to double up, it has burst past 5,000.
Most of those who live there are not Iraqi but Ugandan, Peruvian,
Burmese, etc. They cannot leave the Green Zone, so they have no idea
about what is outside the walls. She overheard a conversation about a
car bomb while she was inside and learned three soldiers were killed.
She wondered why do the United States sends people to Iraq to get
double pay and hazardous benefits when they are not even going outside
the walls.
U.S. soldiers were still a part of Baghdad while she was there.
People are still living without electricity but it has gotten a bit
better, something like two hours on and three hours off, she said, this
change has helped to engender the window of calm she experienced. It
was still spring and she felt like the flowers of Iraq was beginning to
bloom again. There was more hope because less violence, but the country
still is very fragile.
There is nothing made in Iraq for sale. Not even those fantastic
cucumbers we loved so much on our drives through the country. Bremer
had created a five-percent flat tax for imports in one of his edicts,
so Iraqi can't produce anything. It will always be cheaper to bring in
products from the from outside. No other country would ever allow such
a thing. The Bremer policies were made to destroy Iraq from the inside
out.
I asked Zainab about her grandfather's house, a beautiful home on
the Tigres River where she had held her first classes for W4WI there
six years ago. She has since closed W4WI because it became too
dangerous, in the meantime it had become a torture den then a brothel.
This turned the conversation to trafficking, which she said is
horrendous. Most of the girls in prison are between the ages of 12 to
18. They were kidnapped, taken to Syria or surrounding countries, trafficked and
when they got sick or too old were brought home to the authorities. Because
they didn't have the right papers they were put in jail. Midwives also told
her of a huge increase in abortions resulting from the prostitution.
Just six years ago, only the old and very religious were covered,
women were employed everywhere and Baghdad University was bustling with
young women. Now it is bleak. Zainab was able to go uncovered but it is
still mandatory for the Iraqi women. Most businesses she visited had no
women working, not to say they did not try, but they're just fired
within days. Some older women were able to keep their jobs but young
women have no way in. She said the university was very sad with much
less women. Women, young women have been sent back to the dark ages.
She too can't find the way to affect the gridlock of people
believing it is over. The U.S. has not taken responsibility to restore
the country it destroyed. Iraqis need us to hold those responsible who
have done this to them and to leave them to rebuild from the shambles.
She left our conversation with this: "It basically looks like we do own
it and have created our own kind of hell out of it."
Twitter
StumbleUpon
Facebook
Delicious
Digg
Newsvine
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
34 Comments so far
Show AllI can't even read this - another list of the horrors the USA has perpetrated on land, people; is doing; will continue to do despite it being called that we're not doing it and the USA is removing itself from here - see Janet's article.
Norma
normaha@pacbell.net
I believe there are many brave and intelligent people in Iraq . I hope that they will unite and in a non violent way demand that the Oil rights be returned to them and that restitution be made for the carnage of decades of foreign thieves violently trying to steal their resources. They must also demand equal human rights for all girls and women. And health care and free education through college for all Iraqis as they had under Saddam. It would be a good idea for Americans to unite for the same goals.Free health care, education through college,living wage jobs,and protection of reproductive health care clinics to guarantee the human dignity of girls and women.
This comment reflects the effective teaching here in the USA, that others are others and we are different - and better. This person will be sooo surprised to learn that. I hope this is just one of those teaching moments and not one of those rage moments - don't tell me that my well-intentioned comment is actually disparaging of a lot of people!
But it is - and it says - but they're ok - they'll get better - as long as they follow my directions - directions which could well be given to us here in the USA... as she's said.
Notice that WE're 'Americans'. What then are the Canadians, living on the 'American' continent; and the Mexicans - the same; and the South Americans...?
Oh, but we're special.
I'll submit the comment I was going to make until I saw this, on the comment page.
Norma normaha@pacbell.net
the only thing the US will be withdrawing from Iraq is oil.
Correction: The headline to this article should have read:
Iraq: What We Did and Will Continue to Do as We Occupy
The US is not leaving Iraq. We will still be there 50 years from now. Just like we're still in Germany, Japan and South Korea. Does anyone really think the US is leaving Iraq? The main stream media may show soldiers leaving, but the private, corporatized contractors will never leave. Why else would they build the largest fortified embassy in the world, then just abandon it along with the Green Zone?
What goes around comes around. The bill the United States will have to pay for destroying Iraq (I'm not talking dollars) will be devastating. And, like all our other debts, we will be unable and totally unwilling to pay it. Makes no difference; if we don't pay one way, we'll pay another.
True.
Open your umbrellas, the shit-storm is coming.
Evans sez: "It will always be cheaper to bring in products from the from outside. No other country would ever allow such a thing. "
***
Well, except for the U.S.
I still can't believe that the sole purpose of crashing Iraq is aquire control of assets--oil, and everything else. And the business of weapon is also booming because of what these guys are doing. http://www.howtogettallersecrets.com
Still going with the Saddam-is-bad excuse for the war?
It was about usurping control of central Asia's natural resources.
Everything else is cover story or sop for dupes.
Nonetheless, one less Hussein in the world is a good thing.
The US isn't really leaving Iraq. It's simply replacing troops with mercenaries. The only way the US will go is when the oil runs out and Congress stops funding the occupation. The more we're stuck in Iraq, the more evident it is that GOD IS PUNISHING AMERICA TO ETERNAL DAMNATION !
You're right - the US is shuffling troops and bases and hiring private mercenaries. Check out Janet Weil's post over on FDL yesterday: http://bit.ly/16ZxKn
Hi Maxpayne. Yes, I think we're in for a big spanking from God! And as security guards for big oil, I think we're staying in Iraq. We'll just be wearing different costumes.
Hi Bliss Doubt. Long time no see on Alternet but I saw your explanation on another article on this site as well as your other posts on this site and I see JenniferB welcomed you over and so do I. There have been quite a few transfers here. Most have been pretty good with the exception of EncinoM but he was here only briefly. He revealed that he was a police officer in NYC, later a mercenary, later a greedy manager of a Big Insurance corporation, and he now claims to be a self-employed entrepreneur. He was totally offensive when he revealed his pride in mistreating his employees especially women. I think he was kicked out but who knows? Most rightwing trolls don't stay here long as they have no interest in listening to the finer details that we all need to learn. But all that aside, glad to have you with us and I think you'll love it here.
Wow, EncinoM all that? I'm not sure I'd believe him. Online you can be anything you want to be, double agent, ninja, CEO. Interesting if it's true though.
Thank you for the kind words. Glad to find you here too, Maxpayne. I'm way too fond of having opinions, and of expressing them, but online I can do this without stirring the flames of partisan political wars with my people, the tribe of Bubba.
And the devil is always in the details, how many troops are staying behind to guard the Green Zone and the bases? It makes good headlines for saps: Look! "Obama kept his promise!"
The forces that remain then have until 2011 to wreak havoc by which time a new agreement can be strong armed from the Iraqi puppet government. Look to have US presence in Iraq for a long time. We still have bases in Germany, Philippines, and Okinawa etc.
P.S. The withdrawal coincides with a meeting in Bagdad to auction off the largest oil fields to ExxonMobil, Chevron and British Petroleum etc.
The more I learned about oil drilling and the damaging effects, the more pissed off I got with all who chose to take the resource for granted and do everything to guzzle it. Sometimes I get very angry when people complain about high gas prices and tell them to shut their mouths. When I learned about other methods of obtaining light sweet crude oil without having to drill or go to wars for oil, I was even more pissed off that government doesn't even take these ideas seriously. Sometimes, when I see someone begging for gas prices to be cheap so they can continue doing whatever such as taking more frequent trips, I feel like smacking them with my fists. Where do they think they're getting the oil from? We know that the oil is most likely coming from those slave workers in Saudi Arabia or from bombed out lands in Iraq. No wonder I go mad and believe that GOD is punishing America.
PS: No luck on improving public transportation in Hampton Roads and Northern VA. Anyone who claims "improvement" is lying. Then Governor Mark Warner, now senator, proudly cut the funding for building a rail system in Hampton Roads and did nothing to improve the worsening traffic conditions in Northern VA. Instead, he chose to put it on the ballot and tied to to raising taxes which he knew would fail. Kaine was even dumber. Obama is doing the same thing but on the national level.
Thank you, Ms. Evans, for this reminder. It is important, indeed, not to forget any of this.
Among other consequences of the invasion and occupation of Iraq by the United States not mentioned in this article, one might cite the looting and destruction of Iraq's millenia old past: see, for example, Hugh Eakin's article "The Devastation of Iraq's Past" of 2008, at http://www.nybooks.com/articles/21671.
What I find truly amazing is that on NPR (National Propaganda Radio) I heard the mother of an American soldier in Iraq lamenting that the troops were being withdrawn after having made so much progress. She talked about how much better things were in Iraq as a consequence of our invasion and the "wonderful progress" being made.
The great lament on NPR was that withdrawing the troops before they finished their "great work" meant our soldiers had died there in vain. It was a variation of Bush's "stay-the-course" nonsense we heard ad nauseam during his tenure.
From a cynical point of view they didn't die in vain, the US got the lucrative oil contracts they went there for.
Ric T.
I agree. I am always amazed that when a soldier returns to this country either in a body bag or grievously wounded that the families of those soldiers are not outraged at their most uncaring government for having placed their loved ones in that position in the first place. Contrast that with the scene in Sir! No Sir! when the male nurse observed that not one soldier in the hospital that he was caring for believed that what they had suffered was worth it. One has to wonder why the generation of today seems so willing to allow themselves to be brainwashed and to believe that their families are somehow being used for some ambiguous noble cause.
You figure. One would have to be an imbecile to believe the US would devote trillions of dollars to "help" Iraqis when they don't even care enough about their own citizens to offer them single payer health care or enough stimulus money to prevent the loss of a huge number jobs.
odoco
Ric - that is the point exactly: who is investing in the war, and who will profit from it, and who will suffer as a result of it. Find the answers to those questions, and then replace the whole corrupt system of government that is now the USA.
I agree. And how we do that is by having conversations with anybody that will listen and telling them the truth. The truth will win out over the lie in the end.
She doesn't deserve to be called a mother at all for being proud to see her child in harm's way.
I'm sorry, but that's an incredibly insensitive and ignorant statement.
She's proud because it's her son. There are other mothers who may not believe in the cause, but are still proud of their sons or daughters who are in Iraq or anywhere else.
A few weeks ago I saw my cousin who was wearing a black wrist band with the name of her only son. He was killed in Iraq. Whether she supported the war/occupation, I don't know, but I do know she was proud of her son. I didn't have to ask her to know.
"I'm sorry, but that's an incredibly insensitive and ignorant statement.
She's proud because it's her son. There are other mothers who may not believe in the cause, but are still proud of their sons or daughters who are in Iraq or anywhere else."
There is a limit to this kind of false pride. It's like having false hope. Suppose the child is totally uninformed but his/her parent(s) push the kid into wars by our dirty pols. Ric also astutely points out that parents are brainwashed by the rightwing media and government along with poor education. The kids do not deserve to be dragged into this. When one's kid or relative dies in a war that was totally unjustified, there can be nothing to be proud of whatsoever.
"A few weeks ago I saw my cousin who was wearing a black wrist band with the name of her only son. He was killed in Iraq. Whether she supported the war/occupation, I don't know, but I do know she was proud of her son. I didn't have to ask her to know."
I see nothing that the mother and her son gained from this. On the other hand, his life was lost, the military and corporate elites continue to prosper, and the pols get worse about it. The mother was brainwashed into being proud of losing her dear son and that I find heartbreaking as much as the son losing his life when he could have been shining in life by not getting into the military. How many more wasted lives do you want to keep feeling proud of?
"Rightwing media"? Not sure what papers you guys are reading, or what tv news you see, but the media is most decidedly not "rightwing."
It is a tribute to the effective US propaganda machine (like NPR and Fox) that a mother would be so brainwashed she would support putting her son in harms way for the benefit of Big Oil & War Profits Inc.
I won't say that the soldiers are alone. When I think about where I and plenty others are working at and for whom, I realize that like the soldiers, we're also being played for the fools but some of us do it for economic purposes when nothing is available. If I hadn't worked where I'm working at, I would have been unable to afford a lot of those rather expensive solar home installation ideas or keep our monthly bills in order. My parents and my wife's parents act like that stupid "mother" once in a while telling me to be proud of it but I often reply in anger and get into a moderate vs conservative argument.
Part of the brainwashing starts in school too when one looks at the ongoing school bullying, fudged educating, allowing recruiters to hoodwink students, etc ...
Jodie - thank you and all the CodePink gals and supporters for your courage and your integrity.
There will never be peace anywhere in this world until justice and accountability are restored. Obviously, the ruling regimes will battle such changes, using every device at their disposal. It will take the people - massive numbers of 'the people' to bring sanity and humanity back to the forefront. That is, and always will be our mission.
CodePink, Vets for Peace, Iraq Veterans Against the War,and a hundreds of other organizations simply have to find a way to unite - to elect truly honest people who will actually work for the benefit of the massive and not the corporations.
Thanks again Jodie.
They'll find ways to pretend peace and withdrawal but it's all just a shell rearranging game. We're not withdrawing from Iraq. We're simply replacing the US soldiers with mercenaries and Obama has already given the green light to fund it heavily.
odoco
Max - he did that when he not only refused to repudiate Blackwater (Xe), but has now employed not only them, but other mercenary forces against those who would oppose the corporatist regime.
I'm still hopin' for change - and I'm still buying lottery tickets . . . . . .
I'm not hoping for anything. In fact, I never did hope for anything from Obama and yet on the last minute, I voted for him. While I won't hope for anything, I can only say he has 3 years left to prove a growing distrusted and fed up bloc wrong. Obama's nuts if he thinks he can keep pushing his luck.