Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Our Financial 9/11: Can They Save the System?
The Bush Administration’s Rescue Plan Is Not Likely to Work
NEW YORK -- The world is holding its breath.
Many know and the rest of us are just finding out that in this turbulent month of September, the US is experiencing a financial 9/11, probably worse than the one in 2001, as a series of cataclysmic developments rock our economic system which is ,in turn, entangled with others worldwide. Terms like "Armageddon" are now being used in polite company.
Imagine being a fly on the wall last Thursday night as the head of the Federal Reserve Bank, Ben Bernanke, and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson, met behind closed doors in House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's office. The meeting was called urgent; it was also unprecedented.
It was a truth-telling moment as Michael Shedlock describes it on the Seeking Alpha Financial website:
"When you listened to him describe it you gulped," said Senator Charles E. Schumer, Democrat of New York.
As Senator Christopher J. Dodd, Democrat of Connecticut and chairman of the Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee, put it Friday morning on the ABC program "Good Morning America," the congressional leaders were told "that we're literally maybe days away from a complete meltdown of our financial system, with all the implications here at home and globally."
Mr. Schumer added, "History was sort of hanging over it, like this was a moment."
When Mr. Schumer described the meeting as "somber," Mr. Dodd cut in. "Somber doesn't begin to justify the words," he said. "We have never heard language like this."
Until that moment the full extent of this disaster had been hidden from Congress and the American people with all kinds of upbeat blather and outright lies about how the "fundamentals of the economy" were sound.
Suddenly nothing was sound. The government than announced a rescue plan. On Saturday, The Bush Administration said they want $700 billion to fund it, but that may just be the start.
The plan includes creating a new entity like the RTC that ended the S&L crisis in the 1980's to buy up and sell-off bad mortgages and other "illiquid assets," billions to back up money market funds, and new SEC edicts to stop short sellers from undermining stock prices-a measure backed by John McCain who has made "the shorts" his boogie man over the fierce editorial objections of the Wall Street Journal editorial page and most anyone who knows anything about the way the market works.
Barack Obama has so far supported this major intervention into saving the markets that may cost taxpayers a trillion dollars or more although he wants to consult with other countries on what to do.
Much of our media has ignored international fears as this crisis ripples globally. China has already called the crisis a "financial tsunami" and called for a new non-US based currency system.
The stock markets were euphoric Friday and shot up as if the crisis had been solved. It was more "market psychology" which is not the same thing as common sense. Joe Nocera in the New York Times was less positive, likening these measures to a "hail mary pass" in football where a quarterback just flings the ball in the final minutes of the game and hopes someone catches it, noting that "most of the time they fail."
Blogger Shedlock says, at best, these moves postponed Armageddon but did not end the danger:
"Government manipulation can never prevent financial Armageddon. In fact, government intervention and manipulation in the free markets eventually guarantees financial Armageddon. Armageddon was not prevented, only delayed, and at taxpayer expense."
Nocera agrees, concluding with the kind of understatement you expect from the newspaper of record, "as much as we might hope that the government finally has the answer, it probably doesn't."
So much for all that "problem solved" optimism you have been seeing on TV.
Also troubling is the tendency in the media to blame the crisis on "mistakes" by irresponsible lenders and irresponsible borrowers as if their contributions to this crisis balanced each other out and, hence, since everyone was at fault, no one is at fault.
This "logic" compares the Jones family that took a subprime loan after being targeted by fraudulent brokers who assured them it was a great deal and that they couldn't lose, with a powerful industry that knew they couldn't afford to their home but went ahead anyway securitizing the mortgage, slicing and dicing it into financial instruments and then misrepresenting its value to buyers and investors worldwide.
Since when do you equate individuals with institutions?
The buyer was duped; the lender and the multi-million dollar Wall Street market machine behind these unscrupulous brokers were consciously exploiting people who had no idea they were victimized by a well-calculated and criminal ponzi scheme. The FBI is investigating some of these crimes, so far indicting 400 scammers, but our media continues to leave out the criminal cabal behind this crisis. They support the bailouts but have yet to call for a jail out as if they are unaware that Wall Street is not just a financial center but has been a crime scene.
No wonder that a reader to the New York Times called this measure a "No Banker Left Behind Scheme."
This crisis is hardly over.
Listen to economist Nouriel Roubini who has been on target in most of his forecasts,
He predicts, according to financial writer Felix Salmon, "Credit losses of $2 trillion, half the US banking system nationalized, municipal defaults, house price declines accelerating, a sudden stop in consumer spending, global contagion, stagflation, you name it."
Roubini concludes:
"At this point the perfect financial storm of the century cannot be contained. The only light at the end of the tunnel is the one of the coming financial and economic train wreck."
If you think you can trust this Administration to solve this crisis when it has created so many others, think again. Unfortunately neither political party seems to have a clear take on what is happening or any plan to solve it.
So strap in, we are in for volatile rollercoaster ride.



26 Comments so far
Show AllThe Bush/Cheney/Mccain gang couldn't handle the simple task of disposing of the Taliban and Al Quaida so NO they can't and won't save the system except for the elites as always.
http://www.moderateindependent.com/v6iSEPT172008Economicbailout.htm
oh sure, let's replace the Bush/Cheney/Mccain gang with Obama bin Biden gang who aided and abetted them for 8 years.
When will you feeble-minded voters ever learn?
Do you really expect that Nader or any 3rd party candidate in the White House will be able to get anything done? You still have Congress of both parties and the media that's anti-3rd-party. The system is stacked against them. Don't you even bother to learn? Besides, wouldn't you agree that Nader should have spent the last 8 years repairing and uniting the Green party? A Nader/Mckinney ticket would have at least been more sharp. You don't even know the current system of government that was set up by the founding fathers or even the history of how the system has been rigged. I suggest you learn that first before calling voters names.
Right on, Nebraska Nathan.
That is understandable. However, I still think we should take all levels that we can. I never thought about the dangers Nader would face. My only reason for voting is he's taking the stands on the issues that match what I'm looking for in the next president. He may not win but I'd rather just vote my heart out than settle for either GOP or GOP-lite. You are correct though that Nader could have been more helpful in getting the Green Party in shape. It will take at least a couple of decades before we can penetrate the system and turn it more progressive/liberal though there's nothing to lose at this point given the rate at which this country is crashing harder and harder.
Only problem with your assessment is that you appear to be giving Congress its Constitutional power, which, for the most part no longer exists today. Almost all power has been given to the Executive branch, with Congress delegated to reacting (weakly if at all) to Executive actions. And too underscore the real lack of power in Congress today look how they continue to approve and fund legislation they are supposedly against, because the powerful Executive branch demands it. And on the rare occasion the Congress does do anything, the Executive signs a signing statement making the Congressional action mute and Congress eats it. Congress has even rendered the subpoena meaningless, underlings of the Executive disregard such knowing there are no consequences to come when Congress is at the other end. Remember when everybody thought 2006 would stop Bush because the Democrats are in control of Congress....proving 2 things, 1. The Democrats are just the other Republicans, and 2. A force in the executive branch turns Congress into a stable of geldings
A Nader or McKinney presidency WITH THE PEOPLE AWAKE & ANGRY would have plenty of leverage on Congress. Congress fears an awake people, and they would, under those circumstances submit to the will of the people. Unlike a conservative revolution which relies on corporate power and public ignorance, a liberal revolution can only be sustained by an active, educated, militant citizenry.
But since liberals make Congress look brave, we'll never have to worry about that. We attack our own candidates out of childish fear and cowardice, leaving liberals beating the crap out of liberal candidates who fight for their own positions, while supporting candidates who have no intention of ever supporting any of their positions. Lesserevilism really is the surrendering of ones soul to evil.... so there is no need to worry about any liberal candidates or positions ever being effectively fought for, until this group of cowardly liberals thankfully dies off.
This financial crisis isn't a financial 9/11, there weren't foreign terrorists involved, it was a self inflicted wound. The idea that debt could be turned into an asset that generates wealth is akin to the idea that a self powered machine can be built.
The solution offered by bush is to print more money. A tactic that's been tried before with predictable results; you'll be buying a loaf of bread with a million dollar bill eventually.
The author of the article is right, criminal charges need to be brought against those who ran what is the biggest ponzi scheme ever pulled off. Unfortunately for most people, the ones who launched the scheme were bright enough to enlist the aid of their political representatives. Those pol reps aren't going to allow their prosecutors to investigate this crime if they can get away with that.
If "the taxpayers" knew the numbers, they'd be rioting in the streets.
Every $1 trillion "our" government "spends" to "save" their friends translates to $8000 per taxpayer (rounded up, based on 130 million taxpayers. Ignore the 'per citizen" numbers - non-taxpayers are not relevant.)
So far, just this year, "our" government has promised their friends over $3 trillion of taxpayer money (that we actually know of) in return for, what everyone from the NYT to the WSJ refers to as "toxic assets."
That's $24,000 per taxpayer, whose average income is $32,000/year - leaving the average taxpayer with a net-of-gross of $8000K for 08. Minus taxes at, say, a medium 25% (of $32K=$7000,) and, this year, the average taxpayer will take home an astounding $1000, or about 80 bucks a month. (And a handful of toxic assets!)
How many taxpayers voted to give AIG, Fannie, Fredie, and the rest basically their entire year's earnings as a thank you for robbing us blind?
Of course, add in another $8K for the Pentagon ($1 trillion budget,) another $8K for Iraq/Afghanistan ($1 trillion spent so far,) and another $24K to cover the $3 trillion 08 Fed budget...
And every taxpayer is on the hook - this year only, remember - for at least $64,000 apiece, or twice the average income.
Toss in each taxpayer's share of the National Debt, now approaching $10 trillion, or another $80,000 per tp... for a total of $144,000, or nearly 5 years worth of the average taxpayer's income.
These are the real, raw painful numbers that need to be shouted to every sucker - er, I mean taxpayer - in America RIGHT NOW. Maybe, just maybe, We The People will wake the f**k up and, you know, revolt or something...
(Posted repeatedly to encourage wide dissemination.)
Like the first 9/11, this one is being driven by the number one American value: greed.
No solution until the empire collapses. Thankfully, it won't be long now.
good post Danny, thanks. Obama - economy. Oil - water. It will take him at least four years to understand the machine, let alone affect the direction it has been driven... if he wins.
None of them have real solutions as they are so inherently an integral part of the problem. "The Party" is complicit at every step. Changing that means changing fundamentals. It's easier to mortgage the future to China to the tune of a few more trillion worthless pieces of IOU.
Most of those devalued houses belong to China... no, not Chinese investors, but China the country. Why not give them the banks as well? They earned them with the same type of ponzi scheme that the banks used on uneducated Americans. The banks already serve their Chinese masters in more than name.
Well, okay... if you look inside the gas tank of your SUV, you'll realize that China is not alone in "playing" America... the Saudis have "earned" their fair share of the pie.
Fill 'er up... errr... better make that two gallons... I'm a little short this month.
the 'red level security alert' light may be on, but the Democrats won't see it and neither will the Republicans. They say, and do, and believe, that they are saving the country.
It really is too funny. I refuse to be afraid.
wild ;)
Grasping at Straws
By Mike Whitney
21/09/08 "ICH"
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article20828.htm
Well, thank God the economy is fundamentally strong, you know the American worker.
We are as strong as mules, and as dumb,we have to be , we are going to carry the the national debt from two illegal wars, a fear mongering military industrial complex national security crisis, and now wall street.
But , we don't have the money for a national health care system which we all will need to stay as healthy as possible,we have to go to work every day to pay this debt. For who knows how many years.
We don't have the money for social security, but that's OK , all our retired folks need to go back to work full time and get off social security, we will need the tax money.
Gees , I almost forgot, now all we need is for our government to magically create all the low paying jobs needed to put everyone back to work, so we can collect the tax money to pay this debt.
The Right wing neoconservative lunatic greed mister fringe have done what they wanted since good old Ron Reagen. Since I started working full time at age 21 1981, I have seen wages stay flat, benefits go away, health care costs go through the roof and average American credit card debt got to 10,000 per card.
Why , because that's what the real movers and shakers who run this country want, the Federal Reserve.
You know, The Fed-- N.M. Rothschild , London - Bank of England, Brown, Shipley - Morgan Grenfell - Lazard Brothers - Governor, Bank | J.P. Morgan Co ,Morgan Stanley Co,Schroder Bank, Lehman Brothers N.Y , Kuhn Loeb Co. N. Y.
On and On.
www.save-a-patriot.org/files/view/whofed.html
Credit card interest rates are nothing but legal loan sharking. The Fed.
Bad loans to the general public. The Fed.
Control of printing money, not on the gold standard. The Fed.
Its not our country folks, it hasn't been since 1913, when we turned over the constitutional controls of our money to the FED.A private global banking system.
So, surprise, we had to bail out the FED players. Whats funny is, in order to do it, we will have to borrow the money from, Guess who , THE FED.
Are you sick yet? Whats the definition of insanity?
How do you create a One World Order and One World currency?
Make all paper money worthless, and create a computer credit system for banking.
You make think that last statement is crazy, but because of the boom in computer technology and the internet, we are now ready for the financial meltdown of the existing money system.
Debit and credit cards will be our money.
E pluribus unum is a motto found on the Great Seal of the United States, along with Annuit cœptis and Novus ordo seclorum, and adopted by an Act of Congress ..
E Pluribus unum : Annuit coeptis : Novus ordo seclorum
Out of many, one : smile upon beginnings : New world of ages
Why did our founding Fathers give us the Constitution?
So that we the people 232 years later would cast it aside?
Build a powerful nation using the constitution as a tool for that end?
Was that the plan?
It would take one powerful nation to build a global new world order.
Maybe our founding fathers saw America as the leader of a New World Order.
Well, it worked, the constitution built the most powerful country in the world.
Based on a real free market system, the one the the FED slowly started to control since 1913.And a complicit congress has started to dismantle the constitution.
So the new Fascist America is born, hail to the New commander and chief.THE FEDERAL RESERVE.
They make our money, loan it out and have us pay for their failures.
And now the FED is the new world order, and the USA is the hired gun.
More Wars are coming, of that I have no doubt.
BornFreeMen
Good post. Our "fundamentals" are strong. Just disorganized.
Joe
Well, thank God the economy is fundamentally strong, you know the American worker.
We are as strong as mules, and as dumb,we have to be , we are going to carry the the national debt from two illegal wars, a fear mongering military industrial complex national security crisis, and now wall street.
But , we don't have the money for a national health care system which we all will need to stay as healthy as possible,we have to go to work every day to pay this debt. For who knows how many years.
We don't have the money for social security, but that's OK , all our retired folks need to go back to work full time and get off social security, we will need the tax money.
Gees , I almost forgot, now all we need is for our government to magically create all the low paying jobs needed to put everyone back to work, so we can collect the tax money to pay this debt.
The Right wing neoconservative lunatic greed mister fringe have done what they wanted since good old Ron Reagen. Since I started working full time at age 21 1981, I have seen wages stay flat, benefits go away, health care costs go through the roof and average American credit card debt got to 10,000 per card.
Why , because that's what the real movers and shakers who run this country want, the Federal Reserve.
You know, The Fed-- N.M. Rothschild , London - Bank of England, Brown, Shipley - Morgan Grenfell - Lazard Brothers - Governor, Bank | J.P. Morgan Co ,Morgan Stanley Co,Schroder Bank, Lehman Brothers N.Y , Kuhn Loeb Co. N. Y.
On and On.
www.save-a-patriot.org/files/view/whofed.html
Credit card interest rates are nothing but legal loan sharking. The Fed.
Bad loans to the general public. The Fed.
Control of printing money, not on the gold standard. The Fed.
Its not our country folks, it hasn't been since 1913, when we turned over the constitutional controls of our money to the FED.A private global banking system.
So, surprise, we had to bail out the FED players. Whats funny is, in order to do it, we will have to borrow the money from, Guess who , THE FED.
Are you sick yet? Whats the definition of insanity?
How do you create a One World Order and One World currency?
Make all paper money worthless, and create a computer credit system for banking.
You make think that last statement is crazy, but because of the boom in computer technology and the internet, we are now ready for the financial meltdown of the existing money system.
Debit and credit cards will be our money.
E pluribus unum is a motto found on the Great Seal of the United States, along with Annuit cœptis and Novus ordo seclorum, and adopted by an Act of Congress ..
E Pluribus unum : Annuit coeptis : Novus ordo seclorum
Out of many, one : smile upon beginnings : New world of ages
Why did our founding Fathers give us the Constitution?
So that we the people 232 years later would cast it aside?
Build a powerful nation using the constitution as a tool for that end?
Was that the plan?
It would take one powerful nation to build a global new world order.
Maybe our founding fathers saw America as the leader of a New World Order.
Well, it worked, the constitution built the most powerful country in the world.
Based on a real free market system, the one the the FED slowly started to control since 1913.And a complicit congress has started to dismantle the constitution.
So the new Fascist America is born, hail to the New commander and chief.THE FEDERAL RESERVE.
They make our money, loan it out and have us pay for their failures.
And now the FED is the new world order, and the USA is the hired gun.
More Wars are coming, of that I have no doubt.
BornFreeMen
At the very bottom, the root cause is fractional reserve banking. This means that banks are allowed to loan more money than they have in reserve. This is of course, fraud, plain and simple. And it has been going on for about two centuries. We are about to reap what has been sown. Keep your powder dry.
-- EKATON --
“The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results”
Albert Einstein
FREE AMERICA
REVOLUTIONARY (DIRECT) DEMOCRACY
I'm trying to envision what all the upheaval might mean to those of us who have no equity. We go to work and live paycheck to paycheck. If we lose our work then we stuggling in poverty for a period of time until we get another job. These job are low paying and soul destroying. So, what else can happen? There'll be a few BMWs for sale but will our local governments pour money into public transit to assist the rich?
Mr. Schechter
At one point in your column you quote that goverment cannot prevent the economic Armagedon. Isn't that what FDR did so many years ago? If ever there was an elitist president, it was him. Is it truly impossible to do something like that again?
I was listenining to Thomm Hartmann's (sp?) program segment "Brunch with Bernie" this past Friday. A woman called to say words to the effect of 'not only should we not be ashamed of being "liberals" we should also re-embrace a policy of economic protectionism'. (I know the senator has a piece today in the "dream suite", but I haven't read it yet. I thought yours would be more on point.) The Senator ignored her plea for an economically fluid working force in America and moved the topic to universal healthcare.
The Chinese, you say, are demanding the world economy move off of a US currency based system. Can you blame them? What made us the basis for the world economy in the first place? There has been alot of talk about putting make-up on quadripedal animals during this campaign. I would like to remind you of an old nursery rhyme, which I'm sure you know:
"This little piggy went to the market.
This little piggy stayed home....."
Which of these two little piggies best describes the USA today? I await your thoughts.
One hundred and fifty years ago a political party was formed in America. It was "third party". It stood up against vested interests of a vast system of centuries old land ownership. It stood up against a vast wealth of natural resources. It also stood up against slavery and the unrepresentation of America's disadvantaged. It was called the "Republican" party. Isn't that ironic?
Thanks. I think I'll read Bernie's column now.
dene wonders--
"At one point in your column you quote that goverment cannot prevent the economic Armagedon. Isn't that what FDR did so many years ago? If ever there was an elitist president, it was him. Is it truly impossible to do something like that again?"
******************
That's a good question considering that so many of the problems we are now facing are the result of the rescinding of New Deal regulatory reforms. It is important to realize two things as we contemplate this disaster now unfolding:
1. Nobody has any clue of how many other shoes like Bear Stearns, Lehman Bros., and AIG are still waiting to drop. Mostly this is because nobody (including the firms affected) has any clue of how many hundreds of billions of fraudulent"assets" are still being carried on their books.
2. Our manufacturing base is gone, our resource base is gone, and now the value of our currency (pegged to our capacity to finance government operations through the selling of debt obligations known as t-bills) is quickly vanishing.
These problems FDR did not have.
This country is just about on the point of economic serfdom and very few are willing to face up to that reality.
Poet
Danny (as he usually does) strikes just the right note of urgency and thorough analysis to back up such urgency. We all need to stop squabbling among ourselves aqnd focus on punishing the criminal element on Wall Street, the administration, and the Congress (both houses, both parties). Where is Elliot Spitzer when we need him now?--how sad for him, his family, and us.
Poet
Spitzer was ok but only up to a point. He'd slap the wrongdoers with million dollar out of court settlements which were usually nothing compared to what these companies plundered. It's going to take more than Spitzer to clean up this mess and it won't happen overnight.
Agreed--but as a symbol he was important.
Poet
He was a nasty little dog, but very intelligent. I personally suspected that his demise was part of a house cleaning of oppositional feisty types in preparation for the elections.
Joe
Elliot Spitzer? Are we talking about the same Elliot Spitzer who brought eugenics theorists into the public policy in education hearings a few years ago when the state of New York was trying to rationalize its inattention to public school equity?
People will swallow any crap when a "democrat" generates it. Spitzer got what he had coming for being a low-life, and a racist running dog at that. Maybe when we stop thinking about political change in this country in terms of "saving the system" we'll have a political leadership that works with us instead of exploiting our stupider fears. Spitzer, were he still around, would be rationalizing with the rest of the rationalizers.
A bubble by definition is worthless debt. It is caused by speculation that goes far beyond the worth of the underlying wealth source (houses, tulips, slaves). There is no way to fix a bubble by speculating more. It only postpones the inevitable.
It's time to look beyond the crash and figure out a new way to live.
http://www.opednews.com/articles/Why-Save-Capitalism-by-wagelaborer-080920-685.html