Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Apple Inc. Launches Labor Conditions 'Audit' in China Factories
Computer giant Apple Inc, now the world's most valuable company, announced Monday that is has tasked the Fair Labor Association to conduct special voluntary audits of Apple’s final assembly suppliers, including Foxconn factories in Shenzhen and Chengdu, China, at Apple’s request. The audit comes in response to a growing outcry from human rights and labor activists who have protested conditions at Foxconn. Instrumental in the United States was a campaign was a Change.org campaign started by confessed Apple-lover Mark Shields after he learned of the deplorable conditions under which many Apple suppliers working in.
Apple has faced criticism over alleged abuses of workers at supplier Foxconn's Shenzhen plant. (Photograph: Bloomberg via Getty Images) A team of labor rights experts led by FLA president Auret van Heerden began the first inspections Monday morning at the facility in Shenzhen known as Foxconn City.
“We believe that workers everywhere have the right to a safe and fair work environment, which is why we’ve asked the FLA to independently assess the performance of our largest suppliers,” said Tim Cook, Apple’s CEO. “The inspections now underway are unprecedented in the electronics industry, both in scale and scope, and we appreciate the FLA agreeing to take the unusual step of identifying the factories in their reports.”
"As an Apple consumer, I'm relieved to hear that Tim Cook is taking this seriously and is breaking ground in the industry with Fair Labor Association auditing," Shields said in a statement. "But Apple still needs to use some of their trademark creativity and problem solving to create a worker protection plan for new products -- especially the upcoming iPad 3 -- so that they're proactively taking care of their workers."
The Toronto Sun reports today:
Apple's iPad. (Reuters/Luke MacGregor)
In the past, Foxconn, a mammoth electronics manufacturing company that has a million employees around the world, has come under scrutiny because of accidents as well as worker unrest. That includes employee suicides that made headlines in 2010.
Last month, as many as 150 Foxconn workers reportedly vowed they would jump from the roof of their plant in Wuhan, complaining of labor conditions, training and pay.
On Monday morning, FLA officials were allowed into a sprawling facility in Shenzhen, known as Foxconn City. Last year, company officials reportedly put in suicide nets at the workers' living quarters, as well as raising pay and shortening shifts.
And though the news was viewed as a step in the right direction by all, some were more cautious in their praise of the move, especially the role that the FLA has played in previous "audits".
Taren Stinebrickner-Kauffman, executive director of SumOfUs.org, told Wired in the UK, "We're hopeful that this is a step towards the solution, but it's not even close to the solution itself. The FLA does not have a great track record of conducting effective investigations." According to Wired:
... those looking for Apple (as well as other tech companies) to really change their ways, the FLA may not be the best company to perform these assessments, if its history is anything to go by.
Stinebrickner-Kauffman pointed out a site called FLA Watch that's dedicated to monitoring the company's well-publicized audits. It calls the FLA "a public relations mouthpiece" for corporations (particularly the apparel industry).
"The FLA was created in response to student protests around the sweatshop issue in the late 90s, specifically to monitor garment shops, with Nike as a founding member," Teresa Cheng, international campaigns coordinator with United Students Against Sweatshops (the organization behind FLA Watch), told Wired. "Ten years later, we see little to no reform of sweatshop conditions in Nike's supply chain, and no positive changes can be attributed to the FLA."
Another veteran of the garment industry backs up Cheng's opinion of audits.
"Reading that Apple has been auditing their vendors since 2006 does not mean anything," says Sindy Sagastume, production manager for a fashion company called Aimee Lynn, which imports clothing for distribution to US-based companies like Walmart, Target, and Sears. "Audits are truly a tool used by retailers in the US to make themselves seem to be socially compliant, but in fact does nothing to ensure factories are acting appropriately," Sagastume told Wired.
So how much teeth does the FLA really have behind its audits? The organization has developed a code of conduct with which it judges workplace conditions, but all it does is investigate and report on working conditions; it doesn't actually instigate any change itself. According to the organization's website: "The FLA is a brand accountability system that places the onus on companies to voluntarily achieve the FLA's labor standards in the factories manufacturing their products."
In other words: The FLA is a reporting agency, not a policing agency. Any real change for Foxconn workers will come from either Foxconn itself, pressure from the Chinese government, or Apple.
"This is at best a decent first step," echoed Stinebrickner-Kauffman of SumOfUs.org. "At worst, the beginning of a white-washing campaign."
# # #

29 Comments so far
Show AllWhat we need are quality products which last many years with interchangeable parts which fit both older and newer models, so they can be fixed instead of being constantly replaced in their entirety by the latest thing.
This applies to vehicles as well as all other appliances. Rare earths needed for computers and windmills and other techy stuff are just that - rare. China has refused to export any more, the USA has some, so does Russia, but all are getting rarer.
We need to re-think what we really need. My 10-year-old Dell desk-top, the cheap model which I had them load up with gigas, works fine.
Laptops might be needed for others, but people can buy just one and use it for a long time. This using up our scarce resources because people feel they need the latest thing is ludicrous and suicidal..
I did some research and I found a cell phone signal booster, and it turns out it works great. I went from barely one bar to 6. And guess what? This little electronic gem was made in the USA. Granted the company probably doesn't make 800% profit like Apple does, but the unit WAS affordable, and my guess is was made by people in this country under much better working conditions than those who assemble the iCrap in China for Apple.
The cost of transportation is almost nothing even with high oil. Think about it. You are buying pineapples and banannas that are being flown in and one pineapple weighs several iphones so the cost of flying them in is pennies on a $300 phone.
FWIW. I have an old desktop myself. I don't upgrade unless I need to. I do have an iPhone though and wouldn't hesitate to buy Apple at this point. I think they have done a very good job of self policing.
http://tinyurl.com/7unhovo
If you think Apple has done a good job of self-policing, you need to read this article. Actually, we all need to read this article:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/46143670/ns/business-us_business/#.TzrYyoEpBn-
And as for Apple, just like Wal-Mart, if they don't pay their contractors enough, those, in turn, can't pay their workers enough. If Apple really gave a damn, they'd pay a decent amount to the contractors for the goods being made, stipulate a fair wage for each worker and then 'audit' that.
There is an informative article about Apple, its policies and their effect on its suppliers in NYT:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/26/business/ieconomy-apples-ipad-and-the-...
"Voluntary Audits"
That's the entire story right there. With a 'voluntary audit' the company has the CHOICE to comply or not, with no penalty for NOT complying with the audit. This is just another Corporate 'feel good' PR dodge.
They're still milking that myth? Depending on who you believe, China's suicide rate is anywhere between 13 (China gov numbers) and 33 (Global Burden of Disease). But let's go with 22 (US CDC). At 1 million employees 14 suicides in 2010 brings the Foxconn suicide rate at 1.4 (per 100,000). If more Chinese would be emplyed by Foxconn their suicide rate would be 10x or 20x lower..
As for: "as many as 150 Foxconn workers reportedly vowed they would jump from the roof of their plant", it's not a suicide unless they actually do it. Even if they did, it would just bring the Foxconn suicide rate at the national level.
"Think Different"?
You be appear to be locked into the antique "blame the victim" mold. The Apple OS treats the user as a mental cretan. The only ones that proclaim their love of all things Apple are those that know nothing of the true computing power that can be unleashed when the consumer is allowed to control the OS.