Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Disney Factory Faces Probe into Sweatshop Suicide Claims
Human rights campaigners say Chinese factories using children as young as 14 and that workers forced to do overtime
Disney's best-selling Cars toys are being made in a factory in China that uses child labor and forces staff to do three times the amount of overtime allowed by law, according to an investigation.
One worker reportedly killed herself after being repeatedly shouted at by bosses. Others cited worries over poisonous chemicals. Disney has now launched its own investigation.
It is claimed some of the 6,000 employees have to work an extra 120 hours every month to meet demand from western shops for the latest toys.
The factory, called Sturdy Products, makes toys for the giant Mattel company, which last month announced quarterly profits of £48m on the back of strong sales of Barbie dolls and Cars 2 toys. Sturdy Products, in the city of Shenzhen, also makes toys for US superstore chain Walmart. Among the brands produced are the Thomas the Tank Engine range, Matchbox cars, Cars, Toy Story, Barbie and Fisher Price products, Scrabble and the Hot Wheels sets.
The undercover investigation was carried out with the help of human rights group Sacom (Students and Scholars Against Corporate Misbehavior), which helped to expose abuses in Apple's Foxconn plant in China this year.
Workers were interviewed away from the factory, and an investigator then spent a month working inside it to gather more information. He found evidence of the use of child labor and illegal working hours, along with concerns over the use of poisonous chemicals.
Sacom's accusations against the factory include:
■ The employment of a 14-year-old. Staff also reported the presence of other child workers, according to the investigator.
■ Routine excessive overtime. Employees produced a "voluntary" document they said they had to sign agreeing to work beyond the maximum overtime legal limit of 36 hours a month, along with wage slips that suggested they were averaging 120 hours of overtime a month.
■ A harsh working environment in which workers complained of mistreatment by management. One worker injured on the production line was shouted at and ordered back to work despite needing medical treatment.
■ Concerns about the chemicals in use and poor ventilation. Employees claimed three workers had fallen ill. They said they had to hide pots of adhesive and thinners during audits of the factory by its client companies.
■ They also claimed that they were paid by the factory to give misleading answers during audits and that they were fined for failing to hit targets. The calculation of wages for different workers was described by Sacom as arbitrary.
Concerns were raised about conditions at Sturdy Products when a 45-year-old female employee, Hu Nianzhen, jumped to her death from a factory building in May after she was allegedly shouted at by managers.
Colleagues subsequently described the environment in the factory as tense and complained about the demanding workload. "A female worker committed suicide," one said, "because she was always scolded. However, I feel helpless because it is not easy for me to find another job."
The allegations are sure to concern many parents whose children are pestering them to buy the extensive range of Cars 2 toys launched to coincide with the movie, which hit UK cinema screens in July. Cars 2 has so far grossed £303m worldwide, overtaking the original movie despite being panned by critics. The poor reviews have not hindered sales of the merchandise, which Disney expects to exceed the £1.7bn spent last year on Toy Story 3 merchandise. Cars 2 toys will compete with Transformers and Smurfs items as the must-have Christmas toys.
But Sacom said that parents should think twice before buying the toys. A spokeswoman said: "Mattel, Walmart and Disney, the renowned toy companies, always claim they strictly comply with local laws and adhere to their respective code of conduct. The rampant violations at Sturdy Products, including excessive overtime, arbitrary wages, unfair punitive fines, child labor and negligence of occupational health, prove that the pledges are empty statements. There is no effective enforcement mechanism and remedies for workers at all."
She said the violations exposed the failings of the International Council of Toy Industries, which is supposed to police the industry.
"Consumers could never expect that the lovely toys which bring joy to children are manufactured in such deplorable conditions. They should convey messages to toy companies including Mattel, Walmart and Disney to launch remedial actions to compensate the wronged workers. Without remedies, there is no cost for labor rights violations."
She said the companies should already have been aware of the dangers of dealing with Sturdy Products after a previous investigation in 2007 uncovered similar problems. That investigation also found a six-day working week, with staff working up to 288 hours a month. During peak periods there was a compulsory seven-day week and the company was found to be failing to pay the minimum wage. Investigators said that some employees had attempted to raise awareness of the abuses by setting up their own group to inspire colleagues to fight for their rights.
Sturdy Products' parent company, Winson, failed to respond to requests to discuss the allegations.
Walmart issued a statement in which it said: "As soon as we learned of the allegations of human rights abuses at the Sturdy Products factory, we immediately launched an investigation. We are also in contact with the International Council of Toy Industries, a worldwide toy industry organization that is also investigating this issue. We take reports like this very seriously and we will implement a corrective action plan if our investigations confirm any of the findings.
"We remain committed to sourcing merchandise that is produced responsibly by suppliers that adhere to Walmart's rigorous Standards for Suppliers code of conduct."
Disney said: "We take these matters impacting our licensees and business partners very seriously and will continue to evaluate this situation based upon the information available to us."
Mattel declined to comment directly on any of the allegations other than to note that the company was "deeply saddened" by the suicide but that, while it was "very tragic", it was an isolated event and local authorities had found nothing suspicious about the circumstances.
The company said it had carried out a detailed investigation. It said it was committed to working collaboratively through the International Council of Toy Industries' Care (Caring, Awareness, Responsible, Ethical) process "to achieve continuous improvements in factory working conditions".
Sacom's findings brought a rebuke from the International Council of Toy Industries' Care Foundation. "We are the first to concede that much more work lies ahead of us, but we refuse to accept the sensationalist, media-oriented declarations of any group, especially when they are carping and filled with incorrect information. It is simply counter-productive," the foundation said.
"The plain truth is that workers in many toy factories in China are better off now than they were before and that this is due in considerable part to the ICTI Care Process."

20 Comments so far
Show AllIf Disney's goods really bring sincere or authentic happiness to a child, then I would hate to see what the rest of that child's life is like. It must be a total and complete superficial, vacuous hell.
"Humans have free will"
Great!
I was born on this planet and by birthright should have access to clean air, water, and land. Can I please have that? Because my free will is that I do not want to work for or have anything to do with obscene, immoral corporations or obsene, immoral people...
My free will is that I want to live in the wilderness, or maybe on the ocean somewher. I want to have access to fresh, clean, unpolluted streams and waterways. I want to grow my own food and build my own shelter and be free from the loudness of modern technology and bloviating humans.
Yeah, free will works well in a tyrannical, oligarchal, capitalist world. Just ask all of the indigenous people!
Whoa! Bloviator! Well named for what blows out of your mind. It stinks.
I take strong exception to the first and last sentences!It ought to read "its merchandise" and "its many media outlets".And the closing sentence should read "...too high".Otherwise, you have a point. You don't make a Happiest Place On Earth omelet without breaking a few eggs.
It seems that outsourcing is not only bad for the US, but also China. Disney, Ignorance is no excuse, assuming you are ignorant.
It is an exercise in contemplation of what this represents in all its dimensions - to move through the marketing on this scale. It is also a commentary on Disney perception of parent - child relationships to watch their advertising :
http://www.disneystore.com/
So its strike two on Disney, undermining democracy along with Levi Jeans in Haiti, a compliant US supported puppet government squelching freedom to create cheap sweatshop labor. Quit buying Mattel and teach your kids about slave labor, they'll cheerfully help abolish slavery, even if most adults won't.
I don't let my son watch most Disney crap. It is hard to avoid it all. He was into Thomas the tank engine - did not know it was Disney. Had to return half of it for lead in the paint! when my son was two! Haven't bought Chinese toys since then. If my nine year old knew of the abuse of children and their parents making these things, he would boycott too.
Bloviator needs to put a gun to his/her temple, bend over and kiss his/her sweet ass goodbye.
I am not a bit surprised by this story. The name of the game in America these days is corporate greed, selfishness and corruption. We almost have a plutocracy on our hands. Our politicians have been pimped out by these corporate monsters. No one cares about the American people, they need to wake the hell up.
Dr. Hibbert of The Simpsons --
"Well, only one in two million people has what we call the evil gene. Hitler had it. Walt Disney had it. And Freddy Quimby has it."
I can't imagine anything more heinous than using child labor to sell products to children. Maybe if the Disney Corp. killed the children afterward and served their flesh in Happy Meals.
Almost as appalling, in my view, is the very idea of marketing products to children. Sut Jhally of the Media Education Foundation considers it a form of child abuse akin to pedophilia. Why? Because marketers are essentially preying on a child's developmental vulnerabilities. It's sick, sick stuff.
Well, look at the bright side. Now that we have millions out of work, many begging to try to feed their family, the unions destroyed, the banksters rewarded with trillions of secret loans by the Fed. Soon they will be able to bring the sweatshops home to America and save shipping costs!
Lots of homeless hungry families here that will work 120 hour weeks to try to feed their families; lots of hungry kids who would work in the factories and sweatshops to just try to stay alive.
We are rapidly returning to the "Gilded Age" where the obscenely wealthy rode from party to party and occasionally tossed dimes to watch the poor scramble for them.
Is it the Walt Deathly Company now?
I have a friend who is a toy designer, or was a toy designer in Hong Kong. The demands of the mega-corporations were such that he couldn't make even a one HK dollar profit per item. One HKD is worth about thirteen US cents. They force the rates down and honest people who won't exploit the factory workers, who want good quality materials and quality control, quit because they can't do it for what they are told they will be paid. The only ones who stay in business are those who are willing to comply. The demands are coming from the multi-national corporations. After all, those are the ones with all the leverage.
"Sacom's findings brought a rebuke from the International Council of Toy Industries' Care Foundation. "We are the first to concede that much more work lies ahead of us, but we refuse to accept the sensationalist, media-oriented declarations of any group, especially when they are carping and filled with incorrect information. It is simply counter-productive," the foundation said.
"The plain truth is that workers in many toy factories in China are better off now than they were before and that this is due in considerable part to the ICTI Care Process.""
The plain truth really is no one really believes the ICTI is interested in anything but continuing to conduct business as "usual". You know slave owners used to make those same claims about how well their slaves were living. The only thing the "Care Process" cares about is the bottom line.
---Employees produced a "voluntary" document they said they had to sign agreeing to work beyond the maximum overtime legal limit of 36 hours a month, along with wage slips that suggested they were averaging 120 hours of overtime a month."---
Heck, a lot of working-class USAn's work more "overtime" than that - and usually without overtime pay becasue they work multiple jobs or are considered a "1099 contractor" by their bosses. But at least the pay is a bit better.
Recall the recent incident at the Hersheys factory, where foreign exchange students (including kids from the new Chinese middle class) came under a program Hershey participates in where students can learn about the US from real USAn workplaces. They were pressed into sweatshop-like pay, hours, and working conditions. They staged a strike and protest over their treatment - but the USAn workers doing the same work under the same conditions apparently just looked on - confused at the fuss of these foreign kids, then went back to work.
From what I know about Chinese manufacturing, I cringe at the toxic volatile compounds these plastic toys probably give off.
So tired of the "evil Multi-national corporation" argument. That's so 1990's. Two points not mentioned...first, there are plenty of labor issues in the US. If you're going to stop buying toys made in China, have you stopped buying vegetables and fruit in the US? Still drink orange juice made with oranges picked by itinerant workers? Not to mention all of the other allegations of abuse in animal production...still eat chicken and pork and beef? What was it that Jesus said, "Hypocrite! First get rid of the log in your own eye; then you will see well enough to deal with the speck in your friend’s eye! "
Second, the real issue is the expectation of the middle class consumer. Believe it or not, companies and corporations are just filling the needs of the consumer. You want toys made in the US? Great...you can find them, but are you willing to pay 2-3x as much as you do now? If the demand was there, so would the supply. You want affordable clothes and shoes? When they were made in the US years ago, there were sweatshops here too. Labor costs are a huge variable in product cost. And you want them made by union workers? Ha ha. You think we had a credit crisis already...who could afford housing if everything else cost 3x more? Remember, Walmart used to use the Made In America slogan until costs got out of hand. Unless you are WILLING to pay more for everything, look in the mirror when you want someone to blame.
---"Labor costs are a huge variable in product cost."---
Actually, I have heard that the labor cost in a typical brand-name shirt or pants is on the order of a few pennies to the dollar. The major cost is promotion and advertizing, transportation, union avoidance lawyers and consultants, and the multi-million dollar salaries of the upper management, and lots of pure profit.
---"When they were made in the US years ago, there were sweatshops here too."---
Your knowlege of recent US labor history is terrible. It wasn't that long ago (1970's) that all Levis jeans, many brands of shirts, and the cloth and cotton thread they made from, were were union-made in the US in textile and apparel plants - particularly throughout the Carolinas and mid-south, providing many thousands of living-wage jobs. I don't recall any consumer complaints about the cost, nor a consumer clamor to bust the unions and ship the jobs to Honduras or Vietnam. And, I don't recall the price of jeans going down after this was done. These are business decisions, for which the consumer has no say whatsoever.
---"Believe it or not, companies and corporations are just filling the needs of the consumer."---
Actually, beyond perhaps some basic necessities, this is not true. Consumer desire (along with political opinion and consent) is manufactured through modern mass psychology-based advertizing methods, as formulated by Edward Bernays in the 1920's. You should read up on him.
when we reach the planet's end, and stand around, looking at the devastation we have wrought, Christmas will hold much of the blame...