Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
The Iraq Debacle: The Legacy of Seven Years of War
We, the undersigned organizations and individuals, mark the August 31st partial withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq with the following evaluation and recommendations:
- The U.S. occupation of Iraq continues and the reduction of U.S. troops in Iraq can at best be called only a rebranded occupation. While the number of U.S. troops in Iraq will be reduced from a high of 165,000, there will still be 50,000 troops left behind, some 75,000 contractors, five huge "enduring bases" and an Embassy the size of Vatican City.
- The U.S. military's overthrow of the brutal dictatorship of Saddam Hussein did not lead to a better life for Iraqis-just the opposite. It resulted in the further destruction of basic infrastructure-electricity, water, sewage-that continues to this day. The U.S. dropped more tons of bombs on Iraq than in all of WWII, destroying Iraq's electrical, water and sewage systems. Iraq's health care and higher education systems, once the best in the entire region, have been decimated. The U.S. war on Iraq unleashed a wave of violence that has left over one million Iraqis dead and four million displaced, as well as ethnic rivalries that continue to plague the nation. We have seriously wounded millions of Iraqis, creating a lifetime of suffering and economic hardship for them, their communities and the entire nation as it struggles to rebuild. Life expectancy for Iraqis fell from 71 years in 1996 to 67 years in 2007 due to the war and destruction of the healthcare system. The U.S. use of weapons such as depleted uranium and white phosphorous has taken a severe toll, with the cancer rate in Fallujah, for example, now worse than that of Hiroshima.
- The majority of the refugees and internally displaced persons created by the US intervention have been abandoned. Of the nearly 4 million refugees, many are now living in increasingly desperate circumstances in Syria, Jordan, Lebanon and around the world. As undocumented refugees, most are not allowed to work and are forced to take extremely low paying, illegal jobs ($3/day) or rely on the UN and charity to survive. The United Nations refugee agency (UNHCR) has documented a spike in the sex trafficking of Iraqi women.
- Iraq still does not have a functioning government. Many months after the March 7 elections, there is still a political vacuum and violence that is killing roughly 300 civilians a month. There is no functioning democracy in place and little sign there will be one in the near future.
- The Iraq War has left a terrible toll on the U.S. troops. More than one million American service members have deployed in the Iraq War effort. Over 4,400 U.S. troops have been killed and tens of thousands severely injured. More than one in four U.S. troops have come home from the Iraq war with health problems that require medical or mental health treatment. PTSD rates in the military have skyrocketed. In 2009, a record number of 245 soldiers committed suicide.
- The war has drained our treasury. As of August 2010, U.S. taxpayers have spent over $750 billion on the Iraq War effort. Counting the cost of lifetime care of wounded vets and the interest payments on the money we borrowed to pay for this war, the real cost will be in the trillions. This misappropriation of funds has contributed to the economic crises we are experiencing, including the lack of funds for our schools, healthcare, infrastructure and investments in clean, green jobs.
- The U.S. officials who got us into this disastrous war on the basis of lies have not been held accountable. Not George Bush, Dick Cheney, Condoleezza Rice, Colin Powell, Karl Rove, Donald Rumsfeld. No one. Neither have the Bush administration lawyers who authorized torture, including Jay Bybee and John Yoo. The "think tanks," journalists and pundits who perpetuated the lies have not been fired-most are today cheerleading for the war in Afghanistan.
- The war has led to the pillaging of Iraqi resources and institutionalization of corruption. The U.S. Department of Defense has been unable to account for $8.7 billion of Iraqi oil and gas money meant for humanitarian needs and reconstruction after the 2003 invasion. The invasion has also led to the erosion of Iraqi government control over the nation's oil. In 2001, Vice President Dick Cheney's energy task force, which included executives of America's largest energy companies, recommended opening up areas of their energy sectors to foreign investment. The resulting draft Iraq Oil Law threatens global grab for Iraq's resources as the international oil cartel seeks to reestablish its control. Adoption of the oil law, however, has been stymied by stiff popular resistance, foremost by the oil workers and their union.
- The war has not made us more secure. The US policy of torture, extraordinary rendition, indefinite detention, violent and deadly raids on civilian homes, gunning down innocent civilians in the streets and absence of habeas corpus has fueled the fires of hatred and extremism toward Americans. The very presence of our troops in Iraq and other Muslim nations has become a recruiting tool.
Given the above, we, the undersigned individuals and
organizations, mark the occasion of this troop withdrawal
by calling on the Administration and Congress to take
the following actions:
- Withdrawal of all U.S. troops and military contractors from Iraq and the closing of all U.S. bases;
- Reparations to help the Iraqis repair their basic infrastructure and increased funds for the millions of internally and externally displaced Iraqis;
- Full support for the U.S. troops who suffer from the internal and external wounds of war;
- Prosecution of those officials responsible for dragging our country into this disaster;
- Transfer of funds from war into resources to rebuild America, with a focus on green jobs.
- The lessons of this disastrous intervention should also be an impetus for Congress and the administration to end the war in Afghanistan. It's time to focus on creating real security here at home and rebuilding America.
To be listed as an Individual
Signatory to above statement please
click here.
To have your organization
listed below email
us:
- Bay Area Labor Committee for Peace & Justice
- CODEPINK: Women for Peace
- Community Organizing Center
- Courage to Resist
- Fellowship of Reconciliation
- Global Exchange
- Institute for Policy Studies' New Internationalism Project
- Iraq Veterans Against the War
- Jeannette Rankin Peace Center
- Just Foreign Policy
- Military Families Speak Out
- Pax Christi - USA
- Under the Hood
- US Labor Against the War
- Veterans for Peace
- Voices for Creative Nonviolence
- Voters for Peace
- War Is a Crime

11 Comments so far
Show AllBravo -- One friendly amendment, in all caps for identification:
The U.S. officials who got us into this disastrous war on the basis of lies, PROTECT THOSE WHO DID SO, AND/OR CONTINUE TO KEEP US THERE ON THE BASIS OF FURTHER LIES have not been held accountable. Not George Bush, Dick Cheney, Condoleezza Rice, Colin Powell, Karl Rove, Donald Rumsfeld. NOT BARACK OBAMA. NOT THOSE OF HIS ADMINISTRATION WHO PERPETUATE WAR CRIMES BEGUN BY OTHERS, AND COMMIT NEW ONES OF THEIR OWN. No one. Neither have the Bush administration lawyers who authorized torture, including Jay Bybee and John Yoo. The "think tanks," journalists and pundits who perpetuated the lies have not been fired-most are today cheerleading for the war in Afghanistan.
I don't see a single legacy on that list that anyone could disagree with.
And almost all the actions listed are correct.
Click and sign!
I might become a Code Pink fan if they keep this direction.
I agree. Medea Benjamin's argument has really started to become more concise and on topic. The screech tone of "hang Cheney by his toes or nothing"; so prevalent(and threatening to outsiders) in so many sectors of the anti-war(thus not peace) movement, is more effectively diffused here, thus strengthening the force and seriousness of the rest of the argument.
Code Pink Rocks !
while we babble and blog, blog and babble, real power continues to consolidate itself and prepare the future...
AFP
NEW YORK — The former US commander in Afghanistan who was forced to retire after making scathing comments to a magazine about the Barack Obama administration will take a teaching position at Yale, the university announced Monday…."General (Stanley) McChrystal will be a senior fellow with the Jackson Institute," university spokeswoman Dorie Baker told AFP.
...The Jackson Institute opened this year after a 50-million-dollar gift to the university. The center will offer coursework for Yale students interested in diplomatic service or careers with international agencies or nongovernmental organizations
McChrystal will teach alongside such well-known faculty as former Mexican president Ernesto Zedillo and former UN ambassador John Negroponte.
CODEPINK & others: Thank you for your efforts.
The U.S. media acts like a band. After it plays a tune or two, it moves on. Unfortunately, much of the public (along with its limited attention span) follows.
Just as Obama advised that there was no need to look back, thus giving criminals in high places the nod of impunity, many Americans now believe that Iraq is a stable place. Citizens are clueless as to the levels of loss that took place and just how much continues to reverberate.
Note that similar PR tactics are being used to deceive Americans that our own Gulf Crisis is safely behind us. Open the drift nets, send those shrimpers back into the foul waters and presto! Everything is fine! Eat up!
When perception on a massive scale can be so easily directed by the media conductor's baton, then genuine solutions become extranenous. It's all about perception control. "Don't worry. Be happy," style.
did you happen to listen to THE ED SCHULTZ RADIO SHOW? Errol Lewis, a self styled Progessive was filling in.
a caller brought up the illegality of the invasion and theft of the oil. Errols riposte was thus:(not verbatim) yeah i've heard this moral outrage stuff before, i just don't get it...really it's just two Brooklyn crime bosses going at it...i mean i'm no fan of Saddams tyranny and frankly i'm not sorry he's gone...and lets face it if you want the quality of life you have, you have to support overseas troops because we need the shipping lanes to be kept open so you can continue to get your kumquats...from where ever they come from...
i submit to you..this is a bad sign...
I can sign on to the substance of Code Pink if not some of its rhetoric.
Code Pink, and the other horizontal groups, historically play an important role in American politics if they move from "protest to politics." Politics means far more than electing the right people and defeating the wrong people. It means getting your ideas accepted. It also means working with people who don't always have your perspective.
It also means listening, a quality that if it is lacking renders you ineffective. I hope Code Pink and allies start by listening to Representative Jim McGovern (D-Mass) who has provided real leadership on anti-war issues. Code Pink, and its allies, have to turn their agenda into one that wins the day politically.
David Cohen
Washington, DC
The Feds are too busy indicting a baseball player for lying to Congress about steroids to go after the real criminals--war criminals, that is-- like George W. Bush for lying to Congress about WMD, resulting in an insane war of aggression that killed hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians. Roger Clemens' penalty for his misdemeanor offense is a Federal Indictment. Bush's penalty for destroying Iraq and our own country is a $200,000 annual pension and lifetime Secret Service protection. Now there's good old fashioned American justice for ya.
I am an opinion columnist for the Athens Banner-Herald newspaper (onlineathens.com) in Athens, Georgia. Since 1974 I have covered protest marches and rallies in Washington, New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, Atlanta and here in Athens. In 2004 I was arrested and jailed in New York while covering a nonviolent antiwar protest during the Republican National Convention in that city. In a letter to the editor published in the April 30, 2007 edition of The New York Times, I said that I considered my arrest and the 30 hours I spent in New York jails to be an occupational hazard and a badge of honor. Please visit my website, www.edtant.com, to see my protest photos and my writings on a wide variety of subjects. No matter which political party occupies the White House, America always needs a protest movement.
ED TANT, www.edtant.com
I take issue with the last bulleted item. The invasion of Iraq was never meant to make us more secure. It was designed from the beginning--starting with the Project for a New American Century (1999-I think)--to destabilize the Middle East, disrupt the status quo, and make that part of the world safer for Israel. American concerns--other than using her enormous military might--never entered into the equation. Clinton didn't buy it. Bush, rendered more stupid than he already was by 9/11, did.
I still believe Obama will get us out completely by the end of 2012. And if he can foster a genuinely satisfactory two state solution we may not have to abandon that big embassy. But that's some wishful thinking. Not magical, just wishful.