Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Beeline to Extinction
According to the recently released annual survey by the Apiary Inspectors of America (AIA) and the Agricultural Research Service
(ARS), more than a third of U.S. managed honeybee colonies-those set up
for intensified pollination of commercial crops-failed to survive this
past winter. Since 2006, the decline of the U.S.'s estimated 2.4
million beehives-commonly referred to as colony collapse disorder
(CCD)-has led to the disappearance of hundreds of thousands of
colonies: Hives are found empty with honey, larvae, and the queen
intact, but with no bees and no trail left behind. The cause remains
unknown, but appears to be a combination of factors impacting bee
health and increasing their susceptibility to disease. Heavy losses
associated with CCD have been found mainly with larger migratory
commercial beekeepers, some of whom have lost 50-90 percent of their
colonies.
A "keystone" species-one that has a disproportionate effect on the environment relative to its biomass-bees are our key to global food security and a critical part of the food chain. Flowering plants that produce our food depend on insects for pollination. There are other pollinators-butterflies, moths, beetles, flies, and birds-but the honeybee is the most effective, pollinating over 100 commercial crops nationwide, including most fruit, vegetables, and nuts, as well as alfalfa for cattle feed and cotton, with a value estimated between $15-$20 billion annually. As much as one of every three bites of food we eat comes from food pollinated by insects. Without honeybees, our diet would be mostly meatless, consisting of rice and cereals, and we would have no cotton for textiles. The entire ecosystem and the global food economy potentially rests on their wings.
Experts now believe bees are heading for extinction and are racing to pinpoint the culprit, increasingly blaming pesticide usage. U.S. researchers have reported finding 121 different pesticides in samples of bees, wax, and pollen. New parasites, pathogens, fungi, and poor nutrition stemming from intensive farming methods are also part of the equation. Three years ago, U.S. scientists unraveled the genetic code of the honeybee and uncovered the DNA of a virus transmitted by the Varroa mite-Israeli acute paralysis virus (IAPV)-found in almost all of the hives impacted by CCD. Researchers have also found the fungus Nosema ceranae and other pathogens such as chalkbrood in some affected hives throughout the country. Other reported theories include the effects of shifting spring blooms and earlier nectar flow associated with broader global climate and temperature changes, the effects of feed supplements from genetically modified crops, such as high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS), and the effects of cell phone transmissions and radiation from power lines that may be interfering with a bee's navigational capabilities. (Last year, a study revealed that a contaminant from heat-exposed HFCS might be killing off the bees.) However, according to a recent congressional report on CCD, contributions of these possible factors have not been substantiated.
The industrial bee business and the demands of intensified food production could also be playing a role in the bees' demise. Widespread migratory stress brought about by increased needs for pollination could be weakening the bees' immune systems. Most pollination services are provided by commercial migratory beekeepers who travel from state to state and provide pollination services to crop producers. These operations are able to supply a large number of bee colonies during the critical phase of a crop's bloom cycle, when bees pollinate as they collect nectar. A hive might make five cross-country truck trips each year, chasing crops, and some beekeepers can lose up to 10 percent of their queens during one cross country trip. Bees are overworked and stressed out.
California's almond crop is a prime example of our reliance on bees' industriousness for our agriculture success. The state grows 80 percent of the world's almonds, making it our largest agricultural export and bringing in a whopping $1.9 billion last year. The crop-with nearly 740,000 acres of almond trees planted-uses 1.3 million colonies of bees, approximately one half of all bees in the U.S., and is projected to grow to 1.5 million colonies. The U.S. Department of Agriculture is now predicting that Central Valley almond growers will produce about 1.53 billion pounds of almonds this year, up 8.5 percent last year. To meet the demand, bee colonies are trucked farther and more often than ever before and demand for bees has dramatically outstripped supply. Bee colonies, which a decade ago rented for $60, cost as much as $170 this February in California.
Few organic beekeepers have reported bee losses, suggesting that natural and organic bee keeping methods may be the solution. In addition, organic farmers who maintain wildlife habitat around their farms are helping to encourage bees to pollinate their crops. "The main difference between our farm and our conventional neighbors is the amount of wildlife and insect habitat that we have around the edge of our farm," said Greg Massa, who manages Massa Organics, a fourth generation 90-acre certified organic rice farm near Chico. Massa started growing organic almonds six years ago, and works with a small, organic beekeeper in Oregon who brings in 30 hives to his farm. Massa's farm has a large wildlife corridor which has been revegetated with native plants and covered in mustard, wild radish, and vetch, a favorite of bees and also a good nitrogen source for his rice crop.
Time might be running out for the bees, but there are simple actions we can take to make a difference. First, support organic farmers who don't use pesticides and whose growing methods work in harmony with the natural life of bees. In particular, buy organic almonds. Don't use pesticides in your home garden, especially at mid-day when bees most likely forage for nectar. You can also plant good nectar sources such as red clover, foxglove, bee balm, and other native plants to encourage bees to pollinate your garden. Provide clean water; even a simple bowl of water is beneficial. Buy local honey; it keeps small, diversified beekeepers in business, and beekeepers keep honeybees thriving. In addition, you can start keeping bees yourself. Backyard and urban beekeeping can actively help bring back our bees. Finally, you can work to preserve more open cropland and rangeland. Let's use our political voices to support smart land use, the impact of which will not only result in cleaner water, soil, and air, but also just might help save the humble honeybee.
- Posted in



62 Comments so far
Show AllFrogs too are disappearing.
Frogs are the better sentinel species for biodiversity in general, and have been disappearing for decades, unfolding for us the reality of the sixth global exinction event. Honeybees are sentinels for the immediate decline of industrial agriculture.
The author has oversimplified things a bit, lumping all bees in as honeybees. If domesticated honeybees go extinct, there will be a niche to fill and surviving insect species to fill it. Plants will still be pollinated, but not at the intense rates required for industrial agriculture.
This is not the end of the world (nor is the sixth extinction, though it may be the end of the age of mammals), but will be a contributing factor in the coming--and in my opinion--inevitable human population crash.
I would add small bird species to your sentinel species...birds like Starlings for example.
Interesting comment! Small, migratory songbirds are also disappearing, as you point out. Years ago, when I was in school as a field biologist, one of the hypothoses to account for the reduction in migratory songbirds in the U.S. was that deforestation of the wintering grounds in Latin and South America produced increased mortality over winter, and reduced fitness for the migration back north in the spring. I know, as a trained birder in Michigan, I witnessed the decline between the late 70s and late 80s. Early in my career, I could go to Point Pelee in Ontario and identify up dozens of species per hour. As the years passed, the numbers decreased.
I don't know if you're in the U.S. or not, but Starlings epitomize the blight of invasive species over here. They have been wildly successful in North America since their introduction from Europe. Not that they don't deserve to succeed, mind you, but if Starlings are sentinels over here, everything seems dandy!
Not around my house. I was pleased by the sounds of large numbers of chorus frogs this year around my house. Last year I was lucky or was the frog lucky that I fished out of the rain bucket. It was the first frog I had caught in years. It's nice to be able to catch a frog every now and then. As a child in the 70's they were easy to find. They aren't easy to find anymore but from the sounds this spring they are a lot of them nearby. I've only lived in my location for three years but each year the the beneficial organisms seem to be increasing. I'm seeing increased numbers of lacewings this year too. I hope I see increased numbers of mantises and hummingbirds too.
Monoculture is the cause of the bee 'problem'. I don't notice the decline of bee populations out here in the desert. We have to wean ourselves from monoculture. It is the corporate answer to farming, and is a disaster. This country should have tens of thousands of small to moderately sized farms, growing a variety of plants, not to mention fish and fowl and bees and other fauna. Farming should be about raising healthy food for healthy people, not about the bottom line and profits.
The other upside to what you are suggesting George is the reduced need for long distance shipping/trucking. Along with monculture comes increased reliance on cheap oil products. Some products would still require shipping during the various seasonal periods but it could be greatly reduced.
Local bee colonies in my area seem to be just fine also. We have an abundance of locally grown organic honey products. My wife and I also have a vegetable and herb garden along with ever growing flower gardens. We do not use pescticides, there are many natural things that can be used to discourage pests and many weeds. My wife plants marigolds in the vegetable garden for example.
The other by-product of monoculture is laziness. Pull weeds out by hand you say? Well...I never.
Marigolds are great on the perimeter of a garden. Then have a stinky oil that critters don't want to use as cologne.
Another great method to reduce insect damage is companion planting. All the usual suspects show up, but never achieve population explosions. Looks great too. Mimics natural systems, like prairie.
No such thing as weeds. They are volunteer mulch material.
Native bees fine in northern Il on the edge of the Cook County Forest Preserves.
I grow lots of marigolds. They're supposed to suppress harmful nematodes. I've noticed personally that they repel grubs (japan beetle and june bug larvae). I never find any grubs in the areas I grow marigolds. I should try planting the perimeter with marigolds. I've started a perimeter of wormwood but it is far from complete. One thing I've read about marigolds is that they're supposed to repel white flies but in my experience they seem to attract them.
I do the companion planting. I have large numbers of parasitic wasps and flies that used to be a nuisance to me at times but now they are too busy with the flowers to pay any attention to me. The year before last I saw an interesting example of companion planting and nature working. I left radishes growing, that didn't form a good root, as a sacrificial crop. They were attacked by large numbers of harlequin bugs. Then I started noticing birds fly away from the radish plants every time I walked out to the garden. Before the plants were completely destroyed by the bugs the birds practically wiped out the massive numbers of harlequin bugs. It was a pretty cool example of nature doing it's work. This year the Colorado potato bugs are feasting on the amaranth. I'm not too worried about the leaves but I hope they don't eat the seed. I haven't figured out what I should try to do to limit their numbers. Maybe the birds will get them and I need to see what other insects might eat the potato bugs.
This year I should have some new flowers. I'm trying to grow some bee balm and painted daisies. The shasta daisies I planted last year look like they will flower profusely this year. I also started lupines and foxglove and so far I'm struggling with four o'clocks. Two new varieties of sunflowers are being added to the garden this year. Maybe next year I'll have every type of flower I'd like to grow.
"No such thing as weeds. They are volunteer mulch material."
That's something I can't really agree with. I've tried it but the seed makes a real mess the next year. I started using newspaper covered with tree leaves. I don't really like composting weeds either. I'm not diligent enough with compost to get the necessary heat to kill the seed. The soil I got out of the compost pile this year sprouted mass quantities of tomatoes and squash. If I had weeds seeds in it I'd be slightly mad at myself.
old saying- you have to get weeds before they know they're weeds. Never let them go to seed. The wind will bring in enough as it is. Mustards are the latest of the exotic invaders plaguing the upper midwest, garlic and pepper types.
I used to have a three foot wide barrier of marigolds surrounding the garden. They were left to dry standing and come spring, a quick trip with a tiller crunched and seeded them. I quit using power equipment over a decade ago, but it is easy enough to pinch seed heads and store in a paper bag.
Good gardening to you
I hear you. But are the politicians listening? Not really. They are all too caught up in the snares of the corporate structure through which they try and accommodate solutions. Sometimes solutions do not even enter the paradigm for the sake of the preservation of the political corporate structure. What we have here is a structural flaw in terms of the relationship between industry and government. Just look at the oil disaster in the gulf and how cumbersome and ineffective the "system" is proving to be in mitigating the damage.
We are currently in the fifth greatest period of loss of biodiversity and the corporate structure is to blame. But most Americans don't seem to care. It's really sickening. Subsidies for endless war and financial swindlers and big agribusiness but none to build up the natural infrastructures such as local farming networks so desperately needed to rekindle the biodiversity essential for a healthy ecology. All this talk of endless war and constant policing gets all the attention and funding. Meanwhile small farmers are left to fend for themselves at the mercies of big agribusiness and their enablers. But you won't hear about it in the news. It's just not as important as say Lindsay Lohan's whereabouts...
George,
You have to look at monoculture from another perspective: European honeybees are a monoculture. We have relied too much on this single species for pollination and food. We should be working to introduce new pollinators, native bees that are, perhaps less social, but still can do the job. Fencerows planted with trees and shrubs can supply homes for them, though thousand acre orchards are not amenable to this solution. European honeybees were not known in the Western Hemisphere before white settlement. No wonder they are prone to viruses, mites, and various other assaults, man-made or natural--all large populations of any organism--even humans--are subject to parasites, disease, and predators.
I think there were no honeybees in my part of the country (California) before 1850 or so. It was encouraging a few year back to read of the resurgence of native species (due to the decline in honeybee populations), but I haven't heard much more about it.
Of course, the grasses which now compose the "golden hills" of California in the Sierra foothills are also mostly intruders, not to mention many crops and the ubiquitous and highly annoying starthistle (which honeybees love.)
Sorry, small farms do not have millions of dollars to hire lobbyists and corrupt congress in whatever way. They are into growing food not growing influence. I know it's a silly concept - growing food in a natural way but some people still try to do it.
"Monoculture is the cause of the bee 'problem'."
I think that's a huge part. The industrial apiarists truck millions of bees hither and yon and surely it must have an effect on them.
It seems reasonable to also target all kinds of pollution as another main cause. I also wonder about the kind of things we don't even realize that may affect bees, such as electromagnetic fields. So much we don't know, but I think there is enough we can surmise and act on.
And I agree completely about small, organic farming. As well, as the author mentioned, sowing bee-friendly plants also helps. For those with no land, some guerilla seed bombing is a great thing to do!
"...bees are our key to global food security and a critical part of the food chain."
Will there be any national security once food security is gone?
This is another example of what some refer to as the "rivet theory" - an airplane can fly ok with a few rivets missing; lose too many key rivets, and whammo! The plane crashes. Frogs and bees are just two examples of rivets popping out of our wings. Ocean fisheries are being exterminated, over-production and drought are killing farmland world-wide; GMO crops are cross-pollinating with the real stuff; weeds and pests are immune to the high-powered poisons in wide use. Yikes. Rivets aren't just falling out - they're being yanked out - for profit.
"Rivets aren't just falling out - they're being yanked out - for profit."
interesting comment...you make me think of any one of several games I had as a child...
spill the beans, jenga, the one where you hammered out blocks of plastic ice, or pulled pieces from a spring-loaded trap...
in each case, the idea is to try to perform the action without crossing the tipping point...
as the conditions come ever closer to critical, there is a time when there is no longer a correct, or intelligent, choice, but fate takes over, and the game ends...
which piece of our living world, in which amount, will be the one that collapses the entire structure?
best to mess as little as possible, and try to clean up...hard to do that when one is working every day to pay the rent or mortgage...
I will look into beekeeping...that is a good idea...my long-dead uncle used to have a small farm in the Spokane valley, and kept bees...
small point, bees don't visit red clover. red is out of the vision wave length.
It gets worse.
Read this at the Winnipeg Free Press - story from this past Monday.
"Rescue crews stung after truck hauling 17 million bees involved in fatal crash in US"
http://tinyurl.com/38b5pe6
(maybe if they didn't cram 17,000,000 bees into a single truck, accidents wouldn't be so catastrophic)
How many of you saw this story at all? It happened in the US, and would have made "good tv". But as adnoseum writes, at least we know what Lindsay is doing...
Unknown to 99.9 percent of Americans, the tractor trailer drivers of mobile bee colonies are exempted from the licensing requirements of the federal DOT. Whether driver performance was involved in the incident above, I don't know, but it has always struck me as a weird exemption.
Trylon
Layers of SNAFUs - as smipypr says: rivets.
We've planted lavender, and the bees used to love the seeds from our queen palm trees.
This year they are all gone.
They would be if they were tough and unionized killer bees who won't be taken for slave rides.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killer_bee
No Problem, when you garden blooms, you can use that blush brush to pollinate your crops.
All of the bad practices of industrial agriculture can be traced back to cheap oil.
"New parasites, pathogens, fungi, and poor nutrition stemming from intensive farming methods..."
"A hive might make five cross-country truck trips each year, chasing crops..."
What will we do when the oil runs out?
"Few organic beekeepers have reported bee losses, suggesting that natural and organic bee keeping methods may be the solution."
The destruction of the so-called "economy" is not something to be feared, but rather welcomed.
I was just reflecting on the psychological relief to come from no longer living the way we do...
have you ever looked into crisis, and felt an odd sense of welcome, as crisis may be the only way to shake off entrenched bad habits? may be the doorway, as the easterners imply, to opportunity?
can we?
"have you ever looked into crisis, and felt an odd sense of welcome..."
Yeah, I have. However, I can imagine that the step after the crisis may make us wish we had more of a soft landing. People are not prepared.
Docile bees have been replaced with killer bees over the years. My wife studied the history of this trend and she believes that we are witnessing what Sioux Rose would call a karmic blowback. Docile bees are like the typical obedient slaves Corporate America while killer bees are unionized workers who will not allow themselves to be exploited for slave labor.
The author discusses pesticides and cotton but fails to mention that industrial hemp can replace them. Hemp needs to be legalized and put to industrial use immediately so that we will have no excuse whatsoever for not leaving the bees alone. I hope that the author is reading and taking notes on this.
We don't need to resort to karma to understand this. Biology will do just fine.
I would still hold on to both plans just in case. They can fudge biology but not karma.
"industrial hemp can replace them."
I'm glad you mentioned that. It would be you, my hemp loving friend, that will rarely neglect an opportunity to promote hemp. If you didn't I would have. When I read, "we would have no cotton for textiles," my first thought was hemp can easily replace cotton. Plus, hemp is much less environmentally damaging and it will last longer than cotton. You'd think if we had any leadership in this country with the slightest of intelligence. Most textiles and paper products would be made from hemp. Being a carpenter I can only imagine what fantastic building materials could be made from it.
I've been trying to spread the word out for years but it's starting to catch on. There are naysayers who will object to hemp but most will learn. I think there is a bright future for carpenters once hemp gets its legal status. We could also do green crude with algal oil to give us the chemical equivalent of light sweet crude oil but I'll stick to hemp. Do a google search on hemp paint but prepare to be angered as we have to put up with toxic petroleum based paint instead of longer lasting non-toxic hemp based paint.
I was reading a lot about biodiesel a few years ago. Here's an interesting website regarding the subject. http://biodiesel.infopop.cc/6/ubb.x?a=cfrm&s=447609751
What I've read says rapeseed is a better crop for fuel production than hemp. I disagree with you on using hempseed for fuel. It's a minor difference we have but I imagine hemp would be much better overall than the bs the US is doing with ethanol. Algae looks more promising and I think we'd be much better off eating hempseed than using it for fuel. That's just my opinion though.
Thanks for the tidbit on hemp based paint. That is of real interest to me. I was looking at recipes for making my own paint or whitewash because I build so many things outdoors that are made from scrap lumber. They will last a few years without protection but a cheap bio-friendly paint would be nice so I didn't have to replace things as often.
That sounds reasonable. I would assume that for hempseed oil, the engines would have to be changed as I believe that most engines are gasoline based so algal oil will probably have to do. I don't know how well that will work out but I don't expect it to be cheap either.
Starkman sez: "Without honeybees, our diet would be mostly meatless, consisting of rice and cereals... "
***
Maybe we could go to a seafood diet.
Oh, wait ...
For you, I highly recommend today's Gulf shrimp, delicately smothered in oil.
Cicero: "Freedom is participation in power."
Human collapse disorder is just around the bend. The Boomers' grandchildren will live to see it.
It's already happening. Just look around. Boomers are living to see it, and too many of them just deny it. (Note: I'm a boomer, FWIW).
"Hives are found empty with honey, larvae, and the queen intact, but with no bees and no trail left behind."
When I read this I had an image of the slave bees making their escape in the dead of night across their version of the Red Sea. Perhaps they voted with their wings and left the stinking rotten corporate farming system.
I'd have to agree that a lot of the problem is "the stinking rotten corporate farming system". Fertilizers and other chemicals are _some_ of what is causing the loss of bees. From what I've read, wild bee colonies and ones used exclusively on organic crops are not suffering nearly the rate of loss as those used by the chemical laden big agribusinesses.
My father grew food organically all his life, even when he had a GS-13 government job and could easily afford to go to the market to buy anything we needed. He always grew more than we needed, so there was enough for us and the critters. Most American farmers have gotten so roped in by the big chemical companies that they no longer know how to grow food without chemicals, or genetically modified seed.
I wouldn't blame the American family farmer; they are having a hell of a time trying to compete with Big Agra and they only way they can survive in their livelihood is to adopt Big Agra's farming policies.
We need to get rid of factory farming. A big step forward is purchase/barter local foodstuffs, and boycott all imported foodstuffs.
Not so much. Insects that know they are sick will leave the hive to die, so that they don't infect the others.
http://www.paulmurray.id.au
"Widespread migratory stress brought about by increased needs for pollination could be weakening the bees' immune systems."
This transporting of bees back and forth across the country is just another example of wasting oil in food production. If there were many kinds of food being produced on each farm, instead of just one, there would be less need to move bees, because they would be needed at different times as different crops bloom.
Sometimes Americans are sooooo... STOOPID.
Didn't Einstein say that without the bees, it's all over for the human race?
It has been incorrectly attributed to him. Someone said it, but it has never been found in any of his writings, to the best of my knowledge.
Troubling words, nonetheless.
Bounty Is In the We empirePie May 26th, 2010
I plead allegiance to...
the toxic stew
the gentile brew
the red white blue
the disaster too
the masters few
the led all blue
I plead allegiance to...
the might of right
the rule of blight
the soulless flight
our mammon rule plight
the mirror of sight
the nest of spite
the bit the bitten and the bite
plenty..... like apples on the tree
bounty.... is in the we
‘to be’.. is like the bee.
Haven't see a bee in this part of NDallas 3+ years now - and when I point out that the flowers are gone, too, people think I'm crazy.
Why? Because of all the store-bought replants masking the truth. "Look, there's some flowers right there!" "Yea, Home Depot flowers..."
But the bees are truly the coal mine canaries.
Today, we learn that 'Herbal Supplements Contain Carciogenic Pesticides' http://tinyurl.com/3xbas5f
And last week, we learned that All Of Earth Is So Contaminated With Pesticides, Everyone Has Cancer: http://tinyurl.com/38loa33
Any minute now we'll hear this: "Nobody ever could have predicted that the company that gave us DDT and Agent Orange would poison us all for short-term profits.'
regarding your pesticide\cancer link:
yes, I read something here about this recently, and am intrigued by the stance the American Cancer Society is taking...
they appear reluctant to ruffle the feathers of the big chemical houses...
interesting...
why would they take that position?
Sweet honey bees vote with their wings with mass exodus from Nazi USI.
People to follow.