EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
From NYPD Spying to Trayvon Martin: Current Policing Makes Us Less Safe
When I heard that my name was featured in a NewYork City Police Department report, I should have been outraged. I had followed revelations of NYPD spying, but it hadn’t occurred to me that they would come to New Orleans to watch me speakat a film festival.
However, I also knew that the NYPD, in their crusade under the guise of safety, had gone whitewater rafting with college students and aggressively monitored and infiltrated mosques and Muslim businesses. They operate in at least 9 foreign countries, so why shouldn’t they come to New Orleans, listen to me say a few words at a public event, and write a classified report about it? Perhaps the only strange thing about the case is that I don’t fit their regular profile. As a white US citizen, I feel my case is a bit of an anomaly for a department that has developed a reputation for targeting immigrants and communities of color. My privilege has given me a certain amount of security and expectation of privacy that many others simply don’t experience.
Recent revelations about NYPD abuses go beyond spying. The notorious stop-and-frisk program, which has led to the criminalization of virtually an entire generation of young men of color in the city, is one example. The New York Civil Liberties Union reported that more than 4 million stops and interrogations from 2004 through 2011 led to no evidence of any wrongdoing – about 90% of all stops. Other recent revelations about NYPD abuses have included arrest quotas, sexual assaults, and the harassment and arrest of an officer who had turned whistleblower. So my little brush with violation of privacy was just a small taste of what is possible from a police department that never met a boundary it didn’t want to cross.
The Occupy movement – now just over six months old - first captured mainstream attention when police were filmed pepperspraying young white women on a New York sidewalk. Subsequent instances of police violence, such as the wounding of former Marine Scott Olsen in Oakland, and the nonchalant pepperspraying of UC Davis students, brought more public outrage and attention. The response from many in the Black community has been, “welcome to our world.”
Step-by-step, we have seen any idea of privacy disappear – everything we do is the business of police. This has always been true for communities of color; now the scope has simply gotten wider. While law enforcement representatives defend the presence of officers filming at every protest around the country as harmless public safety measures, there is no doubt this has had a chilling effect on dissent.
It is not just in New York that there is a divide in how people see – and experience - police. The national outrage over the killing of Trayvon Martin shows that his death – and the continued freedom of his killer – has struck a nerve among Black communities nationwide.
Here in New Orleans, public outrage has been mounting over the abuses carried out by our own city’s police department. More than a dozen officers have faced charges for their involvement in the murder of unarmed civilians in the aftermath of HurricaneKatrina, most notoriously in the Danziger Bridge shootings. In that incident, two families fleeing the storm’s devastation were attacked under a hail of police gunfire that left four wounded and two dead, including Ronald Madison, a mentally challenged 40-year-old, and James Brissette, a sixteen-year-old who had been called nerdy and studious by friends. Most alarmingly, our local media, district attorney, and other systems of accountability mostly failed in their oversight – it was not until the US Justice Department became involved in 2009 that the officers faced charges. The next year, a Justice Department investigation of the NOPD found "reasonable cause to believe that patterns and practices of unconstitutional conduct and/or violations of federal law occurred in several areas."
In the latest outrage, during the first week of March, two young Black men were killed by New Orleans police in separate incidents. One of the victims, Justin Sipp, was shot by officers during a traffic stop. The other youth, 20-year-old Wendell Allen, was shot in his own home by an officer executing a warrant. Allen was apparently unarmed and only partially dressed. Allen’s killer remains free, as does George Zimmerman, who killed Trayvon.
This week, it was revealed that one of the officers who killed Sipp recently wrote a racist rant about Trayvon Martin on a news website, saying the young man deserved to die, and is now "in hell."
I am disappointed that the NYPD choose to make me a target – however peripheral – of their spying. But I am truly angered by the role that police play in communities of color, at the criminalization of young Black children wearing a hooded sweatshirts. These latest revelations have had the effect of renewing my commitment to fighting for a system that knows that true safety and security comes from providing justice, liberation, and human rights for all; not in the harsh and violent justice of law enforcement.
An earlier version of this article appeared in The Progressive.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

16 Comments so far
Show AllA lot of horrible things happened during Katrina by police, and not all of them involved people.
http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=3265151&page=1
I no longer see the police as "good guys", "public servants" or "heroic 1st responders". Too many senseless shootings, tazings, and pepper sprayings for anyone to still remain blind to their excesses and lack of accountability.
KGB, Gestapo, Mossad, Pinkertons, CIA, FBI, NSA, HS, Police and the Military it's hard to tell them apart anymore. They all feel like state sanctioned "terrorists" to me.
This is a trend that is growing swiftly, nationwide. The police's public image - never that shiny to begin with - has taken a nosedive in recent years, as their new-found fascist power given them by the Homeland Security Dept, a slew of new laws curtailing our freedoms and civil liberties, and criminalizing formerly constitutional freedoms such as the right to peacefully assemble, has erased the thin veneer that barely hid their thuggishness and is now laid bare for everyone to see. I fully expect to see - in the not-distant future - a day when there is virtual all-out war between the police and "everyone else" (excluding the 1%, of course), where the police are openly seen to be "the enemy" instead of the still-tacit support they receive from the majority of citizens nowadays.
Good insights, Demonstorm, but let's also remember that the fish rots from the head. With that being said, the entire climate of suspicion is being promoted in high places, nor is this pattern without a substantial and troubling history. A friend advised me to pick up a copy of "Dangerous Dossiers," by Herbert Mitgang and I did. It would astound most people to learn how serious were the spying campaigns conducted against any left-leaning writer, poet, artist, or activist. The dossiers are held under the banner of National Security! And you can be sure, if this type of thing went on routinely from the l920's (under J Edgar Hoover) well into the l970's, that similar campaigns are profoundly underway today with so much $, muscle & technological instrumentation available to facilitate this dark art.
Someone in the forum posted that the new "red" is Green (as in environmentalism) and that suits up quite nicely with the premise of eco-terrorist, i.e. anyone who holds any polluting corporation to account!
"Dangerous Dossiers" is a book I would put in the highly recommended category. Another eye opening tome on similar subject matter is "Manufacturing Hysteria, A History of Scapegoating, Surveillance, and Secrecy in Modern America" by Jay Feldman. Other reading material I have come across recently puts it out there that J. Edgar Hoover was the driving force behind the Warren Commission, ensuring that the official story was adhered to.
Has the Untied States hired black water or the Klan to keep us in line? Of course if you are owned by the Koch brothers, fox news or Murdock you are considered on the other side. 99 percent of the one percent are republican.
It is simply not true that "99 percent of the one percent are republican."
"The Top 20 Wealthiest Americans list is actually dominated by Democrats. Bill Gates and Larry Ellison are the next two richest people in America. And they are both Democrats. Christy Walton, the heir of the Wal-Mart fortune, comes in at #4 and is an independent. She frequently donates to both Republican and Democratic politicians. The #5 and #6 spots in America are owned by the Kochs, making them the richest conservatives. Overall, the Top 20 is 60% Democrat and 40% Republican. When you take out duplications from the same family, this number jumps up to 75%."
http://www.addictinginfo.org/2011/08/01/are-wealthy-americans-always-conservative/
Blackwater was active in New Orleans after Katrina. Jordan Flaherty, among others, reported that extensively.
Why not start by forgetting all that partisan crap and recognizing we are all Americans. The media brainwashes us into thinking there are two sides--and certainly we have differences of opinion about how to resolve issues, but it's the people we disagree with that we should be debating, don't you think? You convince me or I'll convince you, or we'll agree to disagree---or we might find out we had a lot more in common than not. The media keeps us in these little boxes "our side" and "their side" so that the media can continue to frame the conversation. I don't just mean the lamestream media, but talk radio and everybody else too. They're their to sell their product, so they have to define it and define their audience. Please remember, more than 99% have never met the Koch Brothers.
Thank you for pointing that out Renellin. It needs to be said more often.
In that same vein, an article some might find interesting:
http://www.salon.com/2012/03/26/obama_takes_bushs_secrecy_games_one_step_further/singleton/
"The national outrage over the killing of Trayvon Martin ........– has struck a nerve among Black communities nationwide."
I think it has 'struck a nerve' among all types of communities in which actual human beings reside.
There are so many really important problems we as a species have to solve, it's unfortunate that we still spend so much of our time hating one another because of physical appearance, lifestyle or ideologies - religious, or otherwise. And, it's a disgusting reality that our so-called 'leaders' - political, religious, etc. - continue to do whatever they can to encourage our distraction from what matters by stoking the hate and injustice.
The police exist to protect the 1%. People need to get that into their heads.
Inequality requires force to preserve it. Inequality arises from the notion of property rights, which demands inequality because you cannot distribute property in an equitable manner among 7 billion people.
We can complain all we want about police spying, stop and frisk tactics, brutality, but the 1% pays them to do just that.
Get used to it, because it will get much worse. When the democratic and republican conventions role around with all the secret service protected people, the police will use extreme violence to arrest and detain people, and then the government will use the hammer of HR 347 to lock them up.
This will happen this summer. Mark my words.
Here's a little test....
Ask yourself how you feel when you are sitting at a stop, or driving lawfully, and you see Johnny Law in your rear-view mirror.
Do you feel assured?
“A government afraid of its citizens is a Democracy. Citizens afraid of government is tyranny!”
― Thomas Jefferson
Our government fears its own people, spies on them, searches them before they can enter buildings, sends SWAT teams into their homes, passes laws that allow imprisonment without trial, etc. So according to Jefferson, we must live in a democracy.
All my life I learned to think of Thomas Jefferson as a defender of liberty and democracy. But the real Thomas Jefferson staunchly defended slavery, owned slaves, raped his slaves, held the lower classes in contempt, thought of himself and his allies as superior human beings -- the aristoi, and when he died he did not emancipate even one slave, not even Sally Hemings and his and her children.
OCCUPY (and all other activists) should keep protesting and organizing if they want to see change. OCCUPY is not the first and won't be the last protest movement to face police repression.
The NYPD needs instruction on how to conduct itself in a democracy and how to follow the Constitution, which guarantees the right to peaceful assembly. The NYPD has become repressive and undemocratic...and is therefore a threat to our privacy and civil liberties.
I saw a new teevee program where a business expert on spying on your employees guarantees to improve your business by installing spy cameras everywhere. The business of America is business. 1984 in 2012.
The 'business' of America, from it's foundation as English, French and Spanish colonies up to the present day, has been resource exploitation and war, in that order, for the benefit of the wealthy Elite.
Laws and Police exist only to protect and serve the wealthy Elite.
Do you start to see the connection?
And Orwell would run screaming from the room in abject horror if he were to witness what are commonplace 'security' practices and procedures in the US today.