Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
No Act of Rebellion Is Wasted
I stood with hundreds of thousands of rebellious Czechoslovakians in 1989 on a cold winter night in Prague’s Wenceslas Square as the singer Marta Kubišová approached the balcony of the Melantrich building. Kubišová had been banished from the airwaves in 1968 after the Soviet invasion for her anthem of defiance, “Prayer for Marta.” Her entire catalog, including more than 200 singles, had been confiscated and destroyed by the state. She had disappeared from public view. Her voice that night suddenly flooded the square. Pressing around me were throngs of students, most of whom had not been born when she vanished. They began to sing the words of the anthem. There were tears running down their faces. It was then that I understood the power of rebellion. It was then that I knew that no act of rebellion, however futile it appears in the moment, is wasted. It was then that I knew that the Communist regime was finished.
“The people will once again decide their own fate,” the crowd sang in unison with Kubišová.
I had reported on the fall of East Germany before I arrived in Prague. I would leave Czechoslovakia to cover the bloody overthrow of the Romanian dictator Nicolae Ceauşescu. The collapse of the Communist regimes in Eastern Europe was a lesson about the long, hard road of peaceful defiance that makes profound social change possible. The rebellion in Prague, as in East Germany, was not led by the mandarins in the political class but by marginalized artists, writers, clerics, activists and intellectuals such as Vaclav Havel, whom we met with most nights during the upheavals in Prague in the Magic Lantern Theater. These activists, no matter how bleak things appeared, had kept alive the possibility of justice and freedom. Their stances and protests, which took place over 40 years of Communist rule, turned them into figures of ridicule, or saw the state seek to erase them from national consciousness. They were dismissed by the pundits who controlled the airwaves as cranks, agents of foreign powers, fascists or misguided and irrelevant dreamers.
I spent a day during the Velvet Revolution with several elderly professors who had been expelled from the Romance language department at Charles University for denouncing the Soviet invasion. Their careers, like the careers of thousands of professors, teachers, artists, social workers, government employees and journalists in our own universities during the Communist witch hunts, were destroyed. After the Soviet invasion, the professors had been shipped to a remote part of Bohemia where they were forced to work on a road construction crew. They shoveled tar and graded roadbeds. And as they worked they dedicated each day to one of the languages in which they all were fluent—Latin, Greek, Italian, French, Spanish or German. They argued and fought over their interpretations of Homer, Virgil, Dante, Goethe, Proust and Cervantes. They remained intellectually and morally alive. Kubišova, who had been the most popular recording star in the country, was by then reduced to working for a factory that assembled toys. The playwright Havel was in and out of jail.
The long, long road of sacrifice, tears and suffering that led to the collapse of these regimes stretched back decades. Those who made change possible were those who had discarded all notions of the practical. They did not try to reform the Communist Party. They did not attempt to work within the system. They did not even know what, if anything, their protests would accomplish. But through it all they held fast to moral imperatives. They did so because these values were right and just. They expected no reward for their virtue; indeed they got none. They were marginalized and persecuted. And yet these poets, playwrights, actors, singers and writers finally triumphed over state and military power. They drew the good to the good. They triumphed because, however cowed and broken the masses around them appeared, their message of defiance did not go unheard. It did not go unseen. The steady drumbeat of rebellion constantly exposed the dead hand of authority and the rot and corruption of the state.
The walls of Prague were covered that chilly winter with posters depicting Jan Palach. Palach, a university student, set himself on fire in Wenceslas Square on Jan. 16, 1969, in the middle of the day to protest the crushing of the country’s democracy movement. He died of his burns three days later. The state swiftly attempted to erase his act from national memory. There was no mention of it on state media. A funeral march by university students was broken up by police. Palach’s gravesite, which became a shrine, saw the Communist authorities exhume his body, cremate his remains and ship them to his mother with the provision that his ashes could not be placed in a cemetery. But it did not work. His defiance remained a rallying cry. His sacrifice spurred the students in the winter of 1989 to act. Prague’s Red Army Square, shortly after I left for Bucharest, was renamed Palach Square. Ten thousand people went to the dedication.
We, like those who opposed the long night of communism, no longer have any mechanisms within the formal structures of power that will protect or advance our rights. We too have undergone a coup d’état carried out not by the stone-faced leaders of a monolithic Communist Party but by the corporate state. We too have our designated pariahs, whether Ralph Nader or Noam Chomksy, and huge black holes of state-sponsored historical amnesia to make us ignore the militant movements, rebels and radical ideas that advanced our democracy. We opened up our society to ordinary people not because we deified the wisdom of the Founding Fathers or the sanctity of the Constitution. We opened it up because of communist, socialist and anarchist leaders like Big Bill Haywood and his militant unionists in the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW).
We may feel, in the face of the ruthless corporate destruction of our nation, our culture, and our ecosystem, powerless and weak. But we are not. We have a power that terrifies the corporate state. Any act of rebellion, no matter how few people show up or how heavily it is censored by a media that caters to the needs and profits of corporations, chips away at corporate power. Any act of rebellion keeps alive the embers for larger movements that follow us. It passes on another narrative. It will, as the rot of the state consumes itself, attract wider and wider numbers. Perhaps this will not happen in our lifetimes. But if we persist we will keep this possibility alive. If we do not, it will die.
All energy directed toward reforming political and state structures is useless. All efforts to push through a “progressive” agenda within the corridors of power are naive. Trust in the reformation of our corporate state reflects a failure to recognize that those who govern, including Barack Obama, are as deaf to public demands and suffering as those in the old Communist regimes. We cannot rely on any systems of power, including the pillars of the liberal establishment—the press, liberal religious institutions, universities, labor, culture and the Democratic Party. They have been weakened to the point of anemia or work directly for the corporations that dominate our existence. We can rely now on only ourselves, on each other.
Go to Lafayette Park, in front of the White House, at 10 a.m. Dec. 16. Join dozens of military veterans, myself, Daniel Ellsberg, Medea Benjamin, Ray McGovern, Dr. Margaret Flowers and many others who will make visible a hope the corporate state does not want you to see, hear or participate in. Don’t be discouraged if it is not a large crowd. Don’t let your friends or colleagues talk you into believing it is useless. Don’t be seduced by the sophisticated public relations campaigns disseminated by the mass media, the state or the Democratic Party. Don’t, if you decide to carry out civil disobedience, be cowed by the police. Hope and justice live when people, even in tiny numbers, stand up and fight for them.
There is in our sorrow—for who cannot be profoundly sorrowful?—finally a balm that leads to wisdom and, if not joy, then a strange, transcendent happiness. To stand in a park on a cold December morning, to defy that which we must defy, to do this with others, brings us solace, and perhaps even peace. We will not find this if we allow ourselves to be disabled. We will not find this alone. As long as a few of us rebel it will always remain possible to defeat a system of centralized, corporate power that is as criminal and heartless as those I watched tumble into the ash bin of history in Eastern Europe.

187 Comments so far
Show AllThe "corporate state"= FASCISM! Call it what it is, why play word games?
Perhaps it is because we do not have an avowed fascist party in power. The Corporate State/Empire is similar in actual structure without actually claiming the f-word.
Communism, Fascism, Military Junta, whatever. Hedges is right. There must be a freeing of the person to read history, make works of art, protest, act for goodness and live freely "as-if" the freedom was already won.
Social power, not state power.
You are playing "word games" now.
If you do not resist the fascist amerikan empire you serve it! Far to many people, have been far too quiet, for far too long! The time is NOW to rise up in total opposition to the fascist oppressors in washington !!!!
The collapse is right before you eyes.
Worrying about what to call "it" is playing word games.
AXIOM
There is only one true standard for good government,
when the upper half of society willingly passes its
excessive wealth down to the laboring class where
it belongs.
Are you thick?
The top 1% own it all, not 50%.
Go look it up in a book.
Where did Ellis say the top half owns 50%?
Are you thick? Can you read?
I meant the top 1%
bad grammar on my part
Yeah. The American political system is all about which group of elites throws the best table scraps and is least cruel to us lower class of animals.
Middle class professionals are the house slaves in our system, and are often also abused. Recently their ranks were thinned and many are now experiencing lumpenproletariat conditions in the USA.
This is what the system
looks like
eating
its own
Almost enough rot. Almost enough.
They seem intent on stoking the rebellion with young militants.
The foolish "Me" generation has took the reins with Bill, Hillary, W and of course their little bro Obama.
So maybe boomerLeaders, you should listen again to this:
There's blood in the streets, it's up to my ankles
Blood in the streets, it's up to my knee
Blood in the streets in the town of Chicago
Blood in the halls at the base at Bagram
Blood on the rise, it's following me
Jim Morrison of Doors of Perception by Aldous Huxley, who, if you ask me, owes a lot to William Blake. Take the battle to Heavensgate.
It worked once wit LSD and Vietnam, but methinks the American Aquarian ain't got it in her for another round.
I'll give CD's wise mystic camp this. What goes around has a tendency to boomerang. America better learn how to catch, because IT's comin around, and fast.
Fast times on the planet of the insane deities.
If I were a DJ I would now break to have you seen the saucers?
Have You Seen the Saucers? -Jefferson Airplane, Winterland Album
I've seen revolution's future and it looks like Wikileaks. (for the young people here, that is a very old reference from Rolling Stone).
Honestly, i would love to see and hear americans on the street discussing Virgil, Homer and Cervantes. But somehow i don't think it will happen in our society. Romantic as this is to me, i don't live in Prague (sigh). If i do get to DC on thursday i am wagering that the Inferno will not be discussed...Even if i pay fifty dollars to hear Medea speak at Busboys and Poets.
And feel free to bash me, but these actions in DC, which i have personally participated in over the past nine years are not new. For the life of me, i don't know why Mr. Hedges is writing about this like it is something original. If someone wants to answer, i would sincerely like to know. People, such as Cindy Sheehan even got herself arrested when i was down there last March. At the Whitehouse. What in the world is new here? I know i am not the only poster here who was at these protests over the past nine years. I can't be. Yet it sounds that way when i read the comments. Quite frankly, i can't imagine that anyone who is aware enough to have been reading CD since the 'war on terror' began, NOT taking to the streets. I had no choice. I was compelled. (people who were too young, not included here).
The only thing i can figure is that Chris is attempting to breath new life into the movement, such as it was, which totally died after most of said movement collapsed due to turning their money and energy into electing hero obama. Which, admittedly, pissed me off to high heaven. And it has taken two years into his administration to try to get something going again.
Unfortunately, the majority of the movement during the bush years were mainstream decocrats. Not all, of course. But certainly more than half. I didn't see any obama puppets at any marches since he was in office. Although, who knows, i may have missed something.
I hope that someone mentions freeing julian assange when they are at the whitehouse. At least a sign or two.
I wish i spoke Latin or Greek like the intelligensia of the Velvet Revolution. I really do.
I hate to throw cold water on your admiration of Wikileaks but there are two articles that have been published on Global Research recently that cast doubt on the validity of that organization.
Everyone on this site should be aware that since the 50's the PWB have studied mind control both on individuals and societies. These people are very smart and for over 50 years have had unlimited resources. For a taste look up Operation Mockingbird or read Hank Albarelli's A Terrible Mistake.
They think they can manipulate us and they seem to be right. I'm not saying that these articles are correct...I just want to caution everyone not to deify Assange until we see more. We may never know the truth (do we ever) but any story presented by the corporate media has to be considered suspect.
Anyway here:
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=22357
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=22371
Since when do state agents sit in solitary confinement?
I get your point but the state's dupes often languish in jail or meet with a very timely demise (from the state's perspective) after they have served their purpose.
Feints within feints.
A careful reading of the Engdahl article reveals nothing that would contradict Assange from being exactly who he says he is.
In fact it contains some blatant misinformation in claiming he released the data to the NYT as he was on the run from Interpol.
Anyone who cannot see Engdahl as a state propagandist is naive.
I read it yesterday....Engdahl also claims, with no proof or even telling how he knows this, that Assange made a secret deal with israel! He just throws it in the article for the heck of it....Also, he is a LaRouche follower. It is a good read in how to spot a real disinformation mole.
By the way, i just heard amy goodman say that a secret panel is being convened in virginia to indict Assange on the 1917 espionage act.
When a critic has to grasp at criticisms such as Wikileaks is a "cute" name, you know your reading not only a false person but a stupid person.
I too hear it this morning in DN "..a secret panel is being convened in virginia to indict Assange on the 1917 espionage act.."
This is the same nonsense that another LaRouche-ite, Webster Tarpley, is peddling. Without a shred of evidence, Tarpley et al are suggesting that Assange is a state agent, and that Israel is the real beneficiary of the leaks.
I've watched how Tarpley and his kind works for sometime now, and I am reasonably convinced that he is a disinformation specialist. Thankfully, no one takes that guy seriously.
Sorry, most of the Global Research articles are of the tin hat variety. They even deny ACC.
"Everyone on this site should be aware that since the 50's the PWB have studied mind control both on individuals and societies. These people are very smart and for over 50 years have had unlimited resources. "
See my related comment below as regards the cold war.
RTT I am sure Hedges in no way thinks what he is doing is new.
He is doing what his beautiful heart and mind call him to do.
No act of rebellion is wasted, Neither Assange's nor Hedge's nor Moore's nor Mine nor Yours.
glenn ford: I agree with your comments. It's going to take every single one of us carrying out whatever acts we can to reel in the U.S.E. -- if someone on CD recalls the name of the person who brought us the U.S.E., the United States of Empire, please feel free to add that information to my post! I would like to credit that individual.
No act of rebellion is wasted!
A beautiful response, Glenn.
Since the past nine years of my travels and protests and writing brought me to this moment.....I have decided to go one step further.
I am gonna burn my draft card!
peace,
rita
HAA HHAA HA very good, subtle and precise.
All sincere acts of correct action/ attitude, that come from the inner intuitive voice...they all count, and they roll out like ripples from a pebble thrown into the great ocean; eventually interacting with all other ripples !
nanaste
tioche, bravo!
I wish we had a thousand more like Hedges.
I wish we had a thousand more like Hedges.
I think all Chris is saying is "Don't give up." And he says it quite eloquently. I find this a really inspiring piece, especially the parts about reform being impossible. Really. There is something freeing about understanding that we have no more influence over our government than people in the old Communist countries had over their regimes.
And understanding that we have had no influence for at least 30 years.
Since 1980, most of the reforms that benefited the working class (and helped bring about the middle class) have been repealed piecemeal. We have not noticed - rather like the proverbial lobster in the pot.
And now Obama and his minions want to repeal Social Security - just look at the 'Tax deal' and the deficit commission recs, the last blow to the workers of the U.S.
I won't even go into the use of the USAID to train cheaper labor overseas in ever increasing offshoring of the fewer and fewer better paying jobs here.
Rita,
This is something original to Mr. Hedges, who has throughout his career labored under his Harvard divinity school education. He is one of the liberals whom he himself has called useless. He is able to hold two conflicting thoughts in his head, such as "all energy directed toward reforming political and state structures is useless" but please come watch me chain myself to the fence. That's just how he was trained. I guess we should be happy that most of the rest of the shit he says makes sense sometimes.
Very few people have been able to come up with step one, let alone step two or three. But here's mine:
1. Determine what you can do and then commence to doing it. If you can get to Washington and protest, fabulous. If you can donate money to Wikileaks, cool. If you can recycle, not shop at Wal-mart, bike to work, etc. then do that. Try to make it something that involves getting up off your ass. Blogging the shit out of something only goes so far.
2. Make your plans long-term. God knows we didn't get into this mess in a day or even two years or even ten. Granted the last ten years have had a snowball effect, but the top of the hill was almost 40 years ago or more!
3. Talk about what you're doing. Talk to everyone who will listen. Go to places where the media is and talk about it there. Be ready for ignorance and misunderstanding and a lot of scared citizens.
4. Gather as many like-minded individuals around you as possible. Then change the minds of the rest by being a good example.
I'm sure there are better plans. Like I said this is mine. Chris Hedges is finally listening to some of his own sermons, and good for him. I'm sure the experience will enlighten him. It's interesting to watch him grow.
Your arrogant and smug tone do nothing to advance a social movement. Hedges words are powerful and moving, and his analysis is that of an anarchist, someone that understands that capitalist state power is as criminal as that of the old communist dictatorships. I find your words insulting. I find Hedges words inspiring.
And thus do you validate Mr. Hedges article.
Re-read the title...No Act of Rebellion is Wasted. Isn't that what you advocate in your post?
And so, it's don't look at him - look at me, there is something shiny here!
elainem, i think you make a lot of sense here. I see that some have not appreciated what you have said. I think you are sincere and make some good points. I also see the dissonace in Mr. Hedges thinking. And i agree with your analysis. And i too have watched him evolve. He is both intellectual and insightful, a combination i will always hold in high regard. And he has a right to do nothing more than this. I have no problem with intellectuals if they are speaking to more than each other in the ivory tower of academia. That i see as mental masturbation and have been around that in my time.
I don't mind stretching my vocabulary at all, but i do find the 'who is more obtuse than whom' game worse than boring. It offends me as a human being. I haven't resonated with him when encountering him as i didn't feel passion and down to earth energy. But that isn't his problem. It is who he is as a personality. He is low key and very mentally oriented. I think Chomsky is also intellectually dense, but more down to earth.
I am too tired, as i've just told Kay, so i will end now....
peace,
rita
Hi, Rita. I heard you the other day making this point in another thread and arguing FOR creativity. Both approaches are important.
Please consider this: the woodpecker keeps hammering on the tree, over and over again until finally, at last, a delectable insect emerges to satisfy its labors.
Did you know that a single drop of water dripping from a mountain stream over time will leave an imprint in the rock beneath? That a similar drip, operating inside a cave may form a stalactite?
My point is that we really don't know which action, creative or redundant, will be the one that acts as the straw which breaks the camel's back... or produces a thing of beauty.
If my dog didn't have eye surgery, I'd rent a car and invite Born Free Man, Ezyflyer and any other Florida residents to carpool up there for the event on the 16th. Since the dog is too weak to be left with anyone else, I can't make the pilgrimage this time.
Prayer vigils in cities might be a good complementary action. And like you, I appreciate the creative, unconventional efforts of fellows like "The Yes Men."
Hedges did elegantly point out that it's a variety of rebels that make a revolution happen.
Nor are these battles won once and for all. History's tides circle. Once again we're in a period of inordinate repression, and a time WILL come where liberties are once more the rule of the day. The exact mixture of ingredients to give rise to that more blessed state is nebulous. You said recently that we each have to do our part, and I agree.
This article makes me feel more inspired, too. It reminds us that just because we don't see progress in this hour doesn't mean our sincere efforts are wasted. (I needed that message!)
Thank you , Sioux, for a heartfelt response. There is much wisdom in it. To be honest, i don't know that Eastern Europe is much better off now. In fact, i don't know that India is. Of course, our lifetimes are a flash in infinity, and the cycles are much larger than we can wrap our minds around.
We need to learn something real from our histories. Which means radical reframing and shifting perspective. That over used Einstien quote, "No problem can be solved by the same consciousness that created it", always comes to mind. I think it is one of the most relevant truths of all time.
I am sorry to hear about your dog.....
rita
Thank you for this article about the need for persistence andcourage in protesting the excesses of our corporate government.
With a tax cut for millionaires and billionaires, with speculative cheating on Wall Street, with the Supreme Court's permission for corporations to buy politicians we have become an oligarchy.
"we have become an oligarchy." Yes, were a Plutocracy now officially. The Citizens United SCOTUS decision was the last gasp of the dying Republic called America. The "new" Aristocracy has taken over.
Oligarchy, plutocracy, kleptocracy, empire, fascist state, police state - all of these descriptives have elements of truth to them but none seem to capture the entire picture as well as Sheldon Wolin's "inverted totalitarianism", where politics is subordinate to a totalist economics.
This is going to be a long struggle indeed, whatever you prefer to call it, as anyone confronting it will be faced with the reality that this monster will eagerly package and sell your dissent right back to you in between beatings. The Czechs had it easy compared to what the world faces now.
How long have we been walking upright?
We have been upright for at least as long as we have been immoral.
About one day, as that ancient history book tells us.
Howard Zinn
"If you don't know history,
its as if you were born yesterday."
I'm not sure that Czechoslovakia in 1989 or the other instances Chris mentioned can be compared to what I think he is speaking of today.
Nor do I think he is entirely correct as to the effect of large demonstrations that seem to happen only when a loss of benefit is threatened.
But about Corporate or Business overbearance he is certainly correct. Thought provoking as usual...with Hedges you have to mull it over for a while.
You might want to add the fact that your tax dollars are paying to murder innocent Iraqs, and the people of Afghanistan, so even though to some we aren't doing so bad..we sure are doing bad things. If killing people for oil, and other lies sits well with you, as it does with many other Americans, then when Justice finnally catches up with America, and it will... when asked about what you did to stop the killings, I would love to hear your answer.
It will be a long and pernicious road of sacrifice and economic pain to resist the onslaught of the corporate oligarchy with its militant brand of global disaster capitalism going full swing. The collapse of communism came on the heels of not only its long-entrenched moral bankruptcy but perhaps more imminent its economic failure. An economic demise which ironically was aided by the same mechanism of capitalism and military prowess which opposed it and now has re-set itself against its own societies to do away with whatever economic justice they've managed to secure after decades of conscious and persistent struggle. The road of resistance to the entrenched systems of power in the service of the corporate economic domain will be long and arduous indeed. The economic structure of the global oligarchy is intrinsically morally corrupt but it's far from being financially bankrupt. The long journey of resistance and rebellion against its corrupt political power structure is only just beginning.
Actually, the leaders of communist Russia decided they could get more wealth and glory by switching to a capitalist democracy, one where politicians all act like gangsters.
Actually, the people Hedges is counting on to lead his rebellion, the educated middle-class, they have great jobs, terrific homes and no desire for killing the goose that lays the golden egg.