Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Pledge to See a Movie During This National Emergency
If you are a teacher with 28 children in your class this Fall, four of them live in poverty.
On Thursday the Census Bureau released a report showing that 1 of 7 Americans now lives in poverty. That's 44,000,000 people who, if they live in a family of four, have a family income that is less than $22,000 per year. If it were not for unemployment benefits, another 3,300,000 would be included in the poverty figures. Even with such impressive numbers that exceed the levels of poverty for when President Johnson declared the War on Poverty in the 1960s, higher numbers of people are without health insurance, which now stands at over 50,000,000 for the first time since records have been kept.
What has been the national political response? The Republicans have not mentioned it, preferring instead to continue to hammer their talking points on maintaining the Bush tax cuts for those making more than $250,000 per year. The Democrats are more interested in the middle class who vote, with the President on Friday making the case from the Rose Garden for middle class tax cuts without mentioning the historic poverty report released the day before. In a Washington Post story on Thursday that asked a pundit from each political party what should be done in the face of this accelerating devastation, the Republican urged poor people to make sure they get married, and the Democrat urged the continuation of the surviving patchwork of social welfare programs that are already entirely swamped by the deluge of the poor.
Without comment on poverty reports, however, wealth continues to accumulate for those with the wealth to make it happen. We know this not from any disclosures from the privileged, but from the public disclosures by large investors such as university endowments and retirement funds. Last week brought news that Columbia University has recouped much of what was lost in the most recent Wall Street debacle, with a 17 percent return this year on investments that remain undisclosed. We can only imagine the astronomical returns that the hedge fund gamblers are bringing in for the casino capitalists of Wall Street if a university endowment is able to collect 17% on its investment.
On the other coast in California, a Bay Citizen story published by the New York Times reports that a review of the University of California shareholder voting records show a pattern of disregard for UC's long-standing investment policy "to promote human rights, environmental sustainability and efforts to fight discrimination." It is as if the acrid whiff of economic collapse has placed conscience and moral argument on the losing side of a zero sum game, a sentiment expressed in remarks by a UC Davis law professor who argues that UC must keep in mind the "ultimate beneficiaries:" "Do they want to be socially responsible or do they want to have retirement money when they retire?"
There are those among us, however, who feel as though they will have their cake and will eat it, too, and have more cake as a result. And thus we see the great outpouring of interest and even tears among the wealthy and well-heeled lining up for the new documentary feature on the un-caped crusaders of the corporate education reform movement depicted in "Waiting for Superman," a film amply funded by philanthro-capitalists, those irrepressible investors who do well by doing good from their unique capacity to spot a business opportunity where the rest of us just see the cancerous effects exuding from the malignant neglect of poverty. From what I can learn from the well-oiled promotional machine that, beyond the "Superman" website, is funding op-eds, newsy articles, interviews, and TV specials to generate support for the movie's corporate-approved educational solutions, the film hopes to push over the top an educational revolution of sorts that will sweep away poor children's failure as easily as plans to sweep away teachers and schools where poor children score the lowest on tests.
This new corporate poor children's crusade will not be constrained by burdensome adult work rules, union agreements, due process considerations, or even children's work rules or due process, for that matter. The model chain for corporate school reform, KIPP, works students and teachers 10 hours a day, and then they are on duty for 2 to 3 hours of homework every night. Plus Saturdays. Though costly for students and teachers alike, who must cut short other life activities such as family and friends (and sleep), the new crusade will be accomplished apparently without the need for addressing the many, otherwise, expensive social and economic challenges where poor children live and score poorly in crumbling schools with shortages of decent learning materials, libraries, health care, parent jobs, housing, transportation, equal opportunity, or the diverse social capital that enables healthy cultures to interact and thrive.
What this new "civil rights" crusade based on segregated containment and a "no excuses" mantra disguises is a very old ideology based on blaming the poor for their poverty and blaming public schools in order to dismantle them for corporate benefit, with both unacknowledged goals carried out while diverting attention away from the economic canyon that divides the poor from the rich who now plan to get richer by exploiting the poor in ways that leave them even more contained and invisible than before.
The heart-tugging and anger-pumping machinations of "Waiting for Superman" mask a cynical excuse to impose a cheap form of punitive social triage through a total compliance penal form of schooling for the poor that carries with it the added benefit of a huge financial dividend for the philanthropic investor class that Diane Ravitch has termed the "Billionaire Boys' Club." Though costly for students, parents, and teachers alike, none of these constituencies are even present in strategies for this new crusade, unless they are recruited to serve as passive audiences for lectures by Bill Gates or Arne Duncan. They did have their presence felt last Tuesday in DC, however, and no doubt they will have it felt again.
Trying to turn poor children into middle class ones without the benefits of the family wealth or access to social capital to go along with the psychological and behavioral modifications of the KIPPs will be do untold damage to children and their families that will not be judged kindly by history in the long term, or by voters and civil rights advocates in the short term. It will be of minor consequence to the wealth of the wealthy, however, even if it all falls flat. If this brand of apartheid testing camps were to become the model for urban education, however, corporate education reform would make many of the wealthy even wealthier, with an added social dividend. For if the psychological alterations of the poor are as effective as the corporate "positivity" consultants would have it, we may assume that these poor children, once successfully modified, will become as blind to poverty as the white, and black, missionary types who are lined up for a ticket to feel good about believing that poverty is no longer an excuse for being poor.
Meanwhile, 5 of 35 school children in every overcrowded classroom in America remain impoverished, with nothing on the political horizon or from Hollywood to change that reality or even to challenge it.




15 Comments so far
Show AllHorn is probably still hung up on the old canard about public education being a means to create informed citizens. Public education (like much of the rest of American society) is a means to create compliant consumers with increased debt capacity. Low-SES dropouts can hardly bear any debt at all, and that's a problem which urgently demands an effective solution. Now.
Our society needs to learn to do well by doing good. Job One is to get the country off its deadly fossil fuel addiction, so we can tackle Global Warming and lead the world to a zero carbon, clean energy future.
We can create a brighter world for every child, and good jobs for every citizen by just saying NO to oil wars, and saying a BIG YES to a 21st Century Clean Energy New Deal.
Super insulate every house, build millions of electric cars, connect every city with high speed rail. Plant Billions of Trees to restore our land and clean CO2 from the Air.
Job One should not end until every vestige of the warmongering, planet destroying oil, coal, and gas oligarchy is gone.
Steal a movie during this national emergency. http://deluge-torrent.org/ , http://www.utorrent.com/ , or http://azureus.sourceforge.net/ all give you what you need to work with sites like isohunt.com or even google. Why pay $10.00 for admission, $3.00 for a soda and $5.00 for stale popcorn when you can stay at home and watch some great free movies. I found a good one on Fracking, just by searching for the word.
I agree with the author --- we don't need more student converts to the WASPian way... If anything, WASPs could use a little cultural de-programming - especially around the concept of sharing and being open-hearted!
Unplug your keyboard.
ALERT:
Oprah is featuring this film today (Monday Sept. 20) and claims it's SOOO important she's devoting her Sept. 24 show to audience and other viewers' responses. (Wanna bet it will be all positive, as the sheeple are wowed and shocked in awe of the message and the messenger?)
Today she has billionaire philanthropist Gates pushing this racist, classist, fascist piece of crap, which features, among other luminaries, Ms Rhee of D.C.
CNN earlier today featured a school in Florida that has "gone from an F to an A in national test scores" through its "war on ignorance" in which teachers and staff wear military fatigues every Monday and the classrooms are decked with military insignia to remind the (mainly Black) kids that they are "warriors". One of Arne Duncan's wet dreams.
Meanwhile disgusting shills like the Washington Post keep up their attacks on teachers' unions that represent teachers and decent conditions for education (as opposed to drilling for standardized tests and competing for funds).
So watch out, everyone. Arne and Barry's cohorts and their fan club on Oprah are moving to consolidate their take-no-prisoners campaign. And it's not a video game.
These corporate fascist propaganda campaigns are truly grotesque. Watch America get all gung-ho about a program that is basically Hitler Youth with a little lipstick slapped onto it. We're F'ed big time.
The bottom line is (pun intended) would you send your own child to a school like KIPP? 'Nuf said.
"If you are a teacher with 28 children in your class this Fall, four of them live in poverty."
Except if you live in Arlington, VA.
Can't argue with a thing Mr. Horn says.
Just to add something to the mix though. Global capitalism is in an early stage of its inevitable collapse and the economy of the United States is now fully devoted to war and no longer has the capacity to maintain a functioning public school system. Every state in the Union faces a deepening hole in their budgets. Unemployed people stop paying income taxes. Foreclosed upon people stop paying property taxes. No wealth is created in this country today so there's nothing to tax. Nothing of value is made in the United States anymore!
Nothing that is except weapons of war. War making is the only "healthy" sector of the US economy left, which is why the US is staying in Iraq, escalating in Afghanistan, and expanding the fight to Pakistan, Yemen and Somalia. But an ability to deliver bombs from drone aircraft on people around the world will not rescue a broken economy.
Whatever real wealth hasn't been turned over to the banks or earmarked for keeping our Chinese creditors happy is devoted to war making and the weapons trade. The steadily accelerating destruction of public education in the United States, along with Social Security and every other remnant of our bourgeois democracy, is the result.
Nice analysis. The basement is on fire.
They want to indoctrinate your kids and take your money.
Our society needs to learn to do well by doing good. Job One is to get the country off its deadly fossil fuel addiction, so we can tackle Global Warming and lead the world to a zero carbon, clean energy future.
We can create a brighter world for every child, and good jobs for every citizen by just saying NO to oil wars, and saying a BIG YES to a 21st Century Clean Energy New Deal.
Super insulate every house, build millions of electric cars, connect every city with high speed rail. Plant Billions of Trees to restore our land and clean CO2 from the Air.
Job One should not end until every vestige of the warmongering, planet destroying oil, coal, and gas oligarchy is gone.
The movie's producers are releasing their movie at the exact moment when almost everything it's selling is being shown by study after study to simply not work. Charter schools are not performing any better than traditional schools, even though the "shackles" that supposedly hamper traditional schools have been removed. Merit pay has been shown to do nothing to improve test scores over time, even if you buy into test scores as an assessment, which I'm guessing most readers here do not. Some of the most prominent advocates of "reform" as defined by the charter movement and this movie have long since bailed out on its themes, and are actively promoting their rejection.
I am not so cynical as most here about the "purpose" of public education. Sure, it got seriously derailed by the imperial corporate and military agendas. But when public education was mandated at the origin of our society, consumerism, industrialization, and large standing armies were as much on the radar as space travel. It didn't start out the way it is now, and it doesn't have to stay that way. Of course it's hard to imagine how to stop it, since even the Progressive Caucus voted in force for Bush's NCLB, which explicity tied school funding to militarization of curriculum and school property and records, and now everyone is getting behind the disproven-in-the-starting-gate RTTP.
But if the movie actually succeeds in getting citizens to go to local school board meetings, while they will not succeed in pushing districts towards charter school and RTTP systems, they will become eyewitnesses to the truth about managing a school system. That could provide the opportunity to press state legislators to do the one single thing that will unshackle everyone: get rid of the property tax. I'd have to go way over the word limit to list all the benefits that would derive from that one thing.