EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Amir, Ten Years Old, Abducted by Israeli Soldiers from His Bed
Amir al-Mohtaseb smiled
tenderly when I asked him to tell me his favorite color. Sitting in his
family's living room last Thursday afternoon, 4 March, in the Old City
of Hebron, the ten-year-old boy with freckles and long eyelashes softly
replied, "green." He then went on to describe in painful detail his
arrest and detention -- and the jailing of his 12-year-old brother
Hasan by Israeli occupation soldiers on Sunday, 28 February. 
Hours after our interview, at 2am, Israeli soldiers would break into the house, snatch Amir from his bed, threaten his parents with death by gunfire if they tried to protect him, and take him downstairs under the stairwell. They would beat him so badly that he would bleed internally into his abdomen, necessitating overnight hospitalization. In complete shock and distress, Amir would not open his mouth to speak for another day and a half.
In our interview that afternoon before the brutal assault, Amir said that on the 28th, he was playing in the street near the Ibrahimi Mosque, on his way with Hasan to see their aunt.
"Two of the soldiers stopped us and handcuffed us," Amir said. "They brought us to two separate jeeps. They took me to the settlement and put me in a corner. I still had handcuffs on. They put a dog next to me. I said that I wanted to go home. They said no, and told me I would stay here forever. They refused to let me use the bathroom. They wouldn't let me call my mother. They blindfolded me and I stayed there like that until my father was able to come and get me late at night."
Amir's detention inside the settlement lasted nearly ten hours. "The only thing that I thought about was how afraid I was, especially with the dog beside me. I wanted to run away and go back to my house," he said.
Amir and Hasan's mother, Mukarrem, told me that Amir immediately displayed signs of trauma when he returned home. "He was trying to tell me a joke, and trying to laugh. But it was not normal laughter. He was happy and terrified at the same time," she said. "He wet himself at some point during the detention. He was extremely afraid."
Amir revealed that he hadn't been able to sleep in the nights following his detention, worried sick about his brother in jail and extremely afraid that the soldiers would come back (which, eventually, they did). Today, approximately 350 children are languishing inside Israeli prisons and detention camps, enduring interrogation, torture and indefinite sentences, sometimes without charge. The number fluctuates constantly, but thousands of Palestinian children between the ages of 12 and 16 have moved through the Israeli military judicial system over the past decade since the outbreak of the second Palestinian intifada. Israel designates 18 as the age of adulthood for its own citizens, but through a military order, and against international law, Israel mandates 16 as the age of adulthood for Palestinians. Additionally, Israel has special military orders (#1644 and #132) to be able to arrest and judge Palestinian children -- termed "juvenile delinquents" -- as young as 12 years old.
"This way, they have a 'legal' cover for what they are doing, even though this is against international laws," said Abed Jamal, a researcher at Defence for Children International-Palestine Section's (DCI-PS) Hebron office. "However, in Amir's case, they broke even their own laws by arresting and detaining him as a ten-year-old boy. These laws are obviously changeable according to Israel's whim. We have yet to see a prosecution for crimes such as these."
I asked Amir and Hasan's father, Fadel, to describe how one is able to parent effectively under this kind of constant siege.
"It's not safe for the children to go outside because we've faced constant attacks by the settlers and the soldiers," he explained. "This by itself is unimaginable for us. And now, we have one son in jail and another traumatized ... they're so young."
On Sunday, 7 March, exactly a week after Hasan's arrest and Amir's detention, the family and members of the local media made an early-morning journey to Ofer prison where Hasan had been held since his initial arrest. After a lengthy process in which the Israeli military judge admitted that the boy was too young to stay in prison, Hasan was released on the condition that he would come back to the court to finish the trial at a later date. This trial followed the initial hearing last Wednesday at Ofer, where Maan News Agency reported that the judge insisted that Fadel pay the court 2,000 shekels ($530) for Hasan's bail. According to Maan, Fadel then publicly asked the court, "What law allows a child to be tried in court and then asks his father to pay a fine? I will not pay the fine, and you have to release my child ... This is the law of Israel's occupation."
Consumed by their sons' situations, Mukarrem and Fadel say they are trying to do the best for their family under attack. "What can we do?" asked Fadel. "We lock the doors. We lock the windows. We have nothing with which to protect our family and our neighbors from the soldiers or the settlers. If a Palestinian kidnapped and beat and jailed an Israeli child, the whole world would be up in arms about it. It would be all over the media. But the Israelis, they come into our communities with jeeps and tanks and bulldozers, they take our children and throw them into prison, and no one cares."
DCI-PS's Jamal reiterates the point that international laws made to
protect children under military occupation have been ignored by Israel
since the occupation began in 1967. "Most of the time, we try to do our
best to use the law, the Geneva Conventions, the UN Convention for the
Rights of the Child as weapons against this brutality," said Jamal.
"All of these laws exist, but Israel uses their own military laws as
excuses to defy international law. As Palestinians, we have to work
together to create solidarity against this brutality. Through our work,
we try to tell the international community what's going on with
Palestinian children to create a wide berth of support against this
situation. We believe that the only way this will stop is through the
support of the international community."
Amir slowly began speaking again 36 hours after the beating by Israeli
soldiers. Zahira Meshaal, a Bethlehem-based social worker specializing
in the effects of trauma in children, said that Amir's "elective
mutism," a symptom of extreme psychological shock caused by his beating
and detention, is a common response, but that it is a good sign that he
began talking again. "This is a reaction of fear on many levels. Amir's
house and his family are his only source of security," said Meshaal.
"This was taken away from him the moment the soldiers invaded his home.
It's easy to attend to the immediate trauma, but the long-term effects
will undoubtedly be difficult to address. He'll need a lot of mental
health services from now on."
Meshaal comments on the nature of this attack in the context of the unraveling situation inside Hebron. "We are talking about a place that is on the front lines of trauma," she said. "This is an ongoing and growing injury to the entire community. Parents have to be a center of security for their children, but that's being taken away from them. Especially in Hebron, the Israeli settlers and soldiers know this, and use this tactic to force people to leave the area. It's a war of psychology. This is a deliberate act to make the children afraid and force people to leave so that their children can feel safer."
At the end of our interview last Thursday, Amir sent a message to American children. "We are kids, just like you. We have the right to play, to move freely. I want to tell the world that there are so many kids inside the Israeli jails. We just want to have freedom of movement, the freedom to play." Amir said that he wants to be a heart surgeon when he grows up. His mother and father told me that they hope Amir's own heart -- and theirs -- heals from last week's repetitive and cumulative trauma at the hands of the interminable Israeli occupation.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

36 Comments so far
Show AllDon't breath a word about it though--for fear of being branded an anti-semite.
If it was accptable to condemn Germany then it is fitting that we condemn Israel and not gush over it as some vibrant Democracy (according to Michael Lerner).
Indeed!
IF the peoples of Palestine , react in any way shape or form to this brutality, the Zionists of the World will spare no effort in pointing out how "Violent" Palstinians are and how necessary it is to bomb their cities and villages into submission for the purpose of "self defense".
The actions described in this article are nothing short of official terrorism. There is virtually no difference between the IDF and Hitler's SS.
Meshaal's comment reveals the truth behind this strategy. The Israelis are determined to destroy the Palestinians by crushing even the most basic unit of their society. They will allow no Palestinians to have any peace as long as they live on land that some zionist shithead covets.
Anyone who criticizes Israel or zionism in any way will be labelled as an anti-Semite in an effort to suppress discussion. We cannot let these bastards intimidate us.
I wonder what kind of nonsense Letto and his fellow talkbackers will employ to deflect this story.
q
[I wonder what kind of nonsense Letto and his fellow talkbackers will employ to deflect this story.]
I'm not sure they'll comment on this sort of story. After all, how do you justify the beating of a child? If they do comment it would be to tell us that the story itself is a lie...
"If they do comment it would be to tell us that the story itself is a lie..."
You appear to be correct. See richsmith2 (at 11:23 am) below.
q
I'd like to comment on this, but the words I'd use would not be acceptable.
Soldiers beating children, settlers or soldiers kidnapping children... What more can one say.
Yes, my initial reaction was that this had to be some crappy psyop story. To what end, though? Just to enrage people so they can be targeted for being enraged over a ten year old kid being snatched form his home, beaten horribly and traumatized for no reason. I mean, heh? The only people I know who WOULDN'T be enraged by a story like this are right wing Zionists. Or maybe they'd be enraged that the kid was returned home at all and able to regain his ability to speak just 36 hours later.
I have listened to Nora Barrows Friedman over the many years (of disgusting Israeli behaviour) on KPFA.org. I have known from listening to her that she really goes to these places and spends time with the Palestinian people and is doing everything in her power to get through to people like you. She got through to me. I happen to know that Israeli thugs have no care for anyone who is not an Israeli Jew or sympathizer. Everyone and Especially children because the IDF know that people that are treated this way - should have hate in their hearts.
They just can't believe that others would not be just as wicked as they are. It is a twisted logic which allows them to shamefully hurt children! and terrify their parents. You better get straight. You are seeming like a fake human.
Hey maybe I better get straight then, whatever that actually means.
Why did this happen? There is no prologue. Did the Israeli soldiers detain and beat the child for a reason, or was his selecton random? Why did they come back and beat him? There are holes in the story.
Did I miss something?
no matter what the prelude of this story is, there was no reason to beat the CHILD until he was bleeding internally. That is pure brutality that is akin to Nazi brutality when they were harassing the Jews for sport.
The Israelis just keep ratcheting up to provocations, evidently hoping to provoke a violent response so they can launch their annual decimation of Gaza and/or Lebanon.
To terrorize.
Because he is.
richsmith2, yes, you missed something. It's called state-sponsored terrorism, to further Israel's goal of driving the original non-Jewish inhabitants of Palestine off the land so they can steal every last millimeter.
From the article:
Meshaal comments on the nature of this attack in the context of the unraveling situation inside Hebron. "We are talking about a place that is on the front lines of trauma," she said. "This is an ongoing and growing injury to the entire community. Parents have to be a center of security for their children, but that's being taken away from them. Especially in Hebron, the Israeli settlers and soldiers know this, and use this tactic to force people to leave the area. It's a war of psychology. This is a deliberate act to make the children afraid and force people to leave so that their children can feel safer."
I understand the political and existental reasons for these acts - the Israeli/Zionist lust for "Kleinerlebensraum", but what was the legal reason given to these acts by the IDF through Israeli legal system? With that I could then reasonably say "What the f••k!"
What possible legal justification could there be for such horrendous treatment of children?
If you cannot be reasonably outraged at these acts without knowing the "legal reason" behind them then you are as great a monster as the cowards who perpetrated them.
q
Yes, indeed, q!
You can get further details and followup at
http://www.kpfa.org/archive/id/59197
Flashpoints, for March 8, 2010 - 5:00pm
http://aud1.kpfa.org/data/20100308-Mon1700.mp3
(BTW -- Flashpoints and KPFA are in critical need of funding, if you have a few bucks to throw their way to keep this sort of information flowing.)
The reason for this is that Israeli wants the Palestinians to abandon their land, so the policy is to make life there unbearable. The audio reports fill in all those holes.
The branding of critics as "anti-semitic" ensures that no one criticizes the basic principals of Judaism, or the ideological positioning of European Azkehnazis in the 20th Century.
The media that made anti-Jewish criticism taboo has protected a particular element of the American/British elite.
Doesn't this suggest a level of social control that monarchs used to claim? Even criticizing the king verbally was often punishable by social humiliation or... if you're a 10-year-old Palestinian boy ... incarceration or torture.
US supported terrorism. This is a disgrace. Whem will the MSM finally get it that the Palestine people are also Semites? This is not only a crime, but a sin against their "God" to terrorize and beat a child. I am sick about this and so many other things that we supply the money for Israel to do to the original people of Palestine.
The Israeli government learned well from the Nazi government, but they learned the wrong lessons. They have forgotten the Warsaw ghetto and the heroic resistance of the Jewish youth who held off the Germans until they finally cleared the ghetto with massive armor and troop action.
The lesson? Oppressed peoples fight, even against overwhelming odds.
The Nazis executed or sent to concentration camps any dissident voice. This in addition to the "Untermenschen" needing "extermination," i.e., Jews, Slavs, etc.
The Israeli government now has its own untermenschen, the Palestinians and, the Arab peoples in general. One of the government's people said a few years ago, "The entire Palestine population is not worth one Jewish fingernail."
In France, the Resistance fought on even against terrible reprisals. One act of sabotage, one killing of a Nazi, left whole villages being rounded up and shot. Still the Resistance fought on.
Now, I read, that it is illegal for an Israeli citizen to protest the government's actions. They are rounded up and jailed immediately as, I don't know, terrorists, terrorist sympathizers, perhaps just as protesters, but none-the-less, they are removed from public view and little is allowed to be published about it.
In short, and sadly enough, the Star of David could be replaced by the swastika in the Israeli flag and there would be little difference. People have said, "But the Israelis haven't killed millions, so they can't be compared to the Nazis!"
Remember, when the Nazis started, they hadn't killed millions either. Just beat up and killed opponents. Then dispossessed and jailed many more for having dissident opinions. With power, the cruelty and nastiness was unleashed on all who disagreed with them.
Israel has an estimated 200 to 400 nuclear armed missiles ready to go, largely due to our $3 billions per year that we give them (out of our taxes), mostly in advanced military hardware and advanced military technology. Israel has never admitted to having nukes. They sign no treaties, allow no inspections, and have said that, if it looked like Israel was ever going to be defeated, they would exercise the "Sampson initiative." That would be to launch all their nukes at the various capitals of Europe and the Middle East, to take everyone with them.
We used to have mental hospitals to put such people in so they could do no harm to themselves or to others. I guess the modern tactic, just as with Nazi Germany, is to cower in fear and appease, appease, appease.
At StratCom, the bar against using nukes preemptively against non-nuke forces has been removed. I imagine we can probably add our 3,000 plus ICBM's to Israel's 400, as we seem to do whatever Israel tells us.
I see a terrible end approaching, and see no way to head it off.
Yep, Israel is going to go out in a massive, psychotic global murder-suicide, isn't it? How else could that shitty little black hole of bad karma end?
to minitrue: david ben gurion, israel's first prime minister, promised j.f.k. that israel would never build nuclear weapons. see kennedy's july 5, 1963 letter to the israeli prime minister warning him to allow u.s. scientists to inspect israel's dimona nuclear plant, where j.f.k. suspected israel of developing nuclear weapons. the letters j.f.k. wrote are easy to find over google. if j.f.k. had not died, israel would not have nuclear weapons today. pathetic that we allow a nation of 7 million the opportunity to hang the nuclear sword of damocles over humanity's head.
This article is but the tip of the complete story. IsraHell rounds up approximately 700 Palestinian children each and every year. There are currently 318 Palestinian kids incarcerated by Israel. Many are tortured and are held for days, months or years.
The US government supplies IsraHell $7 million per day - more than any other country. Child terrorism and abuse anywhere is unacceptable, but to see our own US government support israHell child abuse is reprehensible.
I shall hold each and every one of my elected officials responsible for these atrocities.
Counting the days until November...
Isn't there rulings in the Geneva Convention making illegal the detainment of children under 15, AND the forcible restraint (handcuffs) of such children?
Israel has committed so many war crimes, they have stopped counting.
Israeli Nazi Zionist racist pigs rule! Here and There!
Or at least that is the net effect of US policy, courtesy of AIPAC towards Israel
But I could be wrong ! --- But I'm not in this case
Maybe Rabbi Lerner will stop by and lecture us about why it's wrong to get angry over things like this.
When you've had enough. Pass the link around:
http://www.boycottisraelnow.com/list.htm
Oh my god, this article was too horrible to read! The Israelis are too horrible to bear. i will read it because it strikes too close to home. Israelis will burn in Hell. We must stop them, we must free innocent children!!
where's letto?
Not an article that she/he can defend. Some hasbarists do have ethics, not many, but some...
Then again, be careful what you ask for. Mentioning the name might bring it here.
working on a positive spin on this.....I see smoke rising in an illegal settlement somewhere in the occupied territories.
*chuckle*
W