EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Remembering “Suicides” in the Rotunda
In the absence of an intact corpse, families often gather for memorial services rather than funerals.
The families of Salah Ahmed Al-Salami, Mani Shaman Al-Utaybi, and Yasser Talal Al-Zahrani - three Guantánamo prisoners whose earlier purported suicides were declared "asymmetrical warfare" by the Bush Justice Administration - received Salah's, Mani's and Yasser's broken and lifeless bodies. Previously the families had gathered to wake their loved ones, after authorities in their countries informed them that their sons had died in Guantánamo.
Following three grueling years of unanswered questions and heartache, Scott Horton's recent article in Harper's Magazine has revealed that the deaths of these three detainees may not, in fact, have been due to suicide, but to having been tortured to death in U.S. custody1.
Compelled to act by this tragic news, fourteen members of the Witness Against Torture fast (www.witnesstorture.org) were arrested in the Capitol Rotunda on Thursday, January 21st for holding a memorial service in remembrance of the three men. The activists paid respect to the families of the dead in the very room where U.S. presidents are historically waked, adorning a makeshift burial shroud with handfuls of rose petals and filling the enormous Rotunda with story and song.
The Yemeni and two Saudis have stories much like many of the other men who were (and still are) indefinitely detained at Guantánamo; snatched and handed over to the United States for bounty money, 16-year-old Al-Zahrani spent the last five years of his short life in custody. Al-Utaybi, orphaned in his youth and described as "a peaceful person who would harm no one", was intercepted after traveling to a conflict zone that straddles Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan to do humanitarian work. The U.S. Justice Department has no evidence linking Al-Salami to Al Qaeda or the Taliban. Two of them had already been cleared for release by the U.S. government; it was determined that they could not be held any longer, and they were flagged, finally, for return to their home countries.
All three were on hunger strike to challenge their illegal detention.
Although I had never met Salah, Mani, or Yasser, I could imagine the three Muslim men hauled out of their tiny cells on that dreadful night in June 2006. I could see their eyes fill with terror as their head, arms and legs were strapped to their chairs, writhing in pain as military personnel gouged at their eyes and bent back their fingers. Struggling for air as rags were forced down their throats, and then gasping, panicked, hooded and silenced, they finally left this world.
The bodies of the three men were returned to their families mangled and beaten, and, interestingly enough, in pieces. The U.S. government has refused to provide the families with their loved ones' throats.
We entered the Capitol last Thursday - the one-year anniversary of President Obama's inauguration - with hopes that this small act of remembrance would commemorate the lives of those we had never met. In the very spot every U.S. President has been laid before burial, we shared the lives and mourned the untimely deaths of our three Muslim brothers, tortured and killed on behalf of our "freedom" and in accordance with our country's "justice".
As I moved to lay our banner over the spot that marked the middle of the Rotunda, twenty-eight other activists, clad in orange jumpsuits and black hoods, were refusing to move from the steps outside the Capitol building. Our group inside formed a semicircle, and each of us adopted the name of an imprisoned detainee.
If someone had told me a year ago that I would find myself in Washington D.C.'s Central Cell Block, providing the police with only the name of a Guantánamo detainee and not my own, I would have been struck with disbelief. This courage was found through the experience of a twelve-day fast in the midst of a deeply connected and inclusive community. I have wondered how the prisoners who endure torture, indefinite detention and the loss of beloved friends at Guantánamo, Bagram, or any of the other U.S. secret prisons around our world find the courage and will to continue living. From what I've read and heard, they turn to community, faith and an abiding hope to be reunited with loved ones.
Remembering the victims and their families requires that we look in the mirror and see ourselves as we are seen by them. When we see what we have become, we may be prompted to ask ourselves, "If not us, who? And if not now, when?"- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

20 Comments so far
Show Allthank you for the work you are doing!
But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.
!!!!!
/cm
Why would the govt. not provide the bodies of the three detainees with their bodies intact? Who will perform autopsies? The sixteen year old detainee must be now twenty one? Why did our govt. holding on to the detainee's throats?
OMG, 1984 is here.
Because an autopsy of the throats would probably find fibers from the rags which were stuffed into them to choke them lifeless.
Not to diminish this horror, I would say that the recent decision by the Supremely corrupt court to further the unlimited corporate financial control of this government is of the same fabric. For now, We are only being silenced.
Autopsy of the throat would show their criminal behavior (See: Rags)
It would have also shown that they did not hang themselves.
Thank you Jerica and your associates for being true witnesses for humanity.
Yes Jerica, you are brave, very brave.
Thanks again
We are all being "good Germans" and staying quiet in our homes while our Fascist empire destroys, the world ignores our Constitution and kills innocents in broad daylight.
Disgusting!!
Jessica Arents inspires me with hope for future generations of Americans. May she and her colleagues continue and gather many more to join their ranks.
Poet
"The bodies of the three men were returned to their families mangled and beaten, and, interestingly enough, in pieces. The U.S. government has refused to provide the families with their loved ones' throats."
What kind of person would, let alone could, do this? ("Honey, I had to perform a little surgery at work today...can you get me some more coffee?")
"the banality of evil."
Our taxes paid for this outright barbarism. We are become a nation of impunity!
-30-
Jerica, This is the most concise report. Your facts, the response to the criminl activity of our government and your personal reflections tell this impotant story in all these human dimensions. Your courage inspires me, too. May we all support one another as we keep on keeping on. Paki
Jerica,
What a powerful and wonderful and meaningful act of nonviolent civil disobedience!
This action and your report are inspiring!
May God be always with you.
yes thanks for what you are doing.
i do not understand my fellow citizens apparent indifference to the plight of u.s. prisoners. from reading Andy Worthington and Stafford Smith it appears that the detentions are arbitrary, with no apparent cause. and as in these cases, even when the jailers and judges have found them innocent, they stay locked up and tortured anyway.
the entire gulag needs to be opened and exposed to the light of public scrutiny.
not just gitmo and bagram either the whole thing including secret prisons and rendition sites.
Check out Horton's original article in harper's. Shocking. When you read the account of what can literally be proved in a court of law, words fail. I know there are countless reasons to be ashamed of our government. But reading the factual details, understanding the complicity at the highest levels. I feel despair. But I will not stop my personal struggle to take this country back- I encourage everyone to take some action, in whatever way feels most appropriate (short of violence).
There was something that struck me in the Horton's article that I think bears quoting:
[As retired Rear Admiral John Hutson, the former judge advocate general of the Navy, told me, “Filing false reports and making false statements is bad enough, but if a homicide occurs and officials up the chain of command attempt to cover it up, they face serious criminal liability. They may even be viewed as accessories after the fact in the original crime.” With command authority comes command responsibility, he said. “If the heart of the military is obeying orders down the chain of command, then its soul is accountability up the chain. You can’t demand the former without the latter.”]
Yes, thank you. I don't suppose that there will ever be an inquiry.
This in its totality of incident and consequent action is a measure of America's collective significance.
While on this theme, it is pertinent to ask whether America follows Israel or Israel follows America.
One thing certain is that it is a measure of human depravity.
Deep thanks Jerica for your work and your report.
This - intense reflection, in community, followed by direct action, in resistance, at personal risk, with personal accountability - is what is needed.
This is what will actually threaten business as usual, and this is what will have a chance of stopping such horrific actions.
This is what Howard Zinn did, and wrote about, and repeatedly called for.
We the People.