EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Water Wisdom
Since 1966 - and as a consequence of the introduction of the Green Revolution model of water-intensive, chemical farming - India has over-exploited her groundwater, creating a water famine.
Intensification of drought, floods and cyclones is one of the predictable impacts of climate change and climate instability. The failure of monsoon in India, and the consequent drought, has impacted two-thirds of the country, especially the breadbasket of India's fertile Gangetic plains. Bihar, for example, has had a 43% rainfall deficit, and the story is the same in many other parts of India.
In the final analysis, India's food security rests on the monsoon. Monsoon failure and widespread drought imply a deepening of the already severe food crisis triggered by trade-liberalisation policies, which have made India the capital of hunger. They also imply a deepening of the water crisis.
The monsoons recharge the groundwater and surface-water systems. Since 1966, as a consequence of the introduction of the Green Revolution model of water-intensive chemical farming, India has over-exploited her groundwater, creating a water famine. The chemical monocultures of the Green Revolution use ten times more water than the biodiverse ecological farming systems.
In the 1970s, the World Bank gave massive loans to India to promote groundwater mining. It forced states like Maharashtra to stop growing water-prudent millets like jowar, which needs 300mm of water, and shift to water-guzzling crops such as sugar cane, which needs 2,500mm of water. In a region with 600mm of rainfall, this is a recipe for water famine.
A new study published in Nature magazine and led by Matthew Rodell of the NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center in Maryland shows that water levels in North India fell by 40mm between August 2002 and August 2008. And over the same period more than 109km3 of groundwater disappeared from aquifers, most of it extracted for chemical, Green Revolution-style farming.
Not only has chemical agriculture mined groundwater, but it has also mined soil fertility and contributed to climate change. Chemical fertilisers destroy the living processes of the soil and make soils more vulnerable to drought. Chemical fertilisers also produce nitrogen oxide, a greenhouse gas 300 times more potent than carbon dioxide.
The solution for the climate crisis, the food crisis and the water crisis is the same: biodiversity-based, organic farming systems.
Biodiverse ecological farms address the climate crisis by reducing emissions of greenhouse gases such as nitrogen oxide, and absorbing carbon dioxide in plants and in the soil. Biodiversity and compost-rich soils are the most effective carbon sinks. They also help adapt to climate change and drought by increasing organic matter, which increases the moisture-holding capacity of soil, and hence provides drought-proofing of agriculture.
Biodiverse organic farms increase food security by increasing the resilience and reducing the climate vulnerability of farming systems. They also enhance food security because they have a higher production of food and nutrition per acre than Green Revolution monocultures, which measure the yield of a cash-crop commodity, not the total food output, nor the nutritional quality of that food.
Biodiverse organic systems also address the water crisis. Firstly, production based on water-prudent crops such as millets reduces water demand. Secondly, organic systems use ten times less water than chemical systems. Thirdly, by transforming the soil into a water reservoir by increasing its organic matter content, biodiverse organic systems reduce irrigation demand and help conserve water in agriculture.
Maximising biodiversity and organic matter in the soil thus simultaneously increases climate resilience, food security and water security.
However, the dominant paradigm of agriculture based on the Green Revolution and genetic engineering is based on reducing biodiversity and reducing organic matter to promote monocultures based on intensive inputs of chemicals, water and fossil fuels. And as the multiple crises deepen because of these non-sustainable practices, corporations try and transform the crisis into new business and marketing opportunities. Examples include the patenting of climate-resilient traits that farmers have evolved over centuries and projecting this biopiracy as an ‘invention'.
In a recent article published in the Wall Street Journal, ‘Fight Droughts with Science', Henry I. Miller, co-author of The Frankenfood Myth, stated: "The first drought-resistant crop, maize, is expected to be commercialised by 2012. If field testing goes well, India would be a potential market for this variety." What Miller fails to mention is that India already has hundreds of thousands of drought-resistant crops.
These are the crops farmers are growing in times of drought. While cultivation of rice has gone down from 25.673 million ha to 19.13 million ha, the area under water-prudent drought-resistant nutritious crops has gone up from 15.325 million to 15.956 million ha. The biotechnology industry is clearly a laggard in breeding for drought resistance, compared to centuries of breeding by India's farmers. Miller also fails to mention that the genetically engineered drought-resistant maize seed performs badly in normal years. This is not science.
Another example of corporate opportunism in this period of drought is the pushing of Roundup (a broad-spectrum herbicide). Roundup kills everything green other than one single crop and therefore destroys the biodiversity and organic matter that is needed to promote climate resilience, conserve water and increase food production.
It is vital that the government of India does not use this emergency of drought to act as a marketer of GM seeds and Roundup. The alternative is clear. It involves:
1. Conservation and large-scale distribution of the seeds of water-prudent crops.
2. The promotion of organic agriculture to increase climate resilience and food and water security.
3. Incentives to farmers to encourage a shift from water-guzzling Green Revolution agriculture to water-conserving biodiverse organic agriculture.
Farmers did not create the Green Revolution. They should not be punished for its consequences.
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


16 Comments so far
Show AllAh the Green Revolution. A program of plant breeding, irrigation development, and financing of agrochemicals. What a crock. Turned productive farms into industrial sites with depleted topsoil and vulnerable monoculture crops.
Farmers used to rotate their crops to provide natural fertilization. Used green and animal manure. And planted a diversity of crops. But comes the Green Revolution. The product of the well-intentioned but simple mind of Norman Borlaug. Starting in 1943, the Revolution seemed to work. First Mexico increased its wheat production and stopped importing it. And then there was no holding it back.
People got fed alright. Increasing dramatically population growth. Meanwhile, the resource intensive Green Revolution was counting down on itself. There is, as the article explains, a big ticket to be paid with this system of agriculture. And big costs to the the ecosystem.
India is just the first to experience the drawbacks. Before long we will run out of fresh water for irrigation in the United States, the price of chemical fertilizer will continue to skyrocket, and the changing climate will continue to produce droughts and flooding.
And no longer will America be the breadbasket of the Western World.
Farmer Gary
"Never let the fear of striking out get in your way."
-- George Herman "Babe" Ruth, Jr.
Much if not most of the food in my So Cal grocery store is imported today. My Mexican relatives cannot buy good corn because people here purchase it for livestock.
"Water wisdom" -- isn't that homeopathy?
Ha! Great comment.
And thanks Gary for bringing up the large family of elephants in the room (to use CD's new favorite metaphor), population growth.
Vandana Shiva knows what she's talking about. Here is a very informative link concerning population, available resources, illness, energy, food, etc. that we should all bookmark:
http://www.poodwaddle.com/worldclock.swf
Another great reference that puts this in global perspective is the British journalist Fred Pearce's book, "When the Rivers Run Dry: Water, The Defining Crisis of the Twenty-First Century." Some of the water "crimes" in India are shocking, but it's happening everywhere.
Pearce's book deals with the hydrologic cycle from the ground surface down, while another of his books, "With Speed and Violence: Why Scientists Fear Tipping Points in Climate Change," addresses the hydrologic cycle from the ground surface up. Together, they are comprehensive summaries of how bad things are likely to become.
Can anybody say, MONSANTO. Criminal Bastards.
MONSANTO. Criminal Bastards.
Thank You Vandana Shiva.
You know, there are so many smart and good people in the world. How come they are not in Power???
Nature dictates that people live within Her means. History is full of dead civilizations that didn't.
Have other countries grow water intensive crops and then buy their crops. It seems like a sneaky way to buy, or steal, their water.
Vandana Shiva is soooo gangsta!
nobody knows more than she does about the planet and what it needs . it needs ending (subsidized) big agribusiness,
and and replacing it with small local farmers who know how to grow food without the earth killing practices of monsanto and cargill and the world bank.
just take a look
http://www.navdanya.org/
"Roundup kills everything green other than one single crop, ..."
Actually, probably, Roundup doesn't kill everything green other than one single crop. But it does drastically change the ecology of everything it touches.
In the American Midwest, for example, in the early spring one can see a monoculture of weeds appear in the fields. Vast expanses of mustard-yellow weeds (not mustard) that then die off before the corn and beans start growing.
There remains crop rotation in the Midwest---corn sucks up the nitrogen and then beans replace it to some extent---but the use of nitrogen fertilizers remains enormous. The soil isn't "sterile" but it is effectively dead. Over the past year I've dug into several of these fields and have yet to find a worm, for example, while one shovel load in my back yard will almost always contain worms.
Modern American agriculture is a Capitalist Disease and to the extent India attempts to mimic it they do so at their own peril. This disaster also hides under the radar of the MSM because they are a bunch of citified alienated egotistical overpaid bastards who think farmers are bumpkins. (The last two farmers I spoke with just by pulling off the road and asking them questions had Master's degrees!)
Change or die.
-30-
The coming global crisis in food and water is laid out in Dale Allen Pfeiffer's book, EATING FOSSIL FUELS.
Therein he explains that the Current American Diet (way of eating) requires 111 hours of endosomatic labor per capita; that is, without fossil fuels the current US daily diet would demand nearly Three WEEKS worth of labor from each American to produce the amount of food they eat Each DAY! So how is that going to work?
And as far as water, it takes 1,000 tons of water to grow 1 ton of grain. And the Ogalalla Aquifer which supplies the Midwest is now expected to become unproductive in around thirty years at current rates. When it does, the US heartland will go dry- and cease production of food.
Some 'green revolution' miracle! It would be more 'efficient' to just eat the oil directly. Except it can't be eaten. And it is going to be more and more scarce.
And see James Howard Kunstler's book, THE LONG EMERGENCY, which is also Kunstler's name for the coming global era of scarcity and depletion, in place of the era of The Long War... or maybe together with!
Good luck to us all.
Oh, and speaking of farmers... Jim Hightower for President! Now!
Yet, many people still deny that overpopulation is a problem. When the oil and water are gone will they remain in denial?
Thank you Vandana Shiva for all you do to preserve and protect. I feel great shame as a human being when I think of what has happened to Indian agriculture.