Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Haiti, Forgive Us
The tragedy of the Haitian earthquake continues to unfold, with slow delivery of aid, the horrific number of amputations performed out of desperate medical necessity, more than a million homeless, perhaps 240,000 dead, hunger, dehydration, the emergence of infections and waterborne diseases, and the approach of the rainy season, which will be followed by the hurricane season. Haiti has suffered a massive blow, an earthquake for which its infrastructure was not prepared, after decades—no, centuries—of military and economic manipulation by foreign governments, most notably the United States and France.
Haiti was a slave plantation controlled by France. In 1804, inspired by Toussaint L’Ouverture (after whom the now barely functioning airport in Port-au-Prince is named), the slaves rebelled, founding the world’s first black republic. Under military threat from France in 1825, Haiti agreed to pay reparations to France for lost “property,” including slaves that French owners lost in the rebellion. It was either agree to pay the reparations or have France invade Haiti and reimpose slavery. Many Haitians believe that original debt, which Haiti dutifully paid through World War II, committed Haiti to a future of poverty that it has never been able to escape. (While France, as part of the deal, recognized Haiti’s sovereignty, slave-owning politicians in the United States, like Thomas Jefferson, refused to recognize the black republic, afraid it would inspire a slave revolt here. The U.S. withheld formal recognition until 1862.)
The U.S. Marines occupied Haiti from 1915 until 1934. In 1956, Francois “Papa Doc” Duvalier took control in a military coup and declared himself president for life, initiating a period of brutal, bloody dictatorship, with U.S. support. Papa Doc died in 1971, at which point his 19-year-old son, Jean-Claude “Baby Doc” Duvalier, took over, maintaining the same violent dictatorial control until he was driven into exile by popular revolt in 1986. Jubilee USA, a network calling for elimination of debt owed by poor countries, estimates that Baby Doc alone diverted at least $500 million in public funds to his private accounts, and that 45 percent of Haiti’s debt in recent decades was accumulated during the corrupt reign of the Duvaliers.
Loans from the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) imposed “structural adjustment” conditions on Haiti, opening its economy to cheap U.S. agricultural products. Farmers, unable to compete, stopped growing rice and moved to the cities to earn low wages, if they were lucky enough to get one of the scarce sweatshop jobs. People in the highlands were driven to deforest the hills, converting wood into salable charcoal, which created an ecological crisis—destabilizing hillsides, increasing the destructiveness of earthquakes and causing landslides during the rainy season.
Haiti’s first democratically elected president was Jean-Bertrand Aristide, a Catholic priest committed to the poor. He was elected in 1990, then ousted in a military coup in 1991. In 1994, with Haitian refugees flooding into Florida, the Clinton administration was forced to restore Aristide to power, but only with additional structural-adjustment demands. Aristide was re-elected in 2000, only to be deposed again in a U.S.-backed coup in 2004, Haiti’s bicentennial.
The destruction of Haiti’s rice industry, which was replaced with U.S. government-subsidized rice that Haitians refer to as “Miami rice,” as well as the sale of critical state-owned enterprises, like Haiti’s sole flour mill and cement factory, have left the country dependent on foreign trade and aid, keeping Haiti at a permanent disadvantage.
It is critical now to cancel Haiti’s ongoing foreign debt, so that the country can devote its scant resources to rebuilding and not to repaying debt. The G-7 finance ministers met in Canada this week and announced the forgiveness of the bilateral debt between member states and Haiti. But the World Bank, IMF and IDB debts remain (the IMF controversially promised a $100 million loan after the earthquake, eliciting condemnation, and has since pledged to convert it to a grant).
Earthquakes alone do not create disasters of the scale now experienced in Haiti. The wealthy nations have for too long exploited Haiti, denying it the right to develop in a secure, sovereign, sustainable way. The global outpouring of support for Haitians must be matched by long-term, unrestricted grants of aid, and immediate forgiveness of all that country’s debt. Given their role in Haiti’s plight, the United States, France and other industrialized nations should be the ones seeking forgiveness.
Denis Moynihan contributed research to this column.
- Posted in


18 Comments so far
Show AllMs. Goodman's overview once again speaks truth to power... neo-liberal policies wrecked havoc on the nation, not unlike the island's first encounter with Europeans when Columbus and his hatchetmen (followed by the murderous Spaniards, etc) slaughtered thousands upon thousands on the island of Hispaniola. Populations estimated at 500,000 when Chris arrived were all but decimated some 5-10 years later.
The song remains the same.
wow, that was very informative. this really strikes me:
"People in the highlands were driven to deforest the hills, converting wood into salable charcoal, which created an ecological crisis—destabilizing hillsides, increasing the destructiveness of earthquakes and causing landslides during the rainy season."
does this possibly mean... that deforestation in the region could be partially responsible for the destructiveness of the recent earthquake?? actually, i dont think it's too far out of a conjecture... when you mess with the environment, it has to re-stablize itself somehow.
IF this is the case, it would show how much of an impact we humans can have on our environment... and would debunk people's ignorant notions that humanity can do whatever it wants to the planet, free from consequence (i.e. global warming non-believers).
And let's not forget...
"The coup, or the kidnapping, was led by the United States, France and Canada. These three countries were on the front lines, sending their soldiers to Haiti before Feb. 29, 2004, when Aristide was overthrown, by having their soldiers either at the airport or at my residence or around the palace to make sure that they succeeded in kidnapping me, leading (to the) the coup."
Aristide in an interview with Naomi Klein. Evidently Freedom Fries aren't on the menue in Haiti. So much for "spreading democracy".
Goodman's prescription isn't up to par. Instead of calling on the cobras in neckties to cancel Haiti's debt, Goodman should be calling on the US public to stand up and stand by Haiti in complete resistance against any/all elite/imperial/corporate entities/agents, including domestic, exploiting Haiti, past and present. The US public should stand up and support Haitians in rebuilding their economy, their infrastructure, and their lives through mass empowerment of the Haitian people, with NO elite/imperial/corporate involvement. All debts canceled, all shitheads out of Haiti. PEOPLE POWER. What a magnificent project. Anything less is out of the question.
It begins at home, but Haiti is an example of what no taxes, small government and "free enterprise" read private capital brings one and how the primative accumulation of capital really takes place. Historically all private property was the result of theft-originally the commons. Now all of the Western Powers are going to be calling for budget cuts to bring down the deficit after they have just raided the treasury. One good thing about globalization, the impoverishment of the world might just lead to some unified action among the working class across national lines. We are hearing a great deal about Haiti and Iran right now but nothing about the GENERAL STRIKE IN GREECE. We should all be providing support and march in solidarity with the strikers in Greece against any austerity programs their government is now trying to impose. Why because they are coming to a city near you in the very near future.
The fault is great in man or woman
Who steals a goose from off a common;
But what can plead that man's excuse
Who steals a common from a goose?
-Anonymous, in The Tickler Magazine, February 1, 1821.
First, thank you, Amy, for another excellent post giving us the truth behind the disaster(s) in Haiti.
Second, a question: Does anyone know where or how to get to the YouTube video showing the miraculous rescue of "Winnie," the 18-month-old Haitian baby who was rescued by an Australian TV crew? This was very moving, but I can't seem to (re)locate it.
Thanks in advance,
rosie2731
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WKAKaKmUlFI
Amy Goodman gives us the context, historical and political, that our MSM consciously and deliberatly withhold. The apotheosis of MSM reporting on Haiti was provide by ABC harridan Martha Raddatz who (tearfully, it appeared to me)told her viewers how the wretched masses applauded and cheered as US soldiers emerged from helicopters landing on the grounds of the presidential palace. Nothing, need it be said, about the gratuitous cruelty of US treatment of this country which drove them to and keeps them in a stoneage status.
The most dramatic example being the deliberate destruction of their rice industry which Goodman notes, and to my knowledge the MSM has never mentioned.
Amen. I watch her daily instead of the fluff pieces Rachel now does . She used to be excellent on Air America. Would talk about Blackwater and all the evil deeds the military does. Now, it is usually a recap of Keith's show. I wonder tho if she is being muzzled by GE and MSNBC. I would think this would bother her greatly, but maybe money really talks.
Amy give great headlines and follows up with excellent stories.
On Haiti, one guy on her show said that for every dollar donated to Haiti, 33 cents went to the US military. that totally screwed up the rescue. I personnally think this is being done on purpose. Wipe out the population and make it a resort place for the wealthy. Would not but this pass the US
Blackwater was guarding the drugs in the market in Port-au-Prince, and prevented rescue personnel from getting inside
The debt is being erased, and there are still people being pulled out alive.
Did anyone see the news about the drugs and money stored at the mail market in Port-au-Prince
It was at http://www.haitian-truth.org
As of last week, there are reputable groups handling the aid distribution to the rural areas that were hit, but some of the gangs are making it difficult.
Right, its like extorting money from someone youve held in a cage for years and then say to him "Allrite ill cut you some slack, you only owe me part of the money to pay for the chains i put on your ankles years ago. Am I not magnanimous?"
As much as this article does to describe what the U.S. and France have done to Haiti over the past 200 plus years, it understates the perfidy of these two great powers.
Thank you Amy.
We'll stand up for Haiti when we figure out how to stand up for ourselves.
Haiti's future is its past. Just as Baby Doc Duvalier embezzled the national treasury while foreign aid flowed in, so the Tonton Macoute remnants will embezzle the national treasury while foreign aid flows in.
The best thing our government could do for the Haitian people is to stop overthrowing their democratically elected ex-priest President.
It seems as if the thieves make their way into the Palace pretty commonly in Haiti. Preval is up to it again, and is stealing all of the aid.
I was there over the past two weeks, and I saw Preval's gangs sleeping in tents at night in the Palace grounds, and in the day- selling the AID BOXES in the street. Selling the water.
THERE IS NO FREE WATER THERE ANYMORE-unless you are lucky to find a burst pipe somewhere, or a hose that a generous person is letting folks use. You cannot safely drink the hose water, so people are getting sick from that- and now it is raining.
Preval has been blocking the aid flowing. I saw this with my own eyes- Trucks leave the Palace- I follow on a motorcycle. They go to the areas where "Customs" is happening, and they direct the forklifts to put the AID in their truck- they drive a few more miles, and stop- at a store (makeshift retail on the road side) and unload. I wait ten minutes for them to leave, and proceed to the "Store"
There, I pay fifteen dollars US for food and blankets and a tent- Enough to be fed for three days. I negotiated a bit, but they liked my charm, I guess.
I gave my box to a mother that was living under a sheet- right on the other side of the gate of the Palace where these thugs have their tents.
To hell with Preval. If you were there, you would not believe what is happening.
He is not a good man. Bellerive is also a monster to his countrymen. If you have not been there, you must see this with your eyes. It is real. In the coming storms, many more will die- now, there is 80% chance of another 5 earhtquake within the next 90 days???
new reports today at http://www.haitian-truth.org say that very thing.
Haiti is burning and the country in which many of us reside is destroying it further. Our overprivilege is the direct cause of these eventualities. Or is it?
Let's talk.
The Stop Privilege Blog: http://stopprivilege.blogspot.com/
See you there.
Matt