Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Already Forgetting the Martyrs of Egypt
In his news conference yesterday, Obama appeared to suggest that hundreds of protesters were not killed by the Mubarak regime in the last several weeks. Obama said, "what has been true in Egypt is -- should be true in Iran, which is that people should be able to express their opinions and their grievances and seek a more responsive government. What's been different is the Iranian government's response, which is to shoot people and beat people and arrest people. And, you know, my hope and expectation is, is that we're going to continue to see the people of Iran have the courage to be able to express their yearning for greater freedoms and a more representative government." Transcript from CNN; Video excerpt from Democracy Now.
This closely paralleled what I heard McCain say on Sunday. As he stepped out of the CBS studios, I was set to question him. Another reporter asked about Iran, and McCain said that in contrast to Egypt, Iran is a “more oppressive, repressive police state that knows no restrictions. We saw last time, they don’t hesitate to shoot and kill people in streets. Obviously, Egyptian military was not ready to do that.”
I corrected McCain in the course of asking him my question -- "There were hundreds of killings at the hands of the police over the last two weeks, sir" -- but he didn't correct himself or apologize. See the video:
See writeup at WashingtonStakeout.
The facts are rather stark: in Iran, during the protests in 2009, Human Rights Watch documented about 10 people killed. In Egypt, since Janurary 25, there have been over 300.
I did ask McCain: “Do we owe the Egyptian people an apology for having backed a tyrant for 30 years?”
He replied: “Hindsight is 20/20. … There’s many ways this government has been helpful to us ... I can’t apologize for what happened in Indonesia, for what happened in the Philippines, for what happened Romania.” Too bad, because apologizing might be the first step to bringing the dictator backing to a halt.
Obama claims: "But there are certain universal principles that we adhere to. One of them is, we don't believe in violence as a way of -- and coercion as a way of maintaining control." Think for a moment about how that sounds to an Afghan who has had a loved one killed by a U.S. drone attack. Or a Palestinian who has been wounded by U.S.-backed Israeli occupiers. Or, for that matter, an Egyptian who knows the U.S. backed the Mubarak regime for decades.Obama's "universal values" have a way of not being universal. He loves talking about how bad Iran is, but he was asked twice about Saudi Arabia in his news conference yesterday -- ie: "what concerns do you have about instability, especially in Saudi Arabia, as the demonstrations spread?" -- and he didn't mention the country. Compared to Saudi Arabia, Iran is a Jeffersonian paradise.
The dismissal of cheap blood is commonplace. Also yesterday, Obama gave George H W Bush the "Medal of Freedom." Exactly twenty years ago, the elder Bush launched the Gulf War, leading to the direct killing of thousands, the devastating sanctions on Iraq for over a decade and a series of disasters that are still causing great suffering. Just this past weekend marks the 20 years since the US bombed the Amariyah Shelter. The voiceover in the White House ceremony that honored Bush said he "built a broad international coalition to expel a dictator from Kuwait" as well as how his "humility and his decency reflects the very best of the American spirit."
Obama and McCain's comments are just a symptom. Let's hear the stories of the people who were killed by Mubarak's thugs, not just the stories of a few U.S. journalists, or a Google executive who was in detention virtually the entire time.
I've also felt ill at ease with pictures of Egyptians, perhaps at the behest of the military now running the country, "cleaning" the blood of those killed in the protests. Seems to me it should be memorialized, not "cleaned."
Certain victims are routinely invisible. It's remarkable that the victims of Mubark's thugs over the last several weeks -- even while occasionally rhetorically celebrated -- are among them.
7 Comments so far
Show Allc'mon barry soetero lying and/or manipulating facts - there has got to be some mistake in the reportage
barry's heart is in the right place - its sitting next to his birth certificate - man if he could only find that damn birth certificate
on a more serious note - who is taking that nwo scumbag shill for real at this point other than the corporate media trying to parse his utter bullshit into something that looks like a policy
if you believe barry - the zion death machine is a "victim" of those damn palestinians who keep getting in the way of their (amerikan) bombs and bullets
obviously a poor attempt on the part of terrorist arabs to discredit the only "democracy" in the middle east
hey i thought mubarak was elected, as was abbas, as was maliki
guess they don't count
welcome to fascist amerika folks - drinks will be served at 7
Hey, Sam Husseini, you should understand by now that our leaders love to BS.
I couldn't think of what to write and then I saw this quote by Chomsky that sums up my impressions, especially this last month, where it's been on such stark display. This is from The Washington Stakeout link above, and this whole article is recommended for further reading:
"It also mirrors recent comments by Noam Chomsky: “The United States, so far, is essentially following the usual playbook. I mean, there have been many times when some favored dictator has lost control or is in danger of losing control. There’s a kind of a standard routine—Marcos [Philippines], Duvalier [Haiti], Ceausescu [Romania], strongly supported by the United States and Britain, Suharto [Indonesia]: keep supporting them as long as possible; then, when it becomes unsustainable—typically, say, if the army shifts sides—switch 180 degrees, claim to have been on the side of the people all along, erase the past, and then make whatever moves are possible to restore the old system under new names. That succeeds or fails depending on the circumstances. …”
Being an American is not easy. It is very painful to watch and read about the actions of my government. I recommend reading Gingrich's quote. It's really quite sickening. I wish that America was predominantly a force for good, but I'm not seeing it -- I haven't seen it in a very long time. Forces for good in America are routinely assassinated. That's what I've been learning since I was a child -- and I didn't learn that from my family or school.
The more this administration talks the more it is placing the Iranian protesters in danger.
Excellent. Linked to my blog, "Warorpeace.wordpress.com". Stop in some time, please.
"Disappearing" the victims has a payoff both for the ruling class, who get to claim that they're not the vicious predators they constantly show themselves to be, and for their fellow-travellers, the folks who claim that peaceful protest, by itself, is sufficient to turn dictatorship into democracy.
Neither of those groups wants to be reminded of the truncated lives and unending misery for which they're responsible.
Cleaning up the streets and memorializing the victims of government violence and different concerns, no?