Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
The Indefensible Drones: A Ground Zero Reflection
The state of Nevada has charged Libby and me, along with twelve others, with criminal trespass onto the base. On April 9, 2009, after a ten-day vigil outside the air force base, we entered it with a letter we wanted to circulate among the base personnel, describing our opposition to a massive targeted assassination program. Our trial date is set for September 14.
Creech is one of several homes of the U.S. military's aerial drone program. U.S. Air Force personnel there pilot surveillance and combat drones, unmanned aerial vehicles with which they are instructed to carry out extrajudicial killings in Afghanistan and Iraq. The different kinds of drone include the "Predator" and the "Reaper." The Obama administration favors a combination of drone attacks and Joint Special Operations raids to pursue its stated goal of eliminating whatever Al Qaeda presence exists in these countries. As the U.S. accelerates this campaign, we hear from UN special rapporteur for extrajudicial executions, Philip Alston, who suggests that U.S. citizens may be asleep at the wheel, oblivious to clear violations of international law which we have real obligations to prevent (or at the very least discuss). Many citizens are now focused on the anniversary of September 11th and the controversy over whether an Islamic Center should be built near Ground Zero. Corporate media does little to help ordinary U.S. people understand that the drones which hover over potential targets in Afghanistan, Pakistan and Yemen create small "ground zeroes" in multiple locales on an everyday basis.
Libby, at the wheel, is telling Jerica about her visit to Kabul, in 1970. "I worked for Pan Am," said Libby, "and that meant being able to stay for free at the Intercontinental Hotel in Kabul. After landing in Pakistan, we hired a driver to take us across the Khyber Pass into Afghanistan. All along the highway we saw herds of camel traveling along a parallel old road. I wonder if the camel market in Kabul is still there?"
Jerica says she'll look for it. She and I have been hard at work to obtain visas and arrange flights for an October trip to Pakistan and Afghanistan. [Libby is exceptional in that she hasn't tried to talk Jerica out of the dangerous travel.]
Conversation switches to whatever CD has just come on, and I tune out, wondering if I've done my share of issuing warnings to Jerica about traveling in a war zone.
Tinny music and rural Texan countryside blend together.
My thoughts drift to the Emergency Surgical Center for Victims of War, in Kabul. A little over two months ago, Josh and I met Nur Said, age 11, in the hospital's ward for young boys injured by various explosions. Most of the boys welcomed a diversion from the ward's tedium, and they were especially eager to sit outside, in the hospital garden, where they'd form a circle and talk together for hours. Nur Said stayed indoors. Too miserable to talk, he'd merely nod at us, his hazel eyes welling up with tears. Weeks earlier, he had been part of a hardy band of youngsters that helped bolster their family incomes by searching for scrap metal and unearthing land mines on a mountainside in Afghanistan. Finding an unexploded land mine was a eureka for the children because, once opened, the valuable brass parts could be extracted and sold. Nur had a land mine in hand when it suddenly exploded, ripping four fingers off his right hand and blinding him in his left eye.
On a sad continuum of misfortune, Nur and his companions fared better than another group of youngsters scavenging for scrap metal in the Kunar Province on August 26th.
Following an alleged Taliban attack on a nearby police station, NATO forces flew overhead to "engage" the militants. If the engagement includes bombing the area under scrutiny, it would be more apt to say that NATO aimed to puree the militants. But in this case, the bombers mistook the children for militants and killed six of them, aged 6 to 12. Local police said there were no Taliban at the site during the attack, only children.
General Petraeus assures his superiors that the U.S. is effectively using drone surveillance, sensors and other robotic means of gaining intelligence to assure that they are hunting down the right targets for assassination. But survivors of these attacks insist that civilians are at risk. In Afghanistan, thirty high schools have shut down because the parents say that their children are distracted by the drones flying overhead and that it's unsafe for them to gather in the schools.
I think of Nur, trapped in his misery, at the Emergency surgical center. He'll be one among many thousands of amputees whose lives are forever altered by the war and poverty that afflict his country. Many of these survivors are likely to feel intense hatred toward their persecutors. 300 villagers in the Sayed Abad district of Wardak province took to the streets in protest on August 12, following an alleged U.S. night raid. "They murdered three students and detained five others," one of the protesters said. "All of them were civilians." Villagers, shocked by the killing, shouted that they didn't want Americans in Afghanistan. According to village eyewitnesses, American troops stormed into a family home and shot three brothers, all young men, and then took their father into custody. One of the young men was a student who had returned to the family home to celebrate the traditional "iftar" fast at the beginning of Ramadan. Local policemen are investigating the allegations, and NATO recently conceded that they may have killed some civilians. (see www.vcnv.org Afghanistan Atrocities update).
The drones feed hourly intelligence information to U.S. war commanders, but the machinery can't inform people about the spiraling anger as the U.S. conducts assassination operations in countries throughout the 1.3 billion-strong Muslim world. "Sold as defending Americans," writes Fred Branfman, "(it) is actually endangering us all. Those responsible for it, primarily General Petraeus, are recklessly seeking short-term tactical advantage while making an enormous long-term strategic error that could lead to countless American deaths in the years and decades to come."
The Prius is comfortable, but my side of the backseat has become a makeshift office. The most important file contains Bill Quigley's comprehensive argumentation as to why the court should allow us to present a necessity defense based on international law. Bill is the Legal Director for the Center for Constitutional Rights. On September 14, we want to call on him as an expert witness. We and our codefendants have chosen to mount a pro se defense to try to persuade our judge that far from committing a crime we have exercised our rights and our duties, under international and U.S. law, to try to prevent one and to raise public opposition to usage of drones in "targeted" assassinations.
Jerica hands me the questions we can use to elicit Bill's testimony. We try to word our questions so that the evidence will be admissible in court. "Could Bill please inform the court about citizen's responsibilities under international law, could he explain to the court what articles and statutes we will be invoking?" To a layperson, it seems like an elaborate game of "Mother May-I," and we haven't even started developing questions to ask Col. Ann Wright, the former U.S. diplomat, who had helped re-open the U.S. Embassy in Kabul shortly before resigning her job in a refusal to cooperate with buildup toward the May 2003 U.S. Shock and Awe invasion of Iraq.
Rounding out our trio of expert witnesses is former U.S. Attorney General Ramsey Clark. We hope his personal experience within the U.S. government might arouse the court's more careful attention to the seldom-discussed legal issues that are fundamentally at stake here. However, the judge has already indicated that his calendar only allots one day for our trial.
Libby, Jerica, Mary and I have blocked out at least ten days, inclusive of travel, for our small contribution to an ongoing effort of people around the world working to put drones on trial. We're in New Mexico now. I feel cramped and restless, and I wonder if Tucumcari, where we plan to stop for lunch, has internet. We can't possibly bring the testimony of Afghans and Pakistanis to court this Tuesday. Their testimony, borne on bodies scarred and mutilated and harbored in memories of nightmare, will never be given away and cannot be given in court. Extrajudicial killings are killings without rule of law, without trial. Few if any Afghan or Pakistani civilian survivors of U.S. wars will ever travel to a U.S. court of law for consideration of their grievances.
And at this moment I realize that if we were four Afghans or Pakistanis or Iraqis traveling in a war zone, we'd have spent this entire trip watching not the Southwestern landscape, but the skies.
- Posted in


13 Comments so far
Show AllTechnology has evolved.
Humans have not.
Kathy Kelly is a Hero.
After lunch she could have gone down the road abit to OilyBomber's newest Drone Command Center at Cannon AFB, which our Senators gave us, rather than the Smart Green Grid we asked for.
The Drones do target Al Queda but primarily, I calculate, they target Pashtun resistence leaders.
A NATO spokesperson recently said that the Haqani Network is the greatest strategic threat to the NATO occupiers.
Haqani is not even a Talib!
This is a war Between the Pashtun Nation and the USA for possesion of Pashtunstan.
I have often written all my reps and his highness OilyBomber that anyone who supports war criminals are themselves war criminals.
Your meaning implies being responsible and that is decidedly very unchristian and pro American, the "I'm not responsible, god made me do it and/or Satan made me do it but I'm not responsible". Today's pretend christianity appeal is that it institutionalizes the doctrine of "I'm' not responsible" which institutionalizes it thereby giving it legitimacy. This doctrine is also favored and used to the maximum by government, businesses and churches. They are war criminals, just not responsible for being war criminals because "god told them to be and/or Satan made me a war criminal but I'm not responsible". G.W. Bush used it, so it must be true because we all know Bush would never lie.
from the article:
~ And at this moment I realize that if we were four Afghans or Pakistanis or Iraqis traveling in a war zone, we'd have spent this entire trip watching not the Southwestern landscape, but the skies. ~
the sky is global...
if you'd have been driving along the Southwestern border, you might have seen a drone in those skies, as well...
or will, soon...
Good luck to all of you. You are doing the right thing by not being "good" Americans.
Hoa binh
Hoa binh
good luck to you and libby and to your friends...thank you
Christian nation my ASS! A christian nation would NOT be the largest arms dealer in the world. Our country has been taken over by greedy murderous war criminals who will stop at nothing until they achieve world domination. They hide behind the cross or the bible or whatever, and commit unspeakable acts of violence and cruelty in the name of gawd. What a crock of shit!
There is so much wrong this nation is doing, most of us don't know where to begin. Those who put themselves in harms way to "stop the tanks at Tiananmen" are inspirational to us all. Thank you.
Ladies, your defense has had a lucky break!. In the early morning news, I read that a drone had "wandered" into the air space above the Capitol! WANDERNG DRONES? Get along little doggies, Wow, I guess they can't always be controlled, can they!
The military was trying to decided whether to shoot it down, because that could be a problem, but fortunately, control was reconnected and the drone was back on its viral leash.
Even more indefensible about the drones...... The "ghost" in the machine, can now take them for a ride. Well, when the first drone crashes on the Texas border, I wonder who or what will be under it?
We do know what drone stands for anyway:
D-Devilish, R-raptors_ O- of N-Neutral E- Environments....
If the school kids in Afghanistan are afraid to go to their drone surveying school, and citizens are afraid to walk outside ( of course, inside, outside, doesn't matter to drones) then we have really buzz killed life and liberty for Afghanitsan and us. I'm sure that if they think that this is democratic behavior, then why would anybody want it?.
I often have very peculiar thoughts,and one just came to me.( I'm not dissing 9/11 families or survivors.) If a runaway U.S. drone, crashed into the 9/11 memorial, maybe THEN, people would realize that we are the enemies that we should be afraid of. .
KATHY KELLEY: God shed much Grace on thee. Thank you for having an unbreakable heart... for surely you have seen what would break a heart, again and again. And yet there you shine in your radiant immortality, bringing the barbaric lessons of war home, the ones our complicit media sanitizes away.
Whenever I see American children playing, I think of the children who became amputees in Laos/Cambodia/Vietnam from all the unexploded ordnance left there. It was Princess Diana's mission to rouse the conscience of Western nations to desist from using these time bombs that so often end up mutilating children.
And now you tell us of the precious little ones meeting the same fate in Afghanistan and/or Iraq.
It is so hard to make the horrors heard and felt here when people are taught to build walls between themselves and others. There are so many factors that contribute to the erecting of these cognitive walls that allow the horrific to become banal.
We all should be standing beside you, Kathy. Thank you for doing what every sentient soul SHOULD be doing. May the judge allow himself to be moved by the Higher Law... and not feel any political need to turn you and your conscientious associates into "examples."
What Sioux Rose said. Kathy must be the strongest person I know- yes Sioux an unbreakable heart, an unstoppable woman
Also Kathy Kelly I love you, thanks for this and everything else you've been doing for- what is it now 20 years? or more? Your radiance shines around the world- no really, I'm not being extravagant- do this anybody- try thinking of the world without Kathy Kelly- see? see how dark and pitiless it becomes? that's what I mean.
Thanks to Kathy Kelly for doing what we all should be doing, but don't for whatever pathetic reasons we use to excuse ourselves.