EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Image of Gas Attack Against Lone Brazilian Woman Goes Viral
- Transcript: Today's Live Q&A With NSA Leaker, Edward Snowden
- 'Tip of the Iceberg': Senators Warn Far More Data May Not Be Safe
- David Brooks, Tom Friedman, Bill Keller Wish Snowden Had Just Followed Orders
- On PRISM, Partisanship and Propaganda
Popular content
Today's Top News
'Modern Slave' Migrants Toil in Italy's Tomato Fields
RIGNANO GARGANICO, Italy - After crossing half of Africa and surviving a perilous boat trip from Libya in search of a better life in Italy, Boubacar Bailo is now contemplating suicide.
An African immigrant cooks in a makeshift camp in the countryside near the village of Rignano Garganico, southern Italy, September 23, 2009. Every year thousands of immigrants, many of them from Africa, flock to the fields and orchards of southern Italy to eke out a living as seasonal workers picking grapes, olives, tomatoes and oranges. Broadly tolerated by authorities because of their role in the economy, they endure long hours of backbreaking work for as little as 15-20 euros ($22-$29) a day and live in squalid makeshift camps without running water or electricity. Picture taken September 23, 2009. (REUTERS/Tony Gentile) One of an army of illegal immigrants hired to harvest tomatoes in the Puglia region, Bailo squats in a fetid cardboard shack restlessly waiting for a call to the fields.
Every year thousands of immigrants, many from Africa, flock to the fields and orchards of southern Italy to scrape a living as seasonal workers picking grapes, olives, tomatoes and oranges.
Broadly tolerated by authorities because of their role in the economy, they endure long hours of backbreaking work for as little as 15-20 euros ($22-$29) a day and live in squalid makeshift camps without running water or electricity.
"I never thought it would be like this in Italy. Even dogs are better off than us," said Bailo, a 24-year-old from Guinea struggling to survive in an area of Puglia known as the "Red Gold Triangle" which produces 35 percent of Italy's tomatoes.
"It's better to die than to live like this, because at least when you die your problems are over."
Things have been particularly bad this year in Puglia, whose tomatoes end up in dishes around the world, from the upscale restaurants of London to the homes of the village of San Marco just a few miles away.
The economic crisis forced factories in Italy's rich north to shut down or lay off employees, so more migrants than usual -- around 2,000 people -- have come here in search of work.
Rains -- a tomato picker's best friend because the machinery an increasing number of farm owners use to replace manual labor does not work properly on muddy grounds -- have been sparse.
And a crackdown by Italy's conservative government on illegal immigration has made farmers more reluctant to hire "clandestini" workers, particularly those easily identifiable as foreigners because of their skin color.
This month, the government launched an amnesty for immigrants illegally employed in cleaning or caring for the elderly by Italian families, but that does not apply to those bringing tomatoes in from the fields.
Bailo, who was denied an asylum request and has no papers, says he has worked eight days in the past two months "and I didn't even put 100 euros in my pocket."
"FEUDAL SYSTEM"
The going rate for illegal tomato pickers is 3.5 euros per "cassone" -- a big plastic crate that, when full, weighs 350 kg (770 lb).
On a good day, workers can hope to make as much as 35-40 euros from laboring from dawn to dusk.
But in most cases they will have to pay a cut to the so-called "caporali," middlemen who select the workforce for the farm owners and make sure the job gets done.
"It's a feudal system like in the Middle Ages. These modern slaves are handy for the economy: you can exploit them and then get rid of them when you don't need them anymore," said Father Arcangelo Maira, a local priest trying to help the immigrants.
The shanty town where Bailo lives in the countryside along with 600 fellow immigrants is known as "the Ghetto." From afar, it resembles a refugee camp in any war-ravaged African country, but the reality is possibly worse.
People sleep on bug-infested mattresses in overcrowded shacks made of cardboard and plastic sheets or in decrepit houses. Idle youths in dirty clothes brush off the mud from broken shoes, or play draughts using rocks on makeshift boards.
A group of men slaughters a goat in a corner.
After turning a blind eye for years, regional authorities in August set up 60 portable toilets and 20 water tanks to serve an estimated 1,500 immigrants until October, when most will move further south to the Calabria region for the orange harvest. Cheap accommodation for up to 300 people is also being readied.
But medical charity Doctors Without Borders (MSF), which since 2003 has been monitoring the area and helping immigrants get access to basic health services, says more should be done.
"The conditions in which they live and eat are extremely precarious. These are young, strong people who arrive in Italy in good health and fall sick here," said MSF doctor Alvise Benelli.
Spending hours kneeling or bending in the fields means that many suffer from back and muscle pain. The lack of hygiene causes skin and intestinal diseases. There is also an increasing number of people suffering from depression.
"They left their country and came here hoping to find an El Dorado, but they end up living in conditions that are often worse than what they had at home," said Benelli.
"You see it most when they are forced to stay indoors, they sleep for much of the day and don't answer when we speak to them. Sometimes I have seen them cry."
(Editing by Robin Pomeroy)
- Posted in
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...



15 Comments so far
Show AllNo body does migrant labor to find an 'el dorado' - its done because the system has destroyed other options at home.
Correct! Why is that so hard for some folks to see?
The people that enable this, that approve of illegal immigrasnt slaves are the lowest form of life.
When you are in a country illegally you are going to be abused and exploited. Shame on the "Globalist's" and no brder types that are responsible for this suuffering.
"Shame on the "Globalist's" and no brder types that are responsible for this suuffering."
Without borders, there would be no illegal immigrants.
Shame on the anti-immigrant types that are responsible for this suffering.
Supporting illegal immigration is supporting factual slavery in some cases, exploitation, abuse...both mentally, physicall and sexually. SHAME on anyone supporting this or trying to cover their actions by transference.
Beautifully presented.
"Are they members of society, who are owed something on that basis alone? Or are they victims of a latter-day Jim Crow arrangement, in which they are a permanent underclass? The European social philosophy demands the former. The oligarchy desires the latter.
Its not just Europeans, its a world wide problem......The oligarchy wins every single time. When weak social philosophy meets reality and the cost to the citizen population, the illegal loses every time.
Yes, a world wide problem caused by designating immigrants as illegal.
No one has designated immigrants as illegal. Only people in a country illegally are illegal and called illegal immigrants.
Would seem to be a simple concept to me. Immigrants enter a country legally and illegal immigrants enter a country illegally, hence the term illegal.
I have been thinking about a just solution for both the immigrants who leave their beleaguered homelands to try to make a living and the almost as badly off low paid and unemployed workers in the new country.
The only way out I can think of is this: We need reasonable minimum wage and working conditions laws that apply to everyone. The minimums should be high enough so that, for instance, native Italians could survive on them. That would mean that the poorest native workers are not in conflict with the desperate immigrants. The working conditions laws should be enforced regardless of the status of the workers involved.
It should be more of a crime to PAY less than the legal minimum than to ACCEPT less than the legal minimum. Until we start requiring employers to stop these semi-slave conditions, there is no solution. Employers should face punishment of equal severity as deportation to a fate of starvation or death by war.
PS - The one big disagreement I have with Jesus is the workers in the vineyard. Equal pay for equal work, I say.
PPS - Burlusconi has to go.
Joe
I like it.
I read the comments looking for someone to justify the wage-slave system. Usually we hear that those who express concerns are "racists." Didn't see that (yet) but here's a Karl Rove style attempt to deflect blame:
"Shame on the anti-immigrant types that are responsible for this suffering."
Get that? Those who expose and oppose wage-slavery are "responsible" for it.
And this: "Yes, a world wide problem caused by designating immigrants as illegal."
The inverted logic here (thanks Karl Rove) is that to eliminate wage-slavery you must legalize it. Brilliant.
But, then there's that pesky thing called history. (Rove is working on eliminating that.) In 1986 there were an estimated 1 million illegal wage-slaves in the U.S. Comprehensive immigration "reform" legislation passed that year granted them amnesty (made them legal). In all, 3 million got the amnesty. Twenty years later we had between 12 and 20 million illegal wage-slaves in the U.S., and a vastly multiplied set of economic and social problems.
So, if ceasing to "designate immigrants as illegal" doesn't solve the problem, what then?
Perhaps the illegal employers who recruit foreigners, smuggle them across international borders, provide them will fraudulent ID, and replace their citizen employees are the problem. Perhaps the border officials, lobbyists, PR hacks and politicians they buy and bribe are the problem. Perhaps all who disinform are the problem.
Perhaps we will hear now, in response, that those who think such thoughts are "racists." It never fails.