EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Wisconsin Bill Would Treat Organic Milk, Sharp Cheddar, Brown Eggs as "Junk Food"
- As Death Toll Rises Beyond 500, Garment Factory Disaster 'Worst in World History'
- Climate Change's 'Evil Twin': Ocean Acidification
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Disaster Capitalism Strikes as Hedge Funds Circle Near-Bankrupt Municipalities Like Vultures
- Move Over, Koch Brothers: A Bigger, Darker Rightwing Funder Is Out to Destroy Public Education
- Patent Filing Claims Solar Energy ‘Breakthrough’
- Wisconsin Bill Would Treat Organic Milk, Sharp Cheddar, Brown Eggs as "Junk Food"
- Climate Change's 'Evil Twin': Ocean Acidification
- Disaster Capitalism Strikes as Hedge Funds Circle Near-Bankrupt Municipalities Like Vultures
Popular content
Today's Top News
Virtual Living
Last week, the president warned a graduating class against a few gadgets and toys, iPods, iPads, Xboxes and PlayStations, where "information becomes a distraction, a diversion, a form of entertainment, rather than a tool of empowerment, rather than the means of emancipation," but this could easily describe nearly all of our media, with Obama, like the rest of our ruling class, a prime beneficiary. As our entire society unravels and the Gulf of Mexico becomes a dead sea, what do you find on television but singing and dancing contests, huge people losing weight, pregnant teens and endless sports? That is, the usual stuff, all noise and no consequences.
The age of mass media coincides, roughly, with the oil era. Before the 20th century, there were no radios, televisions, movies or recorded music, only newspapers. Oil provided the perfect fuel for the combustion engine. With it, cars and airplanes became possible, shortening distance and making the local less relevant or even real, the same effects achieved by the mass media.
When I went from Philadelphia to Hanoi in 1995, I was definitely there and not here, since there were no internet cafés to keep me in both places. I could not email or check how the Phillies were doing. When I went to Iceland in 2007, each second I spent online distracted me from the magnificence of that country. It's true that all media displace us, even a book, but at least with reading, the imagination is activated and one has control over the pacing, that is, one can slow down, pause and reflect. Not so with television.
Microsoft asked, "Where do you want to go today?" How about nowhere. I just want to be here. Now. Do you know where you are? Eating dinner, the married couple slouch on a couch, their eyes fixated on the garrulous screen. They chat only during commercials, thanks to the mute button. "How was your day, hon?" In separate rooms, the kids are transfixed by their own screens.
No mass media is as pervasive or intrusive as the American one. Now that we've stopped making stuff, more or less, we're still super prolific at selling our own image. (That and 155 billion dollars' worth of weapons of mass destruction annually, 41% of global sales worldwide.) When I was in Vietnam from 1999 to 2001, I had the hardest time convincing friends that, no, Americans don't spend the bulk of their time lounging by the pool, dancing, rapping and tossing money into the air. To quote Harold Pinter, "As a salesman [America] is out on its own and its most saleable commodity is self love. It's a winner."
This hypnosis works even on Americans, who should know better. But we don't live here so much as inside media. The average American watches four hours of television a day, listens to constant music, and there's also the internet with its Facebook, texting, twitter and email, etc, to distract him. Two or more of these activities are often indulged in simultaneously. In a third of American households, the television is never turned off.
For many of us, our first impulse upon entering a new space, be it country, city or room, is to escape it. I must get online. Staring at a computer, a person can flit from NBA playoffs to Katherine Heigl, to a napping and slumping Ken Griffey Jr., to porn, to the boxscore of a game he doesn't give a damn about, to Gisele Bundchen, to Elena Kagan. Gulf oil spill? What Gulf oil spill?
The problem with the media is not that there's no meat in it, but by stuffing lard, blood, scrapple, gristle, chicken mess, acorn, corn syrup, sawdust, meat and whatever else into an unending sausage, nothing could be isolated long enough for anything to matter, not even the tortured death of a nation or a planet. Everything has become a blip in a gush of tedious entertainment, even Abu Ghraib and Goldman Sachs outrages. Of course, in this diseased system, fluff weighs more, since it benefits the Washington and Wall Street criminals to have us fixated on Simon Cowell, Rihanna or some dancing parrot.
Our basic social needs, to mingle, see each other face to face and chatter, have been supplanted by the virtual, with chatrooms and forums replacing taverns and squares. In your typical bar nowadays, the patrons must shout in brief spurts, since the music is too loud for a sustained conversation. Eyes are most often glued to a bright TV. So much for the drinking hole as a social space, and music as occasional and celebratory.
Simply put, our culture is hostile to thinking and talking. About the only American environment where discussions are encouraged, or just made possible, is the university, but these are conducted mostly by people without dirt under their fingernails, hence the gross disconnect between the academy and the rest of us.
In Italy, there's a quaint custom known as the passegiatta. For a couple hours before dinner, people actually hang out or walk around their local square. This bonding and soothing practice embraces even foreigners. This is not possible here because we don't have the proper spaces. Our few squares are landscaped, with paths dictating traffic, unlike an open piazza that encourages congregrating and loitering, that allows free movement and wide vistas. In most American localities, there are no squares at all, only shopping mall food courts.
Our typical mall is surrounded by an oil spill. Here and there, a half-assed berm. Once you've gone through the hassle of driving there, then looping back and forth to seize a parking space, you might as well spend a few hours inside the air conditioning and fork over a Ben Franklin or two. It's designed for that. At a square, however, you can buy nada and not feel like you've wasted your time. With home shopping, even this degraded mingling inside mall can be dispended with altogether.
Cocooned in a virtual universe, many of us can no longer see or care that our real world is being destroyed. In March of 2010, a Korean couple was charged with starving their 3-month-old baby to death, even as they spent twelve hours a day at an internet café, raising a virtual one, Anima. Like them, we've been seduced into nurturing a ghost while our souls die.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

43 Comments so far
Show AllKeep working, drink as much as possible, take your television's advice
America isn't the only nation that has gone virtual yahoo. I have seen it pick up in some of the other nations that I visited. The difference is in most other nations, individualism is not a dominant trait compared to the US. Socializing is so-so at best in the US and I can't tell you how annoying enough it is to watch a teenager walking with a cell phone or someone around my age hooked to their notebook computers even at the airport. Interestingly, in international airports, of all the people using their notebooks, ipods, cellphones, etc... it would rarely be a foreigner. The concept of socializing, face to face, and doing it all local just doesn't click well in the US compared to other nations even as long term unemployment, recession, and depression set it. :(
love the photo blog.... reminds me of my city (denver) and thanks for the reminder to get away from this virtual 'reality' out into the enfleshed spirit of the day.... i have to say it was amazing to me a few years ago when i went on walkabout to live off the grid and landed in a communal situation where it was not atypical for someone to email another (we had wifi--go figure---this was in a place that prided itself on its off-grid permaculture ethic) rather than turn around and speak to the person across the room. this electronic apparatus is not only generating copious amounts of stubbornly nonbiodegradable waste & isolating/separating human beings from their potential as NONaddicted beings, but contributing to a tremendously lonely collective trance that keeps us distracted from (or, possibly worse, entertained by) the violence-economic, militaristic, psychic.... of a commodified and privatized so-called 'life'. i don't want to rag too much on it, but we are a fabulously stupid species and simultaneously with such capacity for kindness and beauty it is breathtaking..... enough said... time to take some breaths outside where the rain has made the grass and leaves into unnameable jewels..... and thank you for this needed post.
Sioux Rose
MATANGICITA: Cool post.
At least one-third of the world's people believe in an after-life or reincarnation. If this is the fact of our essence, then the probable upcoming die-out may be eased by the fact that so many no longer really identify with other living forms, or the earth as a living entity. I am not making apologies for this state, just seeking to understand how this detached behavior being "electronically enabled" may factor into the big picture.
Here on CD I think it's fair to say that most of us feel (or experience) a natural affinity for certain persons, and also the converse. This "feelings nature" is believed to live on as an aspect of the eternal essence of the soul-self.
My point is that with environmental wreckage speeding up, many of these young persons may not live out entire lifespans. Perhaps their souls are being prepared for aborted lives by investing so much into the nether sphere of virtual reality?
This is just a theory of mine. These types of things cannot be proven. They do offer some solace when we take in the magnitude of the probable impacts of a world infested with war, weapons, trick-economics, and now accelerating climate changes. Not everyone of the 6.6 billion hold winning lotto tickets to stick around. Energizing those apsects of the being that do not require a body may be their saving grace or adaptation to death come too quickly upon them.
Is there Wi fi in the afterlife? Might be the cynic's question here.
Woody Allen was asked if he believed in the after life. He answered, "No. But I'm bringing a change of underwear just in case."
Wi-fi is the afterlife. We sure as hell won't continue as "souls"--so the only way we will live on is by way of Facebook pages, postings at blogs like this one, and other remnants we leave on the internet. It won't be a particularly enjoyable afterlife--the Mormon Heaven seemed pretty cool to me--but I suppose it is better than nothing.
We live on through our teaching of youth. When teaching, I often found myself speaking aloud the teaching I received as a youth. And my children are both fine people, as their children are. That assumes, of course, that there will be any futer for them at all - a future I am not terribly hopeful about.
Yep, and we live on through our parenting. But the memories disappear after a few generations unless we are Plato or someone like that. These days I feel my own continuance is of absolutely no importance and only the continuance of the world ecosystem counts for anything. Odd how Christianity places the emphasis on individual salvation instead of on the collective well-being of us all. Is that the ultimate selfishness or not?
Along with virtual living, web connectivity allows for virtual reality, where opinion trumps reality. Idiotic ideas held by fools can live on almost indefinitely because the fools can easily find each other and keep the lies alive by reinforcement. The reasoning seems to go like this, if I am of the opinion that the world is 6,000 years old, and I can find others that think it is 6,000 years old, then it is 6,0000 years old, and no pesky facts are going to change my opinion.
A quick trip around the web, and you you can find people that think Obama is a Moslem, and was not born in this country. Or that we never landed on the moon, or that the gulf oil spill is no big deal because oil is a natural substance, or that there is no such thing as global warming, or if there is, it is not caused by man. And I could go on and on and on...
The lack of common sense, critical thinking, and the idea that opinion = reality, boarders between shocking, and just plain scary. I can see why the country is in the sorry state it is.
I left middle-class America 22 years ago. It was an easy choice to make. Our country had just finished 8 years of an actor for president. What could be more fitting for a country that was educated by their beloved TVs. Most Americans don't know it but what they are watching on their TV is the crumbling and declining empire, their country.
Hoa binh
This is one of the best articles I have ever seen on this website. Dinh is soo right on here. It is the reason I have never purchased a television, that I have a 'Kill Your Television' bumper sticker. I watched neighborhoods die in the early fifties in Maine, when commercial television arrived. I watched families die as TV trays took the place of family dinners. I watched the increasing isolation of the individual as TVs became common in children's bedrooms. And then the social isolation of cell phones and music headsets. And while this was progressing, our government under Reagan did away with the anti trust act, allowing individuals and individual corporations to eat up all media, until 5 entities own virtually all of it. I have been listening to NPR for thirty years, and have listened to its steady slide to the right since Bush appointed Attila the Hun to head PBS/NPR. No people can make rational decisions in the absence of good information, and any population can be controlled by simply controlling the information they take in. Television is the most successful sales device ever created by humans, and what it is selling these days is dead minds. Dinh is so right about this. Most American men will hear none of this, because most American men are addicted to television. More men than women by far, and there is good evolutionary reason for this, having to do with our initial existence as savannah dwelling primates.
KILL YOUR TELEVISION
While I agree with the essence of your post, MichaelC, isn't there more?
The internet, like tv, can be used for educational purposes or brain-dead entertainment. Why do more Americans turn to "American Idol" or "Dancing With the Stars" when they could (perhaps) find a thought-provoking doc on PBS airing at the same time? The fact that there is a dearth of educational programming on television points more to a concerted (collusive?) effort on the part of the programmers (who obtain their "bribes" from their advertisers) to keep the masses voiceless, uniform and gray --- all while ironically and cynically "celebrating" their individualism through commodified "choice".
I asked my mother once, why she didn't like to watch challenging art films, or educational television programs. She said, "I want to be entertained. I don't want to think."
I kinda need my TV, I'm semi invalid and without HD Theater and Discovery Channel my world would be even a smaller place.
Becides I Need to Watch Dr. Who! :)
>^^<
"Virtual Living"
That is a very good quick analysis and comment.
"Cocooned in a virtual universe, many of us can no longer see or care that our real world is being destroyed."
The "passegiatta" of our lives have been commercialized away, our natural impulse for socializing hijacked into moneyspending.
*
'Passegiatta' - Definition:
As evening falls and the harsh sun inches out of your favorite piazza, an evening ritual is bound to begin, the Italian tradition of 'passeggiata', a gentle stroll (slow! think slow!) through the main streets of the old town, usually in the pedestrian zones in the 'centro storico', the historic center.
Italians tend to dress up for 'passeggiata', and tourists are usually easy to spot in their shorts and fanny packs. Older folks sit along the route, nursing a beer or a glass of wine in the bar, and watching for things to gossip about; 'la passeggiata' is where new romances are on display as well as new shoes.
'Passeggiata' is especially popular on Sunday evenings. During the summer, some Italians even drive to nearby cities, the coast, or the lakes for a special 'passeggiata'.
Thanks for the correct spelling, by the way. Two gs, one t.
"About the only American environment where discussions are encouraged, or just made possible, is the university, but these are conducted mostly by people without dirt under their fingernails, hence the gross disconnect between the academy and the rest of us."
You nailed it Mr. Dinh.
Thank you, Linh Dinh! What a wonderful and insightful article!
Sorry but i dont want to live in 1950. I want to live in a world where people are empowered via mass communication and access to information. Where we can bring the peoples of the world closer to each other, use the tools of the information technology revolution to bring down the old nation states and vested interest of transnational corporations.
Just another view on the same tech !
Where in this article does the author suggest that the solution is to get rid of the tools of information technology and go back to living in the 1950's?
The only suggestion of a possible solution to this virtual living problem that I gathered from this article was the idea of the Italian tradition of passeggiata - which, IMO, sounds like a great tradition.
You were obviously not alive in 1950, when there were half as many people on this planet as there are now, when life was much slower and more fulfilling.
If you were black in the United States in 1950, you were just as likely to get the crap beat out of you for using the wrong water fountain in half the country.
When I was ten years old I purposely used the wrong water fountain (I'm what is called white).
I never got anywhere much insisting on the truth (the memory of the times my guts failed me still stings).
I have a message for polite, lying, timid society: go fuck yourself.
I'm old now and don't have to worry much any more about getting into trouble; I'm just a crazy old man who nobody pays attention to. They remember me as one of their more mediocre teachers who stole his salary and is still a social parasite, what with drawing my pension and SS.
I don't remember ever caring what they thought. Now I'm sure I don't.
BawHahahaha! I found a way around that for awile, I was a long hual truck driver. My advise to anyone jump in the car/ truck for a few hundred hours. take out your soul look at wrinkle it bend it fold, and staple it. If you like it keep it. Otherwise make a sharp right turn, at crusing speed. You won't find too many bad people driving trucks. they get weeded. usually by themselves. and nobody will try to change you speech or laugh at your ideas.
That kind of Humans choosen enviroment is the office. Where my soul rots now :(
>^^<
:) sounds like grade school, :( and I ain't Black or Brown :!
And what are we doing on this site now?
Touché, of course.
But we're also actively interacting, rather than being passively mesmerized (only).
We're escaping back to reality the same route we were abducted - we might say.
*
Besides, it's raining outside.
My thoughts on this vitual country.
WHAT IS LIFE?
This question has been dogging me for a while and there has not been an answer that would satisfy anybody that has to struggle to keep body and Soul together for themselves or, heaven forbid, a family. To go down the street and see an old lady going through the trash cans when they are put out on the street on pickup day tells me more than is good for my mental and emotional health. That does not include the homeless that have recycle trash diving down to a science. This is supposed to be the richest and most “advanced” country on this planet is it not? I live in Sacramento, CA and Arnie is aiming to cut welfare altogether, cut other entitlements to seniors and anyone else that has little or nothing to begin with and all the while making sure that them that has keeps. What is life? The country’s leaders torture, execute, steal, cheat, did I leave anything out? All of in the name of safety and I ask; for who or whom? All this and probably stuff we don’t even know about and the whole world gets to “contribute” if they have anything to steal for if they were to buy or pay fair market value it would be seen as a sign of weakness. What is life? My belief in reincarnation is solid and it was my choice to be here at this time but now I ask: what is life?
Tony
It's a chance to be in the physical world with your 6th sense. Whether your on the top of the food chain or the bottom, you make the best of what you have.
Karmic living, you can be a happy pauper or a miserable millionaire. (Vise-Verse)
When your worn out and life leaves your body, I like to think the "soul" stays intact to eventually fill another physical entity.
If you fill your soul with understanding of "life" you move up the chain. If you are a greedy hollow slime ball, you come back as some kind of slime and live in the hell you created.
Just a wish!
I enjoy that fantasy too but one that I like even more is that I put more into the karmic common than I took out and that next time around the surplus will be divided equally among all---the best as well as the worst. It wouldn't be much, not enough to notice, but if I could know I did that I would die happily.
Nietzsche;I like the idea of the pot for accumulated Karma by a Soul to pass on to all who need.You do realize that you would then be a saint;there is work to be done no matter where you are,you can rest for a 1000 years,but eventually one must be doing.Is the life easier,better for a Soul in another dimension,dont remember and that is good otherwise if we had to try and live a life with all the Karma hanging on like a bad suit no one would last past 5 because there is going to be some bad shit as none of us is perfect.Dont know if I want to come back.Tony
The only prayer I have at this stage of life is "Please don't send me back here". I'm trying as hard as I can to hang on until I die from 'natural causes' but I know of the siren call to take a hard right at cruising speed.
Anybody who this world considers sane is crazy.
I am sure I don't have to tick off the evils of this sick society to you, but the thing I hate most is looking at my grandchildren---any kid---and wondering what the hell is going to happen to them.
Nietzsche;agreed and thank you.Tony
NMBill;That answers for Karma but to see so many that suffer I have to ask did all these Souls deserve to "live" this way at this time? Maybe it is like catching a wave by a surfer and they serve all their Karma at one fell swope and with the shit times we have now it would actually help in the long run.Just gets overwhelming as my body gets older.Tony
Read "The Book; On The Taboo Against Knowing Who You Are" by Alan Watts.
Interesting, all my life people ask me who I am. I naver did find a satisfactory answer. I figured i just missed school that day :)
I work, I plan, I sleep, I feed the catz, I pay bills, oh yea! and I go to work.
>^^<
"The man behind the microscope has this advice for you:
"Instead of asking 'What is it?' just ask 'What does it do'?
Clever :) I did, no answer as yet :(
>^^<
I didn't make it up. I play pretty fast and loose with giving credits.
This question is being asked inside of and by the answer, which does not involve meaning. A contradiction, no, a protective mechanism by consciousness that prevents the relative objects that it creates from disrupting it's continuous self referral. In other words the question has no answer in meaning, but the question can be realized as and in being. The question will return after the realization of being, but now is answered with a smile.
It's very true that USans are using too many gadgets, and too distracted with the garbage content pushed through those gadgets. And USans' are too casual about the issue, not making enough of an effort to address it, to improve their lots in life.
But the whole process is carefully nurtured by USan elites as their agenda is to grow the enterprise, for the thrill of the chase, for more munny, power and influence. So thanks to the elites the volume of garbage, both gadgets and content, is ten or twenty times what it should be.
USans' distractions go hand-in-hand with their casual attitudes toward the social/environmental plunder they participate in. And when another elite-induced catastrophe hits the shore, everyone knows that USans will accept it readily as those never impose much threat to the supply lines delivering the petro-opiates.
The context suggests a general action USans may take to contribute to the solution: Shift their market and civic demands away from far-flung elites and toward their local small-scale producers, to help bring the power and influence back home where it belongs.
The author suggests that books are better than TV because the consumer retains control. I agree, and I see the internet as a better book. This is because an ebook may be realized with a tiny fraction of the embedded materials/energy as paper books. Think about it. There's the shared repository. And the client gadgets can be small, and kept for a lifetime, perhaps two or three. No need to replace them.
I've noticed that standards bodies composed of individuals rather than corporations create the kind of industrial structures that work best. Open technical standards are to machine production what open-pollinated seed is to food production.
munch on narcotics and e-tune... the U.S. way. or is it I- tuned out ?
I like it that TV can entertain me and the internet can educate and connect me but I absolutely agree that their power to manipulate us is used very successfully. When I was reading this article I thought about the 1st day of the invasion of Iraq. There was a television set at my work place and employees would stare at the “shock and awe” without much of an expression on their faces, other than a little pride that they were associated with such a powerful military machine. I thought (or I should say, I hoped) that they would react differently if they were thrown right in the middle of it all.
The predominant effect of the media can be either to enable us to better engage with reality or to distract us from that same reality. A civilization can be said to be in decline at the precise point at which virtuality trumps reality. (Also, see Bill McKibben's excellent _The Age of Missing Information_)