Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Activist’s Personal Journey Stretches From Battlefield to Protest March
How does a soldier become a peace activist?
For Charlie Clements, the answer lies somewhere between the lines of a 40-year-old military document that he keeps to this day.
“It says I’m 10 percent mentally disabled,” Clements said with a smile last week. “My protest was quite a silent one in some ways – I went quietly into the night.”
Clements, 64, is executive director of the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy at the Harvard Kennedy School.
He’s also one of 300 or so military veterans who will march through Portland’s Old Port this morning to mark the 25th anniversary of Veterans for Peace, which has grown to more than 6,000 members nationwide since its founding here in Maine back in 1985.
Military service does different things to different people.
Some wear it for a lifetime as a badge of honor, weaving their war stories more deeply into their very identity with each retelling.
Others tuck it away in the closet and rarely, if ever, talk about it again.
Then there are these vets, almost all decades removed from their days in uniform, who spend their gray-haired years marching not to the sound of a military band, but rather to the lyrics of anti-war protest songs.
Each, of course, has his or her own story. For Clements, once an Air Force pilot who flew more than 50 missions in Southeast Asia before deciding one day he couldn’t anymore, it begins as a 17-year-old cadet at the U.S. Air Force Academy in the mid-1960s.
“The dominant thought in my class was, ‘We hope the war doesn’t end before we get there,’ ” Clements recalled as the Veterans for Peace conference got under way Thursday. “Because wars are where young men test themselves, they are where young officers make their mark, they are what we were trained for.”
Upon earning his commission as a second lieutenant, Clements enrolled with the Air Force’s blessing in a graduate astronautics program at UCLA. He could have sat out the Vietnam War with his nose in a book, but he decided eight months into the program that he had a duty to serve in Southeast Asia.
He remembers walking in uniform past protesters at UCLA in the fall of 1967 – back in those early days of the anti-war movement, the protesters would just stand silently with their signs while he and his comrades passed by.
“I remember thinking very clearly that I knew much more about the world than these people did, that this was their right to do this,” he said. “And that I would go to Vietnam and defend their right to do this because I have a better understanding of this threat that faces us.”
CHOSE TO PILOT TRANSPORT PLANE
He also knew he didn’t want to kill anyone. So, upon graduating from flight school, he chose to pilot a C-130 transport plane rather than an assault aircraft and, with the war at full tilt, departed for Vietnam in August of 1969.
“What (the C-130) afforded me was a vast opportunity to see the war from different perspectives,” Clements said. “And with these experiences, I began to have encounters that gradually lifted the scales off my eyes.”
He once watched then-President Richard Nixon insist on the Armed Forces Network that the United States had no military presence in Laos, when he knew for a fact that C-130s just like the one he flew were ferrying personnel and supplies to secret U.S. bases there.
“Before that, it had never occurred to me before that the president would actually go on television and lie,” Clements said.
He once transported a group of 60 Viet Cong prisoners from one location to another – he was struck not just by the hatred in their eyes whenever they looked at him, but by an intensity, a sense of purpose that he rarely saw among young American GI’s.
GETTING THE BODY COUNT RIGHT
He once showed up at a morgue to pick up the body of a soldier killed in action. “You can’t have him today,” a sergeant told him. “The body count’s not right and we have to hang onto him for a few days.”
Known for his sharp intellect, Clements once was asked by his higher-ups to write a history of the Low Altitude Parachute Extraction System by which C-130s delivered ordnance and supplies without actually touching down. The so-called LAPES procedure didn’t work well. That didn’t matter.
“I soon realized they were going to record this the way the Air Force wanted it recorded,” he said. “Not necessarily the way the pilots perceived it was happening,”
Then there was Cambodia.
In the spring of 1970, Clements flew a top-secret delegation of State Department officials to Phnom Penh – he was told at the time it was for an off-the-record meeting about securing a portion of the Ho Chi Minh Trail that passed through that country.
Only later would Clements learn the meeting was actually to plan the overthrow of Cambodia’s Prince Sihanouk – a precursor to the invasion of Cambodia launched that May. As he flew troops into Cambodia the day before the invasion began, he found himself consumed with anger.
“I’d had this rationale that I wasn’t killing anybody, that I was an innocent of sorts,” he said. “But throughout that day I began to understand that I was very much a part of the machinery of war, that I was greasing the skids of war. And I decided what I was being asked to do was immoral.”
He asked for and received an emergency medical leave home. And when he told his stateside commanding officer that he could no longer fly missions in Southeast Asia, he was sent to an Army medical facility for what he thought was a routine psychiatric examination.
Upon his arrival, a hospital nurse handed Clements a set of pajamas.
“No, you don’t understand,” he said. “I’m staying over at the officers quarters.”
“No, you’re staying here,” replied the nurse. “This is a closed psychiatric ward and you’re not leaving.”
There he remained, without visitors or telephone privileges, for weeks. And six months later, after refusing an offer to have his record sanitized if he’d just go back to Saigon and resume flying, the Air Force quietly declared him 10 percent mentally disabled and gave him an honorable discharge.
PUTS MEDICAL SKILLS TO USE
Clements would go on to become a physician and combine his medical skills with human rights work in Central America, where he spent the early 1980s treating victims of the civil war in El Salvador (many wounded by the same U.S. military aircraft in which he once trained). It was there, in 1985, that he met and joined the founders of Veterans for Peace.
He also later served as president of Physicians for Human Rights, traveling to Sweden in 1997 to accept the organization’s Nobel Peace Prize for its efforts to ban land mines.
And now here he is in Maine, one of a small battalion of gray-haired veterans who emerged from war convinced that there has to be a better way.
Clements knows that some perceive Veterans for Peace as a ragtag group of radicals bent on tearing down the same country they once took an oath to protect. He also knows that perception could not be further from the truth.
Even now, he said, he has nothing but “empathy and respect” for those currently serving in the military – not to mention the families who have endured two, three, four or more deployments to Iraq or Afghanistan.
“I think our military is, more than ever in my lifetime, separated from the rest of society,” Clements said. “There’s a gulf between the ordinary civilians in our country and the military. We’re fighting two wars, but nobody (outside the military and their families) feels like they’re making any sacrifices.”
Time will tell whether the aging Vietnam veterans who now dominate Veterans for Peace will be replenished in the coming years with soldiers equally disillusioned by their service in Iraq or Afghanistan. Clements’ experience tells him the transition from the battlefield to the protest march often takes years, not weeks or months.
He’s also come to expect that as he and his comrades parade through downtown Portland this morning, some on the sidelines inevitably will call them a disgrace to the uniform they once wore.
But that piece of paper – the one that all these years later still labels him 10 percent out of step with the powers that once were – leaves him no choice.
“You don’t do this because of what people will think,” Clements said with another anything-but-angry smile. “You do this because of something inside you that compels you to speak your truth.”
- Posted in




22 Comments so far
Show AllExcellent posting! There is NO GREATER disillusionment than the NEED to go to war!!!!!
I, also, am a Vietnam veteran and I have mixed feelings about this article. While I agree with Charlie Clements about having empathy for those who are in the military I do not have respect for them because, as he himself points out, those soldiers are part of the machinery of war who are also greasing the skids of war. And while I have empathy for the soldiers I have even greater empathy for the citizens of Afghanistan and Iraq and Pakistan as they have constantly been on the receiving end of the brutality and terror that have been unleashed by our less than benevolent United States military.
"You still think it's beautiful to die for your country. The first bombardment taught us better. When it comes to dying for your country, it's better not to die at all."-From a speech given by Paul Baumer [played by Lew Ayres] in the 1930 film All Quiet on the Western Front
"A brilliant man will find a way not to fight a war"-Spoken by Admiral Yamamoto [played by the Japanese actor Mako] in the 2001 film Pearl Harbor
"The Pioneers of a Warless World are those Youth who refuse military service"-Albert Einstein
Most soldiers are not trained to think outside the boundaries. In fact, I felt like I was trained to into forbidding myself to be curious. As I had written yesterday, you won't get a direct answer as to why you're really there to fight. Could it be resources, forcing conversion to religion, or what? Each soldiers comes to a conclusion based on the given information and the clues each one collects and interprets. I didn't shut off my curiosity for if I had, I would have never thought of bailing out of Afghanistan.
**Most in here like to refer to this phenom as the 'out of control military
industrial complex', sucking away our $$$ billions tax dollars, and putting us into a Global posture of being pre-emptive war invaders and mongers.
**Pres Dwight Eisenhower warned us exactly on this danger in his
1960 farewell address to the Nation. Many deaf ears never heard nor
comprehended Eisenhower's words or meanings.
Now we are living it, suffering thru it, as did Charlie Clements. Clements
knows well who is suffering.
“MOST people in the US don't have any idea that at least 59 cents out of every one of their tax dollars goes to support the military and the god-forsaken wars they fight.”
This fact seems obvious (to us), but that statement is profound.
Your message bears repeating, by anyone who still cares, over and over and over again.
The Propaganda of the Dark Side is effective because weak-minded people tend to believe Planted Lies, when they are constantly repeated.
The medium seems to be the message (I just now thought of that) - catchy, huh?
The military media complex ensures that most Americans don't realize the damage caused by our militarized society and economy. Still, just because they are unaware of the damage doesn't mean that the damage does not exist.
Charlie Clements, another American hero who refused to go along just to get along.
I met Charlie 20 some odd years ago, have his book, and am also a Veteran for Peace.
Oh, would that there would be 10,000 more just like him!
It was my good fortune to attend an event and meet Charlie in 1984 when he came thru town with a slide show of his El Salvador work. He awakened my anti-war organizing interest, and made me focus on the Central American situation of that time. He is a hidden hero of our time, and it is great to see him recognized here.
Bring America Back !!!!
**Kudos to CD for including this piece in todays clips.
**Aside from Mr Clements personal story and inspiration, it would be more than educational to look into the stated mission of the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy, as well as the Vets for Peace actions, accomplishments, and member requirements.
** Within our Democracy there is but one Dictatorship== which is the Military Srvices. That's where all orders and commands come down the chain of command, and never go back up the chain.
**Should troopers voice dissent or dissatisfaction of their
upper commanders, that is grounds of insubordination and is usually met with a dishonorable discharge, or a Court Martial under the Uniform Code of Military Justice ! Thusly, the Dictatorship has its own judicial system.
**During and after 'Nam, I believe General William Westmoreland admitted to submitting false enemy body counts to LBJ in order to encourage war proliferation, more US involvement, thereby lying to his Commander In Chief.
**Recently, we had a modern day reverse experience between Prez Obama and his Afghan General MacChrystal-- who publicly voiced derision of military policy and plans. The General is now replaced and I think has entered retirement, somehow keeping his chin up==as does Charles Clements after all these years.
"it would be more than educational to look into the stated mission of the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy..."
A search on the Carr Center turned up this mission statement.
The mission of the Carr Center, like the Kennedy School, is to train future leaders for careers in public service and to apply first-class research to the solution of public policy problems. Our research, teaching and writing are guided by a commitment to make human rights principles central to the formulation of good public policy in United States and throughout the world.
Since its founding in 1999 through a gift from Kennedy School alumnus Greg Carr, the Center has developed a unique focus of expertise on the most dangerous and intractable human rights challenges of the new century, including genocide, mass atrocity, state failure and the ethics and politics of military intervention.
Great article.
Charlie Clements as a young academy military officer experienced the same misconception that Andrew Bacevich experienced. “I remember thinking very clearly that I knew much more about the world than these people (protestors) did, that this was their right to do this,” he said. “And that I would go to Vietnam and defend their right to do this because I have a better understanding of this threat that faces us.” And in both cases, it took a good many years for them to clear up that misconception.
They got a building down New York City, it's called Whitehall Street, where you walk in, you get injected, inspected, detected, infected, neglected and selected. I went down to get my physical examination one day, and I walked in, I sat down, got good and drunk the night before, so I looked and felt my best when I went in that morning. `Cause I wanted to look like the all-American kid from New York City, man I wanted, I wanted to feel like the all-, I wanted to be the all American kid from New York, and I walked in, sat down, I was hung down, brung down, hung up, and all kinds o' mean nasty ugly things. And I waked in and sat down and they gave me a piece of paper, said, "Kid, see the psychiatrist, room 604."
And I went up there, I said, "Shrink, I want to kill. I mean, I wanna, I wanna kill. Kill. I wanna, I wanna see, I wanna see blood and gore and guts and veins in my teeth. Eat dead burnt bodies. I mean kill, Kill, KILL, KILL." And I started jumpin’ up and down yelling, "KILL, KILL," and he started jumpin’ up and down with me and we wuz both jumping up and down yelling, "KILL, KILL." And the sergeant came over, pinned a medal on me, sent me down the hall, said, "You're our boy."
Didn't feel too good about it.
Do they still use Whitehall St.? I went through there in 1957 and it was very organized and efficient. A substantial number of us walked in as normal people and walked out as recruits on our way to Ft. Dix. No one that I can remember was drunk or hung over; we were all kids who were cowed by the aura of the place.
These are lyrics by Arlo Guthrie from =Alice's Restaurant= composed in 1967. I had the fun of attending a 1967 Chicago Loop performance by Arlo, and he sang this song for 25 minutes.
The military induction center at 39 Whitehall Street, New York City, was bombed so successfully in 1969 that it could no longer serve its purpose.
Trylon
TRYLON: Okay. At first I didn't think you were giving credit to the source from which you drew these quotes. I see you posted it later.
ERROLL: Thank you for your wise insights on this topic.
PEGGY FOR PEACE: Right on!
My thought for posting Alice's Restaurant lyrics sans credit was, first, to amuse Charlie Clements [AF graduate 1967] and second, to amuse any others of the Vietnam generation here. I didn't expect any readers from The Greatest Generation. My bad.
For anyone patient and interested, here's some of my historical findings, across decades.
From my summer reading, I had a moment of satori in early autumn 1958. It went like this: if 100,000 Vietnamese Jews living in the north of Vietnam decided they did not want to live under =communism=, not one American naval vessel would be assigned to transport a single one of them down the Tonkin Gulf to the newly created South Vietnam in some Operation Passage to Freedom. The US shamefully accepted Albert Einstein as their token Jewish refugee from Shoah.
History wrongly records that in 1954 the United States set up a puppet dictator in the person of Ngo Dinh Diem.
What happened was a subtle coup in which Pope Pius XII reached inside the American Hand Puppet, then HE placed a dictator in Saigon. He was a younger brother of Bishop Ngo Din Thuc, graduate of the Asian College in Rome and from the late 1920s an acquaintance of Francis Spellman. By the way, this was Pacelli's second major coup against US foreign policy.
His first was in 1933 when he manipulated nearly the entire diplomacy between the FDR White house and visiting Commissar Alexander Litvinov. His coup involved getting an agent priest into Moscow, disguised as FDR's =American Chaplain=. Upon arrival, this bloke made a beeline for living quarters at the French embassy, where their diplomatic pouch could be available for communication with the Vatican. The Russians realized this from Day One. Wild Bill Donovan probably figured it out right away. FDR died not realizing it. My guess is the only a handful of Yanks realize it today. So - my POV is in the gladiator's ring battleground for history.
Trylon
On the History channel during interviews of American, Russian, and German vets, many cry. Gone is the bravado and the insatiable pride of youth; it is replaced by a nagging sadness for friends lost and innocence crushed by the senselessness of war. All wars are begun by lies and then stoked by jingoism until one side is starved of it's youth and old men and women push their belongings in carts down ruble filled streets.
VFP 156 is with you in spirit...march on for ....
Peace
Mr. Clements deserves profound respect for his intellect, his emotions, and most improtant, for his heroic actions.
He is a true American military hero and patriot.
Jim Shea
Making peace is something any soldier can do but the hard part is getting people back home who look at them as patriotic heroes to recognize a different meaning and view of patriotism some of us soldiers come up with after we're done serving. Each of us bases our views on our experiences and the clues each of us collects to reach a conclusion and then decides what to do from there.