Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Adbusters Targets Corporate Propaganda With #OccupyXmas
The yurts are barely dismantled and the tents only just rolled up, but there is already a new movement on the horizon — Occupy Christmas.
Canadian magazine Adbusters — which prompted the Occupy Wall Street camp and subsequent set-ups around North America, including Toronto’s St. James Park — has put out a call for another round of capitalism-disturbing.
Customers await the shopocalypse outside Old Navy. (photo: Robert Stromberg)
This time, the target is the gift-giving season.
“Christmas has been hijacked for us,” said Kalle Lasn, editor-in-chief at Adbusters, a non-profit, Vancouver-based alternative magazine. “It’s become this ugly, soulless, consumer-fest.”
In a note on their website, the magazine asks supporters to “launch an all-out offensive to unseat the corporate kings on the holiday throne.”
It is all planned to start this Black Friday on November 25, a notorious day of shopping excess in the United States and also the date of the publication’s 20th annual Buy Nothing Day. American media reports suggest planned protests at stores such as Walmart.
Lasn said Occupy Christmas would extend from the end of November to the sales in early January. He added that the closure of Occupy camps in several Canadian cities, including Toronto, signals the end of “phase one” of the movement but warned of a “spring offensive” in the new year.
The ideas for Occupy Christmas, which Lasn likens to “shenanigans,” include:
— a Santa sit-in, whereby protesters sit outside a store and encourage people to cut up their credit cards;
— a Jesus walk, where people put on a mask in the Holy Son’s likeness and walk through malls, to create an eerie sentiment;
— a “whirly mart,” in which would-be shoppers fill their carts with products but abandon them at the cash register.
“This movement is somewhat about angering people,” Lasn said.
At the soon-to-be shuttered Occupy Toronto site, participant Shirley Ceravolo said she’d be interested in joining the Christmas movement.
“It’s a great idea. You don’t need to spend money to show your family and friends that you love them,” said Ceravolo. “Santa is just a symbol of corporate propaganda.”
But some think targeting Christmas goes a step too far.
“There’s a difference between protesting in a public park and on private property,” said Sally Ritchie, vice-president of communications and marketing at the Retail Council of Canada, which represents 43,000 storefronts.
“It’s illegal to do it on private property, such as malls or stores, because it’s dangerous and it interferes with rights of other people.”
Ritchie said the holiday season is most important to retailers.
“Christmas is vitally important to retailers ….it’s their make or break time,” said Ritchie, who added the industry contributes $74 billion annually to the Canadian economy.
“This is going to hurt very vulnerable, small independent retailers. They live and die on Christmas.”
Steve Tissenbaum, a professor of business strategy at Ryerson University’s Ted Rogers School of Management, said disruptions in stores may simply force more people to do their shopping online.
And while it could raise awareness around corporate culture, Tissenbaum said the Christmas season is too meaningful to too many people to simply be abandoned.
“I think they’ll alienate people more so than build on the cause.”
Adbusters created an #OCCUPYXMAS hashtag to mark the movement for those to follow and share online. As of Wednesday afternoon, more than 1,600 people had tweeted the page and some 20,000 had liked it on Facebook.
- Posted in

111 Comments so far
Show AllCan you imagine how any large-scale event like #Occupy could get started without an organizer? And "organizer" is quite different from "leader." From what I've seen, the various #Occupy venues have no leaders, though, it is human nature to look for them.
Adbusters has been working for over 20 years to awaken people to the destructive effects of mass-psychology (advertising) and consumerism. That they have organized #Occupy is fitting.
So far, Occupy Whatever has accomplished exactly nothing.
10,000 liberal bloggers blog blog blog about “consciousness raising” or similar New Age crapola, and meanwhile we’re sliding into war with Iran, real unemployment sits at 15%, and millions of homes are in foreclosure.
But there’s just about one last chance to make a difference:
OCCUPY THE IOWA CAUCUSES!
DUMP OBAMA!
NOMINATE ELIZABETH WARREN!
Or you can piss and moan for the next four years, and the rest of your life.
That's a false dichotomy.
Ex: americanselect.org
Wow. I totally agreed until you went into what our one last chance to make a difference should be. Same old tired establishment liberal line. What a load of crap.
_____________________________________
Agreed!
A lot of what you say is very interesting and pertinent. I think we can all learn something from your as-you-describe-it cynicism (I might call it knowingness or sophistication or skepticism). Certainly a viewpoint worth hearing/reading. It makes me think, anyway.
"I think we can all learn something from your as-you-describe-it cynicism (I might call it knowingness or sophistication or skepticism)."
Cynicism is none of those things. Cynicism is giving up. When folks start doing, instead of pointing fingers at the imperfections of others who ARE doing, then I listen to them. Otherwise, they are just cynics.
Here's a small excerpt from an article by Ralph Nader, published in CD in April this year:
****************************************************
Waiting for the Spark - by Ralph Nader
>>"What could start a popular resurgence in this country against the abuses of concentrated, avaricious corporatism? Imagine the arrogance of passing on to already cheated working people and the jobless enormous corporate losses? This is achieved through government bailouts and tax escapes.
History teaches us that the spark usually is smaller than expected and of a nature that is wholly unpredictable or even unimaginable. But if the dry tinder is all around, as many deprivations and polls reveal, the spark, no matter how small, can turn into a raging inferno."<<
****************************************************
The folks at the Adbusters just happened to throw the spark on to dry tinder that already existed. In fact, just before OWS started, there was this civil disobedience act to stop the Keystone pipeline and people got arrested. And before that, there was Madison, Wisconsin. It was only a matter of time. And as Ted Markow points out, it is fitting that the spark was lit by this particular group. I just hope that they don't get carried away by it all. One thing I was unhappy to see was the misuse of the "Robin Hood" legend for a financial transactions tax, and Adbusters was among the cheerleaders, NOT realizing that the Robin Hood name is better used for a real redistribution initiative such as a package of progressive tax, property tax and estate tax that **actually** will have some real effect. But can't complain too much and no one is perfect.
"The folks at the Adbusters just happened to throw the spark on to dry tinder that already existed."
Agreed. And who started what when is really beside the point. As you said, the tinder was dry and ready to burn, so whether it was Adbusters or Ghostbusters who got it going doesn't matter. The fact is, it started and needs all the oxygen it can get.
"But can't complain too much and no one is perfect."
Oh Alcyon, c'mon, you've been around here long enough to know that there are quite a few perfect people here on CD. Just ask them!
Yes, be good little sheep and do as you are told! Go out and spend all of that money that you don't have! And when you've gone even deeper into hock, we will still take your house and your car! So don't forget to vote republican or democrat and keep the status quo strong and secure! SUCKERS!
There are a lot of small, local businesses that need to be bought from. Buy if you may, buy if you must, but buy local as much as possible. Keep those dollars circulating in your community.
Unfortunately, if there is a WalMart in your community or small town, that's where the crowds continue to go, with the excuse, "WalMart has everything so much cheaper." When I'm told by a healthcare person, or someone trying to be helpful when I'm looking for a certain item, that I can probably find it at WalMart, my response is always the same -"thank you, but if I can't find it elsewhere, I'll just do without."
Me, too. When someone says, "You can get it at Walmart", I say "I NEVER shop at Walmart" and then go on to tell them of the horrible anti-employee practices of that place. Sickens me seeing people on-line waiting to go into Targets and Walmart. Yeah, go ahead. Throw your sparse dollars at the very institutions that are repressing you! You didn't like your Medicare or Social Security or Unemployment Insurance anyway, did you? What's the matter with them??!! Here's a gift to give your children and your loved ones this year -- A BETTER WORLD!!! Make homemade gifts or buy someone elses homemade gifts. So many unemployed people can make gifts to sell to others to give. Or we can pay a little more and invest in the future for your children and buy fair trade. Amnesty International has gifts. Options options options. We cannot go on living as we have been.
"There are a lot of small, local businesses that need to be bought from. Buy if you may, buy if you must, but buy local as much as possible. Keep those dollars circulating in your community."
thanks, joe, for decades i've felt that i've staged an ineffective one-woman boycott against wal-mart. gee, it can be frustrating to cruise strip mall after strip mall looking for a local gift shop to support. american express has a promotion going for "shop small, local business saturday" and i thank them for that, but suggest we all avoid going into debt. that would make for a less stressful HAPPY NEW YEAR, huh?
"Unfortunately, if there is a WalMart in your community or small town, that's where the crowds continue to go, with the excuse, "WalMart has everything so much cheaper." When I'm told by a healthcare person, or someone trying to be helpful when I'm looking for a certain item, that I can probably find it at WalMart, my response is always the same -'thank you, but if I can't find it elsewhere, I'll just do without'."
good for you, shadre! i hear that long ago, there was something called "common sense"? well, today it's neither. the mass merchandisers continuously maximising profits for themselves have no desire to "save you money." mom & pop, dad & son support local banking which keeps cash, as joe wisely suggests circulating, circulating, circulating at home not horded in some offshore account.
"see the usa in your chevrolet" and thank wal-mart and customers for town after town of identical boarded up store front windows!
"american express has a promotion going for "shop small, local business saturday" and i thank them for that,"
While I agree with the rest of your post, it's helpful to know that the AMEX promotion is a complete joke. American Express treats small businesses like annoying gnats. I used to take AMEX at my business, until I received a letter from them stating that if I didn't upgrade my card reader within 30 days, they were going to fine me $25,000. Fine me? Bye, bye AMEX.
Occupy Santa Fe is demonstrating at Wall Mart and then gathering on the Plaza at 1:00 in support of local Merchants. And no Mr. Adbusters we are not here to make citizens angry, but Aware and Active. And no we are not beholden to any magazine, agenda, leader only our own General Assembly. We are our own entity, Adbusters was a breath on a smoldering inferno.
Here, here. Gift giving is an ancient and deep human behavior. Probably every culture has some celebrations that involve giving and receiving gifts. You can make gifts. You can buy products from local producers, or buy products from nations that need the business (Greece, Portugal, Spain, Iceland, Ireland) or that need a "thank you" (Turkey, Argentina, South Africa). You can buy gifts at the Salvation Army store, Goodwill, or March of Dimes. We do not need to destroy our humanity in order to boycott corrupt corporations.
Well, Buy Nothing Day is nothing new, and Adbusters doesn't run the mvmnt. They throw out ideas, people run with some, ignore others. Occupy Wall Street stuck, but the "ask for one demand" thing didn't. OccupyXmas and BND seem to be less the focus of Occupy right now than a shopping local campaign. As well as other community outreach projects. BND and Occupy are the perfect combo, but everyone is just doing their own thing based on what their GA's decide.
Right now, there are people all over the USA camped out in tents on city streets in front of major retailers. Those camps won't be busted up by batons and pepper spray. I suppose this tells us: Occupy encampments = bad. Shopify encampments = good.
That was interesting...insightful. So we could just join them.with signs.
But there was a shopper at a WalMart in California (I believe) using pepper spray to keep other shoppers at bay 'till she got what she wanted.
http://slatest.slate.com/posts/2011/11/25/black_friday_walmart_shopper
_injures_20_with_pepper_spray.html
"Meanwhile other Black Friday violence broke out in other areas, like a North Carolina shopping center where two suspects fired guns before running into the mall. Thankfully no one was injured in either incident, and, shockingly, the stores involved stayed open!"
In Duluth, a black clad team of shoppers let loose an aerosal of nuerotoxins before entering the store with gas masks. In Little Rock a woman with an infant in her shopping cart was clearing her path with stun grenades. In a DC mall a man created his own doorway with an RPG.
HAHAHAHA!!!! Best laugh I had all day...thanks.
"Calif. Black Friday shopper shot in failed robbery"
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5hwjkdsny
CvQRyB8JtbtoGpQOh6wg?docId=103b26e9514b47bf8939f419ee8bbafb
How's that Consumer Confidence Index going for ya now?
Well frankly the camps for Walmart disappear in a day or two, Occupy camps do not. If they were there for two months, they would be treated the same way...
I doubt that they would if they were waiting in line to shop. Duration isn't the point anyway. From what I've heard from those who attended, these were mob gatherings and even though violence was kept to a minimum, the attendees were apparently quite hostile to one another in mood and in passive aggression.
— a Jesus walk, where people put on a mask in the Holy Son’s likeness and walk through malls, to create an eerie sentiment
~ ~ ~
i'm not convinced that anyone knows for sure what jesus looked like. some historians believe the man may have been a philosophical composite created on paper. well, there's "the shroud of turin", but after monsanto performed carbon dating on a scrap, the vatican wished not to reveal the results. i wonder, though, would a bunch of guys marching around all dressed up like hippies anger "real christians" even more than wishing them, "happy holiday!" i saw a bit about the creators of "south park" that showed jesus and santa in a big fight over which gets to be the icon for the season. funny.
on another thread here 'petrkrop' gave a link for a movie, "what would jesus buy?" thanks for the recommendation, 'petrkrop'! we watched the flick yesterday. thumbs up!
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1056487665981560376#
Thanks for the film recommendation. I watched it this morning and have shared it on FB. I LOVE Rev. Billy!
I think targeted events like Buy Nothing Day are useful in that they get a message across. And while I do agree with shopping locally, I think abstaining from buying for one day won't put anyone out of business. If you must buy the item, buy it the next day - locally.
BND is a start, but a drop in the bucket, really. What is needed is that we, as individuals, learn to buy less. “Use it up, wear it out, make it do or do without” is an old saying that our grandparents (and theirs) lived by. That has been subsumed by marketing (mass psychology) and it's time we brought our grandparents' ethos back. But that won't/can't happen by any mass movement, only by each of us - individuals. And that is truly a leaderless movement!
Hear hear! You can't simply not buy on one day, you have to forgo buying for an extended period or from one specific store/industry. As for shopping locally, if you can, please do and if you can, support craftspeople.
Love the 'whirly cart' idea. And who said we would attack the little mom&pop stores. That's just outrageous. If anything, a little big box slamming would be a boon for the little guys.
The whirly cart idea is the one I really don't like.
I like the idea of abstaining from buying, and even some of the other ideas to get people to think, but the idea of leaving a cartful of items just makes it hard on a store clerk who will have to re-stock the items - someone who already works hard, for peanuts. I know, I work in retail.
We should be mindful of who we are targeting and how we go about it. Making hard-working individuals pay for their boss' actions is a tough sell. No pun intended.
Yes. I agree with Ted Markow. It is a de facto attack on the staff of the big box stores, who are harried enough as it is at Xmas time, with the stocking of shelves, dealing with the seas of customers, and managing their own economic hardships and their families'. It's unfair and cruel to add work for the store clerks. It might be a photo op for the local tv or newspaper but it just will irritate and alienate people living on the brink and trying to eke out an existence working for those horrid corporate entities.
Find ways to register your anti-consumer sentiments at local big box stores.
Target head offices and CEOs . I couldn't think up a more divisive shtick --us the folks who have the time and $$ to do the protests vs. the working stiffs without the education or the time and $$ to reflect on, and act upon, anti-consumerism.
On the other hand the anti-credit card Santa campaign is fairly harmless, fun, and clearly messaged.
AND BUY LOCAL!
@hoodeet and Ted Markow: I'm sorry if it inconveniences the clerks, but, they CHOOSE to work there. Maybe it's time for a mass "employee walkout" from the big box stores? Not that this would make any difference at WalMarts - they are so understaffed already, it's impossible to get any help, checkout in a timely fashion, or even find a sanitary restroom in one. Therefore, I say: Whirly-Carts GOOOO!!!
Yes, they choose to work there because they choose to eat everyday, feed their kids everyday, and have a roof over their heads everyday.
I mean, do you not read the news? People are losing their homes, poverty is on the rise, but it's ok to torment low wage workers trying to just get by somehow? What a terrible sentiment.
I totally agree whirly carts will do nothing but frustrate workers who are probably supporters of the Occupy movement or at least potential supports. Yes, they choose to work there because they choose to work. If given better choices, you can bet they'd be working just about anywhere else. Walmart has no unions so organizing a strike is near impossible.
The Occupy movement is here to offend those in power. It is not here to offend our fellow 99%ers.
Another problem with the whirly cart is that you'd actually have to go into Walmart to do it Yuck! Something I avoid if at all possible.
@Reality in TN - Yes, it's true they "choose" to work there. But often times its the difference between having no job and working at that hole. And the Walmart management will probably make the clerks put everything back.
So how about doing things to jerk around the management? Be creative - there's probably a lot that could be done....
I have to echo the other sentiments here--going out of your way to fill a shopping cart with merchandise with the express purpose of abandoning it "to make a point," is a terrible idea. Wal-Mart's CEO doesn't give jackshit about that, and no, the store isn't going to hire more employees to handle such a useless "point." All you're doing is creating more work for some hapless employee who already is under stress and strain to do a thousand things in their shift, always with a smile, for a few bucks an hour, with no benefits. Acting like a jackass to retail workers is no way to build a movement.
I agree. In fact, during most of my shopping trips, I make it a point to pick up at least a few items left on the floor or in the wrong places by careless, lazy shoppers who change their minds after picking up stuff (and their little brats) and put them back in the right place. This is just to make it a tad bit easy on the already hassled retail worker. So leaving a cart full of stuff after filling it is a bad idea. And bad karma, too.
Bad karma, indeed!
So what do you think is going to happen to the workers at Wallmart once an effective block is put in place against the company? It is effective, because the worker will be working anyway and they can only work so much, the store manager would have to hire more people or work at restocking to make the same sales level if everyone did this.
"the worker will be working anyway and they can only work so much"
With all due respect, this is not accurate, at least in my experience. I worked at Target about 10 years ago, for several years, and the pressure on those workers is tremendous. The pace is ungodly. Workers routinely worked off the clock to get the barrage of work done. When I complained to HR, I was fingered by unhappy employees, who figured I was the one that blew the whistle, thus jeopardizing jobs. We never took our 15 minutes break. Why bother? There'd only be 100 more things that had to get done when we got back.
Bottom line: these companies will not hire more employees to even out the workload. Ever.
It is like that all over, you should have made your complaint to the labor board. The point is, it is not going to get better until you stand up and there are lots of ways to do it.
totally agree. who said anything about little stores. This kind of tactic is likely to be better at big stores anyway. I'd be a good laugh to be there and watch the chaos.
Well intended but the first goal of OWS should be to make sure every citizen knows how much income and wealth the top 1 percent "earn"/hold, how much taxes are being paid, as well as the trend over recent history. If people are still asking, "what is is the movement about?", then it's not time to branch out, it's time to teach to the talking points. That's the lesson progressives can't seem to learn from the regressive folks. The regressive folks would have the message more digestible than whipped potatoes and as familiar as the morning commute.
The movement is about Everything, it is not difficult to discover the endless ills and even their causes are fairly evident. And the movement itself is the solution. This "They need an agenda Meme" usually originates with MSM propagandists, though sincere people may also voice the same. It is part of a briliant strategy of no leaders, no agenda. It befuddles the opposing state security. It is very difficult to strangle air. Though they are not reluctant to beating heads, but that is often self defeating to the state. In the 60's&70's the state assassinated the leaders. And we have the recent Senator Paul Wellstone and his family.
""They need an agenda Meme" usually originates with MSM propagandists"
I see how you could say that, but when people who could be convinced and won over still don't "get it" it would be nice if they would at least know what the 1 percent and 99 percent namesake is about. I'm grateful for what all the OWS protesters are doing but they should beware they don't become divided and conquered.
If Economists are so concerned about spending, why is there so little talk about putting more money into the hands of wage earners? I hear about low interest rates, consumer confidence, etc. But the bottom line is, if you want people to spend more, they need to earn more, not just borrow more or expect some magic to make it come out O.K. if they do spend.
All of this amounts to a temper tantrum, solves nothing, and ignores the work that needs to be done to solve the underlying issues.
Stop shopping?
Then all those people in the store will be unemployed. The people who make the products will be unemployed. The people who deliver the products will be unemployed.
Adbusters uses the very products it claims to boycott. Where did they get their stuff? From Jesus? From some pure hearted pixies who only lavish goods on the moral and the righteous?
I think we have pointed out the problem. Now you can continue to have temper tantrums, or you can actually use your intellect and hard work to solve the problems.
Climate change. Resources lost. Population growth. Wars to manage the supply lines.
Make the change peacefully and respect the civil rights of eight billion people.
Okay go!