Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
U.S. Considers Erecting Fences Along Canadian Border
OTTAWA—The United States is looking at building fences along the border with Canada to help keep out terrorists and other criminals.
A U.S. Border vehicle drives along the U.S. and Mexico border fence in Naco, Arizona. The United States is looking at building fences along the border with Canada. (photo: REUTERS/Joshua Lott)
The U.S. Customs and Border Protection agency has proposed the use of "fencing and other barriers" on the 49th parallel to manage "trouble spots where passage of cross-border violators is difficult to control."
The border service is also pondering options including a beefed-up technological presence through increased use of radar, sensors, cameras, drones and vehicle scanners. In addition, it might continue to improve or expand customs facilities at ports of entry.
The agency considered but ruled out the possibility of hiring "significantly more" U.S. Border Patrol agents to increase the rate of inspections, noting staffing has already risen in recent years.
The proposals are spelled out in a new draft report by the border service that examines the possible environmental impact of the various options over the next five to seven years.
Customs and Border Protection is inviting comment on the options and plans a series of public meetings in Washington and several U.S. border communities next month. It will then decide which ideas to pursue.
U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano noted last month the challenges of monitoring the vast, sparsely populated northern border region. She stressed manpower, but also a greater reliance on technology.
Ironically, the moves come as Canada and the U.S. try to finalize a perimeter security arrangement that would focus on continental defences while easing border congestion. It would be aimed at speeding passage of goods and people across the Canada-U.S. border, which has become something of a bottleneck since the 9-11 terrorist attacks.
Relatively speaking, Washington has focused more energy and resources on tightening security along the border with Mexico than at the sprawling one with Canada.
But that may be changing.
A U.S. Government Accountability Office report recently warned that only a small portion of the border with Canada is properly secure. It said U.S. border officers control just 50 kilometres of the 6,400-kilometre boundary.
The Customs and Border Protection report says while fences have been a big element in deterring unauthorized crossings of the U.S.-Mexican border, "it is unlikely that fencing will play as prominent a role" on the northern border, given its length and terrain that varies from prairie to forest.
However, the agency would use fencing and other barriers such as trenches to control movement and sometimes delay people trying to sneak across the border, increasing the likelihood they could be caught, says the report.
It doesn't provide details about what the fences might look like, but suggests they would be designed to blend into the environment and "complement the natural landscape."
The approach would also involve upgrading roadways and trails near the border.
"The lack of roads or presence of unmaintained roads impedes efficient surveillance operations," says the report. "Improving or expanding the roadway and trail networks could improve mobility, allowing agents to patrol more miles each day and shortening response times."
Over the last two years, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has already made what it calls "critical security improvements along the northern border," adding inspectors at the ports of entry and Border Patrol agents between ports, as well as modernizing land crossings.
Nearly 3,800 Customs and Border Protection officers scrutinize people and goods at crossings. The number of Border Patrol agents working between crossings along the northern parallel has increased 700 per cent since Sept. 11, 2001. And some three dozen land ports of entry are being modernized.
Unmanned U.S. aircraft patrol about 1,500 kilometres along the northern border from Washington to Minnesota as well as more than 300 kilometres of the Canadian border around New York state and Lake Ontario.

106 Comments so far
Show AllThe walls are closing in.
Feeling squeezed yet?
"Beefing up" Canadian Border security is a huge expansion of the US police state and a huge corporate welfare program.
From 2007 through 2010 I worked for a contractor expanding US Border Patrol facilities on the northern border across the western half of the US. Many one horse border towns that had less than a half dozen officers in 2006 now have dozens of officers with projections of many more officers to be stationed at these locations in the near future. The US Border Patrol stations in some of these one horse towns are now as big as the rest of the town.
After working the southern border, nearly all of the officers now working the northern border will tell you this is their dream job. Ask them what they actually do and they tell you they "ride horses and ATVs during the summer and ride snowmobiles in the winter".
I agree this is Boola Boola wrapped up in total BS.
Where do I enlist?!
I can't help but feel that this is more intended to keep us in, than to keep "them" out. Canada has always been a safe haven for radicals who are fleeing this insane authoritarian system.
That was my first thought, too. Especially if we were to end up with a President Perry, there will be lots of Americans making a run for the border, and I'm not talking about Taco Bell. Our best hope then would be some Mariel boatlift-type thing where Perry and his junta let Americans leave.
Just like they did in Berlin, more to prevent escapes than any other reason.
>^^<
This is exactly my first and scariest thought. Borders keep people in as well as out. This should not be tolerated nor the money spent on it. I don't see Canadian running for our borders but it might stop a mass exodus from the US to Canada! Children of Men, anyone?
Yep - like radelcamino sez, fencing and militarizing the US-Canadian border smells a lot like another MIC corporate contractor boondoggle, another ratcheting up of the institutionalized police state mindset. I sense the proposal also has a fake "who-me-racist?" subtext.
If all the walls and fencing and electronic surveillance and swarthy immigrant fear mongering is overwhelmingly focused by the federal government along the southern borders of yahoo states like Arizona and Texas, Hispanics regardless of citizenship status are understandably aggrieved by the stereotyping singling them out. I know! Rather than dealing with those rampant racist realities, let's instead open up a public policy discussion about erecting a DMZ barrier in places like Michigan, Minnesota, and Montana - complete with checkpoints, armed sentries and circling overhead drones - a red-white-and-blue show of manly paramilitary force sufficient to keep undocumented Canucks from ever even dreaming about trying to sneak across the border on to American soil.
There you have it - color blind, culturally neutral equal protection of the law in action, plus another big potfull of federal contractor subsidies clearly demonstratjng how neoliberal Uncle Sam has become very serious about not discriminating against our Spanish-speaking neighbors of the southern hemisphere.
By all means, spread the crony contract largesse geographically, and keep a watchful eye the growing Maple Leaf peril in the process. Rumor has it some of those foreigners just north of here even speak French. Fifty Four Forty or Fight!
Bill from Saginaw
En fait, c'est vrai!
Just aim for the center on the Maple Leaf!!! lol
>^^<
Notice that the need for this evpenditure of time and money was not deniniated nor the number of convicted terrorists.
Well I'd imagine that the fence builders (Hailburton) need work, so until the shooting on the southern border slows down they'll be gainfully employed building the fence they were gonna build later... lol
>^^<
Yepp, I left after Bush got "re-elected" in fact. Now we have PM Harper doing everything he can to despoil our way of life in the shortest time possible, turning us rapidly into USA North. But, I figure we have to be at least a decade behind from turning as fascist up here. Ten more years to figure out where I can flee to next...
Last year, for the first time ever on record, more illegal immigrants were caught crossing from the USA into Canada than from Canada into the USA. Historically, Americans fleeing to Canada were escaping forms of slavery, runaway slaves in the 1800s and runaway military draftees in the 1960s. Is it possible that the US is preparing for new forms of slavery, and wants no one to escape?
They don't even suggest what "numbers" of criminals and terrorists get across the border into Canada. How many do we have to stop? I know Bush got in.
Even worse - Cheney got out.
Yeah, we really screwed that one up.
HAHAHA so true!
"The United States is looking at building fences along the border with Canada to help keep out terrorists and other criminals."
A little late don't you think? Dick Cheney has already been and gone.
And W too.
I hate you, America. You are a pestilence on this planet. You have nothing to offer but death and despair. What a hateful horror you've turned into. You ruin everything you touch. Soon, you'll be drone-bombing "terrorists" - no - "supected terrorists" in Canada. It's not about "security" but about resources. You're running out, and Canada still has lots. Water.
Thanks to you, the whole gentle character of this country has changed. You've parasitized the "brain" of idiot Harper, and now Ontario is in danger from neocon Hudak, our very own Rick Perry.
Fix yourself, America. You're dragging the whole world down.
The US can be blamed for a whole hell of a lot of things, but is it really fair to blame the US for Harper, Hudak, or Ford? I read the right-wing rants in the comment sections in the Toronto Star. Your right wingers are entirely home grown. You let the ghosts of Ayn Rand and Reagan in all by yourselves. Deal with them.
Yes. But I no longer care about fair. The US has been a toxic influence for the ast 40 years. Somehow everyone puts their brains on hold and sleepwalks zombielike to the American drum. The toxic bilge just oozes over the order. I also blame the idiots that follow along, absent spine and stones. And heart. It is deeply distressing to see what has happened to Canada since 9/11, especially. I wish our politicians and dealmakers could resist the American juggernaut. Like a mouse sleeping with an elephant, every time you roll over, we have to negotiate how to not be squashed. God bless America! cuz everyone else on the planet is cursing it.
Now we have the killer-drones and we don't have to worry about our pilots defecting.. We can get down to business!!! LOL
>^^<
Too true. We took down the walls protecting our media and industry by agreeing to the Free Trade pact. We let Rush L. in too with all the American networks. We let in Globalization. And with all these reforms we removed almost all restrictions on money flowing across borders. Money and "legal persons" do not seem to see the borders and fences at all any more. But the people are seeing them more clearly than ever.
I do not blame the US for Harper, Hudak, and Ford. I will assign much culpability for their influence and that of our rabid right to various financial interests and "legal persons" that also afflict the good and decent people who live south of us.
Rush is on Canadian radio? Which city, and are you sure that it's not the US signal just coming across the border? I ask because I live in the North and have never heard him or seen him advertised up here.
But yah, our own home-grown kooks are getting their inspiration from the home-grown ones down south. (not sure they need that inspiration, but hey...)
memento - Yup. and double yup. Is it something in the water? don't know why the whole world is following that pattern. (IMF, WTO, etc) Soon, there will be no room for real people.
Im an American redbaloon, and agree with you 100 per cent.
And that's why I love Americans. Personally, you guys are treasures, politically you are poison. (I'm married to an American, BTW, 20 years - he's relieved, happy he's here)
Quit your whinin'. We gave you America's Got Talent. Thanks for the Labatt's. No give us our oil you hid in your tar sands.
Watch it or I'll sic my caribou on ya!
We're all armed to the teeth, we'll simply shoot your caribou and eat it. Take that you walled out Canuk!
You'll just end up shooting each other in the face - like Cheney on his canned hunt with Whittington ;-) Anyway, all our caribou are trained to toss pie.
What a farce: 9/11 was an inside job, so there's certainly no point in "building fences along the border with Canada to help keep out terrorists", since the real terrorists are already WITHIN the U.S.
It was the probably the fence-builders who blew up those towers.
Cui bono
We need someplace for all those land-mines we can't get rid of, can't use them in the south.. That'd be RACIST! but on the Canadian fence it's cool.. It will help deter the escapees,,, dam I did it again... "it'll keep the godless commie free-healthcare freeks out! (that's better)
>^^<
Why would any sane Canadian want to cross into the US anyway?, far too dangerous a place!
No surprise that the US is vetoing the Palestinian bid for statehood at the UN - US and Israel probably the last two countries in the western world with a 'fence mentality'. I suspect that the real reason for the US to erect a Canadian fence will be to stop all their skilled workers and engineers fleeing northwards when the economy in the US really tanks, which, make no mistake, it will very soon and big time!!
Here's one Canuck that wouldn't even dream about going to the states; not for money or love. Me and my friends regularly talk about how god damn crazy south of the border is getting. You got religious radicals, war hungry hawks, crooked cops, gang warfare, Quran burners, crumbling rights, no healthcare, racism of every stripe, zealous zionists. America's got crazy for days, they're full up, they got it on lock, they're taking it to 11...
As Bowie said: I'm afraid of Americans.
Theres a huge defence contract there. hardware, people, electronics, etc... so they compose scenarios and arias on the theme of "terrorists from canada". And everyone in congress roars approval.
as for canada being the land of the terrorists, i hope canadians have a healthy sense of humour when it comes to the antics of their eccentric neighbour.
Last night, here in Vancouver, we had an 'eccentric neighbor' who behaved in much the same way the US does with it's international policy, ie. shooting at anything that moved. The Police moved in, and after waiting when they heard a single shot as they approached, sent in paramedics to see the mentally ill man had shot himself.
There's a neat parallel, don't you think?
i reckon once the canadians have been safely warded off, the next step is to build walls around states. otherwise the terrorists will have won!!!
"Blame Canada! Blame Canada!" la la la la la la la
We'll roll in ballistas armed with hot wads of poutine!
And throw teddy bears or pie.
Thank God! This comes not a moment too soon. There is not a day that goes by that I don't worry about hordes of rampaging Canucks (with the razor-sharp hockey sticks they all carry) skating across the border and occupying American paradises like Detroit. And almost every night, I have blood curdling nightmares about Eskimo tank columns smashing their way down Collins Avenue in South Beach, Miami.
Lets get that wall built. It doesn't matter how much tax money is paid to the friends and benefactors of congressmen. It's worth the price if our homes and children can be protected from the modern day Mongol Hordes in Canada.
Why on the gods green earth would we want to invade a pestilential wasteland hell-hole like the USA?
Signed,
The Mongol Hordes of Canada
You grubby fools, so you forgot we paid Iraqi insurgents not to shoot at us. Think now of what you're passing up - easy money and you can just claim that you didn't know the safety was off.
And don't forget our Atomic Beavers! Scary stuff!
When will the endemic paranoia of we American people stop and we will realize the problem is not from without, but from within?
Q: "When will the endemic paranoia of we American people stop and we will realize the problem is not from without, but from within?"
A: # Occupy Wall St. (it's a start, but hey, ya gotta start somewhere...)
And God bless all of you for what you are doing. If I were 50 years younger I would give it a try.