Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Report Suggests 'Correlation' between U.S. Aid and Army Killings
BOGOTÁ - "There are alarming links between increased reports of extrajudicial executions of civilians by the Colombian army and units that receive U.S. military financing," John Lindsay-Poland, lead author of a two-year study on the question, told IPS.
Lindsay-Poland is Research and Advocacy Director for the U.S.-based Fellowship of Reconciliation (FOR), which presented a new report, "Military Assistance and Human Rights: Colombia, U.S. Accountability, and Global Implications", in Bogotá Thursday.
The report, produced in conjunction with the U.S. Office on Colombia (USOC), studies the application in Colombia of the so-called Leahy Law, passed in 1996, which bans military assistance to a foreign security force unit if the U.S. State Department has credible evidence that the unit has committed gross human rights violations.
The Leahy Law is one of the main U.S. laws designed to protect against the use of U.S. foreign aid to commit human rights abuses.
"If the Leahy Law was fully implemented, assistance would have to be suspended to nearly all fixed army brigades and many mobile brigades in Colombia," Lindsay-Poland said.
The report points out that most military training in Colombia is funded by the U.S. Defence Department.
Colombia, caught up in an armed conflict for nearly five decades, is one of the largest recipients of U.S. military aid in the world, along with Israel, Egypt and Pakistan.
The study reviewed data on more than 3,000 extrajudicial executions reportedly committed by the armed forces in Colombia since 2002 and lists of more than 500 military units assisted by the United States since 2000.
"We found that for many military units, reports of extrajudicial executions increased during and after the highest levels of U.S. assistance," Lindsay-Poland said.
The results were obtained by comparing the number of reports of such killings in the two years prior to the start of Plan Colombia -- the multibillion-dollar U.S. military aid package -- in 2000 with the number of killings after the launch of that counterinsurgency and anti-drug strategy.
It also found that reports of alleged killings of civilians by the army dropped when assistance was cut.
"Whatever correlation may exist between assistance and reported killings, there are clearly other factors contributing to high levels of killings. Yet, while we could not fix the causes of increased reports of killings after increases in U.S. assistance, our findings highlight the need for a thorough investigation into the reasons for this apparent correlation," the authors say.
"The U.S. government should respond to the questions raised by the report," Lindsay-Poland said.
For example, "why U.S. officials neglect their duties under the Leahy Law, not only in Colombia but in countries like Pakistan, where the situation is very complex."
The U.S. military presence in Colombia dates back to the 1940s, when leftwing guerrillas became active in the country. But it escalated to a new level in 1999 when Plan Colombia was agreed by the governments of then presidents Andrés Pastrana (1998-2002) and Bill Clinton (1993-2001).
Plan Colombia was complemented and extended in 2004 by Plan Patriot, signed by President Álvaro Uribe, whose term ends Aug. 7, and former president George W. Bush (2001-2009).
The two plans have undergone radical changes since 2009, according to Lindsay-Poland, when they reached beyond the initial aims of counterinsurgency and counternarcotics, with a view towards strengthening U.S. control in the region.
U.S. army Southern Command documents state the importance of establishing a base "with air mobility reach on the South American continent and a capacity for counter-narcotics operations until the year 2025," he said.
Uribe offered the U.S. military the use of seven bases at strategic points in Colombia, including both the Atlantic and Pacific coasts, the province of Caquetá in the Amazon jungle, and the provinces of Meta, Tolima and Cundinamarca in the centre of the country.
Lindsay-Poland and other members of FOR tried to visit the Palanquero base in Cundinamarca, one of the seven, on Wednesday. But "they did not let us in," he said. "They demanded authorisation from the U.S. Embassy. So what kind of autonomy are we talking about here?"
Furthermore, the agreement for U.S. military access to the bases has not been approved by the Colombian Congress, as required by law.
As a result, the Constitutional Court ruled the agreement unconstitutional on Jul. 22 and gave Congress one year to approve or reject it.
If the legislature ratifies the deal, the Constitutional Court will once again study it, to determine whether or not it is in line with the constitution.
The report presented by FOR and USOC coincided with the start of an investigation of reports of unmarked graves in the La Macarena cemetery, which is next to an army base, according to a Jul. 22 public hearing in that town in the central province of Meta, which was attended by opposition lawmakers and international observers, including European legislators.
At the hearing, witnesses said military helicopters flew in the remains of bodies to La Macarena, 340 km south of Bogotá. Human rights groups say the bodies were those of civilians killed by the army.
"This is happening at the end of a government marked by grave human rights violations, which have largely affected the most vulnerable groups in society, and which are reflected in the thousands of 'false positives', as the extrajudicial executions have been popularly known," Alberto Yepes, director of the Observatorio de Derechos Humanos (DIH - Human Rights Observatory), told IPS.
The scandal over the so-called "false positives" -- young civilians killed by the army and passed off as guerrilla casualties in the military's counterinsurgency campaign --broke in the press in September 2008.
Although there are no hard statistics on the number of people killed, the report by FOR and USOC puts the number at over 3,000 in the last decade.
A group that calls itself the Madres (mothers) of Soacha, a vast working-class suburb stretching south of Bogotá, has filed a complaint with the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights over the loss of their 16 sons in 2007 and 2008. The young men were recruited with the promise of jobs, but their bodies were found in morgues or mass graves hundreds of kilometres away.
Yepes said the complaint filed by the Madres de Soacha "is a way to pressure the state to modify this kind of behaviour."
While activists and groups mobilise to pressure the armed forces to live up to the constitution, "the United States should assume its responsibility through better oversight, holding (authorities in Colombia) accountable and adopting corrective measures, so the money of U.S. taxpayers does not end up financing killings in Colombia," he said.
- Posted in



43 Comments so far
Show AllIt seems there on striking difference between Chavez and his "Leftist Government" and that of an Uribe (A God send as one commenter on these forums claims) and his right wing government.
This difference bothers the supporters of Somoza/Uribe/Mont/Pinochet and the like to no end.
The LEFT wing Governments deal with the powerful on the right by seizing their wealth and distributing it to the poor.
The RIGHT wing Governments deal with those on the left by mass campaigns of murder using death squads.
Chavez is villified for nationalizing assets own by the "elite". Crimes against the sanctity of "private property".
Uribe a hero because he had death squads murder Union leaders.
A strange world is it not? The "Right to private property" a greater one then ones Right to life?
GwNorth, the **biggest** difference is that even those who participated in the coup in Venezuela went through a legitimate legal and judicial process, whereas anywhere else they would have been summarily executed. And despite claims to the contrary, there exists a powerful media controlled by the "opposition" (the wealthy elite). In that sense, Venezuela is doing one better than Cuba.
Given the proclivity of human habits, I'm capable of imagining alot of things... however, I can't imagine anything surprising about Pirates using Other Peoples Money to facilitate the most heinous crimes - in the name of profits.
Realpolitik is a B***h!
I am truly pleased to read there is oversight regarding the awful consequences to private citizen - at least oversight from those on the ''right''. As it should be period, both right and left. Where is the oversight regarding those from the "left"? Forces would not be in those area's if it were not necessary.I find it frightening to read the hero worship of Chavez,with no concern for those who are paying a huge price for his self worship and ever greater localized power.The consequences of Mr.Chavez's take over of private business and property is not benefiting the people of Venezuela to the degree imagined by some.In a country where freedom of press is not tolerated.A country where it is considered a crime to openly question the Presidents actions. A country in decline of public and private services. A country where the OAS has been asked, but so far refused too, investigate the questionable and sometimes alarming tactics of Mr.Chavez.Why does there have to be sides when something is wrong?I totally support and agree with the investigation and the call for further investigation into the disappearance or known death of private citizens - regardless of which side is investigated.Lets not be blind at the expense of others life and freedoms,investigation is necessary for both the left and the right.
Please provide your evidence that death squads operate in Venezuala. Please give the evidence of mass graves found.
In your beloved Honduras Right Wing Death squads killed tens of thousands of Native Hondurans. Many of these were part of the infamous Battalion 3-16 and have yet to be bought to Justice. Where is your oversight?
Why is Uribe and those responsible for mass graves all over Colombia not in Jail and why did you refer to him as a God send?
You are very transparent here. Under the guise of pretending to be for human rights you make unsubstantiated charges against Chavez while ignroing the documented evidence of literaly hundreds of thousands of deaths at the hands of right wing death squads.
You try and equate the nationalization of a countries oil resources and the redistribution of wealth from those with to those without to mass murder.
Are you an ex student of "The School of the Americas"?
Charging Chavez with "questionable and alarming tactics" is such a baseless and non specific charge it borders on the ridiculous. I can charge any leader in the world with "questionable and alarming tactics" . That hardly means they all as evil as the leaders you support as God sends.
Godsend(s): one word, NOT "God send(s).
mocomments: May I recommend a documentary made by Irish filmmakers("The Revolution Will Not Be Televised")who happened to be in Venezuela when the 2002 attempted coup took place. The coup, carried out by Venezuela's elite with at least "moral" support from the U.S., meant that for the two days Chavez was held prisoner, their Constitution, government, and all civil rights were gone. The documentary shows how The People took their country back.
Since 2002, the U.S. under Bush has used constant disinformation in both Venezuela and our country in an attempt to vilify Chavez to the point where he could be un-elected. To the Bush administration's chagrin all such attempts, including a second coup attempt, failed.
The only media outlet Chavez has opposed (and apparently refused to renew licensing of) was the private station owned by and serving the wishes of the elite. It was the only station the coup-makers allowed to remain on the air when they stopped the public station(s) from broadcasting.
While our economy limped along during the 2000s, Chavez used the additional percentage of oil profits (10% more? 20%?) to virtually wipe out illiteracy, establish factories in abandoned buildings and otherwise create jobs, trade oil to Cuba for doctors who provided free health care, and grew the economy by 10-20% per year, and with Venezuela's neighbors created a Latin American lending agency to take the power to interfere with local governments away from the IMF and World Bank. Our mainstream media has following the administration's line since the beginning of Bush's first term, but you can read year by year refutations by Mark Weisbrot of all the lies about Chavez at www.cepr.net.
Chavez does not hate America or Americans. He DID hate the constant plotting against him carried out by the previous administration, and has been somewhat disappointed to see that Obama has so far not repudiated it.
Dear Sir, I reply to your comment about President Obama not repudiating certain items as i will paste below.
I wish to say as a democrat for the people in a duly elected position in America.
He faces a formidably funded right wing Republican opposition that is much better funded than the Democratic party, as the Corporations and fanatic religious factions are so well funded against any Democrat.
Therefore he has the added burden of balancing out his political priorities against what he feels is or should be said as not to loose votes in the next election.
Believe me you want this man Obama re-elected and don't want a &*^-%$# like Sarah Pallen another *()^$% like George W. Busch in office.
As you stated,
"Chavez does not hate America or Americans".
He DID hate the constant plotting against him carried out by the previous administration, and has been somewhat disappointed to see that Obama has so far not repudiated it.
Please keep your bitterness to yourself and find some harmless and helpful way to expunge it.
WHAT?! USA funds Death Squads?!!!
OH MY GOD!
And they do it outside the law!
OH MY GOD!
Death Squads have a long rich tradition is this Evil Empire of ours.
All Hail Peace, All Hail The Death and War Machine!!
...
Please, do we need a two-year study to find this out? The whole world knows the US is behind each and every effort to subvert peace and democracy on the planet.
A waste of time, money and energy.
No, the whole world does not know that the US is behind each and every effort to subvert peace and democracy on the planet. The whole world EXCEPT THE UNITED STATES knows this. Too many of us are brain damaged (by T.V. and P.R. and lack of education) so that we believe the lies of our corrupt government.
We have our troops and all their weapons of mass destruction ALL OVER THE WORLD. The United States is an empire and it is an EVIL EMPIRE. We need all of our tax funds to take care of ourselves here at home. Our government is bankrupting our nation with these endless wars and the people in this nation are silent. Cindy Sheehan marches for peace all alone.
This is insane. We must do something to get rid of those paid servants of the corporations who serve in Congress claiming to represent us. We must close ALL those hundreds of foreign bases and end the empire. Our Republic could flourish if we would mind our own affairs and let other nations have their own government without our interference.
Your Representative and your two Senators are not heeding what you say. Don't vote for them to stay in power. Look at the mess we are in. Let's take care of ourselves and stop our 'super power' act. We are in serious trouble and so is our mother the earth.
I think we need to go back to the Article of Confederation where all the states are independent. It might be possible to have some democracy in smaller units. I don't think we have a chance to get control of our national government from the corporations who have bought our 'honored' representatives.
The least we can do is kick the corrupt out of Congress---and that is nearly every single one of them.
Every word of your comment is all too true, "wantrealdemocracy".
Surprise, Surprise! Heavens to mergatroids!
Shouldn't the Leahy Law apply to Israel's illegal attacks (and all-out wars of mass destruction against Gaza and Lebanon), as well as the on-going imprisonment in their city and mistreatment of several million people in Gaza AND infringements on the rights of Israeli-Arab citizens and peace groups within Israel???
The population of The Gaza is about 1.5 million, not several million, and it can't really support any more growth. It's size is about the same as the south branch of eastern Long Island. Other than that, your point is well taken. As far as the general population of Israel is concerned, everyone would be better off if the inmates of the Gaza disappeared from the face of the earth.
Perhaps you might consider re-wording that last sentence as it sounds like you are calling for the extinction of the Palestinians residing in Gaza.
What is going on in Gaza AND with infringements on the rights of Israeli-Arab citizens and peace groups within Israel???
is and has been sickening.
Just like the pedofile priests & their Bishops protecting them so their criminal acts go unpunished to this day with approval from the Vatican with due knowledge and diligence about the situation for decades.
Why can't the Israel's people as historians that are intelligent see what the entire world sees!
I cannot conceive why they treat and do what they do to the Palestinian people.
It's just as terrible as what the Nazi Empire did during WW2 to the Jewish people.
Oh, no, no, no, please, don't bring Israel into this because they may have complain to the UN about it.
Viva, Hugo Chavez. May the world be blessed someday with more leaders like he is, and less of the ones who are callous, murderous brutes who don't give a FtFk about human life, unless it's their own.
Viva, Hugo Chavez!
/cm
How many are aware that the new incoming President Santos was Defense Minister under Uribe? Was he leader of the death squads? This is an article worth reading: http://www.petras.lahaine.org/articulo.php?p=1814&more=1&c=1 James Petras writes articles in English and Spanish.
Of course he was the leader of the death squads, backed by and with full support of the US. They have to be able to control the politicians. Having dirt on them is the best control thing.
It's all about capitalism.
Keeping control over it.
Making it last another 100 years.
Not letting a hint REAL democracy, like is what is happening right now in Venezuela, from getting loose from the bottle they keep so tightly capped.
I refuse to believe that America is involved in arming nations that dance to America's tune. Peace-loving America would never do that!
America is dedicated to freedom, to human rights, to democracy! It is a beacon on the hill, an example to us all.
Well, once it was!
http://www.dangerouscreation.com
For the politicians and citizens who turn military service into a fetish, the truth is militarism damages democracy, exacerbates poverty, and causes human rights violations.
We are ever ready to complain about human rights violations in left countries but love countries that butcher their own people;
Six Yawns in a Defunct Culture
USA is the world's leader in terrorism.
Yawn!
US citizens all know this.
Yawn!
Some complain vociferously.
Yawn!
They all do nothing about it.
Yawn!
Ah! They say they will vote in a new President.
Yawn!
Well, as they say in the USA,
Every yawn brings the new day.
All strength to John Lindsay-Poland.
The mass media helps control the minds of the American People!
Admiral Mullen claims, "Wikileaks has blood on its hands."
And, the media is on a campaign to shut down the leaks and
punish the leakers not the murderers.
"Excuse me sir, the murder of thousands of unarmed civilians
is a crime." "Excuse me sir,the coverups of those murders
is Obstruction of Justice." Perhaps the Admiral should look
at his own hands.
Next on the U.S. Mullen/Petraeus Agenda is Iran!
U.S. Aid to Colombia is meant to provoke Venezuela.
Chavez knows his oil is another target of the U.S.
Military Industrial Complex!
Hear hear!!
The "blood on its hands" quote struck me as truly Orwellian. In this article we see:
"The report, produced in conjunction with the U.S. Office on Colombia (USOC), studies the application in Colombia of the so-called Leahy Law, passed in 1996, which bans military assistance to a foreign security force unit if the U.S. State Department has credible evidence that the unit has committed gross human rights violations."
The whole point of US aid to these governments is to support right wing paramilitaries that kill innocent civilians. Anyone who doesn't understand the lawless nature of this government needs their head examined. Trying to counter this government with their own laws is about as fruitful as urinating in the wind.
Your tax dollars at work. Winning hearts and minds around the world for imperical empire!
"The US is at war with Latin America and has been for almost forever."
The US is also at war with the Middle East, Africa, the Caribbean, Asia, Russia, the American people... Seems like the only one in the world the US is not at war with is Israel.
The article states was has been obvious to those who care about such things for decades. I worked side by side with Salvadoran political refugees for 2 years in the 80s. We have been murdering people there and elsewhere, with impunity, for centuries. The Leahy Amendment is a sad joke. To the shame of all of us, our human rights record in and around the South American landmass, is yet another sad joke. Murder is not a joke, however, it is a crime. Our gov't and corporate officials must be brought to trial and convicted. This would possibly end some of this mindless brutality. I am not hopeful. I support the efforts of the groups to expose this murderous foreign policy but I remain highly skeptical that our country will ever take off the blinders of patriotism long enough to see the situation for what it is. It is extremely sad. That's no laughing matter.
I just read that the human death toll of the wars for empire is a whopping 14 million. Imagine that, 14 million innocent women and children callously massacred for the sake of greed and arrogance.
"Report Suggests 'Correlation' between U.S. Aid and Army Killings"
No, shit, Sherlock! The only thing one needs to do is look at any country that receives weapons from the US (which is roughly half of the world if not more) and see what happens.