Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Suicide Note Posted by Man Linked to Austin IRS Plane Crash
"Well, Mr. Big Brother IRS man; take my pound of flesh and sleep well"
If you're reading this, you're no doubt asking yourself, "Why did this have to happen?" The simple truth is that it is complicated and has been coming for a long time. The writing process, started many months ago, was intended to be therapy in the face of the looming realization that there isn't enough therapy in the world that can fix what is really broken. Needless to say, this rant could fill volumes with example after example if I would let it. I find the process of writing it frustrating, tedious, and probably pointless... especially given my gross inability to gracefully articulate my thoughts in light of the storm raging in my head. Exactly what is therapeutic about that I'm not sure, but desperate times call for desperate measures.
We are all taught as children that without laws there would be no society, only anarchy. Sadly, starting at early ages we in this country have been brainwashed to believe that, in return for our dedication and service, our government stands for justice for all. We are further brainwashed to believe that there is freedom in this place, and that we should be ready to lay our lives down for the noble principals represented by its founding fathers. Remember? One of these was "no taxation without representation". I have spent the total years of my adulthood unlearning that crap from only a few years of my childhood. These days anyone who really stands up for that principal is promptly labeled a "crackpot", traitor and worse.
While very few working people would say they haven't had their fair share of taxes (as can I), in my lifetime I can say with a great degree of certainty that there has never been a politician cast a vote on any matter with the likes of me or my interests in mind. Nor, for that matter, are they the least bit interested in me or anything I have to say.
Why is it that a handful of thugs and plunderers can commit unthinkable atrocities (and in the case of the GM executives, for scores of years) and when it's time for their gravy train to crash under the weight of their gluttony and overwhelming stupidity, the force of the full federal government has no difficulty coming to their aid within days if not hours? Yet at the same time, the joke we call the American medical system, including the drug and insurance companies, are murdering tens of thousands of people a year and stealing from the corpses and victims they cripple, and this country's leaders don't see this as important as bailing out a few of their vile, rich cronies. Yet, the political "representatives" (thieves, liars, and self-serving scumbags is far more accurate) have endless time to sit around for year after year and debate the state of the "terrible health care problem". It's clear they see no crisis as long as the dead people don't get in the way of their corporate profits rolling in.
And justice? You've got to be kidding!
How can any rational individual explain that white elephant conundrum in the middle of our tax system and, indeed, our entire legal system? Here we have a system that is, by far, too complicated for the brightest of the master scholars to understand. Yet, it mercilessly "holds accountable" its victims, claiming that they're responsible for fully complying with laws not even the experts understand. The law "requires" a signature on the bottom of a tax filing; yet no one can say truthfully that they understand what they are signing; if that's not "duress" than what is. If this is not the measure of a totalitarian regime, nothing is.
How did I get here?
My introduction to the real American nightmare starts back in the early ‘80s. Unfortunately after more than 16 years of school, somewhere along the line I picked up the absurd, pompous notion that I could read and understand plain English. Some friends introduced me to a group of people who were having ‘tax code' readings and discussions. In particular, zeroed in on a section relating to the wonderful "exemptions" that make institutions like the vulgar, corrupt Catholic Church so incredibly wealthy. We carefully studied the law (with the help of some of the "best", high-paid, experienced tax lawyers in the business), and then began to do exactly what the "big boys" were doing (except that we weren't steeling from our congregation or lying to the government about our massive profits in the name of God). We took a great deal of care to make it all visible, following all of the rules, exactly the way the law said it was to be done.
The intent of this exercise and our efforts was to bring about a much-needed re-evaluation of the laws that allow the monsters of organized religion to make such a mockery of people who earn an honest living. However, this is where I learned that there are two "interpretations" for every law; one for the very rich, and one for the rest of us... Oh, and the monsters are the very ones making and enforcing the laws; the inquisition is still alive and well today in this country.
That little lesson in patriotism cost me $40,000+, 10 years of my life, and set my retirement plans back to 0. It made me realize for the first time that I live in a country with an ideology that is based on a total and complete lie. It also made me realize, not only how naive I had been, but also the incredible stupidity of the American public; that they buy, hook, line, and sinker, the crap about their "freedom"... and that they continue to do so with eyes closed in the face of overwhelming evidence and all that keeps happening in front of them.
Before even having to make a shaky recovery from the sting of the first lesson on what justice really means in this country (around 1984 after making my way through engineering school and still another five years of "paying my dues"), I felt I finally had to take a chance of launching my dream of becoming an independent engineer.
On the subjects of engineers and dreams of independence, I should digress somewhat to say that I'm sure that I inherited the fascination for creative problem solving from my father. I realized this at a very young age.
The significance of independence, however, came much later during my early years of college; at the age of 18 or 19 when I was living on my own as student in an apartment in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. My neighbor was an elderly retired woman (80+ seemed ancient to me at that age) who was the widowed wife of a retired steel worker. Her husband had worked all his life in the steel mills of central Pennsylvania with promises from big business and the union that, for his 30 years of service, he would have a pension and medical care to look forward to in his retirement. Instead he was one of the thousands who got nothing because the incompetent mill management and corrupt union (not to mention the government) raided their pension funds and stole their retirement. All she had was social security to live on.
In retrospect, the situation was laughable because here I was living on peanut butter and bread (or Ritz crackers when I could afford to splurge) for months at a time. When I got to know this poor figure and heard her story I felt worse for her plight than for my own (I, after all, I thought I had everything to in front of me). I was genuinely appalled at one point, as we exchanged stories and commiserated with each other over our situations, when she in her grandmotherly fashion tried to convince me that I would be "healthier" eating cat food (like her) rather than trying to get all my substance from peanut butter and bread. I couldn't quite go there, but the impression was made. I decided that I didn't trust big business to take care of me, and that I would take responsibility for my own future and myself.
Return to the early ‘80s, and here I was off to a terrifying start as a ‘wet-behind-the-ears' contract software engineer... and two years later, thanks to the fine backroom, midnight effort by the sleazy executives of Arthur Andersen (the very same folks who later brought us Enron and other such calamities) and an equally sleazy New York Senator (Patrick Moynihan), we saw the passage of 1986 tax reform act with its section 1706.
For you who are unfamiliar, here is the core text of the IRS Section 1706, defining the treatment of workers (such as contract engineers) for tax purposes. Visit this link for a conference committee report (http://www.synergistech.com/1706.shtml#ConferenceCommitteeReport) regarding the intended interpretation of Section 1706 and the relevant parts of Section 530, as amended. For information on how these laws affect technical services workers and their clients, read our discussion here (http://www.synergistech.com/ic-taxlaw.shtml).
SEC. 1706. TREATMENT OF CERTAIN TECHNICAL PERSONNEL.
(a) IN GENERAL - Section 530 of the Revenue Act of 1978 is amended by adding at the end thereof the following new subsection:
(d) EXCEPTION. - This section shall not apply in the case of an individual who pursuant to an arrangement between the taxpayer and another person, provides services for such other person as an engineer, designer, drafter, computer programmer, systems analyst, or other similarly skilled worker engaged in a similar line of work.
(b) EFFECTIVE DATE. - The amendment made by this section shall apply to remuneration paid and services rendered after December 31, 1986.
Note:
- "another person" is the client in the traditional job-shop relationship.
- "taxpayer" is the recruiter, broker, agency, or job shop.
- "individual", "employee", or "worker" is you.
Admittedly, you need to read the treatment to understand what it is saying but it's not very complicated. The bottom line is that they may as well have put my name right in the text of section (d). Moreover, they could only have been more blunt if they would have came out and directly declared me a criminal and non-citizen slave. Twenty years later, I still can't believe my eyes.
During 1987, I spent close to $5000 of my ‘pocket change', and at least 1000 hours of my time writing, printing, and mailing to any senator, congressman, governor, or slug that might listen; none did, and they universally treated me as if I was wasting their time. I spent countless hours on the L.A. freeways driving to meetings and any and all of the disorganized professional groups who were attempting to mount a campaign against this atrocity. This, only to discover that our efforts were being easily derailed by a few moles from the brokers who were just beginning to enjoy the windfall from the new declaration of their "freedom". Oh, and don't forget, for all of the time I was spending on this, I was loosing income that I couldn't bill clients.
After months of struggling it had clearly gotten to be a futile exercise. The best we could get for all of our trouble is a pronouncement from an IRS mouthpiece that they weren't going to enforce that provision (read harass engineers and scientists). This immediately proved to be a lie, and the mere existence of the regulation began to have its impact on my bottom line; this, of course, was the intended effect.
Again, rewind my retirement plans back to 0 and shift them into idle. If I had any sense, I clearly should have left abandoned engineering and never looked back.
Instead I got busy working 100-hour workweeks. Then came the L.A. depression of the early 1990s. Our leaders decided that they didn't need the all of those extra Air Force bases they had in Southern California, so they were closed; just like that. The result was economic devastation in the region that rivaled the widely publicized Texas S&L fiasco. However, because the government caused it, no one gave a shit about all of the young families who lost their homes or street after street of boarded up houses abandoned to the wealthy loan companies who received government funds to "shore up" their windfall. Again, I lost my retirement.
Years later, after weathering a divorce and the constant struggle trying to build some momentum with my business, I find myself once again beginning to finally pick up some speed. Then came the .COM bust and the 911 nightmare. Our leaders decided that all aircraft were grounded for what seemed like an eternity; and long after that, ‘special' facilities like San Francisco were on security alert for months. This made access to my customers prohibitively expensive. Ironically, after what they had done the Government came to the aid of the airlines with billions of our tax dollars ... as usual they left me to rot and die while they bailed out their rich, incompetent cronies WITH MY MONEY! After these events, there went my business but not quite yet all of my retirement and savings.
By this time, I'm thinking that it might be good for a change. Bye to California, I'll try Austin for a while. So I moved, only to find out that this is a place with a highly inflated sense of self-importance and where damn little real engineering work is done. I've never experienced such a hard time finding work. The rates are 1/3 of what I was earning before the crash, because pay rates here are fixed by the three or four large companies in the area who are in collusion to drive down prices and wages... and this happens because the justice department is all on the take and doesn't give a fuck about serving anyone or anything but themselves and their rich buddies.
To survive, I was forced to cannibalize my savings and retirement, the last of which was a small IRA. This came in a year with mammoth expenses and not a single dollar of income. I filed no return that year thinking that because I didn't have any income there was no need. The sleazy government decided that they disagreed. But they didn't notify me in time for me to launch a legal objection so when I attempted to get a protest filed with the court I was told I was no longer entitled to due process because the time to file ran out. Bend over for another $10,000 helping of justice.
So now we come to the present. After my experience with the CPA world, following the business crash I swore that I'd never enter another accountant's office again. But here I am with a new marriage and a boatload of undocumented income, not to mention an expensive new business asset, a piano, which I had no idea how to handle. After considerable thought I decided that it would be irresponsible NOT to get professional help; a very big mistake.
When we received the forms back I was very optimistic that they were in order. I had taken all of the years information to Bill Ross, and he came back with results very similar to what I was expecting. Except that he had neglected to include the contents of Sheryl's unreported income; $12,700 worth of it. To make matters worse, Ross knew all along this was missing and I didn't have a clue until he pointed it out in the middle of the audit. By that time it had become brutally evident that he was representing himself and not me.
This left me stuck in the middle of this disaster trying to defend transactions that have no relationship to anything tax-related (at least the tax-related transactions were poorly documented). Things I never knew anything about and things my wife had no clue would ever matter to anyone. The end result is... well, just look around.
I remember reading about the stock market crash before the "great" depression and how there were wealthy bankers and businessmen jumping out of windows when they realized they screwed up and lost everything. Isn't it ironic how far we've come in 60 years in this country that they now know how to fix that little economic problem; they just steal from the middle class (who doesn't have any say in it, elections are a joke) to cover their asses and it's "business-as-usual". Now when the wealthy fuck up, the poor get to die for the mistakes... isn't that a clever, tidy solution.
As government agencies go, the FAA is often justifiably referred to as a tombstone agency, though they are hardly alone. The recent presidential puppet GW Bush and his cronies in their eight years certainly reinforced for all of us that this criticism rings equally true for all of the government. Nothing changes unless there is a body count (unless it is in the interest of the wealthy sows at the government trough). In a government full of hypocrites from top to bottom, life is as cheap as their lies and their self-serving laws.
I know I'm hardly the first one to decide I have had all I can stand. It has always been a myth that people have stopped dying for their freedom in this country, and it isn't limited to the blacks, and poor immigrants. I know there have been countless before me and there are sure to be as many after. But I also know that by not adding my body to the count, I insure nothing will change. I choose to not keep looking over my shoulder at "big brother" while he strips my carcass, I choose not to ignore what is going on all around me, I choose not to pretend that business as usual won't continue; I have just had enough.
I can only hope that the numbers quickly get too big to be white washed and ignored that the American zombies wake up and revolt; it will take nothing less. I would only hope that by striking a nerve that stimulates the inevitable double standard, knee-jerk government reaction that results in more stupid draconian restrictions people wake up and begin to see the pompous political thugs and their mindless minions for what they are. Sadly, though I spent my entire life trying to believe it wasn't so, but violence not only is the answer, it is the only answer. The cruel joke is that the really big chunks of shit at the top have known this all along and have been laughing, at and using this awareness against, fools like me all along.
I saw it written once that the definition of insanity is repeating the same process over and over and expecting the outcome to suddenly be different. I am finally ready to stop this insanity. Well, Mr. Big Brother IRS man, let's try something different; take my pound of flesh and sleep well.
The communist creed: From each according to his ability, to each according to his need.
The capitalist creed: From each according to his gullibility, to each according to his greed.
Joe Stack (1956-2010)
02/18/2010


118 Comments so far
Show AllRIP Joe Stack
WHAT??!!!
F@*% Joe Stack!
Wacko individual terrorism does not a class war make, you nutcases! How can you praise this sort of right wing, fake populist drivel on a supposedly progressive site?
This sort of individualist terrorism tends to happen in the priveledged First World countries, by disenfranchised people with a sense of social entitlement (read: white males). It is definitely a marker of regressive, reactionary thought. It is indefensible, and any idiot who's been part of a REAL progressive social movement would know that.
Those who would make peacful revolution impossible make violent revolution inevitable.
JFK
Nothing here douglitas but simple causality. What would it take for you to turn to violence? The insurance corp killng your child through denial of payment? A cop violently raping your wife or tasering her to death and laugh about it as he walked away free? Everyone has their breaking point and VERY many Americans are too close to it for my comfort or for the comfort of the ruling class for sure.
This guy's "breaking point" was financial difficulties that left him with still far, far more money and property (Car, house, airplane, grand piano) than most people here in Pittsburgh could dream of.
This guy was NO hero of the working class. Fuck his mutilated and burned remains.
Sorry, but you nor I know his true financial status. I inferred from his note that he was hocked to the hilt, that the tax code and its cronies had just finished screwing him yet again. I've written, and I think you agree, the System kills. It tormented him into his act, which is to say it abetted it. It would be great to not have to write about such things, but that's not our reality.
Why do you want sexual intercourse with his remains? Or are you just talk and not much of that. Are you the officer in charge of revolutionary acts?
Oh, please. This has nothing to do with violent revolution. This is no revolutionary act!
And really, Define Freedom, you're using that old, tired JFK quote to justify this crap? Followed by your weirdo scenarios of people "losing it" because of vague violent actions taken by unseen oppressors.
You have no "causal" analysis of events. Just cliches masquerading as sophistication.
And you, my friend, just have anger and stupidity and name-calling masquerading as concern.
Well its nice to see the plebs fighting amongst themselves in this thread, as the raping from the top continues. Face it we're a bunch of losers, and we deserve what is being done to us. Anybody who risks anything to stand up to the Fascism that is taking over this country is wasting their time. If you so much as piss on the Goldman Sachs building you will be condemned by your fellow plebs. The powers that be have nothing to fear from us. Go back to watching American Idol.
Oh Joe, Give our love to the ancestors!!!!
We hardly knew ye!
Wow
Hope? Change?
Kucinich 2012
When my turn comes, I hope to have even half as much courage. Rest well, Joe.
So sad, but so true. Sleep well Joe Stack. Your message is clear, and has been heard. Whether anybody will act upon it in a meaningful way is another question.
We the Sheeple seem quite content to follow the nice goat with the bell right up the ramp and through the door, into the abattoir.
Joe,
Sorry we could not have met in your life. I would have wanted to tell you that you are not alone in your revulsion of living in this Fascist nation.
As I conjectured in another post. This is just the latest salvo in the emerging class war.
Watch your backs you rich filth!
What, exactly, qualifies as "rich filth"? A person in America living below the poverty line is still richer than 80 % of the human population. Thus the question. Please define.
Define this:
Ask the Supreme Court about how corporate money buying our future is freedom.
How do you define that and how much more can you take?
Most people do not take out others in a suicide, and it is wrong.
But not everybody is most people and we should take this as a warning about letting things remain the same.
I guess it's the "scoop!" mentality that caused CommonDreams to publish this suicide essay; I consider it irresponsible and ghoulishly creepy at best that it was rushed into "print" without an editorial preface detailing its provenance.
If this proves to be authentic, and Mr. Stack indeed committed suicide, this is certainly tragic. Condolences to his family.
Still, even if Mr. Stack's final essay is an important historical statement by one of millions of victims chewed up and spit out by ruthless capitalism and tyrannical government, I don't see the point in presenting it so quickly and nakedly.
I believe that people have the right to end their own lives, and that for some suicide becomes an imperative that can't and shouldn't be corrected by medical/psychological intevention.
Still, whatever sociopolitical statement the poor man may have intended is undermined by his choice of a method that subjected innocent third parties to, yes, terror and harm.
He would've done better to drench himself and that mysterious piano he references in gasoline and light a last cigarette as long as he was blowing his stack.
· Yr Obd't Servant
I agree about harming others. He probably thought about many other options but went for the one that would get the most publicity.
Yes, "collateral damage" is always regretable. But I do not think it was incorrect of CD to provide this essential context.
"If this proves to be authentic, and Mr. Stack indeed committed suicide, this is certainly tragic. Condolences to his family."
This is indeed authentic. Yahoo news has an article on the crash that was published about 1:45 CST (2/18/2010).
Unfortunately, the press is saying that Mr. Stack simply had a beef with the IRS and that was the reason for the crash.
"Still, whatever sociopolitical statement the poor man may have intended is undermined by his choice of a method that subjected innocent third parties to, yes, terror and harm."
1. Obviously, Joe did not believe that anyone working for the IRS - the agency of most of his misery - is innocent.
2. Joe's final act does not undermine the strength of his document but, in fact, underscores it. Without the impact of the plane crashing into the IRS offices, the document would never reach the audience that it now will. Had he simply crashed the plane into a field, no one would have paid much atention.
I don't agree with Joe on point 1 and I do agree that the loss of any life - even of IRS agents - is deplorable. However, the act and the document are inseparable.
q
And now that we know about the presence of nano-thermite in WTC dust, which proves US government involvement, we should all think of Joe's decision to attack one segment of the monster, and to also reconsider McVeigh's.
On the other thread, it was mentioned that this was all about The Class War. That judgement was 100% correct.
Joe Stack deserves a medal.
karlof, it's not just the government ---- though the corporate/financial/militarist EMPIRE that controls our country by hiding behind the facade of its owned TWO-PARTY, 'VICHY' sham of democratic government would love rubes, scoundrels, and 'useful idiots' (like this modern phony TEA PARTY) to conflate and confuse this as just an anti-government movement.
The first American Revolution was not just an anti-government movement. Our forefathers were much smarter than that (although the Tea Partiers don't even know this high school history).
The first American Revolution was a well informed 'Anti-EMPIRE' movement that sought (and succeeded) in expunging a sophisticated and integrated political, financial/corporate, and militarist EMPIRE ---- which all Empires are ---- and replacing that indivisible political-economic-militarist EMPIRE with a democratic government of the self-governed.
The only flaw in the ointment was that the founding Americans thought that they might be able to insure that their newly created democratic republic of a government could be protected from the influence of any imperial economic/financial trend to Empire the same way that they tried to protect democratic government from religion, by keeping a separation of church and state. They tried the same with corporations (which were known to be dangerous, form their experience with the economic side of the British Empire (the Royally chartered British East India Corporation) but the early American chartering of corporations for "socially, publicly, common-interests" was bit by bit torn down by the legal guilefulness of the "financial royalists" (as FDR termed them).
Unfortunately, Empire is a pathology of economics first, and then the tumor spreads to the political sphere of life.
Now that oversight of the first American Revolution must be repaired by a Second American Revolution to complete the fight against EMPIRE and for complete democracy in all spheres of our society, life, and common-wealth.
Alan MacDonald
Sanford, Maine
Hi Alan--The First Amrican Revolution in 1776 created the Articles of Confederation--constitution #1--which was then overthrown in what ought to be called the Second American Revolution of 1787, which was actually a coup, and replaced a very democratic document with an anti-democratic document. That aspect of US history is very skillfully swept under the rug and very few learn the facts. What has occured in the USA could NEVER have happened under the Articles, but it was CERTAIN to happen under the 1787 constitution, Bill of Rights or not [What proves that certainty were the Alien and Sedition Acts]. The Anti-Federalists were correct to oppose the Philadelphia Golpistas; they were unfortunately unable to make their case to the very limited voting public of the time who were swayed by Federalist propaganda, who promised that the Bill of Rights would provide the remedy for their grievences. That is the biggest lie of all as we know well today.
amacd and karlof1, well said.
Good to reiterate these historical events and implications for today. If only Joe Doe would know.
One interesting 'documentary' is THE EMPIRE OF "THE CITY"
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=4675077383139148549
The film is obviously an amateur production, but the content is verifiable, comprehensive and definitely a great introduction to 'the EMPIRE'.
That's saddening. :(
But it does not vindicate the harm he brought to others.
Well we are just living the inevitable consequences of our own Fascist leadership.
JFK put it best:
When peaceful revolution is made impossible, violent revolution becomes inevitable.
Is this the first shot heard round the world in Amerika's next revolution?
Police beatings
Agent provocateurs
Sound cannons
Pepper spray
Tear gas
All deployed aganst people excercising their supposedly protected rights to redress their grievances with the government.
I would say to the ruling class now you may have a real uprising on your hands. Well done.
"Is this the first shot heard round the world in Amerika's next revolution?"
I'm wondering the same thing. The way the average person is being shit on by the powers that be, I'm surprised this hasn't happened sooner.
It's beyond ironic that while the corporatist media had no problem in coining the very first shooting by a postman as "going postal", that the self-described insightful, 'investigative' journalists of the corporatist 'Vichy' media flaks for this EMPIRE have ignored with impunity the hundreds of documented husband, wife, and often children 'family suicides' occurring in all regions of our country based on the economic peonization and feudalization of average Americans since the corporate/financial/militarist EMPIRE that controls 'our' country by hiding behind the facade of its TWO-PARTY 'VICHY' sham of democratic government, has never thought to call people, who in their financial desperation, kill themselves by the far more accurate term as "going Wall Street".
Yes, it looks like more and more people, average people, "poor/working/middle-class" people are "going Wall Street" every week --- as Joe did.
The only solution for us, the average Americans who naively believe in America, instead of the waste of "going Wall Street" and taking our own lives, is to start getting together in 'Anti-EMPIRE' clubs in our local areas, and then 'Anti-EMPIRE' leagues regionally, and finally thru solidarity in a national and even global 'Anti-EMPIRE' movement of solidarity to educate ourselves about the hidden EMPIRE that controls our lives, and then to expose the Global corporate/financial/militarist Empire which is the proximate cause of all our problems, issues, and "Sorrows of Empire", and finally to confront and excise this imperial sized tumor of cancer which is metastasizing through-out our world ---- and then continue on the true democratic path that America started on, of applying democracy to all spheres of our lives and liberty; the political, as well as the economic, the social, and the educational.
A Global People's Movement is the only way to confront this Global Empire.
Alan MacDonald
Sanford, Maine
Let the word go forth that the torch has been passed..._
ZERO INCUMBENTS next election. Maybe always.
*Comment deleted by site administrators for violating our Comment Policy*
see: http://www.commondreams.org/comment-policy
Poor Mr. Stack. Its terrible he felt dying was a better alternative to growing old.
Though his suicide note sounds a bit confused; he seems to go from left to right and back again in what he says.
Is there something I'm missing or is he damning all out of exasperation?
Maybe he goes from right to left and back, because he saw a bigger picture that the two opposing sides missed.
If this proves to be authentic: A sad testament to be sure... illustrating the anger and frustration many of us feel with 'leadership' in this country. However, this act could hardly be considered 'just' and the result, as poor Joe is no doubt discovering now, may not be quite the 'final' solution he wished for. To demonize any sect ('government workers,' 'the rich,' etc....) ultimately is a disservice to everyone and doesn't accomplish anything constructive. What we CAN do is be the change we want to see and work for constructive change; great examples have lived on from making this commitment, and it is not hopeless. Developing a more spiritual outlook (maintaining a longer-term outlook on life, despite personal hardships) can help, and prevent actions one later regrets.
No offense but, I think you're quite possibly mad. "Be the change you want to see" is nothing but a beautiful platitude that has done nothing, and I mean nothing, to bring about any real progressive change anywhere, at any time.
I'm so sick of whiny liberals who know we need real, deep and substantive change to our whole way of life yet, decry anyone who counterattacks the violence arrayed against us and actually makes a real statement, rather than marching down the street at some fashionable, richlefty protest. Fuckin' garbage.
Whether you agree with him or not, the people he attacked have no problem using whatever violence they want against us and him to get what they want. I say it's payback and if violence is all we have left to bring this mad house to it's knees, then bring it and right soon.
Isn't the IRS the wrong target? What "violence" is the IRS using? If anything, any post-revolutionary order would have an even more powerful "IRS" so we could tax the rich till ther are rich no more.
Or are you one of those "free market" anarchists.
Even if, purely for arguing, we accept that such violence works, He would have suicide-bombed any of a number of corporate or banking CEO's, or members of the Bush administration (John Yoo is currently on a speaking circuit) to much greater effect. (Disclaimer: just so it's clear, I'm NOT advocating assassinating anyone).
My mother worked for the IRS for many years. I'll never forget when she told me about the ARMED Revenue agents and their raids on people's houses. Let's not also forget that there was a ton of armed shootouts during prohibition was against the 'shiners and the rev'nooers. Since the IRS has been in existence, it's been armed, not against foreigners, but against your stupid asses.
Hell, your question about what violence the IRS is using is definitely either satire or sheer ignorance. What taxing entity in history HASN'T used violence to force compliance with taxation? Let's face it. You can't enshrine the principle of 'private property' as a maxim of society and expect people to not be hostile to those who take your stuff without your consent.
As for his choice of targets, well, I think he chose just fine. By the way, I object to your use of the term violence to describe his counterattack against this system but, I'll ride with you. I can prove violence works in a simple and visceral way. How do you think European Americans became the majority here in Fortress Amerika? I'll give you a hint. It wasn't through hugs and Girl Scout cookies. They attempted (and still attempt) to slaughter every living thing that they couldn't use in some way. VIOLENCE ABSOLUTELY WORKS. It just doesn't work for weak willed, milquetoast, sorry ass "liberals" who'd rather talk than fight. If taking out one single dam, no matter how much damage would be caused in the short term; if that would end this whole nightmare once and for all...you're immoral if you DON'T do it.
I guarantee you that if my ancestors waited on "liberals" to help us get free, we'd still be slaves here in Amerika. I'll take 10 John Browns over 10,000 William Lloyd Garrisons. There comes a point when talking is done. Everything has a season. If even a bee will rip out its own guts, trying to stop you from destroying what it values, you have no right to disparage Joe Stack for his effort.
Oh...and what the hell is a free-market anarch but a greed head disguised as a lover of freedom? Many things I may be but, Dog protect me from being anything "free market". Maybe I'm a free-range anarch... Peace to the people and long live the fighters!
To attack and kill employees at a local IRS office over being screwed over by one's capitalist bosses, or more accurately in this case, to be indignant over his sense of white-middle-class entitlement to succeed at capitalism, is disgusting.
Like the writings of most suicidal mentally ill peoiple, this rant screams of narcissstic self-absorbtion and entitlement. He most decidedly did NOT commit this act in the name of the wage-earning poor and down-trodden!
Quit the romanticising. This man is not one of the Haymarket seven. What this man did is just a variant of "going postal".
Here at MSHA, we are already talking about the possibility of a laid-off coal mine manager crashing a plane into our workplace.
And those people at PaDEP better keep their heads low if they deny any Marcellus Gas drilling permits!
Are you a member of the ruling class/elites? I have to wonder. To me, this man has completed a tragedy, by no means entirely of his own making. He was desperate, not insane.
Before you judge so harshly (and what gives you the right to judge anyway ?), give yourself a few more years of exposure to the inequalities of the American way and re-examine how you respond to joblessness, to pressure from the rightfully-despised IRS, to working your butt off for a corporation/government that really, really does not give a s..t about you, to a corporation that as it is failing tells you with a smile to put more of its stock into your retirement plan. I suspect that there are going to be a number of these desperate acts in the future and you, sir, may not be immune.
Things change.
Would he have done this to protest the wanton destruction of Iraq?
No, he did it because the IRS came down on him with a heavy hand. Money is the only thing that seems to be a common motivator here in the U.S. and though he may have felt persecuted, it seems he was living better than I am.
Again, I can't see this guy sacrificing himself for the cause of anybody else's justice, merely his own.
I suspect the details will all come out. Things may not be quite like he portrayed them.
GO SUPERCLASS, GO.
The guy OWNED and maintained an AIRPLANE a rather large SUBURBAN HOUSE, and a GRAND PIANO for crying out loud!!!
He Is NO hero of the working man! Wake the fuck UP you stupid liberals!
Cool your pipes, pjd. You can buy used Piper Cherokee for 30 thousand dollars or less, and apparently he needed it for business purposes. The piano was his wife's - she is a professional musician, and all we know about it is that it was "an expensive new business asset". And he probably "owned" his house in the same way that millions of other people "own" their houses - that is until foreclosure.
While I don't condone violence, and I think his act was misguided, especially since it caused death of innocent people, I think your comments here are totally off the mark.
Your big concern here seems to be that he was not visibly poor or homeless.
Your argument seems to be that "Stupid Liberals" would be right if a homeless person stole a plane and did a similar angry can't take any more act of goin postal.
I do not blame him nearly as much as the reality that drove him when things don't change and keep getting worse.
We all share some responsibility for what is happening and reactions like this are inevitable.
So, you would say the woman in Huntsville who very methodically shot and killed 3 of 6 co-workers--all people of color except her--not because she was denied tenure and while the people of color were, but becasue she was "indignant over his sense of white-middle-class entitlement to succeed"?
Could be the reason. I didn't know the killer was white and the victims were black. The main problem was probably that she was not mentally sound.
Why didn't Norman Finkelstein kill his former Dept head at De Paul, then go to Harvard and kill Alan Dershovitz? He didn't because he is mentally sound.
pjd412--Thanks for providing the rationale proving most US presidents mentally unsound.
He is the Paul Revere for the modern age. A martyr for 95% of the american people. RIP JOE.
You are so right. He will not be the only martyr to the failed state of the U.S., I am sure. It's unfortunate that his desperate, discouraged mind led him to include fellow Americans in his action, but I can't say that I don't understand it.
The whole situation makes my heart ache.