Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Farm Suicides Turn Children Into Farmers
YAVATMAL, India - Eleven-year-old Digambar Rathod looks older than his age. Shy and uncertain, he stares disconcertedly at the garlanded photograph of his father Jaideep, a 42-year-old cotton farmer who committed suicide on Jan. 1, 2009 in Tiwsala village, in eastern Maharashtra state's suicide-torn Yavatmal district.
(Fawzan Husain for The New York Times) As the new head of the household, the boy-turned-farmer has adult responsibilities like the repayment of a bank loan of 190,000 rupees (roughly 3,960 dollars) that was the cause of his father's death.
Digambar has dropped out of school, says his mother, Sunita, grief-stricken and burdened by the terrible tragedy the family has suffered. His older sister Roshni too has left school to take over the household work. The two younger children, a boy and a girl, are too young to work, says Roshni.
But everyone knows that it won't be long before all four Rathod children join the ranks of Vidarbha's baccha-kisans (child farmers). Here in six districts including Yavatmal, Wardha and Akola, thousands of cotton farmers have taken their lives due to mounting debts and a dramatic decline in farm incomes over the past decade or so, and their children have stepped into their shoes.
According to the National Crime Record Bureau (NCRB), 40,000 of the 184,000 farmers' suicides reported in India between 1995 and 2007 were from Maharashtra. Over 25,000 of the deaths in the state were registered after 2002.
Ganesh Diliprao Kale in Ralegaon village, Yavatmal, was barely 13 when he became the eldest male in both his own and his two uncles' families. Over a span of five years, between 2003 and 2008, his father's brothers and father were driven by debt to suicide.
"Ganesh cultivated our farm last season with little support from relatives," says his mother Shalini. Her school-going daughter, Ashwini, 11, assists them on the weekends. She's already taken over much of her mother's work in the house.
A few miles away, in Khadakdoh village, in south Yavatmal, Kavita Kudmethe and her two daughters, around 13 years of age, scrape a living as farm workers. Her husband killed himself in 2007, and his parents threw Kavita and her daughters out of the house.
She knows that had one of them been a son, the family would not have turned her out. Girls are considered a social burden in India. The tension of finding a groom for their daughters has emerged as a contributing cause to the spate of farmers' suicides, according to a 2005 study commissioned by the Maharashtra government.
Kavita hopes to marry her daughters off as soon as they turn 15 although the legal age of marriage for girls is 18. "That'll relieve me of my burden," she says. Farm suicides in Vidarbha have robbed so many children of their childhoods.
Swati Thote, 12, shoulders the responsibility of domestic chores and tending the livestock while her mother Sarla works on their 4-acre farm in Kosurla village, Wardha. Swati's cotton farmer father committed suicide in December 2005.
At 13, Roshani Shete takes care of her mother, Shobha in Pimpalkhuta village, Amravati district. Her landless father took his own life, having accumulated huge debts for a farm he had leased. The girl, a constant smile on her face, does most of the chores, and goes to school without fail. "She's become my mother," says Shobha.
But the smile may be hiding a deep emotional scar. Roshani has not slept soundly since her father's suicide in October 2008, her mother says. The father and daughter were very close. In fact, she is terrified to sleep in his room in their tiny mud hut, her mother reveals.
"These children are inheriting debt, distress and emotional upheavals," laments Vijay Jawandhia, a sexagenarian farmers' leader from Vidarbha. "The impact of the agrarian crisis on generations (within families) is terrible and has long-term consequences."
Dr Sujay Patil, a young psychiatrist in Akola has been offering free consultancy services to farmers showing signs of depression or mental illness from his home district of Akola. He says, "younger and younger farmers are turning up for medication as they are unable to cope with the pressures of agriculture and the new economic order."
According to Dr Shailesh Pangaonkar, a Nagpur-based child psychologist, "early maturing of children, who haven't had time to mourn the loss of their fathers, could lead to a subtle depression throughout their lives." He advises that such children need "education, cultural involvement and economic stability, for healthy growth ..."
For most rural families, especially in Vidarbha, this is a distant dream. Cotton farmers have been acutely affected by soaring input prices, declining incomes, lack of irrigation, and volatile global prices, among other things.
"I simply can't support my daughters emotionally or feed them nutritious food," says Kavita, the dispossessed widow. "My daughters are as vulnerable to (sexual and physical) exploitation as I am," she adds in a resigned voice.
A random study of 20 children from suicide-affected households by this journalist in 2008 found them emotionally disturbed. While some were extremely aggressive, the others were very docile.
Saraswati Amberwar, in Telangtakli village of Yavatmal, says her second daughter, Jaishree has not recovered from the shock of her father's suicide 10 years ago. "She is on medication, and has become silent and submissive, as if she's dead from inside," she says.
In contrast, Prasheet Pethkar, 14, in Kurzadi village, Wardha district, spews abuse at his mother who he blames for the family's problems and his father's suicide.
"There should be government intervention," says Vilas Bhongade, a social worker and child rights campaigner in Vidarbha. "The impact of the farm crisis on children must be seen in the light of a child's right to survival, protection, development and participation."
"These children desperately need emotional support," adds Prabhakar Nakade, a school teacher in Wardha and member of the District English Language Teachers' Association (DELTA) which has experience with children from suicide-affected farm households.
"Though they work and support their families like adults, we must not forget they are just children," he pleads.
- Posted in



13 Comments so far
Show Allwe are all lee kyung hae now. solidarity. seed and food sovereignty now. end the privatization and commodification of life and peace and justice will follow. we human beings need to stop treating this planet and its inhabitants as private property we can endlessly mine and abuse. where is our conscience? our kindness? our intelligence?
IF I GIVE TO THE POOR, THEY CALL ME A SAINT;
IF I ASK WHY THERE ARE POOR, THEY CALL ME A COMMUNIST.
-DON HELDER CAMERA
i am not an anything-ist. just a grieving human being wanting this violence and cruelty to stop.
Good post. Joe
Bring an end to this crap!
Come to the G-20 in Pittsburgh - September 24 and 25, 2009.
>>>According to the National Crime Record Bureau (NCRB), 40,000 of the 184,000 farmers' suicides reported in India between 1995 and 2007 were from Maharashtra. Over 25,000 of the deaths in the state were registered after 2002.
A large number of these farmers where induced into, or left with no other choice than to buy Monsanto's cotton seeds. They call it Bt cotton, and it's genetically modified - which the Indian government agencies approved despite stiff opposition from environmental and social activists.
>>>Jaideep, a 42-year-old cotton farmer who committed suicide on Jan. 1, 2009
That's new year's day - when the yuppie Indian crowd would have been recovering from the previous night's partying. There is a growing class divide in India - where those who can find opportunities in the "new" economy don't give a damn about what happens to the farmers or even where their food comes from. Talking to them about economic equity, environment, climate change, ecological footprint, etc. would only elicit blank stares, or some wise ass comment about how westerners are consuming more. The fact is that the elite in India (and other countries) are conveniently hiding behind the poor - whose abysmally low levels of consumption brings down the national average to a tiny fraction of western consumption levels.
The blame for the farmers' suicides in India MUST squarely rest with the Indian government and the Indian elite themselves for enabling (and often working for) the multinational corporations and foreign banks to play havoc with the livelihoods of the poor people in India.
I couldn't agree with you more. I was in New Delhi for two months in 2004, and whenever I brought up the subject of the hundreds of millions of desperately poor people in the country, the typical answer I got was:"Oh, the massive poverty will always be there. That's not going to change."
The fact is that those who've prospered in the "new" India don't give a damn about the poor--starting at the top with the government.
Monsanto: 'Kill 'em all!'
You fuckers.
The program that oversees our posts believes that I am spaming the site because I post this URL so often.
http://emrojapan.com/
I have been reading Dr. Higa's books for just over a year and experimenting with Effective Microorganisms (EM-1) for about that time. Dr. Higa has 20 years of real world results using microorganisms to be able to do away with the use of all agricultural fertilizers and chemicals - pesticides and herbicides. The microorganisms are also able to mitigate environmental pollution - inexpensively.
Farming can be profitable when the agro chemical companies and bankers are taken out of the picture.
Terran
How about suicide rates in occupied Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and the US military. Suicide bombers don't count.
A PIECE OF MY HEART
Got to thinking today about what people do in concert with other people and it has not been a picture that one would put in an album because of this we have repeated down through history all that we would find abhorrent, my heart lost pieces in oh so many pages of books where the greed soared and innocents lost and perished. Is there any continent that is pure? Nay and for every race or nation has there been the greed and my heart left a piece. Why is this so; why must a small portion of a species so foul its nest with things that are so fleeting in the measure of time that others are left to the outer reaches of this planet we call home? A piece of my heart goes to current pages on CD and other venues for the India farmers who perish by their own hand and force children to be adults and forego childhood, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq where being collateral is a way of death and other Arabian states have much and share not with their own, Israel, which is supposed to be a Democracy, how, when you shove your neighbor out of his home? Africa, a big piece of my heart and South America, Central America where transition takes pieces too. My home the US of A has taken a chunk and left me wondering why is this tragedy so? The heart is of love and when whole it will share with all who were, are and will be and this is where I wish my heart should be. Tony 6/10/2009
That was heartfelt, and 'beautiful' in its own lamenting way...Well Tony, compassion cannot go to waste - even though we don't always see the results in our lifetime. Take care of your sensitive heart.
Thank you.Tony
The sheer numbers of suicides are appalling--from one region, from one profession, even in a ten-year period. Why hasn't this been brought to the media forefront? As distasteful as I find her, THIS should be on Nancy Grace's marathon, over-the-top sensationalistic "news" show. 184,000 people committing suicide in ten years is like 5-6 people from a moderate-sized city killing themselves everyday for the next 3652 days.
But, nobody cares. They are the lower class, so why care about or try to help them? It's not my problem, right?
One man living in such poverty that a debt of $4000 was enough to drive all hope out of him, to the point of such desperation that he took his own live. He is only one of almost 200,000 to do so in the last ten years. Bernard Madoff, one man, stole $165 million and probably still smiles when he thinks about what he got away with for so long.
Humanity today has NO sense of social responsibility. Only in the last few decades have we realized what impact we're having on our ownenvironment. Why is profit more important than working together to secure the futures of mankind and the only planet we have? Why do we spend billions of dollars figuring out how to kill each other, when we obviously have enough problems learning how to stay alive?
it's called 'corporate personhood' which enables an amoral entity fueled by the profit motive to seek growth and profit by any means necessary. it is being fought against all over the planet and becoming more transparent everyday for what it is. a paradigm doesn't shift overnight, but every boycott of a product awash in blood and every truth fearlessly told to power DOES make an incremental difference.
jeffersonlee, in the interests of sincerely answering your heartfelt question, here's a quote by wendell berry i recently ran across in woody tasch's book, 'slow money' and posted as answer to a similar question to yours:
THE CORPORATE MIND IS REMARKABLY NARROW. IT CLAIMS TO UTILIZE ONLY EMPIRICAL KNOWLEDGE-THE PREFERRED TERM IS "SOUND SCIENCE", REDUCIBLE ULTIMATELY TO THE "BOTTOM LINE" OF PROFIT OR POWER-AND BECAUSE THIS RULES OUT ANY EXPLICIT RECOURSE TO EXPERIENCE OR... CONSCIENCE, THIS MIND IS READILY SUSCEPTIBLE TO EVEY KIND OF IGNORANCE AND IS PERHAPS NATURALLY PREDISPOSED TO COUNTERFEIT KNOWLEDGE. IT COMES TO ITS WORK EQUIPPED WITH FACTUAL KNOWLEDGE AND PERHAPS ALSO WITH KNOWLEDGE SKILLFULLY COUNTERFEITED, BUT WITHOUT RECOURSE TO ANY OF THOSE KNOWLEDGES THAT ENABLE US TO DEAL APPROPRIATELY WITH MYSTERY OR WITH HUMAN LIMITS. IT HAS NO HUMBLING KNOWLEDGE. THE CORPORATE MIND IS ARROGANTLY IGNORANT BY DEFINITION.