Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
The Tossed Shoe Award
"Businesses exist to serve the general welfare. Profit is the means, not the end. It is the reward a business receives for serving the general welfare. When a business fails to serve the general welfare, it forfeits its right to exist."
Do Adam Smith's famously forgotten words of caution for capitalists apply to journalism? Is this why, when I go to the newsstand these days, I see my city's two great newspapers sitting there like twin anorexics, panhandling (I mean pandering) for quarters?
Taking my inspiration from University of Texas journalism professor Robert Jensen, who has written a manifesto challenging J-schools to become relevant again, I see that the time has come to engage in the envisioning of the future of my beloved, gasping profession.
What kind of newspapers will, or should, rise from the wreckage of today's collapsing empires? What principles should they embody that incorporate the best of the old tradition - fairness, accuracy, jargon-free language, fearlessness in seeking the truth wherever it may lead - and at the same time move beyond that tradition and establish crucial, indeed, spiritual relevance to today's far more dangerous and complex world?
No small task - moving these great entities away from their cynical certainties and commitment to the special interests of money and power. How do newspapers begin serving the general welfare more effectively than they do now? It will take courage from journalists at every level: beat reporters, editors, executives.
"The best traditions of journalism are based in resistance to the illegitimate structures of authority at the heart of our problems," Jensen writes at Common Dreams.org ("Can Journalism Schools Be Relevant in a World on the Brink?"). ". . . the most revered journalists have had the courage to take a stand for ordinary people and against arrogant concentrations of power."
And the Tossed Shoe Award goes to . . .
Jensen's words made me think immediately of Muntadhar al-Zeidi, the reporter for Al-Baghdadiya TV who threw his shoes at George Bush at a press conference during the president's final visit to Iraq last December. Al-Zeidi, released from prison a few days ago, declared: "Here I am, free, but my country remains captive."
I guess, technically, hurled shoes don't count as journalism, but they set a standard for courage in speaking truth to power. Men and women of the press, go out and do that with your laptops and your cameras! Those flying shoes certainly stand in contrast to the timidity of mainstream reporters over here on the power side of the war equation, who, with a few notable exceptions, exercised no independence from the Bush White House and the lies that made the war on terror, and the ensuing suffering of Afghans and Iraqis, a done deal.
But courage and passion are only the starting place if we are to rebuild - re-envision - the media. Here are a few more principles that I believe are crucial for a revitalized media to embrace:
1. As Jensen notes, journalism's great heroes and role models took a stand for ordinary people. I would push this thought further: This is not merely a political matter, a demand for justice or redress. To take a stand for "ordinary people" means, first of all, to listen to them - to dig, in one's reporting, for the soul of their hopes - and to celebrate their lives. When I began my career as a reporter, my first big surprise was the rush of gratitude I felt from people simply because I had listened to them.
2. A re-envisioned media must learn how to tell complex stories, simply and compellingly. This requires a reorientation toward truth and away from lowest-common-denominator journalism: fear-mongering, celebrity fawning and other forms of know-nothingism that have only gotten worse in recent years, as the reeling media empires grow ever more desperate for quick, cheap profits.
3. The media must grow up. Reporters must stop flailing the good-vs.-evil, winner-vs.-loser narrative, which explains nothing, justifies everything and only fuels the moneyed status quo. My friend Jake Lynch, an Australian journalist and director of the Centre for Peace and Conflict Studies at the University of Sydney, talks about "peace journalism": journalism that looks at all sides of a conflict, examines all consequences of military violence, and pursues the "why" of a story beyond the official sources (usually anonymous) who turn most war reportage into propaganda.
4. The media must expand their horizons and find an intelligence independent of the "experts" they so often quote to avoid saying anything. They must try to understand and learn to write about the real news people crave, sometimes unknowingly. This is the news about social and environmental healing. Right now, the media doesn't even recognize healing as news, yet without it we have no future.
- Posted in




20 Comments so far
Show AllJournalism today is a lot like Walmart - selling cheaply manufactured products made by underpaid workers, but the marketing is excellent.
"I guess, technically, hurled shoes don't count as journalism, but they set a standard for courage in speaking truth to power."
**********
This is why the shoe-hurler when released, after months of imprisonment that included torture, was hailed as a national hero. He was presented with his own house and generaly cheered wherever he went.
He literally risked his life for the priceless opportunity to speak for those whose voices were ignored and the ignored knew it and will likely never forget it or him.
Poet
Those hurled shoes were a statement--more powerful than anything Al-Zaidi might have written.
There should be an Al-Zaidi journalism award.
Poet, nicely stated
calling upon the media to clean its act up is like calling on a crack head to keep his teeth flossed - aint gonna happen
as far as adam smith goes: often evoked by the right wing welfare/capitolists on wall street as a "free market" bastion, adam smith based his economic visions on a strong national economy, one where businesses would invest in their own country, even locally, as that would provide the best investment results.
for smith to see the de-industrialization of this country and the removal of our jobs to china and mexico would have mortified him
he is probably quivering in his grave as we speak...
i wish: that shoe thrower guy would have smacked bush in his face with the shoe and given hima case of facial athlete's feet
i also wish that taylor swift would have smacked kanye west upside the head with her award
two down, many to go
i also wish that taylor swift would have smacked kanye west upside the head with her award
Mee tooo!
US troops recently shot a mentally disturbed man in Iraq for throwing a shoe at them.
Al Zaidi is fortunate it was Iraqi Guards that arrested him at Bushes news conference.
A shoe throwing incident by a crowd in Fallujah eary in the Iraqi war led to US troops gunning down some 14 unarmed iraqis which led to Fallujah becoming a center of resistance against US forces.
Fallujah - no better example to illustrate what an extremist nation the US has become. I sat in on an House Appropriations Committee meeting where military brass bragged about how they had "brought Fallujah in under-budget." With the help of napalm, we/they set fire to over 50% of the homes - apparently an inexpensive way to hit the delete button on an entire city. Makes me want to get right up and bellow out a few versus of America the Beautiful.
Thanks Obama for getting that war shut down.
don't forget the usage of depleted uranium and white phosphorous during the attack not only in fallujah but in iraq generally
it is a war crime but apparently we don't give a fuck about that either
GwNorth
Agence France-Presse reports that the Iraqi man, Ahmed Latif, 32, whom the American soldiers shot at, had died at the hospital that had treated him for his wounds which he had received at the hands of the Americans. The army thought that the man, whom they accused of being "mentally disturbed", had thrown a grenade at them even though a standard grenade is one third of the size of a shoe. Apparently the US army believes that if an Iraqi shouts out that the Americans should leave their country, which, I believe is what Ahmed Latif said to the Americans, then that qualifies that person as meeting the definition of being mentally disturbed. Latif had the temerity to insult the soldiers who were patrolling Fallujah a city which, like other Iraqi cities and towns, the Americans have illegally entered and occupied.
Latif was certainly correct. The Americans do not belong in Iraq just as they do not belong in Afghanistan. The hope is that the Iraqis will make their concerns known at the Americans through more vociferous means which would go beyond merely throwing shoes at the occupying army.
Maybe the Imperial Stormtroopers thought the poor guy was throwing a "shoe bomb", à la Richard Reid.
In Amerika, summary execution by cops is SOP. All they have to say afterwards is that the victim "appeared to be reaching for his waistband". Case closed!
(AFAIK, only men are summarily executed in this manner-- at least I've never heard of a woman being executed after reaching for her waistband. The moral of the story is: men, don't pull up your sagging pants if there's a cop around-- and don't DARE scratch your balls, no matter how bad they itch.)
· Yr Obd't Servant
US troops are carefully trained to be brave in defending each other, cowardly in incidents like these. The Seven Samurai, recast as The Guns of the Magnificent Seven, did win hearts and minds as well as the battle. Those of us old enough to remember either film know what happened to them.
US cops are often pretty bad, too. To Protect and Serve - each other. The public be damned.
I remind everyone to celebrate this coming December 14th as CONTEMPT FOR MOFO'S DAY in honor of Muntadar al Zeidi. I will be pasting a large photo of George Wanker Bush on my garage door and hurling an old pair of Doc Martens at it. This year, however, a photo of Barack H. Obama will be pasted in a place of dishonor right next to The Wanker and the Doc Martens will get a second round of action. "This is for you, you dawg!"
Perfect, I love it. If only I could get big enough posters... I would totally do that...
As the Supreme Court noted in the O'Brien case (1968), there is such a thing a symbolic speech. Shoe throwing would seem to qualify if its intent was to communicate rather than to attack.
Here was my idea: Dec. 14, International Bronze Shoe Award, or other creative name. Bronze shoe made by Fernando Botero (he does incredible bronze work; and he did the Abu Ghraib work). Every year dedicate to the person who is as contemptible as Bush. Would be great to be formally presented and publicized so people won't forget.
Who should be awarded with a shoe in his face this year?
You cannot have a corrupted government without a corrupted mainstream media. We have both.
Al-Zeidi, released from prison a few days ago, declared: "Here I am, free, but my country remains captive."
That is an incredible statement, considering all that he probably went through while in jail (and maybe an understanding that he could wind up there again), he still remains true to his message, and willing to say it publicly.
Al-Zeidi is a true hero journalist, who used actions and words to speak the truth. While the rest of the journalists, Iraqi and otherwise, blathered about everything was ok, he spoke the truth. He continue to speak the truth and be unafraid to do so - "Here I am free, but my country remains captive." All of you so-called journalists, why don't you learn from Al-Zeidi? Especially those of you who played the piedpiper's flute leading us into the war.
What will we call the awards? Perhaps "The Gepettos"? Gepetto, a humble and kind shoemaker, started out by making a lying little woodenheaded puppet - but the puppet eventually turned around and became a real live human.
Joe