Gaza: Where Civilians Become Targets
Israel accuses Hamas of hiding 'terrorist infrastructure' among civilians, but does that justify the slaughter of innocent Gazans?
My colleague in Gaza was between BBC Radio interviews early Sunday morning when a powerful blast shook her flat. Glass shards seemed to come from all directions, and for several moments of sheer panic, in the dust, smoke and debris, Fikr tried to stand and find her husband. Still shaken, fearing more attacks, they ran to their neighbour, who was screaming in terror, trying to find her four young children.
Yesterday, before her home was damaged by one of Israel's "targeted" attacks, Fikr spent the day doing emergency response, bringing additional supplies and surgical kits to hospitals barely able to cope with the dead and wounded. Al-Shifa, the largest hospital in Gaza, had run out of space in the morgue almost immediately. Now the dead overflow into the corridors, and outside on to the streets.
Gaza's hospitals were at a breaking point long ago. After months of collective punishment and the denial of the most mundane and most essential, it is near impossible to treat the hundreds of injured streaming in to the emergency wards. The situation today for hospitals - just like for all Gazans - is like being slowly starved, strangled and deprived of oxygen, then having your head plunged and held underwater. Our medical sources in the hospitals report that of the injured from yesterday's attacks alone, more than 100 will likely die in the coming hours and days. Injuries are severe, and the hospital wards are not only overwhelmed by the numbers, but have less resources - such as alcohol, morphine, plastic gloves - to treat the wounded.
It is hell and chaos, says Fikr. Gaza has experienced severe attacks before, but nothing on this scale. Hundreds of anxious and terrified people are searching hospital wards and the bodies to find sons, daughters, relatives. When a family member is identified among the dead, the family is told that they must bring their dead relative away - there is simply no space, and more dead and injured are still arriving.
While organising for additional medical supplies, Fikr tries for over an hour to reach another colleague. Further south, Nawrez is coordinating MAP's blood donations facility. But in the chaos, the phone networks are down. When we finally get through to Nawrez, she tells of the ongoing horror where she is. That morning, several major attacks were very near her home. One of the worst - with reports of 40 dead - was a mere 50m from her children's school. Classes were in session at the time of the attacks, and hundreds of terrified children and frantic parents struggled to find each other.
Back in the near empty medical storage room at Al-Shifa, Fikr sees the man in charge of medical supplies faint: he had just been told that his son was killed.
Israel's spokespersons may constantly repeat that these attacks are "targeted", but targeted attacks don't kill this many civilians. They don't destroy and cause chaos and panic in entirely residential areas. If we accept - by silence or without questioning - that anything and everyone can be defined as "terrorist infrastructure", then we are designating all civilians in Gaza as being targets. And the targeting continues.
Twitter
StumbleUpon
Facebook
Delicious
Digg
Newsvine
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
17 Comments so far
Show All"Hamas is targeting deliberately kindergartens and schools and citizens and civilians because this is according to their values. Our values are completely different. We are trying to target Hamas, which hides among civilians."
- Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni
Amazing how you take Israel's poor excuse for a Foreign Minister at face value.
The first two children killed by Qassam rockets in this war were two Palestinian girls!!! The first Israeli killed was a rabbi yes but then the second was a bedouin!!! The PA has rejected Hamas because they have killed over 60 Fatah members in the last few months. Hamas may be elected, but then, if they decleare an end to a ceasefire, which they did, shouldn't they be responsible for the response??? Israel has to protect the Palestinians from Hamas too, under international law as an occupier as you people say. And as for fascism, Hamas's policies and charter are anti-gay, anti- women's rights, and anti Jew. At least Israel is trying to create a multi racial govt.. Iran is trying to push a fascist, homophobic, racist rule on the Middle East and liberals are the ones suporting them??? What is wrong with you people??? Hamas does not give a shit about Palestinians, they want martyrs. They asked for war. You can support the Palestinian people for a change. Abbas was also elected, the west bank is relatively quiet, and he says Hamas brought this on their own people. hamas is not Palestinian, they are the Ayatolah's men.
We all need to start using proper word "GENOCIDE" to describe the actions of Israelis against Palestinian nation.
In 1944 Raphael Lemkin a Polish-Jewish lawyer sought to describe German actions of the deliberate and systematic destruction of the European Jews, Gypsies and others. He formed the word "genocide" by combining "geno" from the Greek word for race and "cide" from the Latin word for killing.
16 October 1940 Germans established Warsaw Ghetto then one month later
they closed off the Warsaw Ghetto from the outside world as Israelis did to Gaza Strip 50 years later. Israelis call thys a "genocide", guess how they call the same actions 50 years later a "seciurity barrier".
18 January 1943 Jewish with help of Polish Home Army and People's Guard started “Warsaw Ghetto Uprising” they called themselves a "freedom fighters", guess how they call Palestinians now – "terrorists".
How do you call a victims of past crime of "genocide" who later in time committing very similar crime against others. Logical people usually call they actions a "GENOCIDE".
Did the Israelis learn from their own history "Not a bit".
Since our own government funds and supports (and veto's UN resolutions) these crimes against humanity and the murder and maiming of Gaza citizens I have already started using the proper word "GENOCIDAL MONSTERS" to describe my elected officials.
From now on "Chanukah" will always mean the sadistic slaughter of innocent children.
This is State-Terrorism... nothing less.
Israel's lies about conducting a "defensive" war and not targeting civilians must be clear to anyone with a minimum of brains. Is the Islamic University a Hamas stronghold? Israel bombed it today. Are police stations Hamas strongholds? Israel is targeting them. In fact, Israel is targeting the civilian infrastructure--just as it did in Lebanon two years ago. World leaders will never go on record of criticising Israel, so it is up to the people--BOYCOTT ALL ISRAELI GOODS!
I did stop buying Israelis Dill Pickles over 10 years ego.
Oh how good they tasted, but no more bullets for the criminals.
If only life was that simple. I have my doctor and two brothers supporting Zion
Howard: "The people of Palestine elected Hamas in free and fair elections widely monitored, and Hamas has brought the wrath of Israel down on them again."
"Free and fair elections" unacceptable to the Bush Administration or the Israeli government.
I've read your comment several times, Howard. I highly recommend you read some history starting with a timeline from biblical days through the Kingdom of Judah and its fall, and then what happened to the Jews, the different branches and different genetic lineages, and all the nations and areas they settled in or were brought to as slaves and then travelled on as free people.
Then read the history of Zionism, available by various Jewish and non-Jewish writers and scholars, and what happened when Zionists settled in Palestine in the 1920's and even before, and then to the present day.
Then read what happened after The Holocaust and the decisions and opinions of U.S. presidents, including their personal papers, and other world leaders of the time, and how many and who of the Holocaust victims came to Israel.
Then read the history of the Palestinians and what happened to them before and after Israel became a nation-state.
Read the histories of Israel's leaders, generals, prime ministers, leadership of opposing parties, and their decisions and intentions regarding Palestinians, and their conduct and the aftermath of various battles.
Also read about the terrorist organization Rahm Emanuel's father belonged to before and after Israel became a recognized nation-state, and what his role and activities were, and why. And then examine the differences between a Hamas fighter and an Israeli fighter who were/are called terrorists.
A grave injustice has been done here to a SEMITIC people who lived in Palestine for a thousand years and were and are called Palestinians. Perhaps 200, likely less, Jewish families, SEMITIC peoples, whose lineage went back to biblical times, lived side by side with the Palestinians for centuries. Read what happened to the Palestinians and their ancestral lands, and their treatment for 60 years when they were ejected from their homes and lands after Israel became a nation-state.
Then read and examine the relationship between Israel and the United States government and earlier, with European powers, and what's that all about strategically and financially.
Harry Truman, who courted the Jewish vote in the 1948 election, was warned by Secretary of State, General [ret.) George C. Marshall that recognizing the statehood of Israel would bring nothing but trouble to the mid-east and the world. Truman joked: But last I knew there were more Jewish votes here than Arab votes. Political expediency has a way of nibbling away at ethics and morals, and Truman over-all had a great deal of integrity, but he was a politician who wanted to serve another term of office in the presidency.
Not too long after Israel was recognized as a nation-state, Truman became irritated and said he didn't want to talk to any of the Israeli leaders anymore. "They never can get enough. No matter what I do, they are always complaining. They are never satisfied. They always want more." TRUMAN LIBRARY, personal papers.
Sorry, I can't buy what you are saying, Howard. Your information is faulty and skewed. Get the whole picture, and you will find the angels and the devils and everyone in between dancing a very, very complex dance through many, many years of history.
But regardless, Israel is engaged in a genocide of the Palestinian people in Gaza. Read the Genocide Convention of the United Nations, and its history too, and what constitutes genocide. Out of five criteria, what Israel is doing fits three of them to a T, and doing any one of them is enough to call it Genocide.
peace - /cm
I occasionally see the israelis-and-palestinians on tv. It's totally obvious that the arabs are semitic and the israelis are white. The whole israel thing is just another example of white guys from europe taking land off indigenous people and killing them.
http://www.users.bigpond.com/pmurray
http://www.paulmurray.id.au/ageofworms
The high civilian casualties show the success of the strategy that has been employed since the very beginning of the Israel / Palestinian conflict.... of doing exactly what Israel claims.... Placing targets in areas that will maximize civilian casualties. The reaction of most people to this carnage shows the success of this, though the responsibility lies with Hamas which as with previous Palestinian group is using their civilians for maximum public outrage effect. This is exactly the same as if criminals in our country committed a criminal outrage and instigated an armed conflict with police, then retreated into a schoolyard full of children to fight it out with the law. It is reprehensible and criminal... and with these barbarians it is standard operating procedure. Attack and kill Israeli civilians......always these "courageous freedom fighters" kill civilians..... human bombs in nightclubs, and on buses, hijackings, rape and murder, etc...... until the government MUST respond..... then retreat to places where innocents are guaranteed to die. Should Israel NOT respond? Should they allow their citizens to be murdered? The Palestinians have shown themselves time and again not to be fit to join the community of civilized nations, not only by their barbaric strategies but by their constant and inevitable sabotage of any and all peace process.
After over 40 years of watching the same scenario played out over and over, I have no patience with these people. The people of Palestine elected Hamas in free and fair elections widely monitored, and Hamas has brought the wrath of Israel down on them again.
It is the responsibility of governbments to protect and defend and serve the interests of their people. That includes making the consequences of attacking them to high to be acceptable to enemies. Hamas has done the opposite. They have repeatedly provoked Israel and brought down this consequence upon their people. This constant provocation has resulted in the blockade of Gaza, and now the current crisis, and their cries for sympathy and for the condemnation of their oppressor are falling on deaf ears...... They have done this too many times..... This need not be happening.... they themselves have made their own bed and find it to harsh.
Howard
Dear Howard I am still amused how some people defy logic and history.
Advice for you, go to library and start reading history of Palestine and Israel.
I bet you will find that Israelis where the fist to implement terrorism as avenue to steal the land from legal owners. Irgun Tzva'i Leum, Haganah, Lehi (Stern Gang) and other Zionist terrorist groups conducted brutal bombings against Arab civilians and British, Damascus gate, Haifa, Jaffa Gate, King David Hotel, al-Dawayima, Kafr Kassem, Deir Yassin, Qibya, Safsaf, Rafah Refugee Camp, Lebanon, etc etc the list runs in countless thousands Arabs civilians killed, For your information Stern Gang started as common criminal group of bank robbers and merderers. Progresed to terrorists then to political party they even ofered to take part in the war on Nazis side in return for German support to establish Jewish state. First question for you how do you call a organisation who blow hotels, restaurants, apartment buildings, threw grenades into a crowd of civilians, assassinated UN diplomats, peacekeepers, red cross, journalist and even blowing up ships in far away country’s. I call them terrorist. You must be calling them settlers. Second question how do you call a government originating mostly from ex terrorist, I call them terrorists heaven. You must be calling them democratic. Third question how do you will call invasion by terrorist of your land owned by your family not for centuries but for millenniums, throwing you out of your house, confiscating your land, killing your friends, parents, wife and children, occupying your country for over 60 years. I call it annihilation by criminal horde . You must be calling it wrath of Israel. Fourth question how do you call a government sancioned terrorism, torture, assasinations and genocide. I call it legitimate actions by gang of usurpers on the loose. You must be calling it responsibility of governbment to protect and defend. Fifth question do you belive in uberrimae fidei. I do not. I believe in freedom, fairness and pace but I despise the current earth biggest blood sucking insect. You probably are one of the Zionist devil worshippers with “Book of Fairytales for the dispossessed” in one hand and “Hollywood's History Book” in other.
Regards Moshe
My understanding of the Gaza Strip is that it is the size of Belconnen. Where *can* they possibly make a stand *but* in civilian areas? It's *all* civilian area.
http://www.users.bigpond.com/pmurray
http://www.paulmurray.id.au/ageofworms
So this is Israel's 'final solution' for the Palestinians. How far this terrorist State come all these years ... in flagrant violation of every imaginable International Law, in complete violation of any standards of ethics or morality ... they continue inexorably towards what can only be assumed is their version of the Final Solution.
There is no targeted killing by Israel. That was evident in their murder of Lebanese civilians in 2006. What we are seeing is pure genocide. Nothing more and nothing less....Paid for by the US taxpayer.
To stop the madness join the effort to confront any and every Jew any and everywhere with truth and this logic !!
Forget about antisemitism and the Hollywood Holocaust code of silence !!!!
See this link below -- incredible Auschwitz Revelations by a brave Jew.
http://hidhist.wordpress.com/holocaust/david-cole-incredible-auschwitz-revelations/
Jews consists of 0.02% of the World's population.
Islam consists of 23% of the World's population.
How do Jews or ANYONE think that 0.02% of the World's population killing 23% of the World's population at will is acceptable ?
There are only 14 Million Jews in the World and yet they are causing so much misery ---- WHY ??
Jews via their "Poster Child" Israel are pushing a "PERPETUAL" war--on Islam by the USA for the benefit of Israel !!
"Shock and Awe" the neocon US Pentagon response in Iraq = neocon Israel the "other" Super Power's response in Gaza!!!
It was the same in 2006 when Israel was given a clear hand to destroy Lebanon with cluster bombs & Depleted Uranium !!!
Gaza is a place where people are reduced to eating grass to survive and an unfinished part of the larger Jewish/Israeli Agenda !!!
Israel with 250 NUKES the 4th strongest Military in the World created by the USA is just "completely" out of control!!
Israeli agenda seems to include-- 1.US extended stay in Iraq 2. Attack on Iran ASAP. 3.Possible attack on Pakistan. 4."Transfer" all remaining Palestinian people out of Palestine. 5. REVENGE on the World and Israel's rightful acceptance as a World Superpower.!!
Some 65 UN resolutions condemning Israeli actions against Palestinians have been defied by Tel Aviv & the US.
The Geneva Convention -- broken all the time -- Israel/American regimes could care less -------!!!!!
Americans are fed their Israeli/American P.R. from CNN & Fox TV like with the Iraq WMD's and Zionist propaganda to invade Iraq.
Israel is/was out of control for years and years and has "raped and killed and pillaged"ever since its creation in 1948!!
Israel with 250 NUKES the 4th strongest Military in the World created by the USA is out of control in the middle of a sea of Islam.
http://wake-up-america.net/
Are Americans STILL that dumb that they can still wonder ---- "Why do they hate us" ??
Jews must awake ASAP to knowing that Zionism is the real enemy of the Jews !!!
http://zionism-realenemyofthejews.com/
Does any sane person doubt that the only clear beneficiary of the AMERICAN war agenda is Israel.
http://www.twnside.org.sg/title/2411.htm
G.W.Bush calls it a Crusade. A Judeo/Christion Crusade against 23% of the World's population who "adhere" to Islam.
http://petras.lahaine.org
http://www.apfn.org/apfn/WTC_STF.htm
HELP WANTED PLEASE -- the World may be counting on you ---- yes you !!!!!!