Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Chilean Girls Stage 'Occupation' of Their Own School in Education Rights Protest
For five months, girls demanding free university education for all have defied police to occupy their state school
Sleeping on a tiled classroom floor, sharing cigarettes and always on the lookout for police raids, the students of Carmela Carvajal primary and secondary school are living a revolution.
Chilean demonstrators are hit by a jet of water during a rally against the public state education system in Santiago. Photo/Ivan Aldarado/Reuters It began early one morning in May, when dozens of teenage girls emerged from the predawn darkness and scaled the spiked iron fence around Chile's most prestigious girl's school. They used classroom chairs to barricade themselves inside and settled in. Five months later, the occupation shows no signs of dying and the students are still fighting for their goal: free university education for all.
A tour of the school is a trip into the wired reality of a generation that boasts the communication tools that feisty young rebels of history never dreamed of. When police forces move closer, the students use restricted Facebook chat sessions to mobilize. Within minutes, they are able to rally support groups from other public schools in the neighborhood. "Our lawyer lives over there," said Angelica Alvarez, 14, as she pointed to a cluster of nearby homes. "If we yell 'Mauricio' really loud, he leaves his home and comes over."
For five months, the students at Carmela Carvajal have lived on the ground floor, sometimes sleeping in the gym, but usually in the abandoned classrooms where they hauled in a television, set up a private changing room, and began to experience school from a different perspective.
The first thing they did after taking over the school was to hold a vote. Approximately half of the 1,800 students participated in the polls to approve the takeover, and the yays outnumbered the nays 10 to one.
Now the students pass their school days listening to guest lecturers who provide free classes on topics ranging from economics to astronomy. Extracurricular classes include yoga and salsa lessons. At night and on weekends, visiting rock bands set up their equipment and charge 1,000 pesos (£1.25) per person to hear a live jam on the basketball court. Neighbors donate fresh baked cakes and, under a quirk of Chilean law, the government is obliged to feed students who are at school – even students who have shut down education as usual.
So much food has poured in that the students from Carmela Carvajal now regularly pass on their donations to hungry students at other occupied schools.
Municipal authorities have repeatedly attempted to retake the school, sending in police to evict the rebel students and get classes back on schedule, but so far the youngsters have held their ground.
"It was the most beautiful moment, all of us in [school] uniform climbing over the fence, taking back control of our school. It was such an emotional moment, we all wanted to cry," Alvarez said. "There have been 10 times that the police have taken back the school and every time we come and take it back again."
The students have built a hyper-organized, if somewhat legalistic, world, with votes on everything including daily duties, housekeeping schedules and the election of a president and spokeswoman. The school rules now include several new decrees: no sex, no boys and no booze. That last clause has been a bit abused, the students admit.
"We have had a few cases of classmates who tried to bring in alcohol, but we caught them and they were punished," said Alvarez, who was stationed at the school entrance questioning visitors. Alvarez, who has lived at the school for about four months, laughed as she described the punishment. "They had to clean the bathrooms," she said.
Carmela Carvajal is among Chile's most successful state schools. Nearly all the graduates are assured of a place in top Chilean universities, and the school is a magnet, drawing in some of the brightest minds from across Santiago, the nation's capital and a metropolis of six million.
But the story playing out in its classrooms is just a small part of a national student uprising that has seized control of the political agenda, wrong-footed conservative president Sebastián Piñera, and called into question the free-market orthodoxy that has dominated Chilean politics since the Pinochet era.
The students are demanding a return to the 1960s, when public university education was free. Current tuition fees average nearly three times the minimum annual wage, and with interest rates on student loans at 7%, the students have made financial reform the centerpiece of their uprising.
At the heart of the students' agenda is the demand that education be recognized as a common right for all, not a "consumer good" to be sold on the open market.
Currently, many Chilean schools are for-profit institutions, run as businesses. Until recently, the classified section of the leading newspaper, el Mercurio, regularly featured schools for sale, in adverts that often described the institutions as highly profitable investments.
The Chilean uprising has changed that. Now owners of public schools have begun posting employment ads in local newspapers for security guards to fend off attempts by students to seize the schools. One advert offered employment to able-bodied men who could use dogs to repel potential student takeovers. ("No experience necessary," it read.)
Politicians and many parents fret that the cancellation of classes has turned 2011 into "a lost year" for public education, but for many of the students the past five months has been the most intensive education of their life.
"I have become a lot more mature. I used to judge my classmates by their looks. Now I understand them and together we stand up for what we believe," said Camila Gutierrez, 15, a freshman at Carmela Carvajal. "It has been exhausting, but if you want something in life, you have to fight for it."
The first murmurings of the "Chilean Winter" came in in late May with the first takeover of a public school. Five months later, around 200 state elementary and high schools as well as a dozen universities have now been occupied by students. Weekly protest marches gather between 50,000-100,000 students throughout the nation, with especially large turnouts in coastal cities of Valparaiso and Concepcion. Charismatic student leader Camila Vallejo - known as Comandante Camila - has become a cult hero across Latin America. Initially, the protestors's demands for free universal education was flatly rejected by the conservative administration of president Sebastian Pinera, but the government is now moving incrementally towards meeting their demands.
Talks between the ruling conservative government and striking students collapsed on Wednesday evening with irate students accusing the government of failing to provide new proposals. But Government officials responded that the students would be welcomed back to negotiate.
On Thursday when thousands of students gathered for a protest march in downtown Santiago, Government officials refused to authorize a march route that included a central thoroughfare and defiant students used social media to send out a singular message – the march is on. For much of Thursday, downtown Santiago was awash in tear gas and rioting youth. Smashed cars, 137 arrests and mutual accusations that the violence was avoidable further highlighted the gulf between student leaders and the Pinera government.
With imaginative protests including a kiss-a-thon in which 3,000 couples groped and smooched for exactly fifteen minutes, the Chilean student movement has captured the imagination of a long dormant but apparently disenchanted Chilean public. The unified front of students also counts on support from an estimated 6 of 10 adults in Chile, far higher than the nation's political coalitions or President Sebastian Pinera whose recent approval ratings has ranged from 22% to 30%. However the frequent violence which accompanies the street marches has outraged many Chileans who see their cherished stability now on the edge of social chaos.

13 Comments so far
Show AllCamila, one of the Chilean students (in Spanish):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1KYWcYK38k&feature=related
ezeflyer,
Thanks for the brief YouTube link of Camila Vallejo.
YouTube URL: www.youtube.com/watch?v=l1KYWcYK38k&feature=related
Camila Vallejo es la Presidenta de la Federación de Estudiantes de la Universidad de Chile (FECh) y un miembro de Juventudes Comunistas de Chile.
- -
"Camilla Vallejo", Wikipedia (in English).
Article URL: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camila_Vallejo
Globally, the people appear to be center-left while their corrupt, dysfunctional and unrepresentative politics remain center-right. Hence, we are seeing a clash of enormous proportions.
"Globally, the people appear to be center-left while their corrupt, dysfunctional and unrepresentative politics remain center-right."
Who needs unrepresentative representatives in the Internet age?
Direct democracy. No politicians!
.
ezeflyer (in reply to freefallen) wrote:
"Globally, the people appear to be center-left while their corrupt, dysfunctional and unrepresentative politics remain center-right."
Who needs unrepresentative representatives in the Internet age?
Direct democracy. No politicians!
- - - - -
Excerpt from Chilean Girls Stage Occupation Of Their Own School In Education Rights Protest:
"We have had a few cases of classmates who tried to bring in alcohol, but we caught them and they were punished," said Alvarez, who was stationed at the school entrance questioning visitors. Alvarez, who has lived at the school for about four months, laughed as she described the punishment. "They had to clean the bathrooms," she said.
* * * * *
My Reply:
ezeflyer,
Slow down there, eze.
Even in this small community of students who are occupying their school, they decided to elect a president and a spokeswoman.
You mentioned Camila Vallejo. Camila Vallejo is a leader and a politician, a young and charismatic leader and politician, who may never have intended on becoming a leader or a politician, but she is a leader and politician all the same. Camila Vallejo is president of FECh and a member of Chilean Communist Youth.
No unrepresentative representatives!
Power to the people!
Including more direct democracy and better representative democracy!
"Including more direct democracy and better representative democracy!"
That only works when you have leaders, politicians that won't sell out or be threatened into submission by the money-power. That has seldom been the case.
http://ni4d.us/
ezeflyer (quoting PuffinThrush in reply to PuffinThrush) wrote:
."Including more direct democracy and better representative democracy!"
That only works when you have leaders, politicians that won't sell out or be threatened into submission by the money-power. That has seldom been the case.
* * * * *
My Reply:
ezeflyer,
No, that only works when you have people who know what to do, who are willing to join the struggle to establish genuine democracy.
We need to replace Plurality Voting with Category Scale Power Voting in single- member district elections, which include gubernatorial and presidential elections; and we need to overturn both the Buckley v. Valeo and the Citizens United v. FEC Supreme Court decisions through legislation that will also democratize political parties.
I think that you expect more from direct democracy than direct democracy can deliver.
freefallen wrote:
Globally, the people appear to be center-left while their corrupt, dysfunctional and unrepresentative politics remain center-right. Hence, we are seeing a clash of enormous proportions.
* * * * *
My Reply:
It's amazing and wonderful that people are fighting back around the world.
At the time of the Chilean election that put Pinera in office, relatively few young people had bothered to register to vote. Chilean law says that it is illegal not to vote, but this only applies to those who are registered. Many young people were not interested in the election, largely because the previous president, Michelle Bachilet, did not appeal to them. She was a very moderate Social Democrat who had been friendly toward business, was careful not to challenge the United States on an international level, and in fact was gradually installing neo-liberal "reforms," like a "free trade" treaty with the US. Pinera coasted in because the people who might have voted for a Social Democrat to succeed Bachilet saw no reason to get involved.
It seems likely that many of those young people will be registering to vote next time.
Hi Peter Lackowski,
Thanks for the comments, blog post, and article.
Please use fewer html break tags, so that it is easier to read you comments. Two html break tags at the end of a paragraph are enough to insert a "single carriage return and line feed" to use the old typewriter terminology, when posting comments like this that do not insert the "carriage return and line feed" automatically..
Like this < br >< br > except without the spaces.
I guess I missed the recent article you mentioned that Common Dreams published on Honduras.
In any case, thanks again.
It should be noted that a very similar process is being played out in Honduras. President Porfirio "Pepe" Lobo, who has been lavishly praised by Obama during his visit this week to Washington, is also pushing a scheme to privatize education in Honduras, with charter schools, attacks on the teachers' union, etc. The Honduran Resistance has been defending the right to free education, and there have been hunger strikes, school occupations, strikes by students and teachers, and marches, often brutally repressed.This has been completely blacked out of the US media, of course. Sadly, it has been ignored by Common Dreams as well, as has the whole resistance movement that came into being after President Zelaya was deposed by a Military coup d'etat in June of 2009.Bizarrely, Common Dreams ran a story recently about a squabble among the ruling class of Honduras, in which some of the very people who have been participating in the post coup system are now complaining about the military having too much power. Meanwhile, the real story of the non-violent resistance movement enduring massacres of peasants, murders of activists, and repression of any dissent never shows up in Common Dreams. Why not?
This is delightful. As to the youth who are currently protesting, 15?, to ?? college age?? How young can they be to vote in Chile?
And a word to the US on that privatized education crap...but then the kids will do what they do so well.
Thank you young people all over the world. You are our hope.
From quotha.net, a blog by Adrienne Pine--excellent source on HondurasPepe & Barry-O's love-fest vs. today's bloody reality
Lanny Davis's propaganda machine is in full swing today, with Lobo's visit to DC. Having ghostwritten him a piece in the Wall Street Journal ("The Threats to Latin American Democracy: Authoritarianism, international terrorism and the drug trade retard regional progress"), Lobo's PR agents also saw to it that largely uncritical—even glowing—articles would be published in other corporate media, like Bloomberg ("Obama Lauds Progress of Honduras on Democratic Governance") and Reuters ("Obama hails return of Honduras to democratic fold"). The absurdist propaganda that these and other pieces from today represent would be comical, if it weren't for the ongoing slaughter they mask in the Aguán. The following is my translation of an article by journalist Giorgio Trucchi, also from today:
Honduras
More bloodshed in the Bajo Aguán
Five deadly attacks against campesino organizations in less than a week.By Giorgio Trucchi - LINyMAt 10:30 in the morning this Wednesday (10/5), two leaders of the La Aurora settlement, members of the Unified Campesino Movement of the Aguán (MUCA), Pedro Alfredo Matamoros Bonilla and Heder Jael Sánchez Cruz, were shot by unknown parties at the San Isidro, Sinaloa farm in the Bajo Aguán.According to a preliminary analysis of the actions, the shots fired at the two leaders of MUCA, who are currently hospitalized in serious condition, came from the African Palm plantations of the San Isidro farm, property of landholder and palm producer Miguel Facussé Barjum.
The news arrived just as, in Tegucigalpa, the United Nations special envoy for freedom of expression, Frank La Rue, spoke of the constant violation of freedom of expression and of impunity in Honduras, in a forum organized by national and international human rights organizations.
"It is unfortunate that this is happening in the Aguán, at this very moment while we are carrying out an activity that has so much to do with freedom of expression, respect for human rights and for life," said Jonny Rivas, leader of MUCA.
Rivas explained that Pedro Alfredo Matamoros Bonilla was shot with three bullets, one of which entered his mouth and exited through his ear. Heder Jael Sánchez Cruz was shot twice in the groin. "They were driving by the San Isidro farm, which is under permanent vigilance by Miguel Facussé's security guards, who shot from there at the vehicle. There is no doubt which side of the highway they were attacked from; it was from the plantation. Pedro Matamoros is gravely wounded and his life is in danger," Rivas stated.
For the leadership of MUCA the Xatruch II operation promoted by the Porfirio Lobo regime is not only not resolving the dire agrarian conflict in the Aguán Valley region; it is worsening it. In less than a week there have been three attacks against organized campesinos that have left a total of two people murdered (Carlos Humberto Martínez and Enelda Fiallos) and three severely wounded (Germán Castro, Pedro Alfredo Matamoros Bonilla and Heder Jael Sánchez Cruz), an attempted kidnapping (Marco Antonio Paredes) and a violent eviction (on "La Consentida" farm).
"We have always maintained that militarization is not the solution, because it only adds to the problem of the paramilitary groups already operating in the region in the service of large landholders. The result is a series of attacks against organized campesinos. They want to destroy the stability and development of campesino organizations," Rivas concluded