EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Watchdogs: Government Overpaid for Wall Street Assets
WASHINGTON - The federal government overpaid by about $78 billion for stock and other troubled assets when it bailed out big banks last year, and it lacks sufficient internal controls to police and protect taxpayers' investment in the institutions, government watchdogs said Thursday.
The federal government overpaid by about $78 billion for stock and other troubled assets when it bailed out big banks last year, and it lacks sufficient internal controls to police and protect taxpayers' investment in the institutions, government watchdogs said Thursday. The new special inspector general for the bailout effort, formally called the Troubled Asset Relief Program, issued his first report Thursday and said that the Treasury Department needs to put more safeguards in place to protect taxpayers.
Neil Barofsky said that the Treasury Department, under the Bush administration, focused on purchasing assets from troubled banks and failed to put a plan in place for managing more than $279 billion in preferred stock that was acquired during the bailouts.
Now he's asking 319 financial institutions for detailed accountings of how $300 billion in taxpayers' bailout money has been spent. He said his office also would examine whether any bank had misrepresented the value of securities exchanged for the cash.
"If any entity lied to get our money, we will investigate that. We will find it out and we will . . . make sure those people are brought to justice,'' Barofsky told McClatchy in a telephone interview. "It is a fundamental part of our mission to root out those types of fraud."
The inspector general's office is working with the FBI and other federal law-enforcement agencies, he said. It's hired veteran prosecutors and investigators with a broad range of experience, including securities law. Using about a half-dozen investigators detailed from the FBI and IRS, Barofsky said, his office is conducting several criminal investigations related to the relief program. He declined to discuss details.
The relief program is sure to be a hot topic in Washington on Friday morning, when Elizabeth Warren, the chairman of the program's congressional oversight panel, releases a report on the overpayment of $78 billion for bank stocks and other assets.
Testifying before the Senate Banking Committee on Thursday, she said that the Treasury paid $254 billion when it purchased stocks and other bank assets last year. It received assets worth only about $176 billion, however. Her numbers are close but don't correspond exactly with the inspector general's.
"Because Treasury has failed to delineate a clear reason for such an overpayment, however, the panel is unable to determine whether these objectives have been met or whether they justified the large subsidy that was created," Warren said in prepared remarks. "Once again, Treasury needs clear goals, methods and measurements."
Warren challenged Bush administration assurances that all purchases of Wall Street bank warrants and stocks were at "par," meaning that for every $100 injected into the banks, taxpayers got securities worth $100.
A valuation study of 10 transactions - part of the oversight panel's report due to Congress on Friday - suggests that the government overpaid by $78 billion, she told lawmakers.
While Warren looked backward, Barofsky looked forward and said that much greater internal controls were needed.
"Treasury needs, in the near term, to begin developing a more complete strategy on what to do with the very substantial portfolio that it now manages on behalf of the American people," his report says. "In particular, Treasury needs to develop effective valuation methodologies to value the preferred shares and warrants that it holds and an overall investment strategy to manage the equity portfolio it holds."
The Treasury, according to the report, has invested almost $300 billion in 319 financial institutions and received $279.2 billion worth of preferred shares in these lenders. It's received common stock from 230 institutions.
Yet there's no asset manager who's overseeing these shares, and no strategy in place for government stewardship.
"How long these securities should be held and when, and under what circumstances, they should be sold into the market are vitally important questions that implicate not only the taxpayers' return on investment but also the stability of the markets," the report says.
In the interview, Barofsky said that months had passed since the relief program had been established and that a management strategy was sorely needed.
"It would be unfair for us to say on Nov. 10, you have (to have) a full asset-management plan in place. That time is now, or in the very near term," he said.
Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner already has announced new executive compensation restrictions and other measures designed to improve transparency in the program. He's expected to outline his plans for new finance-sector rescue efforts Monday.
Barofsky's report also says that insufficient safeguards are in place for a $600 billion program that the Federal Reserve is about to unveil. The Fed and Treasury Department are set this month to start buying top-rated asset-backed securities. These are pools of car loans, student loans and credit card debt that are bundled together and sold to investors in a secondary market.
Private investors won't touch these securities, so the Fed is stepping in to unfreeze this vital credit market. However, the Fed is relying too much on rating agencies and investor due diligence to evaluate the health of these assets, Barofsky warned, and needs better risk-screening procedures to protect taxpayer investments.
A Fed spokesman said efforts were under way to create "a robust compliance program" and that the central bank would "carefully consider" Barofsky's recommendations. The spokesman spoke on condition of anonymity because the Fed's response plan hasn't been completed.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...

8 Comments so far
Show AllPlunder, Thunder, Blunder and soon America is torn Asunder!
A question for you all: How do you overpay for something using an irredeemable fiat currency?
Walk in peace.
Noone knows what these bundled mortgages are worth, noone wanted our govt to buy them either. I had thought that our Treasury was investing in banks and financial institutions not using this worthless paper as collateral.
It is not profitable to continue to rail against every instance of welfare for the rich without understanding that we need to dramatically alter our system of governance. We the people have lost this government to we the board of directors.
All the eloquence of President Obama, all his futile attempts to govern in a bipartisan fashion, every cent of continued spending to prop up what are basically rotten and greedy men taking huge profits personally while the companies they lead flounder and wither are wasted and contribute to the coming disaster.
"Most people would sooner die than think, in fact they do so. Bertrand Russell
Right On Red Rick - the system has been corrupted so thoroughly that only a major deconstruction of its parts will save it. Capitalism has reached its historical malignant stage, it is eating itself up, profit surpassing humanity - as always. Hopefully such a calamity can be resolved peacefully - if not - I suspect the 20,000 3rd Infantry Division forces now employed in the US (first time since Civil War) will simply harrass, incarcerate or kill the people when the revolution starts. KBR has already built the prisons. Blackwater is set to go. The community thugs have been briefed by Bush's Homeland Security boys - and it may all come to pass. Thomas Jefferson predicted this would happen when the people relinquished control to the few. Sadly, sadly, he seems to have been correct.
One modification, Red............."We the People have lost the government to 'THEM'...the board of directors". We the People were never meant to sit around the table...only to serve the coffee.
I have a greater respect for the INTENT of our founders than do you, apparently. We can, certainly, continue to work together towards common goals. I would further note that this sort of opinion you offer leads only to further alienation and estrangement from the process at a time when we need more engagement from the people, not less.
"Most people would sooner die than think, in fact they do so. Bertrand Russell
Oh, gee, the Repubs looted the treasury on the way out for the benefit of rich people. This is news? one old atheist
"Because Treasury has failed to delineate a clear reason for such an overpayment, however, the panel is unable to determine whether these objectives have been met or whether they justified the large subsidy that was created," Warren said in prepared remarks. "Once again, Treasury needs clear goals, methods and measurements."
The clear reason for such an overpayment is personal wealth. The clear goals, methods and measurments are personal wealth, theft/obfuscation and ALL OF THE MONEY. That the panel was unable to determine whether objectives have been met means the objectives have been met. Again, they got away with it.
While it may be tempting to think of these billionaire elites as competent by virtue of their wealth, it is important to consider that any fool could be financially independent given the opportunity to create favorable legislation, hide the accounting, print money and dip into the treasury at will.
It is time to prepare for the impending total collapse of the economy that these morons continue to nurture and do not understand. The dollar will be useless, fuel unobtainable, allies unheard of, grocery stores empty, working people will no longer be able to depend upon the too big to operate conglomerates to keep the food chain going and employees of those companies will face a whole new way of life. Work as we know it will not be available, jobs will stem from local supply and demand.
This will require planning and community involvement if life is to be even somewhat comfortable and will take time. But of course our so called leaders are going to continue accumulating wealth until it is too late to prepare.
As the dollar (which is no longer the sole accepted currency in oil trade) becomes less valuable, it will not be accepted by OPEC. Oil will become so scarce that only the elite will have access to it. Small to midsized companies will fail and be consumed by the few remaining larger ones. Unemployment will be at monumental levels to the point that people will be farming, stealing, hunting and begging just to survive. Transportation will come to a halt forcing even stable families to pursue alternate means of feeding themselves.
We don't have to wait for the government to tell us there is a problem although it appears that more than 50% of us prefer to do just that. Individuals can make arrangements beginning now. Structures could be in place to produce and distribute food on a local level. We could refocus our life's energy on something more humane than the pursuit of money. What are we waiting for?
It is not if but when. Be prepared. Your leaders suck.