Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Cuba is Missing... From US Reports on the International Response to Haiti’s Earthquake
There are only two US media outlets that have reported on Cuba’s response to the deadly 7.0 earthquake that hit Haiti. One was Fox News, which claimed, wrongly, that the Cubans were absent from the list of neighboring Caribbean countries providing aid. The other was the Christian Science Monitor (a respected news organization that recently shut down its print edition), which reported correctly that Cuba had dispatched 30 doctors to the stricken nation.
The Christian Science Monitor, in a second article, quoted Laurence Korb, former assistant secretary of defense and now based at the Center for American Progress, as saying that the US, which is leading the relief efforts in Haiti, should “consider tapping the expertise of neighboring Cuba,” which he noted, “has some of the best doctors in the world--we should see about flying them in.”
As for the rest of the US media, they have simply ignored Cuba's role and actions.
In fact, left unmentioned is the reality that Cuba already had over 400 doctors posted to Haiti to help with the day-to-day health needs of this poorest nation in the Americas, and that those doctors were the first to respond to the disaster, setting up a hospital right next to the main hospital in Port-au-Prince which collapsed in the earthquake.
Far from “doing nothing” about the disaster as the right-wing propagandists at Fox-TV were claiming, Cuba has been one of the most effective and critical responders to the crisis, because it had set up a medical infrastructure before the quake, which was able to mobilize quickly and start treating the victims.
The American emergency response, predictably, has focussed primarily, at least in terms of personnel and money, on sending the hugely costly and inefficient US military--a fleet of aircraft and an aircraft carrier--a factor that should be considered when examining that $100 million figure the Obama administration claims is being allocated to emergency aid to Haiti. Considering that the cost of operating an aircraft carrier, including crew, is roughly $2 million a day, just sending a carrier to Port-au-Prince for two weeks accounts for a quarter of the announced American aid effort, and while many of the military personnel sent there will certainly be doing actual aid work, delivering supplies and guarding supplies, many, given America’s long history of brutal military/colonial control of Haiti, will inevitably be spending their time ensuring continued survival and control of the parasitic pro-US political elite in Haiti.
Otherwise, the US has basically ignored the ongoing day-to-day human crisis in Haiti, while Cuba has been doing the yeoman work of providing basic health care.
But that’s not a story that the American corporate media want to tell.




66 Comments so far
Show AllThe older I get and the more I read about world history, the more I am ashamed of America.
Even a brief reading of the Spanish American War would tell the casual reader of the courage of the early Cuban revolutionaries in their attempts to rid themselves of Spanish Imperialism. Then, in a few weeks, TR and his elitest run up a hill and get all the credit for the victory, while the real victors, the Cubans, got no credit for decades of fighting - but, they did get a new imperialist. Just like in the Philipines, the local heroes get lied to and screwed by Americans and have to fight again for their independence.
I will never understand why Americans are so afraid of admitting that Cuba is a nation, though poor and struggling, that is successful without American help.
Haiti would have been better without any American help from the beginning, and the help that America provides now must be looked at as having an alterior motive. Already, American generals are calling for Haiti to be under American military rule.
Watch out Haiti - America is there to help.
"I will never understand why Americans are so afraid of admitting that Cuba is a nation, though poor and struggling, that is successful without American help."
Because Cuba refuses to submit to U.S. corporate domination. Acknowledging Cuba's independence might encourage other nations to be less submissive.
Right on target. Socialism is not evil.
"I will never understand why Americans are so afraid of admitting that Cuba is a nation, though poor and struggling, that is successful without American help."
Actually, you answered your own question.
Notice how all of the mainstream media reports talk of "The American led relief effort?" Hey, we lead in everything...we're number one!!! Such bullshit.
"I will never understand why Americans are so afraid of admitting that Cuba is a nation, though poor and struggling, that is successful without American help."
That's because Cuba is a socialist country and socialist countries are always governed by fat-headed cannibal types who eat their young while oppressing their elderly population not tender enough to be devoured. This invariably leads to a constantly declining Gross Domestic Product and economic ruin. There has never been a success story in a socialist country. You really should pay more attention to your tv news.
It's a big game of cat and mouse between the US and Cuba. A symbiotic relationship. They both need each other in order to continue with the charade. The stand-off helps both. Imagine if the US went in and bombed Cuba to smithereens? Or if Cuba turned around and became Capitalis? Oh, my! Who they would then demonize? How could that be beneficial to either side? And make no mistake, the Castros benefit as much from it as the US does. Everything that happens in Cuba is the US's fault (real or imagined). Much like the US needs Al Qaeda, Cuba needs the Yankees. Absent one, the other goes to pieces.
Given the text, the first three words of this heading certainly should not be 'Cuba is Missing...' even if it does refer to what the US media is claiming.
-"There are only two US media outlets that have reported on Cuba’s response to the deadly 7.0 earthquake that hit Haiti. One was Fox News, which claimed, wrongly, that the Cubans were absent ..."
Yes this is why South and Central America and the rest of us in the world are coming to see that the arrival of Obama a year ago will not improve relations between the world and America. No matter what overtures we make to the Americans, the people there are not even aware of it, so Obama, or whoever is in charge in the US, is free to continue with warfare as usual.
Otherwise put, peace and democracy requires an informed public. So while the Americans build their new army bases in Columbia and support the coup in Honduras, the rest of us will have to work closer and closer together.
Cuba's involvement was of course reported by Democracy Now yesterday. On that program it was reported that Cuba had already established 2 field hospitals while we were doing the George Bush, now Obama thing, flying over to survey the situation. The program also reported, though I've not read or heard anything in the western corporate media, that China had been the first country to land a plane with relief supplies. I do know that only us the Western saviours can be heros in any disaster after all we've figured out how to text message a dollar or 2 with no fuss to the place.
re China: I heard the same on Caribbean TV which added that they had three sniffer dogs already on the job. No mention of that on any mainstream US news...
Off on a tangent, does anyone here know that China sent $5 million in aid to Katrina victims 9 days after the hurricane hit New Orleans...? Just thought I'd mention it...
"may you live in interesting times"
Or that Cuba offered to send to New Orleans hundreds of aid personnel including badly needed doctors, and people trained in flood rescue--an offer that the Bush administration flatly refused, even as people in N.O. were dying for lack of rescue equipment and personnel.
See: http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=896
Visit Dave Lindorff's website at www.thiscantbehappening.net
I felt sick when I heard the US military was being sent to Haiti to help with aid and "peace keeping." We all know what that means.
China is supposed to be sending 1000 anti-riot police. We know what that means, too.
Not to worry - they don't have oil. Just cheap labor. Which will probably be even cheaper after this.
Despite unending US efforts to the contrary, the Cuban people have better health care than we do in the United States.
Bless the Cuban doctors for their solidarity with the Haitian people, not only now, while the world is watching, but always.
Wait a minute. Does the U.S. aid figure include the money spent on the propaganda campaign to tell the American people what a great humanitarian effort the U.S. is providing to Haiti?
That number should greatly inflate the overall expenditure figures.
We seem to be sending more soldiers than water and food.
Well the earthquake did not kill the "right" type of people so the US marines will make up for it.
100 million is a drop in the bucket.
My small city just completed building its municipal jail for 78 million.
"...the reality that Cuba already had over 400 doctors posted to Haiti.."
This is wrong, so please do not perpetuate this lie - it makes Progressives look stupid.
The reality is that Cuba had over 400 "emergency workers" in Haiti before the first US C130 landed, as I reported yesterday in another thread.
These workers are doctors, EMTs, crisis workers and S&R dog teams. They are NOT all doctors.
I think that the article was referring to the Cuban doctors that Cuba routinely sends to many poor nations under it's "barrio adentro"-like programs - well before the earthquake.
Judging from the following, Lindorff is largely but not exactly accurate.
"In that context, he clarified that there are currently "403 Cuban cooperative personnel, 334 of whom are working in the heath sector as doctors and paramedics," in the devastated country."
SOURCE
http://www.granma.cu/ingles/2010/enero/juev14/Cuba-Haiti.html
It's with omissions like this that the US establishment builds the prejudices they want the American people to have -- consistently presenting just our side of the truth.
"Otherwise, the US has basically ignored the ongoing day-to-day human crisis in Haiti, while Cuba has been doing the yeoman work of providing basic health care."
"But that’s not a story that the American corporate media want to tell."
So, who owns American corporate media?
What other news do they keep under their shirt?
Americans must gather information from a variety of sources or we will be lead down the garden path again and again.
ABC, NBC, CBS, FOX, MSNBC, all lie!!
Thank God for Common Dreams!
I watch mainstream news strictly for entertainment purposes. I really don't know how much different it would be if it was state run like the old USSR. A very narrow view of the world, with certain talking points repeated over and over, and things that don't fit those points are left out. (Cuba for example)
I get my real news from the internet. More views from my perspective, not the perspective of the rich and powerful.
One more thing. Cuba also offered many doctors when Katrina hit the US, but their offer was denied by the Bush administration. After all we can't have Cubans helping Americans, that wouldn't support the illusion of the all powerful US Empire...
I agree 100% Chuck. Watch MSM for entertainment purposes only.
Democracynow.org by far had the best coverage yesterday on Haiti. Not only did they give us news of the current situation but gave an excellent lesson on Haiti's history of being exploited which along with earthquake was the reason the tragedy has been so tremendous.
Other good places for real news (all on the internet), in my opinion, are counterpunch.org, blackagendareport, presstv, truthdig, the independent, voxunion and znet (zmag). As well as commondreams of course.
Thanks for this list!
I'm increasingly disgusted with MSM assumptions, especially now about Haiti.
Hey, don't forget
ThisCantBeHappening.net
Dave
Visit Dave Lindorff's website at www.thiscantbehappening.net
Thanks, Dave.
I just signed up for your newsletter.
"So, who owns American corporate media?"
The same ones who own Wall Street and Washigton DC and the MIC: our only ally in the ME, the Bersteins, Shapiros, Greenbergs, Madoffs, Harmans, Geithners, Greenspans, Emmanuels, Kissingers, you know? The usual suspects cross-referenced with the AIPAC gang.
Oblabla's first blabla on Haiti was that "With just a few hundred miles of ocean between us, Haitians are our neighbors in the Americas and here at home" ... as though Cuba wasn't even THERE. Haiti's ALREADY Obama's Katrina.
Maybe that's because of the US base at Gitmo -- from where you'd think "the US" could have air-dropped, at least, water. That CNN got there days before "the US" speaks volumes.
--> Aristide, Haiti's exiled ex-president, offers to return and help rebuild
http://www.latimes.com/news/nation-and-world/la-fg-haiti-aristide16-2010jan16,0,6151310.story
Oblabla's? ROFL! How befitting! Till now, I thought Obomber was the best. I like Oblabla better! Thanks for that gem.
I am glad to see that my fellows here have reported Democracy Now's excellent coverage of the crisis and distinct mention of Cuba's positive involvement.
While Lindorff is "correct in spirit" or something of the sort, Democracy Now is likely the single first place he should have gone to have vetted or verified such a statement.
Had he simply qualified the statement by a "virtually" or "almost," the exception of Democracy Now, a program clearly apart from the overwhelming mass of commercial disinformation, would raise no objection.
One cannot check every single media outlet in 48 hours or so, but by that very token, one should realize that one has not done so.
There is a fairly important something to be gained from such cautions: it's veracity.
Really man, you are a piece of work. I'm talking here about the establishment media. Most readers seem to get that. And I'm writing about something that nobody is mentioning, which is the blatant blackout by that media of Cuba doing something good. What is the matter with you dude?
Democracy Now is a great program. I watch it daily. But it's not mainstream media, sadly. And it's not corporate media, happily.
There is a difference, and a reason for that difference. It's why DN is different from NPR.
And for your information, it's not the only news media in the US that reported on the Cubans. So did Cuba News. So did People's World. But my point wasn't to talk about the alternative media. It was to chastise and expose the shabby behavior of the corporate mass media.
You need a new focus for your rants.
Visit Dave Lindorff's website at www.thiscantbehappening.net
I don't often cross-post, but I put this on another story and it seems apropos here
Hmmm, you don't see this in the mass media.
http://www.dominicantoday.com/dr/world/2010/1/14/34483/Cuba-sends-more-doctors-to-Haiti
------------------------------------------
Cuba sends more doctors to Haiti
Havana.– The first contingent of Cuban doctors specializing in assisting after natural disasters and serious epidemics headed for Haiti, following the massive earthquake that struck the empoverished Caribbean country on Tuesday.
The brigade was first established to offer help to the United States when Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans and the Gulf Coast in 2005, an offer rejected by ex-President George W. Bush.
Since then the brigade has been on the scene after earthquakes in Pakistan and China, the Tsunami in Indonesia and major flooding in Guatemala and Bolivia.
Cuba already had 344 doctors and other health professionals working full time in Haiti under an agreement with the Haitian government.
------------------------------------------
Cuba is already working on relief, while our scamsmen are trying to figure out how to make the most bucks and the government makes plans.
Just as in the Katrina aftermath, we will plan while the people die of thirst, hunger and disease. Eventually, we will arrive there with much fanfare, after most have died or are dying.
DIsaster workers know that there is about a three day survival window for those who are trapped. After that, finding anybody alive is more a miracle than anything else.
But, we won't send cargo drops in because there might be riots. We can't do much at the airport because it is clogged, so we'll posture and wait until the 10,000 troops and no doubt mercenaries are in position to invade and make sure nobody riots. By that time, the number able to riot will be severely curtailed.
Then, we'll trumpet how much we helped and what it cost us (rented aircraft carrier and troop transports, etc.) and how noble we are. I imagine the Haitians will be much like the poorer survivors of Katrina, living in camps for years, until forgotten.
My heart grieves for humanity as it goes through the same lessons time after time, learning nothing.
I raised the question of the Cuban presence and the news blackout at another thread yesterday.
Today I'm wondering why people in Haiti are barricading the streets with anything they can find, including bodies.
"The Marines are coming. The Marines are coming"???
As usual NPR is taking too much time with "human interest" stories.
As for listening to the MSM, I don't find them entertaining at all. I just want to find out what lies most Americans are being told.
-30-
.
Cuba today is an independant and honorable nation.
Free of the domination of Imperial powers like the U.S.A.
The Cuban Freedom and its generous people are a nobel example to the rest of the world.
I question why my country, the United States of America is so afraid of CUBA 2010 !!!!!!!!!!!!!
.
FWIW, I found mention of Cuba helping in several articles over the past couple days on the MSM including on Fox. (http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,583000,00.html - ). The article on Fox that states they are absent is really just a survey and relies on the official Cuban ministry of information web site and unanswered (justly) calls to the Cuban mission to the UN(?). At any rate, the story is worthless and contradicted in several places in other articles on Fox. Also on Fox is a short article on Cuba cooperating to open restricted airspace to US flights from Miami which cuts down the roundtrip time to Haiti by 3 hours.
One note is that as far as I can see Cuba's help has been primarily by the hundreds of teachers in has on the island and several field hospitals that had been set up prior to the earthquake.
I anticipate that they will give much more over the coming days and weeks as they always do in situations like this.
I don't love the MSM, but frankly they report, although don't highlight, a lot more than they are credited with here on CD.
Hmmm...I wonder if you'd be of the same opinion if you had lived there for 50 years. I only lived it for 21 and I know my opinion is very different than yours.
I was amazed by the lead on BBC World Radio this morning: "Haitians spent a third night sleeping out in the open"- THEY"RE COUNTING DAYS! For an ordeal which is likely to extend for MONTHS, YEARS and even the whole of their remaining LIVES!
And I think its only natural to wonder why there is hardly any damage at all in neighboring Santo Domingo- could it be because they actually use reinforcement and the proper amounts of cement in their concrete structures? And will "reconstruction" in Haiti follow the same direction as it has in Iraq- by means of private contractors who line their own pockets by doing shoddy work? Will the lives of poor residents be given the same consideration as those in New Orleans after Katrina? One should also inquire for what purpose the now estimated 10,000 marines will be used, especially with respect to the current government of Haiti which was fundamentally dis-functional, serving only the interests of an oppressive elite, before the disaster.
It's nice to be able to point to the despicable remarks by Rush Limbaud ( that no aid should be sent at all) or Pat Robertson ( The disaster was Divine retribution for the pack that Haitians made with the Devil)- THAT OH SO HELPFULLY DRAWS ATTENTION AWAY FROM THE OTHER SIDE OF THE COIN: the question whether our government- which is failing its own citizens on so many levels, has the moral and intellectual capacity to apply what aid it does provide appropriately i.e. with justice and equality!
It is no wonder that President Clinton, in his hopeful remarks about being able to help, was on the verge of tears the whole time. Was he simply "feeling the Haitian's pain", or fighting a sense of the incredible difficulty of the operation, real doubts about the willingness of Congress to make the long-term commitments and the truly humanitarian judgments necessary to make it work- and the catastrophe that is likely to develop while Americans immerse themselves in the pornography of human disaster, and then finally boil down their entire effort to a matter of 'security' and a "war on Terror"
While you make some good points. I should point out that there will be only 2200 marines on the ground. The rest are Army Airborne. The current government being disfunctional is a direct result of having the whole infrastructure killed and shaken. The difficulty of the operation is intense but we've dealt with that level of problem before. It's possible to fix the problems, we only have to commit to the program
Viva Cuba--a shinning example of social righteousness--although a dictatorship, it is a very brave and honest one--I rather be living under the rule of a good dictator than greedy,evil,destructive, and deceitful manipulators, such as we have here in the USI at this present time. I believe that the US government has always been very jealous of Castro,their ex-president--hell they tried to murder him in cold blood at least eight times--and the power of Jah would not allow it to happen.
Newsflash: you are living under the same paradigm. I left it 30 years ago but it followed me. Bad luck? Paradox? Who the hell knows?
There is always plenty of commentary to describe the spectacle and and point to the
many causes of Haiti’s ongoing disaster.
This often leads to the conflict paradigm with revolution suggested to change the major structures in the complex money / power arrangements.
I suppose being informed how these mazes of structures inter-react by sites like this one and others eg: (getoffyourbutts) post are certainly helpful.
The discussion that often follows though seems to be a left - right argumentative synopsis or a cynical view that the system is totally dysfunctional and there is no possible outcome except word wide tragedy or breakdown.
Perhaps the elites will have an epiphany or a ‘glasnost’ that fairly traded products and a fair wage for labor will in the long run actually benefit the ever ruling bottom line.
I meant to offer some prose ..... here goes....sorry!
The Mystery Other empirePie January 15th, 2009
Imagine an apple
that didn’t occur as a conjecture with fruit.
What if ‘to be’ was reasoned out of the we
and said: ‘it you can’t explain it it ain’t’
How could you have an ain’t without symbols?
How could you do some jive without rhythm?
What sort of mystery ‘ism’ doesn’t require imagine?
What sort of other can you have without mother?
The other as in the ‘Pandora’ other;
a force as real as a tree;
the mystery ‘other’ that we may strive to be or to join.
Imagine a garden without a serpent pushing tree fruit
or a metaphor without a cause;...
.........a warning clause,
or a bite for a symbol
that said: “just cause”
or because...
we said so often enough;
so logic could win the apple hand
and...
our garden could become..... the damned.
Is this a put-on or an actual attempt at rational comment? I think I'll take it as a put-on and move on to something that words just randomly chosen and thrown onto the page like that so-called art in which paint is just splashed onto a canvas and sold for a million dollars. There's an idea. Create a greeting card with art splashed onto the front and this "creation" printed inside. It should sell really well, like the pet rock. Rotsa ruck! LOL LOL LOL LOL ;-D :-) :( !
Cuba prides itself on its provision of free universal healthcare. Media coverup???
For all the old Cold War Warriors and associated right wing Cuban white Miami-ists, Cuba is still the ongoing punching bag. Unfortunately the the US media has followed these hateful bastards down the rat-hole. I suppose this will continue even after Castro dies.
This is Florida Politics:
You have your South Florida, I hate Castro Cubans.
Your Central Florida vote Republican till I die seniors,
and the North Florida bible thumpers and rednecks.
People are flying out of here like cockroaches on a swampy August night.