Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Americans Swap Homes for Hotels as Recession Bites
CAMBRIDGE, Massachusetts (Reuters) - Some Americans are swapping homes for motels as the ranks of the homeless swell during the recession, crowding out shelters and forcing cities and states across the country to find new types of housing.
Tarya Seagraves-Quee washes the dishes in the bathroom sink at a motel in Cambridge, Massachusetts July 8, 2009. (REUTERS/Brian Snyder) In Massachusetts, a record number of families are being put up in motels due to high unemployment and the rising number of homes going into foreclosure, costing taxpayers $2 million per month but providing a lifeline for desperate families.
"I feel like this has saved my life," said Tarya Seagraves-Quee, a 37-year-old former nurse.
Seagraves-Quee has lived in a cramped one-bedroom suite in a hotel in Cambridge, Massachusetts, with three of her four children for nearly two months. "I'm managing the best way possible. I've learned to make things in the microwave oven."
In Massachusetts, homeless shelters are at capacity. State law requires temporary accommodation for those without shelter, leading authorities to place 830 families, including 1,125 children, in 39 motels -- an unprecedented number.
"This truly is the highest we have ever seen it," said Nancy Paladino, director of the family team for the Boston Health Care for the Homeless.
Other cities are noticing a similar trend. In Indianapolis, Indiana, overcrowded homeless shelters are turning families away, forcing growing numbers to seek vouchers for hotels provided by nonprofit groups such as United Way.
"Anecdotally, it's increased," said Michael Hurst, director of the Coalition for Homeless Intervention and Prevention Indianapolis. The advocacy group started to compile statistics on the number of homeless families living in hotels this year after noticing signs of an increase.
"The hotel owners will tell you it has increased. The homeless service providers and the school officials will say we know there are more people living in hotels and putting their kids in school because that is the address they are giving us."
'JUST A STEPPING STONE'
In the Dallas-Fort Worth metropolitan area, the large Wilson family turned to a budget motel as a weeklong transition between a homeless shelter and an apartment.
"Each step we're going it's just a stepping stone," said 42-year-old Frederick Wilson as he sat with his wife, Annette, in a one-bedroom suite they share with four of the six children in their care, including a grandchild.
Called by God, they said, to move from Minnesota to Texas, the family has rapidly made a shift from homeless status to paid employment. Annette has just landed a job as a bus driver, while Frederick said he will work in an office that offers clerical support to Medicaid patients.
They spent two-and-a-half weeks in a homeless shelter in Dallas and were preparing to move into an apartment from the motel. The Urban League, an organization that helps struggling African Americans, is paying the $204 cost of their suite, which does not include sheets, pillows or toilet paper.
In Phoenix, demand for emergency accommodation is swamping available services as the recession and spiraling foreclosures turn even more families out of their homes.
One nonprofit bought two former hotels -- a Days Inn and a Super 8 -- in a gritty downtown neighborhood to provide emergency accommodation for homeless and low income families. When the $23 million project is finished in September, it will be able to house 156 families, up from 112 now.
"We've seen a whole new subset of homeless families due to job loss and foreclosures, and our waiting list has doubled in the past year," said Nichole Barnes, chief fund development officer of the UMOM New Day Centers.
"Some were previous homeowners. Due to the housing market out here, they'd got into a mortgage with a flexible interest rate. Some were working full time, but lost their jobs, went through their savings trying to save their home, and then found themselves without a home due to foreclosure," she said.
FORECLOSURES AND FAMILIES
In many cities, foreclosures are a big part of a spike in homeless and rise in families living in hotels or motels.
Nearly 80 percent of homeless services providers and advocacy agencies say at least some clients became homeless as a result of a foreclosure, according to a joint report by four of the largest U.S. homeless advocacy groups.
Staying with family or friends and in emergency shelters were the most common post-foreclosure living conditions, followed by hotels or motels, according to the June report.
"In many areas shelters are now completely full, so the only option to keep their families together is to rent a motel room for $200 a week. That's pretty standard for many who lost their homes to foreclosure," said Michael Stoops, executive director of the National Coalition for the Homeless.
Unlike Massachusetts, most states do not pick up the tab. "People are spending 80 percent of their total income on hotels," he said. "And food costs are higher because they can't cook."
In Cambridge, Massachusetts, Seagraves-Quee found refuge at a budget hotel after losing her job in Georgia more than a year ago and going without health care for 10 months. She suffers from multiple sclerosis, anemia and lupus, and was recently found to have two cancer spots on her breast. Two of her children, aged 16 and 6, are autistic.
She spent $700 -- almost all her savings -- on plane tickets to Boston, where she had relatives. Soon the family was in a shelter.
Local authorities later moved her to the hotel and Seagraves-Quee was given medical treatment as part of a program carried out by Boston Health Care for the Homeless.
"Right now, I am picking up from where I left off in Georgia 10 months ago. When I got here I was in really bad health," she said. "I've heard some people say 'Oh that is a ghetto shelter.' But to me it's a wonderful place."
(Additional reporting by Ed Stoddard in Dallas and Tim Gaynor in Phoenix; Editing by Doina Chiacu)



28 Comments so far
Show AllAmerica is full of empty condos and foreclosed Mcmansions.
And empty wallets too.
And empty-headed socialists who think that the government is the answer to every problem in the world.
china night life - government / india daily hunger - no government
edweg
And empty headed right-wingers that think capitalism and free markets are the answer to every problem in the world.
I'm sorry, was it socialists who caused this financial meltdown? I must have missed something in all the headlines because the last time I checked, we haven't been in power since... wait a second, we were never in power in the US!
Ha! Pretty good!!
As has been pointed out, there needs to be socialism and capitalism working side by side to have a good society. Read the story on this site about how Norwegians view Obama. Health care should be a no-brainer. It shouldn't be a bone of contention.
You know, I voted for Obama, but I have come to the conclusion that I do not like Obama -- in those stark terms. I do not like him. I read an article on HuffPo about Obama's adventures in Ghana and I read the comments at the end: Undying love, extreme pride, etc., etc. Obama gave many pretty speeches, again. The Ghanians apparently wish Obama was their President. I really wanted to be snide at the end of that article and say, well, in 2012 you can have him -- maybe he can do for you what he is doing for us, but I didn't want to be up for a major attack or be called a Repub troll, or a Bushie. But that's what it it has come to for independent or Democratic progressives who voted for Obama.
BTW, have you seen the pics where the Ghanians put Obama's face on our flag? They wear clothes made out of fabric that is nothing but Obama's face. I feel bad for these people. Obama will never do anything for them of real meaning, anymore than he will do anything for us.
ezeflyer July 10th, 2009 6:02 pm
"America is full of empty condos and foreclosed Mcmansions."
And they'll probably stay empty until the real estate market tanks another 20%. At that point, we'll see the "to-big-to-fail" banksters and hedge-funds scooping them up for pennies on the dollar while the taxpayers abosorb all the losses.
I think I'm gonna make my ass homeless at the end of this month. Unplug from the grid and go live near a national forest in a tent with my dog. Tend a little pot and a lotta vegetables. Count stars and colors in fires.
The number of homeless in America will rise without cease until the Revolution. Then all the condos and McMansions ezeflyer referenced will become homes for real peaple. Yeah!
What's the Revolution and what do you call real people? 95% of homes are not being forclosed on and as far as i know real people live in them. You know, the kind of people going to work every morning and coming home in the evening, paying taxes. That kind of people?
And trust old Chameleon: you don't want Revolution (in the sense that you mean it). It's gonna be a lot worse than you imagine it.
Who cares about your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free?
Apparently undercapacity Best Westerns. Who knew?
Money for Zionists and Bankers but none for desparate homeowners.
Do not these greedy idiots in Washington know that is much less expensive to maintain prosperity than clean up after social calamity?
And somewhere some asshat is already forming a company called "Revolutionary Urban Cleaners" and grabbing no bid contracts.
I'll say this for capitalism: without any form of a conscience, it proves remarkably adaptable.
Maybe they may have some spare tents left over when all of the Pakistai's are taken care of.
Just another way of using taxpayers money to prop up another 'capitalist' sector called the hotel/motel industry and it will reach a max-point and fail.
I mean what is happening or going to happen with all those empty homes that have been foreclosed? Just remain empty or bought at pennies on the dollar by more 'fat cats' looking to profitize at everyone's expense?
Capitalism sucks and is, in this current guise, the true terrorist threat to this country and obama is looking more and more the osama we keep looking for to kill or capture to end this 'ghost' war.
I'm beginning to wonder if that's not the plan. We watch the continuing giveaways, the 300 billion to the war machine, meanwhile losing our jobs, pensions, health care (if any) and finally evicted to live in the street.
NorthCom is training combat brigades to deal with "civil unrest." The KBR concentration camps are waiting.
You don't suppose they are deliberately pushing us into a corner so we will revolt. If you've kept current with the Executive Orders awaiting signatures, any disturbance can lead to martial law and a suspension of government. The various EO's, if put into effect, will leave us with a state similar to the CCCP. Try this site and run down to the EO's.
http://www.mindfully.org/Reform/2004/FEMA-Concentration-Camps3sep04.htm
They've been preparing this for a decade or longer. Perhaps they are just tired of playing the "democracy game," now that there is not a whole lot left to extort from us. What's a little whips and chains and slave labor to a fascist?
Also, remember that during the WW-II Japanese internment, a young man could get out of the camps. All he had to do was join the army.
A million or so crowded into camps, forced labor for food; becoming cannon fodder in the "Stans" for Big Brother to get out might not seem so bad.
There is no other explanation making more sense than 'The Ghosts that I called...'.
Capitalism was celebrated winner over Communism by most people in the US. Their so called victory broke this country's neck. That's why there are ample historical examples of 'winners' that lost their country due to excessive military spending.
To look at all those homeless people breaks my heart. Having been homeless for a brief time, I know what they are going through in a blasphemic country that tells them their problems are just the result of their own 'wrong choices'. True, if You consider being born into this nation was the 'wrong choice'.
Incomprehensible that some people really think they can afford a revolution, because they have the military upperhand and enough concentration camps. Fortunately history shows it clearly: Things will never play out as You thought. The Nazis found that out and the Americans should have with Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan.
"We got to fight 'them' over there, that we can be homeless here."
May All Beings Be Blessed.
No Restrictions Or Limitations Shall Apply.
Isn't It Self-Evident That There Is No Alternative?
"To what?"
"Our rising up en masse."
"And then what sort of world?"
"It'll be up to us."
"Otherwise?"
"Doomsday."
"Based on?"
"Perpetual war + global warming + doomsday."
I am one of the newly integrated middle-class gone homeless (at 40 yrs. old luckily w/o children but alone) and am living in a tiny trailer and unable to pay my two cc bills and car payment....I qualify for 200.00 in food stamps and that is it! When are we going to revolt??? We need to rise up and confront our politicians....time to act on our behalf not the BANKS!
Gail makes a good comment.
"And they'll probably stay empty until the real estate market tanks another 20%. At that point, we'll see the "to-big-to-fail" banksters and hedge-funds scooping them up for pennies on the dollar while the taxpayers absorb all the losses."
Thats what usually happens. Hopefully this time the average American citizen will recover these properties at the discount.
.............................................................
It is however a joke to blame this on capitalism. Capitalism is not bailing out failing banks and financial institutions. Its not about political payoff's to Unions and politicians.
The foreclosures are indeed because many home loans were made to people that should never have gotten one. A truth that some here will find hard to swallow, but nonetheless a truth. The result of that was an overheated market which speculators jumped into. I remember watching TV shows about people flipping houses and the profits being celebrated by the States where it was occurring. Then the bubble burst. But it just uncovered a bigger bubble that the politicians had allowed to grow for the last 20 years. Bad trade policies and agreements, deregulation and little oversight. Allowing American companies to import cheap labor into our country and getting fools to defend their exploitation of these poor people.
There is nothing simple about this problem, nor can it be defined in any simplistic slogan nor cured by following bad policy and bad governance.
Pelosi and her ilk encourage us to follow California style solutions and policies. Notice how thats working out for them?
A short comment on this post......
GothmogIV "And empty-headed socialists who think that the government is the answer to every problem in the world."
Socialist are no more empty headed than Conservatives that think every problem can be answered by Privitization. They are both wrong. But together they have all the answers.
Have to agree here, capitalism has to have social programs if it is to survive without destroying the workers that make it float.
Socialism has to have a capitalistic side if it is to compete in the world.
Somewhere in the middle we will find a system that works if we EXPOSE the crooks in high places through the Main Stream Media!
"Have to agree here, capitalism has to have social programs if it is to survive without destroying the workers that make it float."
Thats the part that these MORON's forgot.
"Socialism has to have a capitalistic side if it is to compete in the world."
Absolutely.
"Somewhere in the middle we will find a system that works if we EXPOSE the crooks in high places through the Main Stream Media!"
AMEN!!!!!!!!!!!
If the government buys up bad debt, why not hire people to manage these places as temporary homes for the homeless?
They are just going to fall apart if they sit!
That's where stimulus dollars should be going!
--------
I don't believe in a free ride for anybody. There is a lot of work that can be done right now, match people to work and give them a place to stay and enough money for their work to find a real job.
Well said, especially the idea of managing foreclosed homes as temporary shelter. The residents could be required to do property maintenance as long as they live there rent-free until they can locate work. It would certainly be a lot cheaper than putting up the "forclosed homeless" in motel rooms at $3000 a month.
So now the taxpayers are paying to house people in motels, people homeless as a result of foreclosures. Wouldn't it have cost taxpayers less to just pay the mortgages on those houses until the people living in them could get back on their feet? Surely a motel room costs more per month. It is all becoming skewed and surreal. What? you can't make your $1500 a month mortgate payment. Well, heck, don't worry about it, we'll just put you up in this motel for $3000 a month. The taxpayers won't mind.
This kind of skewed logic has been going on for years. Homelessness spiked during the Reagan years and the same thing was happening. It makes no sense. And see how our health care problem just keeps coming showing its ugly face front and center.