When I was a young activist, the '60s were not yet far enough away, and people still talked about "after the revolution." They still believed in some sort of decisive event that would make everything different-an impossible event, because even a change in administration cannot bring a universal change of heart, and the process of changing imagination and culture is plodding, incremental, frustrating, comes complete with backlashes . . . and is wildly exciting if you slow down enough to see the broad spans of time across which change occurs. A lot of people then were waiting for the revolution; a lot of people now have lost faith that there will be one. The overthrow of the United States government seems extremely unlikely at the moment, but the transformation of everything within, around, and despite it has been underway for decades, including radical transformation in the governments of many other countries.
Sex before marriage. Bob and his boyfriend. Madame Speaker. Do those words make your hair stand on end or your eyes widen? Their flatness is the register of successful revolution. Many of the changes are so incremental that you adjust without realizing something has changed until suddenly one day you realize everything is different. I was reading something about food politics recently and thinking it was boring.
Then I realized that these were incredibly exciting ideas-about understanding where your food comes from and who grows it and what its impact on the planet and your body are. Fifteen or twenty years ago, hardly anyone thought about where coffee came from, or milk, or imagined fair-trade coffee. New terms like food miles, fairly new words like organic, sustainable, non-GMO, and reborn phenomena like farmers' markets are all the result of what it's fair to call the food revolution, and it has been so successful that ideas that were once startling and subversive have become familiar en route to becoming status quo. So my boredom was one register of victory.
Although we typically associate revolution with the sudden overthrow of a regime, the Industrial Revolution was an incremental change in everyday life and production that began a little over two centuries ago and never ended. It's a useful reminder of what else revolution is. Late in 2006, I had the pleasure and honor of meeting Grace Lee Boggs in Detroit, where she's lived and organized radical politics since the 1950s. Grace, who was born to Chinese immigrant parents in 1915, earned a PhD in philosophy in 1935, and married the African-American labor organizer Jimmy Boggs in the early 1950s, has lived long enough to see the whole idea of revolution change. She said to me, "In the first half of this century people never thought revolution involved transforming ourselves, that it required a two-sided transformation. They thought that all we had to do was transform the system, that all the problems were on the other side. It took the splitting of the atom and the Montgomery bus boycott to introduce us to a whole new way of thinking about revolution as tied to evolution." In another interview, she expanded on this rejection of the idea that everything would change suddenly: "In revolutionary struggles throughout the twentieth century, we've seen that state power, viewed as a way to empower workers, ends up disempowering them. So we have to begin thinking differently. The old concept used to be: first we make the political revolution and then the cultural revolution. Now we have to think about how the cultural revolution can empower people differently."
The fantasy of a revolution is that it will make everything different-and regime-changing revolutions generally make a difference, sometimes a significantly positive one-but the making of differences in everyday practices is a more protracted and incremental and ultimately more revolutionary process. Last month, I was asked in public about where the antiglobalization movement now stood. I gulped a little. I'm a slow thinker-I like to have a month to a year to mull something over, which is why I'm a writer. My first thought was that there wasn't anything so dramatic and dynamic and visible as those ten thousand blockaders in the streets of Seattle on November 30 and December 1, 1999. Fortunately, I made the other person go first, and by the time her answer was complete, mine had grown to encompass how the very ideas around corporate globalization had spread, so that what was wild new thinking by radicals or revolutionaries in the streets in 1999 had become a reasonable position for many governments to take by 2003 or so-and even some of the Democratic presidential candidates by 2008.
In recent years, most Latin American nations have turned against the ideology of unfettered markets and trade pacts, and even in countries whose governments have not, most of the citizens have. Immanuel Wallerstein, the left-wing sociologist with a talent for prophecy, wrote an essay earlier this year headed "2008: The Demise of Neoliberal Globalization." In it he said, "The political balance is swinging back. Neoliberal globalization will be written about ten years from now as a cyclical swing in the history of the capitalist world-economy. The real question is not whether this phase is over but whether the swing back will be able, as in the past, to restore a state of relative equilibrium in the world-system. Or has too much damage been done?" Such critiques of globalization have ceased to be inflammatory or extraordinary as the global public has grown increasingly educated in economics and the sinister underside of all those free-trade treaties. Those of us who fought against them won some practical victories and a lot more in the realm of public imagination, but the position ceased to belong exclusively to us as it became a reasonable position for many to take. This is why we need training in slowness, and the long attention span that makes it possible to see the remarkable changes of our time.
There's also the widespread greening of the public imagination, with climate change having finally arrived on center stage. Cities and states across the country are now pushing to regulate emissions (and having to fight the Bush administration's EPA in order to do so). My own state is even looking at regulating commercial airplane emissions. The revolution is here, but it doesn't look like what people expected, and it isn't even visible to those who aren't practiced in the long view.
If the term revolution can be used to describe the Industrial Revolution, then perhaps we are launched upon something as profound-a backlash against the industrial revolution that brought us the acceleration of everyday life, the industrialization of time and space, the shrinkage of the contemplative time and space in which to understand ourselves and our lives. That is to say, the revolution is in part against the very speedup that has made us all busy, distracted, anxious, and unable even to perceive the tenor of our own times. So it is a revolution in perception and daily practice, as well as against the concrete institutions that spell the misery of everyday life for too many and the destruction of the Earth for us all.
It may never be finished, but the time to join it is now.
Rebecca Solnit was born the same summer that the Berlin Wall went up and the Freedom Rides began in Mississippi. She is a year older than Silent Spring. Things change. She writes for a number of outlets and periodicals including Orion.
© 2008 Orion Magazine
Delicious
Digg
StumbleUpon
Newsvine
Facebook
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
26 Comments so far
Show Allwow, thanks, pacorabo! i don't have a copy of the crippled giant of my own and i'd love one.
To find hard-to-find books always try www.abebooks.com
Their censorship is not as severe as in Amazon (owned by Bezos...)
The crippled giant ;: American foreign policy and its domestic consequences (ISBN: 0394482425)
James William Fulbright
Bookseller: Seashellbooks.com, Inc.
Price: US$ 1.00
Book Description: Random House 1972, 1972. A wonderful copy with some minor edgewear to the cover. Dust Jacket may have chips and close tears. - Hard Cover, Very Good / Good. Bookseller Inventory # 83C22A2746173
FIREFEM (Laila?):
thanks. appreciate it. thanks for the note on Skousen's book, The Naked Captalist, i'll look into it.
i received in email a similar comment, perhaps twas you.
old books of all stripes indeed 'suddenly' have taken on new aspects these days. -which i suppose says a lot about 'these days'...
i recently came across a phrase 'you may not take an interest in politics but politics will take an interest in you.' which i believe sums up the situation for many who otherwise may not be so politicized. personally, that's my own situation. i just want to do my own thing and draw and write and so on and not have to worry about liberty -but liberty is ill-served by such an attitude. last year this phrase "conformity supports what passivity enables" fell out of my fingers onto my keyboard (by the grace of a higher power i dare say).
A revolution, or even a cultural evolution, takes place when ideas begin to manifest themselves in our daily lives, and that's the point, isn't it.
The problem for our civilization now is can we move fast enough to offset what's happened over the last 200 years of industrialization?
Second problem: Can we protect ourselves from similar follies in the future?
Many thanks to all those who have given so unselfishly of their time and effort to get us to change, even when we didn't want to hear what they had to say - such courage, such fortitude, these are the real heroes of humanity.
snydly----beautiful post---thank you
Couple of good books on the subject:
Blessed Unrest, by Paul Hawken
The Great Turning, By David Korten, and my fav,
1. Those who would take over the earth
And shape it to their will
Never, I notice, succeed.
The earth is like a vessel so sacred
That at the mere approach of the profane
It is marred
And when they reach out their fingers it is gone.
For a time in the world some force themselves ahead
And some are left behind,
For a time in the world some make a great noise
And some are held silent,
For a time in the world some are puffed fat
And some are kept hungry,
For a time in the world some push aboard
And some are tipped out:
At no time in the world will a man who is sane
Over-reach himself,
Over-spend himself,
Over-rate himself.
LaoTzu #29 600 BC
cheers.
Excerpt from "KEEP HOPE ALIVE" Chapter 12- and EVERYTHING actually happened, except Jack is the fictional character I told my experience through:
"The Revolution starts now, when you rise above your fear and tear the walls round you down."-Steve Earle
On Wednesday, July 20, 2005, in Berkeley, California, Jack intuitively sensed opportunity blowing in the wind as he rounded the corner from Durant and Telegraph on his way to UC Berkeley's MLK student union building for TIKKUN's first annual conference on spiritual activism. As he crossed Bancroft Way, a young, beatifically-smiling latte-skinned youth handed him an electric green slip of paper announcing:
"Compassionate Caregivers: Medical Cannabis. Two locations, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., seven days a week."
Jack mused, "Now that my third anti-inflammatory has been pulled, I can't do narcotics in moderation, and I am not ready for joint replacement; I wonder if maybe this is an invitation from You to move out here?"
Jack soon forgot all about the aches in his joints--in particular, his knees, which had been crushed in an auto accident when he was twenty-three and then again at twenty-six. The MLK student union building was jammed with people from all faiths, and those who were spiritual, but not religious, who were imagining a new bottom line for America and her true place in the global village. Jack glided up the stairs to the second floor and deeply inhaled the energy emanating from over thirteen hundred American citizens who had gathered in the Pauley Ballroom in support of a new bottom line based on love, compassion, caring, ethical and ecological sensitivity, and behavior; and motivated by generosity, kindness, cooperation, nonviolence, and peace.
Jack imagined a society that honored all human beings as embodiments of the sacred, a society that enhanced one's capacities to respond to the earth and the universe with awe, wonder, and radical amazement. He imagined the Kingdom of God, where men would turn their swords into plowshares and not make war anymore.
The invocation was offered by Father Louis Vitale, a Franciscan who reminded Jack of one of the least of the seven dwarves, until he spoke and revealed himself to be a man of profound wisdom, enrobed in well-worn burlap:
"The Holy One has called on us. In all of earth's sixty-five-million-year history, we are living in the most dangerous of times. The fact that a bomb was dropped on Hiroshima and two hundred thousand lives were vaporized within twenty minutes has not prevented man from dreaming up more ways to fill space with weapons of mass destruction. We were not created for militarism, but to turn our swords into plowshares. We have arrived here today by no accident. We have been summoned by the universe to claim the highest common ground. As the Dali Lama said, the radicalism of our age is to be compassionate human beings. We have been called to bring love and compassion back into the equation and assist others to connect with the deepest parts of themselves. Now is the time to realize, as never before, that when any of us suffer, we all suffer. All life is interconnected, interdependent, and greatly loved by the creator, the sustainer of the universe. We are called by love, for love, and to love."
Professor Nagler, M.C. and scholar, stoked the fire of hope within Jack. "We are not facing a spiritual crisis, but a spiritual opportunity. We offer the power of moral ideas to a country with a lot of religion yet which suffers from a great lack of spirituality and imagination. As William Blake said, 'Imagination is evidence of The Divine.' And spirituality is how we grow in sensitivity to ourselves, the other, and to God. Einstein wrote, 'Human beings are limited in time and space. We experience ourselves in an optical delusion. We see ourselves as separate from others. Our task must be to free ourselves from our prison of self. Only through compassion can we begin to embrace all of Creation.' The bumper sticker got it right; we are spiritual beings having a human experience."
George Lakoff, the author of "Don't Think of an Elephant" affirmed what Jack already knew, that a nurturing parent raises a child as best they can to be responsible to self and others. A nurturing parent is not permissive or overindulgent, but models cooperation and honesty, and understands that everything is grace, an unconditional gift from God that one is free to accept or reject. Lakoff spoke about God as father, mother, all-knowing, all-good, all–powerful, and the source of the free gift of grace that will open one up to God in the world. Jack thought of Father Matthew Fox's recent publication, "A New Reformation."
During Pentecost week, in 2005, Father Fox traveled to Wittenburg and nailed a new ninety-five theses to the church door, where Luther had nailed his five hundred years before. Father Fox wrote Jack's heart about an interfaith collaboration and community that intuits God as mother-father God of divine wisdom, and understands that the earth itself is to be tended; its health is just as much a moral imperative for us all as our human relationships. Jack had long ago rejected the concept of a punitive father God and understood that nature is God's primary temple, and war the greatest abomination.
Jack's mind wandered to the leper kisser, Francis of Assisi, and he thought...
The rest
March 4, 2007 WAWA Blog:
http://www.wearewideawake.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=...
ZUMA, thanks for the links you posted to J. William Fullbright's book, The Crippled Giant. I read the last 5 pages of The Empty System of Power and now I want to find the book and read it entirely.
If you can find a copy of it somewhere, because it's now out of print, find The Naked Capitalist by W. Cleon Skousen and read at least the first 5 pages of that book. It'll blow your socks off! I believe we can find the answer to where the U.S. is headed by reading books that were published 35-40 years ago. Another good book is Who Will Tell The People, written 38 years ago.
I feel sorry for anyone who still believes in The American Dream because of what George Carlin says, "you have to be asleep to believe in it".
I also went to your website and poked around a bit. I like what you have there.
Luckylefty is really Karl Rove. Don't fall in hisorher slime.
Too funny luckylefty, but to some extent true.
Obama is an anomaly, he was not one of the chosen by the eliete for this election.Obama beating Hilary ( the chosen Dem ) was a huge twist in events.
The question is this , is Luckylefty correct about Obama
or is DD correct about Obama.
One thing is for sure, we have had nothing but rich white men as president for this country and that in and of itself warrants Qbama getting a shot. The last forty years of bad ledershp from Rebublican Neocan right wing religiuos lunitc fringe rule in the white house , with the aid of the complicit Democratic party have got America in the bad shape its in right now.
So maybe we shake up the status quo with Obama, maybe he is not a ture insider, you can bet Mccain and Clinton are insiders.
Save the constitution, NO IMMUNITY for warrentless spying by any group,law agency,corporation, and the white house.
safiyya,
Too busy blogging.
JK Galbraith was right.
There is/was no revolution. Money/Power controls all.
There is no revolution going on at this moment. Americans haven't shown the energy to even go out and 'vigil' against the war, let alone do anything more substantial. They're too busy doing nothing...
>>negate sacred connection BETWIXT ALL LIFE<<
Betwixt is only between TWO things not many things. Sorry.
We have a "green revolution" in the same sense that a child with a squirt-gun is a "fire brigade."
Houston will go dry, Los Angeles will go dry, Atlanta will go dry, and tens of millions of refugees will have to be relocated in the United States.
Are you ready?
I know Obama traverses tricky dangerous waters, sells parts of his soul and is a main-line politician.
Thank Freakin God; After the torturers and killers, let's just see! He was compared to Carter by McCain....could back-fire on the old Alzheimers 'war hero,' killed how many of his own men on deck in a fiery blaze? And then got shot down while shooting civilians, then divorced his wife when she was injured badly; got a trophy b****.
Oh-Bama!!
Obama
~ MOUSE ~
___ please do keep roaring __
~ ELLYDOZER ~
___ thankfully you're AWAKE ( not dozing ), as
___ we've much detritus for ALL to plow through.
___ The light is glowing and drawing us toward
___ our transformed existence, forward
___ inward
Thank you for BE'ing present to change
Namaste
ellydozer - nice and refreshing to see some sanity here. People, the change is going to be with you, and in you. The powers that be know it, and this is the main thing they are trying to keep from you. Learn about what is happening regarding the shift of the ages and prepare for 2012, for the shift is here now and will only continue to get stronger. Meditate, give, grow, and learn to live with nature rather than fight her, for the Earth itself and your own personal ascension will be your deliverance, not any lying politician. This is our time. This is our revolution.
In the world since the Nazi and Communist revolutions (and actually long before) "revolution" is one group of murderers and thugs taking power from another group of murderers and thugs. Should there be a 360 degree economic collapse in this heavily armed country, the dust will clear and we will find ourselves with a government run by Elmer Gantry and Hannibal Lector. To understand the consequences of that, read about life in Zimbabwe or the collapse of the former Yugoslavia. We will become a beast that devours itself and USA will stand for Unlimited Shock and Awe.
yes.....we will be leaving our Planetary evolution for the Universal period around the beginning of 2011. one does not need to believe in the mayan calendar to feel its effects. so......quit putting all your soul eggs into someone elses basket, BE THE CHANGE. polititions have never succeded in management cuz ITS NOT THEIR JOB!! its your job to manage yourself. free yourself from the only path THEY have ever given us. find YOUR path. and, yes, revolution is indeed in the near future, but......will you recognize it???
38 years ago, Sen William J. Fulbright wrote a book called 'The Crippled Giant' that was very much ahead of it's time, particularly the last chapter, 'The Empty System Of Power'.
Power is seductive, addictive, deluding, and intoxicating. All presidents do things they later regret. Even now, we are still wrestling with the overgrown ogre of consequences of the Carter Doctrine -as good as Jimmy was, even *he* wasn't immune -but has at least since then doing his best to rectify the results and with some limited results. So revolutionary is he now, he's a pariah, even for an expresident, but certainly wields what moral and persuasive and stateman powers he retains ever so much more effectively, principled man that he is...
Nicely put, Rebecca. We often forget the basics when we are in the midst of another political game show ... selection ... election. It is too easy to reject the slow, deliberate growth of knowledge in favor of the quick and dirty guns and knives revolution, which doesn't ever change much at all. I am guilty of this approach myself, as I am often too ready to take up arms again and just shoot a bunch of politicoes in DC. Republicats or Democrans, it doesn't matter. But your insight about the boring reality of change brought me upright in my chair, and I understood - instantly - where you were going with it. Very nice insight. And very right. Of course the forces of fascism will continue to tighten their grip on America. Blackwater troops, like the thugs in the film Equilibrium, will be everywhere. But what we often forget is how very, very far we have come in our thinking since those sleepy days of the 1950s when I was growing up. They can shoot me, they can shoot you, but they can never shoot the ideas which comprise the new thinking, and tghe revolutionized culture we helped to make.
The "revolution" actually going on (as opposed to imagined) is being led by Dennis Kucinich, Barney Frank, those in independent media such as Amy Goodman, other such journalists as Bill Moyers, and historians such as Howard Zinn and Noam Chomsky and Gore Vidal, millions of other individual citizens, to turn America to something of both effectiveness and principle. That's the one to join. Obama, revolutionary? No. Not when he refuses to stand for freedom of conscience and consciousness or nonimperialism or our inalienable rights as sovereign individuals. Not when he vacillates on issue positions even in campaigning. No, he's not a nazi per se', but he's not a neocon's nightmare either, no matter they'd prefer McCain. By placating Pelosi et al, Obama is as bad as they. The "revolution" is about disabling the corruption that undermines the efforts of people like Kucinich to equally and fairly run. Where was Obama? In your imagined revolution?
38 years ago, Sen William J. Fulbright wrote a book called 'The Crippled Giant'. It was way ahead of it's time en toto, with the last chapter, 'The Empty System Of Power' particularly germaine to now. I wish Jimmy Carter had taken more of that to heart when he was president. I appreciate Jimmy, but the 'Carter Doctrine' he established as president is something of an overgrown ogre now. All presidents do things they regret, even Jimmy, good as *he* was.
crippledgiant26-27.jpg
crippledgiant177.jpg
crippledgiant180-181.jpg
crippledgiant192-193.jpg
crippledgiant204-205.jpg
crippledgiant206-207.jpg
crippledgiant278-279.jpg
and from the last chapter, The Empty System Of Power:
crippledgiant-275.jpg
crippledgiant-276.jpg
crippledgiant-277.jpg
crippledgiant-278.jpg
crippledgiant-279.jpg
Citizenblog: Ditto.
DD is still on the pipe. BHO LEADS NOTHING AND NO ONE. HE SERVES MASTER (on all fours). The same thing Lieberman said of himself, BHO can say as well, "I am a Different Dim. I swallow."
DD, your consistent support in the face of LIES, MORE LIES, AND THEN BETRAYAL, is reflective of a species of madness, or a paid hack. MASTER OWNS THE OREO COOKIE.
Hope is the food of the hopeless. It has no nutritional value and is no substitute for a self-directed plan. Full stop.
When do you plan to shut down your Kool-Aid stand DD? After he gets elected or will you continue to make excuses for "your boy" until in the face of food riots he declares Martial Law to preserve Master's property and perquisites?
No FDR this time children. This ain't '32. This time the hammer comes done. The South has rose again. We are back to the same 80-20 Slave Plantation model that this abattoir started with.
The "revolution" actually going on (as opposed to imagined) is being led by Barack Obama to transform the Democratic Party back to something of both effectiveness and principle.
That's the one to join now. It is a tangible step to enable some of the others that at this time are not yet tangible.
Ha ha