Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Put America Back To Work
The biggest domestic policy failure has been the refusal of top officials in the White House and in Congress to recognize the severity of the employment crisis that has settled like a plague over American workers.
What we are experiencing is an economic disaster, the worst reversal to hit the U.S. since the 1930s. The human suffering is profound. Some 14 million Americans are officially counted as unemployed. Nearly half have been out of work for six months or more, and many have been jobless for a year or two or longer. And, what's worse, we know exactly how to lift ourselves out of this morass and only lack the political vision to pull it off. There is no longer any excuse for believing that the Great Recession and its aftermath was a more or less typical economic downturn to be followed by a robust recovery. That’s a pipedream. What we are experiencing is an economic disaster, the worst reversal to hit the U.S. since the 1930s. The human suffering is profound. Some 14 million Americans are officially counted as unemployed. Nearly half have been out of work for six months or more, and many have been jobless for a year or two or longer.
Poverty is once again on the march, moving like Patton’s Third Army through communities that had never had more than a tenuous hold on the American dream. The few jobs now being created too often pay a pittance, the minimum wage or just above, not nearly enough to pry open the doors to a middle class standard of living.
Starved of tax revenues, the federal budget is submerged in a vast ocean of red ink. One of the tragic results is that social services are under furious attack at the same time that the need for such services has grown enormously. If dramatic steps are not soon taken to put millions of jobless Americans back to work, the quality of life for much, if not most, of the population will be irreparably damaged. The American dream itself is at risk.
Politicians have given little more than lip service to this terrible turn of events. If there was but one message that I would try to get through to the nation’s leadership, it is that we cannot begin to get the United States back on track until we begin to put our people back to work.
And there is so much work to be done. Start with the crying need to rebuild the nation’s aging, deteriorating infrastructure – its bridges and highways, airports and air traffic control systems, its sewer and wastewater treatment facilities, the electrical grid, inland waterways, public transportation systems, levees and floodwalls and ports and dams, and on and on. Lawrence Summers, until recently President Obama’s top economic adviser, has pointed out that 75 percent of America’s public schools have structural deficiencies. Twelve percent of the nation’s bridges have been rated structurally deficient and another 15 percent are functionally obsolete.
Three to four trillion dollars worth of improvements will be needed over the next decade just to bring the infrastructure into a reasonable state of repair. Meanwhile, we’ve got legions of unemployed construction workers, manufacturing workers, engineers and others who are ready and eager to step into the breach, to take on jobs ranging from infrastructure maintenance and repair to infrastructure design and new construction. It shouldn’t require a genius to put together those two gigantic pieces of America’s economic puzzle – infrastructure and unemployment.
Yes, it would be expensive. But the money spent would be an investment designed to bring about a stronger, more stable economic environment. Putting people to work bolsters the economy and the newly-employed workers begin paying taxes again. Improving the infrastructure would make American industry much more competitive overall, and would spawn new industries. Creation of a national infrastructure bank that would use government funds to leverage additional investments from the private sector to finance projects of national importance would lead to extraordinary longterm benefits.
But even rebuilding the infrastructure is not enough. The employment crisis facing the U.S. is enormous and is taking a particularly harsh toll on the less well-educated members of the society. We need to take our cue from Franklin Roosevelt who understood during the Depression that nothing short of a federal jobs program was essential. The two-pronged goal was to alleviate the suffering of the unemployed and, as the workers began spending their wages, improve the economy.
Roosevelt put millions of Americans to work, including artists, writers, photographers and musicians. It was an unprecedented undertaking, and it worked.
We need a public jobs program in America now. A number of approaches have been offered, including a particularly thoughtful and comprehensive proposal prepared for Demos by Philip Harvey, a professor of law and economics at Rutgers University. The idea is simple: “Create jobs for the unemployed directly and immediately in public employment programs that produce useful goods and services for the public’s benefit.”
As Harvey’s report explains:
“When jobs program participants spend their wages, and program administrators purchase materials and supplies for program projects, the benefits delivered in the first instance to unemployed workers trickle up to the private sector, inducing private sector job creation that supplements the immediate employment effect of the job creation program itself.”
A crucial aspect of the program is that it would begin to fill the demand gap that is hampering the economic recovery. With so many millions of people out of work, the demand for goods and services is diminished. Consumers are tapped out. Private businesses are not hiring workers because the demand is not there for the additional goods and services they would be producing.
Direct job creation would put people to work quickly, without having to wait many long months, or possibly years, for the economy to fully recover. The money from their paychecks would be pumped immediately into the economy.
Like infrastructure spending, a carefully crafted direct jobs plan would be an investment that would be repaid many times over, just as investments in Hoover Dam, rural electrification, the Works Progress Administration and the G.I. Bill delivered enormous longterm benefits to the society.
F.D.R., in his first inaugural address, told a worried nation that “our greatest primary task is to put people to work.” It was a task, he insisted, that should be treated “as we would treat the emergency of a war.”
The question today, in one of our darkest economic hours, is whether we’re smart enough to heed that essential lesson of history.

25 Comments so far
Show AllVery good idea but unfortunately the Rethuglicans will never let it pass
Dims didn't do much when they had both houses of Congress and the WH either.
More specifically, for two years Obama and the Democratic Party controlled House of Reps. and Senate enacted serial legislation that transfers resources from 99% of us to the wealthiest 1%.
Although the Republican controlled House of Reps. gives the Democrats cover to continue this wealth transfer scheme, the problems that Herbert addresses resulted from Democrat/Republican collaboration.
My best educated guess is the Republicans and some Dims will do EVERYTHING in their power to keep unemployment high for as long as possible. Reason one is that it keeps wages low for the businessmen that pay them bribes, and two it allows them to slash and burn regulations in the name of creating jobs. It's a form of the Shock Doctrine in action.
Tired of the duopoly?
You aren't the only ones.
http://www.americanselect.org/
There is no "failure of the White House and Congress to recognize the problem". The corporations that own the White House and most of Congress have mandated that the DC electeds turn the US into a third world nation and that program is moving ahead at full throttle.
Exactly. It's Mens Rea all the way. From the time of Nixon devaluating the dollar and taking the US off the gold standard to makes us more "competitive" through the deindustrialization and globalization, the goal of the power strucure in the US has been to impoverish workers so much that they would be willing to work for slave wages. The dismantling of social programs and safety nets was an integral part of this sociopathic, greed permeated policy.
Articles like this are part of the problem because they give cover to the evil bastards perpetrating these policies by implying they are incompetent rather than conspiratorially evil.
I would agree. Though not an American it is obvious that countless solutions like the one presented in this article are available to the American politiicans and business leaders. They are being willfully igonored and instead a planned, slow motion, collapse of the middle class is being foisted on the public. Anyone who is still believing that the problems are being addressed or at least attempted to be addressed has been fooled. Half of your government electeds openly despise the government and have long made claims supporting it's destruction. Your supposed liberal members are taking the same money, supporting the policies, and claiming cooperation. They don't want you to win America. They want you poor, scared, and struggling for basic amentities, like much of the rest of the world. America's business is oppression. They've been successful with that business model elsewhere and now they're turning it inwards. America is being cannibalized and most of the population is still watching for that big market comeback or the magic quarter to restore job security and consumer confidence. It's not coming back, they don't want it to come back, they want to drown your voice, your security and your equality in a bathtub.
"The question today, in one of our darkest economic hours, is whether we’re smart enough to heed that essential lesson of history."
No.
"Roosevelt put millions of Americans to work, including artists, writers, photographers and musicians. It was an unprecedented undertaking, and it worked."
Roosevelt didn't have 14+ trillion in debt, drained resources, 300+ million citizens. 3+ wars, a Forever War, and an out-of-control empiric military sucking the life out of its host nation, either. Not to mention the ungodly amount of toxic debt the banks are currently sitting on. Lastly, there is little 'can-do'-ness left in a land of greedsters & grifters and a AA and falling credit rating. Summers (along with others) needs to be standing in line awaiting the gallows. A platform on front lawn of the White House would do nicely. It could accommodate everyone.
The author's ideas are wonderful. But, he needs to get real. This is not the America of the past.
This is going to be ugly as hell.
Wait, if 9% are unemployed than 91$ are employed. Isn't 91% an A? Am I wrong?
Yes.
I figured we already had a jobs program. It's called "prison". As we get poorer, more activities are criminalized, bloating US jails with slave labor. Hey, at least that's what my memo told me.
The solution is not more war. The solution is public works.
“Creation of a national infrastructure bank that would use government funds to leverage additional investments from the private sector to finance projects of national importance would lead to extraordinary longterm benefits.”
That’s what’s wrong with capitalism. It perpetually depends on the “investment” of the same top 1% that have all the money. Why do we have to entice these f**ckers with our tax dollars? A better use of the money would be to create an infrastructure of commerce that relies on worker-owned businesses and companies; completely divorced from contact with Wall Street banksters. Once you ask them to invest any of their money you’ll forever be indebted. Have we learned nothing yet?
The Democrats and Republicans are just two wings of the Corporate Fascist Party. This game of capitalism is over.
They're the left and right wing of the Bankers party that owns DC these days. This crowd has no intention of creating work for anyone but itself. If your unemployed that's your tough luck is their attitude. The only domestic jobs program they're creating is prisoner labor jobs for the new indentured slaves they fill the now newly private prisons with. The drug laws are designed to do this. Get caught using drugs you become a private slave , steal trillions form the taxpayers and you get rewarded. This is the "new" Corp / Fascist Security State the so called parties are creating.
Putting America "back to work" in any meaningful way isn't going to happen. As someone once said, "you can't make a living cutting each others hair" and this is about all we have now. New technologies spurred the 40's and 50's. Plastics from oil created a boom in manufacturing. Factories now for the most part are closed and the jobs have been shipped to where labor is cheap.
Jobs created after the Depression by Roosevelt consisted of mostly manual labor. I don't see hundreds of folks sweating digging ditches, building bridges and other make work jobs today - especially when one machine can do the work of hundreds.
NO INCUMBENTS is the only way out of this hole. The current Congress is so corrupt that it literally can't get any worse. They have voted their personal pocketbooks 100% of the time. No matter how painful it might be, replacing these corrupt officials is the only solution short of a violent revolution. I'd rather see a revolution thru the ballot box than by firearms, but who knows? With wages in the last ten years worse than they were during the depression, we could see anything!
WE are NOT BROKE. Corporations and the wealthy have more money than ever. The middle class and poor are broke. If we employ a decent tax system, stop the wars, stop the corporate welfare, we can easily afford to stimulate employment and arts, increase education, fix our broken infrastructure, and all the other good things. Remember, the money didn't just vanish. It just got funneled to the wealthy right out of your pockets, the money is still there. Check out Obama's own pockets, for instance.
Has any member of Obama's team ever worked in the private sector and actually created a job?
If not, why would we expect them to be able to do something they've never done before?
Anybody with his head so firmly up the backside of that specious word American as applied exceptionally to themselves by the people of just one nation on the two continents of the Americas cannot be taken seriously.
In effect he is sloshing about deepening the already huge quagmire into which the US is sinking.
Articles like this reinforce my opinion that the US had better just disappear off the face of our earth. Some originating from the USA have an idea of how deep the mud in the hole already is but such is it that it is almost certain they have all left the USA.
The USA is dead. The corpse is huge. The smell of corruption is astonishing and it asphyxiates and compromises the lives of people all over the world. The 'American' understandings of wonderful words like wealth and love and religion and duty and even its buzz word Democracy form an evil infectious slime. We must fold the sides of the hole inwards over the top of the place so covering it to make a huge grave. It is happening and is unstoppable. Ironically and wonderfully it is deep enough to contain the huge corpse easily given the industry with which 'Americans' have trudged repeatedly in the slush and slime about the core of stupidity at its centre.
Are US citizens exceptional? No. US citizens are people like us all. They are American like all others who live in the Americas. In fact we are Earthlings all. Capable of faults like us, US citizens are as well worth forgiving for like all people they are good. But the corpse is not the people. The corpse is the structure of language and understanding that is often referred to as the American Dream.
The American Dream or whatever it is called is what stinks. US citizens must stop lovingly sticking their noses up its rear end and licking the repulsive leakage of slime there. The truth is that, whatever there is that is of value in it, Bob Herbert's article that asks us to do so with its 'American' and 'Dream' and such stupidities, is just stupid and childish. Grow up US'ns!
What a bloody embarrassment!