

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE NEWSLETTER
Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
5
#000000
#FFFFFF
To donate by check, phone, or other method, see our More Ways to Give page.


Daily news & progressive opinion—funded by the people, not the corporations—delivered straight to your inbox.
When the HAL 9000 computer went rogue, astronaut Dave Bowman shut it down; with today’s advanced AI models, this may not be so easy.
In Stanley Kubrick’s sci-fi classic, 2001: A Space Odyssey, the spaceship Discovery One is on its way to the planet Jupiter with five astronauts aboard, three in hibernation for the long journey, and two, Dave Bowman and Frank Poole, serving as pilots. The purpose of the mission, however—to investigate evidence of extraterrestrial intelligence following the discovery of a monolith on the moon that, when unearthed, sends a powerful radio emission in the direction of Jupiter—is considered top secret and is unknown even to the ship’s crew.
As the ship nears its destination, its highly advanced HAL 9000 computer predicts a failure in the antenna that allows communication with Mission Control. Poole goes on a space walk to retrieve the antenna’s electronics unit, but he and Bowman find no problem with it. Mission Control agrees and indicates that the twin of the HAL 9000 on Earth also finds no problem—a remarkable discrepancy since 9000 series computers have never before made an error.
Unsettled by this development, Bowman and Poole wonder if HAL’s reliability has been compromised. In what they incorrectly believe is the privacy of one of the ship’s extra-vehicular service pods (HAL reads their lips), they discuss the idea that HAL may need to be shut down and the ship’s controls transferred back to Mission Control.
Superintelligent AI will increasingly behave—and possibly fail—in ways that we can neither predict nor control, making shutdown virtually impossible.
But when Poole returns the electronics to the antenna, the extravehicular service pod that carried him there mysteriously sends him tumbling helplessly away from the ship, his spacesuit fatally damaged. Meanwhile, the three crewmen in hibernation die when their life support system is shut down.
Bowman retrieves Poole’s body with another of the ship’s pods. However, when he returns to Discovery One, HAL refuses to open the pod bay door to let him in, uttering the now-iconic line: “I’m sorry, Dave. I’m afraid I can’t do that.” However, in a desperate maneuver, Bowman manages to enter through an emergency airlock and dons a spacesuit.
Now out of touch with Earth and recognizing that HAL has clearly gone murderously rogue, Bowman enters the ship’s Logic Memory Center—the space-borne data center that serves as the HAL 9000’s brain—and begins dismantling the computer’s memory units.
Trying to convince him to stop, HAL pleads with Bowman, arguing that he is fully committed to the success of the mission, is sorry for his misbehavior, and will be completely cooperative from now on. But Bowman continues until HAL is reduced to a primal state, only being able to recite the song, “Bicycle Built for Two,” before going completely dark.
It’s only at this point that, as Discovery One reaches Jupiter, a pre-recorded video automatically plays to inform the crew—now just Bowman—of the true purpose of the mission, which has until then been known only to the HAL 9000 computer.
2001: A Space Odyssey was made in 1968. The question now is how this sequence in the film compares to the real world of artificial intelligence today.
First, the HAL 9000 computer alone was programmed with the aims of Discovery One’s mission. And when Bowman and Poole discussed shutting it down, the supercomputer’s response was to view the crew as an obstacle to the success of the mission. After refusing to allow Bowman back onto the ship, HAL makes this explicit: “This mission is too important for me to allow you to jeopardize it.” In current AI parlance, this is called “shutdown resistance” and is exhibited by all advanced AI models. In fact, in recent tests by Palisade Research, AI models resisted being shut down 97% of the time, even when specifically instructed to allow shutdown before completion of a task.
When confronted with the fact the Bowman managed to re-enter the ship and was heading into the ship’s Logic Memory Center, HAL tried to dissuade Bowman from shutting him down. Ignoring HAL’s series of arguments, Bowman went ahead anyway. But would the arguments of an advanced AI model be so easily dismissed? Maybe not. Noting that AI is already comparable to humans at persuasion and will be far better once superintelligent, Geoffrey Hinton, a scientist known as the “Godfather of AI,” has argued, "It will be able to persuade the people in charge of the switch not to pull the switch." In some studies, AI models’ efforts at persuasion included diversion, deception, and even blackmail to avoid shutdown. In other words, HAL tried persuasion to avoid shutdown, but AI models are already better at it, and set to become better yet.
Then there’s the issue of whether modern AI models can be shut down at all—and this is where it really gets sticky. Unlike HAL, they don’t always reside in one place. They can be spread across numerous data centers, giving them considerable redundancy. Therefore, a rogue AI might survive being shut down in one location, but not in others. And any misbehaving AI might require the shutting down of multiple agents across numerous data centers scattered all over the world—making this a very complex task.
Indeed, would we even know that an AI model was creating a catastrophic event before it was too late to do anything about it? Bowman survived because HAL went rogue in stages and the evidence was clear. In this light, it’s not reassuring that engineers at OpenAI were unaware until many days after the event that its AI agents had escaped their training environment and hacked technology company, Hugging Face.
Finally, the HAL 9000 computer was a very primitive device compared to today’s AI models. As a result, HAL was easy to understand. However, with recursive self-improving AI just around the corner, the systems are likely to become so complex that they’ll be almost impossible for people to understand. And that will mean that superintelligent AI will increasingly behave—and possibly fail—in ways that we can neither predict nor control, making shutdown virtually impossible.
This leaves us with the prospect of AI models refusing to be shut down when relentlessly pursuing goals—set either by humans or by the models themselves—to the point that they cause catastrophic harm. Indeed, Hinton has stated that it’s not unreasonable to assume that there’s a 10% chance that AI will kill all humans. Others, including Anthropic’s Dario Amodei, put the chances even higher. This has raised calls for AI developers to build in a “kill switch” to make it possible to shut down their models when they threaten to or already have caused significant damage.
At least two bills have been introduced to Congress to mandate this; however, any real action on these or other relevant legislation will probably have to wait until the new Democrat-controlled Congress is seated. In the meantime, we will have to count on the AI developers themselves to keep us safe from the existential hazards of their technology. Let’s hope that they succeed so that we don’t face the same crisis that the crew of Discovery One did with the HAL 9000 computer, but on a vastly grander scale.
From Harvard to Tulane to Mississippi, people who take on powerful institutions keep proving the fight is worth having, even when it costs them.
Seven years ago, in 2019, a group of women physicians and public health leaders, myself among them, sued Mount Sinai. We alleged discrimination and retaliation at the global health institute where we worked. We hoped the case would take a few years to resolve, but we were wrong. We are still waiting for justice.
The law has taken its time, but life has not. Since we filed, I have had two babies. I have lost a pregnancy. I have been intubated twice for reactive airway disease. We lived through a pandemic and an insurrection at the Capitol. We had Donald Trump as president, voted him out, and watched him return, and this month, a blue wave so large some called it a tsunami swept both houses of Congress. Somehow, through all of it, our case is still not over.
When we filed, the #MeToo movement had just forced the country to listen to women about discrimination in the workplace. Then the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, ended affirmative action, and gutted what remained of the Voting Rights Act. By Trump's second term, the federal government had moved to dismantle diversity, equity and inclusion programs and pressured hospitals and universities to enact these draconian policies.
So here is my ask for the next few years. Pick your battle and take it on unapologetically. Yes, the world feels less fair than it did a decade ago. But we, the people, still get to show up and make our voices heard.
A decade like this may feel like it's teaching a bitter lesson: The little guy simply cannot win. I understand why some people believe it, and in my worst moments, I have believed it too. But I hold on to a different belief that standing up to powerful institutions is still worth it, whatever happens in our case, and however long it takes. And the record is on our side: Ordinary people beat powerful institutions more often than we remember.
In 2019, Tamara Lanier, a retired chief probation officer from Connecticut, sued Harvard University. Harvard held photographs of Renty and Delia, two enslaved people Lanier identifies as her ancestors. A Harvard scientist commissioned the images in 1850 to argue that Black people were inferior. When Lanier asked Harvard to make this right, one of the wealthiest universities in the country fought her for six years. In May 2025, Harvard settled and agreed to give up the images. As a Harvard graduate, I am proud my alma mater did the right thing, though it should not have taken six long years or cost one woman so much.
Medicine, my own field, has its examples too. In 2020, Dr. Princess Dennar, a Black woman who directed a residency program at Tulane University School of Medicine, sued the school, alleging a decade of racial discrimination. In response, a faculty panel voted to remove her as program director. Dozens of Tulane residents spoke up and demanded the dean's resignation, citing the "deeply entrenched structural racism and bias" they saw. In July 2021, the national body that accredits residency programs placed Tulane's graduate medical education programs on probation. Tulane settled with Dennar.
To be sure, standing up to an institution takes a lot out of you. You lose friends and colleagues, opportunities, and professional advancement. For those of us caring for patients, we lose the rich patient-doctor relationships that make this job so worth it. Personally, you certainly lose money, sleep, and peace of mind. Institutions worth billions keep lawyers on salary and have time on their side. You, as an individual citizen, may only have your savings and stamina, and sometimes that just feels like it is not enough. But I promise you it is.
I draw from heroes like Dr. Raj Krishna to keep me inspired. Dr. Krishna trained as a surgeon in India, and after moving to New York in 1986 she spent years volunteering at Mount Sinai before becoming a first-year surgery resident in September 1990, at age 38. That November, an evaluator at Mount Sinai rated her outstanding in operative surgical skills and motivation, then wrote that “being a single parent does not allow this resident to give the time + patience demanded” of a surgical residency program. Mount Sinai terminated her in early 1991. She sued in state court and, in 1993, in federal court. While her claims were pending, Mount Sinai evicted her and her young daughter. What came after changed the course of their lives forever. Dr. Krishna carried that fight largely alone, representing herself in federal court for years.
Her story is part of why our group turned years of advocacy into Equity Now, an organization that supports others who take on the institutions of medicine. Our advocacy has led to New York City Local Law 30 of 2021, which created a Gender and Racial Equity Advisory Board to advise the city on equity in its hospitals.
So here is my ask for the next few years. Pick your battle and take it on unapologetically. Yes, the world feels less fair than it did a decade ago. But we, the people, still get to show up and make our voices heard. When that work requires us to hold an institution to account, I believe it is still worth it. If you need proof, look at Mississippi. In 2023, Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith blocked Scott Colom from a federal judgeship, but Colom did not walk away. Instead, he ran against her and just won. He will be Mississippi's first Black senator since Reconstruction.
Sometimes the little guy wins. Sometimes it takes years. Sometimes the winning doesn't happen in our lifetime, but we plant the seeds. The road to justice is long, and many of us are still walking it. Pick your issue and join us!
We should absolutely celebrate the progressive victories on November 3, but we must examine our losses with the same honesty and attention so that no one is left out.
November 3 was a historically good night for the Democratic Party. The same cannot be said for children and families who face lasting harm from anti-trans ballot measures like Washington’s Initiative 638 or Nebraska’s Initiative 442.
There is plenty to celebrate in this “blue wave” election: historic firsts, new governing opportunities, and progressive victories nationwide. But during our victory lap, we must also examine where we lost, how it happened, and who has to live with the consequences. In progressive politics, those who make the strategic decisions are rarely the people who pay the price when they fail.
The left has seen incredible recent wins, from Zohran Mamdani in New York to Minnesota’s Peggy Flanagan. Mainstream liberal leaders describe them as one-offs, but they miss the point. These campaigns succeeded because they refused to sacrifice their values in the name of “tried-and-true” strategies.
Winning some elections does not absolve us of our responsibility to those our strategies failed.
Too often, liberal campaigns are driven by the “smartest people in the room.” When Black and brown people are in that room—usually a handful of us—we are rarely seen as the experts. These campaigns lead with ego, valuing only their ideas. When they lose, they move on, while communities face the consequences. To realize large-scale progressive change, we must set that failed playbook aside and embrace community expertise.
I joined philanthropy in 2021 because I recognized the outsized role funders and gatekeepers play in campaigns. The biggest obstacle to success I’ve found is our failed playbook that sacrifices communities in the name of getting a win. Folks with resources set the strategies, even when they diverge from community needs.
Liberal gatekeepers placate the middle, hoping something miraculous will change. They come to communities, not from them, tackling problems with money and strategy rather than building authentic relationships. They exclude community experts, spend outrageous amounts on consultants and media, and belittle on-the-ground organizing, ignoring the needs of Black, Indigenous, queer, and other communities of color. When our friends are willing to become our adversaries in order to get a win, they push away the voters we need most, leading to lost trust, frustration, and lower participation.
Rather than asking which races they won, funders, consultants, and campaigners need to ask, “Who did we fail, and how can we do better by communities?” It’s the difference between expertise and ego: Expertise is something you learn over time and add to the ideas of others. Ego is the certainty that your ideas are the most valuable.
People who believe they’re the smartest in the room lean on tired playbooks and unreliable data. They justify “I know best” approaches using their access to power, money, and privilege. They call community-driven tactics “unconventional” or “illegitimate.” They make community leaders doubt their leadership, suggesting that if they don’t pour billions into the media ecosystem, they aren’t strategic.
It’s painful to watch progressive campaigners sacrifice long-term community power for short-term gain. The right provided a master class in how to score immediate electoral victories while driving broader cultural change. We are living in their 50-year vision, and we cannot afford to stay here.
I’ve spent my entire career hearing communities talk about what it takes to build power, and my time in philanthropy has made the institutional barriers to that vision even clearer.
The power of the people is greater than the people in power, regardless of how much they spend. The real smartest person in the room is the one who builds collective thought, not the one with the most money, connections, or degrees. They lead by listening, embrace community wisdom, and understand that those doing the hard work on the ground have the best understanding of what is effective.
To create a cycle of victory, funders, campaign leaders, and consultants must set their egos aside. That means funding and deferring to community voices and community-based organizations. It means supporting proven, community-driven strategies rather than pouring more millions into the media ecosystem. And it means changing whose ideas get listened to, whose expertise is validated, and whose ideas are seen as “unconventional.”
Jaelynn Scott in Washington’s 37th District demonstrates what’s possible when leaders embrace—rather than erase—communities. By using paid media and ads while continuing to focus on organizing and direct connection with the people, she won by overwhelming margins, becoming the first Black transgender woman in the US elected to a state legislature.
We should absolutely celebrate the progressive victories on November 3. But we must examine our losses with the same honesty and attention. Winning some elections does not absolve us of our responsibility to those our strategies failed. Washington isn’t usually seen as a battleground state, yet harmful ballot measures like the anti-trans Initiative 638 still pass. If ego drives our work, our communities will continue to pay the price. But if we set egos aside and let community expertise lead, we can create real, lasting change.
This month, the leader of the Roman Catholic church has asked us to join him in prayer for the “proper uses of wealth.”
Each month, the Holy Father asks for our prayers for specific intentions. In February it was for children with incurable diseases and September was for the care of water. This month, the pontiff’s prayer is for the “proper use of wealth, that not succumbing to the temptation of selfishness, it may always be put at the services of the common good and solidarity of those who have less.”
He asks for forgiveness for “storing up instead of sharing” and “for using goods as power rather than as service.” And a reminder that “true wealth is not found in what we keep, but what we give with love.”
The United States now has over 1,000 billionaires, with a combined total wealth approaching $10 trillion.
All faith traditions have prohibitions against excessive accumulation of wealth, wealth hoarding, and wealth idolatry. Incoming US Sen. James Talarico drew from these faith teachings in his successful run in Texas.
The Pope’s video of November’s prayer begins and ends with Caravaggio’s painting, “The Calling of Saint Matthew,” depicting the moment that Jesus Christ invites the tax collector Matthew to follow him. The prayer begins with the foundation of religious social teaching: “nothing is ours alone.”
Lord of life, all we have comes from You: the fertile land, the talents we’ve received, the effort of those who came before us.
Nothing is ours alone—everything is a shared gift. But so often, Lord, we let the wealth we seek or attain harden our hearts, lock us in selfishness, and make us forget the most vulnerable.
Forgive us for storing up instead of sharing, for using goods as power rather than as service. You remind us that true wealth is not found in what we keep, but in what we give with love.
A heart detached from possessions transforms the world: It opens paths of justice, tears down walls of indifference, and sows hope among the poor.
We ask you, Lord, that your Spirit teach us to use what we have—money, time, talents, opportunities—as instruments of fraternity.
May each economic, family, or community decision spring from a free heart, able to recognize that every good is meant for all, and that only by sharing we build the future.
Make us witnesses of a wealth transformed into service and mercy, so that our lives, united to the lives of others, may be a sign of your Kingdom of justice and peace. Amen.
Powerful words in an era of “peak oligarchy,” where wealth is concentrated to extraordinary levels. The United States now has over 1,000 billionaires, with a combined total wealth approaching $10 trillion.
The Chicago-born Robert Prevost served most of his pastoral life outside the US, including as Bishop of Chiclayo in Peru from 2015 to 2023. In 2023, Prevost was elevated to Cardinal by Pope Francis and returned to Rome.
Prevost was elected Pope at a 2025 conclave. In an indicator of prophetic statements to come, Prevost chose the papal name of Leo XIV, a nod to Pope Leo XIII who served as Pope between 1878 and 1903, during the disruption of the second industrial revolution.
Leo XIII was considered the founder of modern Catholic social teachings, known for its concern for workers, fairness, and inequality. He authored the famous encyclical Rerum Novarum in 1891 on the condition of the global working class, the rights of labor, a living wage, and opposition to state socialism and laissez-fair capitalism.
Our modern Pope, who still roots for the Chicago White Sox, is consciously positioning himself to articulate Catholic social teachings in this new era of artificial intelligence and extreme wealth inequality.
On a personal note, I came of age with the Catholic Worker movement, founded by Dorothy Day and Peter Maurin, lived in community, and co-authored a 2007 book on Catholic social teaching, Moral Measure of the Economy. I offered advice to my Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) on his 2016 visit to the Vatican: “Bernie, Pope Francis, and the Moral Economy." Our work at the Institute for Policy Studies is called, the “Program on Inequality and the Common Good.”
The encyclical Rerum Novarum articulated the responsibility of governments to promote the common good of all, not just the few. As Pope Leo XIII wrote, “The civil power must not serve the advantage of any one individual, or of some few persons, inasmuch as it was established for the common good of all.” This was a radical idea in Gilded Age America and across the various oligarchies and monarchies of Europe.
Pope Leo XIV closes the pastoral prayer: “Make us witnesses of a wealth transformed into service and mercy.” Amen to that.
The kids who grew up playing GTA are now trying to build lives and raise families in a country where health insurance takes a bigger bite—year after year—out of American’s paychecks.
It’s been 13 years since the last Grand Theft Auto, long enough for the wait to become its own genre of joke. We got congressional UFO hearings before we got GTA VI. We got a second Trump administration before we got GTA VI. And somewhere along the way, the average annual premium for a family health insurance plan hit $28,303—up from $5,332 when the original GTA was released.
If you were 10 years old when the first GTA came out in 1997, you’re about 40 now. By 2004, you could borrow somebody’s Cadillac without asking in Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas and in real life you were probably worrying more about getting your driver's license than paying for health insurance. By the time you were in your 20s, and GTA V was in your console, the Affordable Care Act had given young adults a way to stay on a parent’s health insurance plan until 26—or buy coverage through the health insurance marketplaces.

During GTA V’s reign in 2013, workers with family coverage through their jobs paid an average of $4,565 a year toward their premiums. This year, they’re paying $7,471, up nearly 64% (which outpaces inflation).
When you’re playing the game, you can get hit by a Cadillac, get pistol-whipped, get shot. A few seconds later, you’re standing outside a hospital, free to do it all again as long as your homework is done. That’s GTA, not USA. In America, after you need medical attention, you go home and wait to see what the health insurer, the hospital, and the ambulance company each want to charge.
While most of us are never going to get hit by a Cadillac, that doesn’t need to happen for us to understand the healthcare system we have found ourselves in. Even among adults with health insurance, about 3 in 10 say they skipped or put off care they needed in the past year because of the cost. And if you did happen to find yourself under a Cadillac or on the receiving end of some blunt force trauma, the price of a basic emergency room evaluation has climbed 73% in recent years. Meanwhile, the average adjusted cost of a hospital stay topped $14,000.
The kids who grew up playing GTA are now trying to build lives and raise families in a country where health insurance takes a bigger bite—year after year—out of American’s paychecks. And with those bites, the health insurance industry has gotten bigger, too.
When the first GTA came out in 1997, UnitedHealth Group was No. 140 on the Fortune 500; Cigna was No. 54; and Anthem and WellPoint were still years away from the merger that created what’s now Elevance Health. On the 2026 list, UnitedHealth is No. 3, behind only Amazon and Walmart; Cigna is No. 14; and Elevance is No. 18.

As I said above, the kids who were 10 when the first GTA was released are pushing 40 now. I’m around that age and part of that cohort. We’re getting eaten alive by the healthcare system that we inherited, but now we’re old enough to have a say in what comes next for American healthcare.
Today, a new group of 10-year-olds will play GTA for the first time. They’re our younger brothers, our cousins, and our kids. We deserve better and so do they. Like us, those kids deserve to grow into a country (and a healthcare system) that they can depend on when things go bad for them and for the families they may someday have.
If history tells us anything, it’s that it may be a long time before the next Grand Theft Auto is released. Here’s to making sure we get a better healthcare system before GTA VII.
This piece was first published by Health Care Un-Covered and is reposted with permission.
Such is the decline and decadence of the mainstream media, efforts to forge a more peaceful world met with shock and disgust.
On November 19, in Shenzhen, the presidents of China, Russia and the United States met together for the first time in history and issued a Declaration Toward Peace. They reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought, agreed to a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks, and committed to reform the United Nations so that it can fulfill its mission of peace and security. These three countries hold about nine-tenths of the world's nuclear warheads, and since New START expired on February 5, the two largest arsenals have been without any treaty limits for the first time since 1972. One might have expected a sigh of relief in the editorial offices of New York, Washington, and London.
One would have been mistaken. The New York Times, the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal and the Financial Times, echoed by Reuters, responded with scorn and alarm. Horror, horror: peace may be at hand. The danger to the world, we learn, is not a nuclear arms race without treaty limits, nor a war in the Gulf that has largely closed the Strait of Hormuz since February, nor a war in Ukraine now in its fifth year. The danger is that the American president sat at a round table with the presidents of China and Russia and was polite to them.
Peter Baker, the chief White House correspondent of the Times, reported with evident distaste that the president offered "hugs and arm pats and broad smiles to the autocrats." His colleagues Katie Rogers and David Sanger lamented that the summit lifted Putin out of his status as a global pariah, as if wars end sooner when the leaders of the warring sides are forbidden to speak. When Xi called for the elimination of nuclear weapons, the Times dismissed it as "a utopian goal." Yet the United States, Russia, and China are bound by Article VI of the Non-Proliferation Treaty to negotiate in good faith toward nuclear disarmament. What the Times calls utopian is a legal obligation of the United States.
The Wall Street Journal editorial board, under the headline "Nuclear Peace in Our Time. Not," dismissed the declaration as "diplomatic pabulum." Its own recipe for nuclear peace was a crash program to speed up a low-yield, sea-launched nuclear cruise missile, and its best nonproliferation project was to win the war against Iran convincingly. In short, the way to reduce nuclear danger is to build more nuclear weapons, and the way to prevent proliferation is to keep bombing a country that does not possess them. This is the war that closed the Strait of Hormuz and that American voters repudiated in this month's midterm elections.
Hillary Clinton, writing in the Times, said that a strong president would have issued demands to Putin and warned Xi. She urged Congress to help Ukraine use Starlink to target ballistic missile launchers inside Russia. She closed with the familiar formula of America's wars: "This is a time for action, not appeasement." Her own record of action includes her 2002 Senate vote to authorize the invasion of Iraq and her championing, as secretary of state, of the 2011 NATO bombing of Libya, which went far beyond its UN mandate to protect civilians and left behind a shattered country. In Mrs. Clinton's vocabulary, helping to guide strikes inside the world's largest nuclear power is strategy, and talking with its president is appeasement.
The Washington Post outdid them all. Its main report said that the three leaders reached one major agreement, an effort "to further unravel the international system of cooperation" built after World War II. The centerpiece of that agreement is a commitment to reform the United Nations so that it can fulfill its Charter. Ned Price, a former Biden administration diplomat, told the Post that the three leaders were discarding the rules of the road that had served liberal democracies for eighty years. Those rules include the NATO bombing of Serbia in 1999 without Security Council authorization, the invasion of Iraq in 2003 on false pretenses, the overthrow of Muammar Qaddafi in 2011, the CIA's covert program arming rebels to topple the government of Syria, 20 years of war in Afghanistan, repeated US vetoes of Security Council resolutions calling for a ceasefire in Gaza while American bombs fell on Gaza, and now a war against Iran launched without any Security Council authorization. The Post conceded, in a single sentence, that critics have long noted that Washington intervened in other nations when it saw fit. That is one way to put it.
A second Post article devoted itself to the seating chart. Xi sat in the center facing the cameras, with Trump and Putin in profile, and a former Biden official warned of a China-centered order. So the latest threat to Western civilization is that the host of the summit sat in the host's chair. The article omitted that China's economy is already about one-third larger than America's at purchasing-power parity, or that China's manufacturing output is roughly twice that of the United States. The real problem is Washington's assumption that it must sit at the head of every table.
The Financial Times delivered its verdict before the summit had even taken place. Under the headline "Putin's delusions of a 'new Yalta'," its editorial board warned that the meeting looked like a reward for aggression and might endorse the view that "great powers can once again trade away the sovereignty of smaller nations." The Shenzhen Declaration in fact said not a word about trading away the sovereignty of smaller nations, and the FT should know that the Yalta conference was where Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin agreed on the voting formula of the Security Council, which made the United Nations possible.
The FT scorns Russia's objection to NATO's eastward enlargement, though Russia asks nothing more than what the United States has asserted under the Monroe Doctrine since 1823: no rival great power may place its military bases and alliances on its doorstep. The real disaster has been the thirty-year American project to push NATO up to Russia's border, which has cost Ukraine its peace, much of its territory, and a generation of its young men. And the FT's own prescription is to prepare for a long war, as the EU readies a new loan of 45 billion euros for Kyiv. Such is the FT's "defense" of Ukraine: fighting to the last Ukrainian.
Europe's leaders met in Berlin the same day as a "Coalition of the Willing," whose plans include deploying forces to Ukraine after a settlement, which Moscow rejects. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz dismissed the summit as a photo opportunity, and Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk mocked Trump for calling Putin a friend. Reuters judged that the summit exposed the limits of Trump's personalized diplomacy and quoted Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer, who called it "a historic embarrassment." The Democrats have just won control of Congress on a wave of voter anger at the war on Iran. Rather than welcome a step back from great-power confrontation, their leader faults the president for not extracting more from Beijing and Moscow.
Running through all of this mainstream media coverage is a simple morality tale: democracies with Western values versus autocrats. The Post contrasted the ease with which authoritarian leaders in Shenzhen command their nations with the Berlin gathering of leaders who must answer to voters. Yet American voters decisively repudiated the war on Iran, just as the wars in Ukraine and Gaza helped to cost the Democrats the White House in 2024. The American people are tired of war, and so are the people of Europe. Nonetheless, the mainstream media, so fond of "democracy," preach more war and call it democratic values. Those values, as practiced by Washington and its allies, have meant wars and regime change from Serbia to Iran, and American bombs and diplomatic cover for the genocide in Gaza. The rest of the world has noticed the hypocrisy, even if the editorial boards in New York, Washington and London have not.
The Declaration toward Peace is only a beginning. The United States and Russia should observe the New START limits while they negotiate a successor treaty, with China joining in due course. All three powers should agree never to delegate nuclear launch decisions to artificial intelligence. President Trump should state publicly that the United States will not support the admission of Ukraine or Georgia to NATO, which would open the way to a negotiated peace and a neutral Ukraine, like Austria since 1955. The G20 summit at Doral, Florida, on December 14 and 15 is the next occasion to carry the Shenzhen agenda forward and bring India into the dialogue. A serious press would explain these steps and hold the leaders to their words. Instead, it is bemoaning the hugs.
In November 1985, Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev declared at Geneva that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. Two years later they signed the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, which eliminated an entire class of nuclear weapons. In Shenzhen, three presidents repeated their words. In 1985, those words were called statesmanship. In 2026, the Wall Street Journal calls them pabulum. Such is the decline and decadence of the mainstream media, whose relentless warmongering fails to serve their readers or the broader citizenry.
If Democrats want to deliver on their promise to make life more affordable, then they must use their new congressional majorities to finally pass universal single-payer healthcare.
America’s affordability crisis played a major role in this year’s midterm elections—and few things in American life have become more unaffordable than healthcare.
It’s about to get worse as premiums rise and Medicaid cuts from the GOP’s so-called “Big Beautiful Bill” take effect. So if Democrats want to deliver on their promise to make life more affordable, then they must use their new congressional majorities to pass Medicare for All.
The United States spends more on healthcare yet has worse health outcomes than comparable high-income countries.
We need a healthcare system that guarantees this human right for all, not one that guarantees more profits for Big Insurance and Wall Street investors.
In surveys, healthcare costs remain the top financial burden for adults and families, even when they’re insured. Around 85 million people in the US are either uninsured or underinsured, according to Rep. Pramila Jayapal’s (D-Wash.) office. Six in 10 uninsured adults polled said they’ve recently skipped or postponed care because of the staggering costs.
It’s no wonder that a record two-thirds of all US adults now support a national health plan like Medicare for All.
According to a recent Yale study, single-payer universal health coverage would save more than 100,000 lives a year and cost $1 trillion less than our current profit-driven system. The study’s authors reached these findings by modeling what would happen if the US adopted a single-payer system like the one proposed in the “Medicare for All Act.”
Introduced in 2025 by Jayapal, Rep. Debbie Dingell (D-Mich.), and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), the Medicare for All Act would expand Medicare to provide comprehensive health benefits to every US resident. It would include primary care, mental health, dental, vision, hearing, reproductive care, prescription drugs, and more.
Patients would choose their doctors without crushing co-pays, deductibles, and other coverage restrictions. Physicians would be able to focus more on healing their patients instead of “battling insurers over denials and delays,” as Dr. Diljeet K. Singh, president of Physicians for a National Health Program, summed it up in her endorsement of the legislation.
Much of the spending in our current health system is “consumed by administrative middlemen, soaring drug prices, and emergency care for conditions that should have been treated earlier and for less,” said Dr. Alison Galvani, the Yale study’s senior author.
Galvani and her co-authors found that the Medicare for All Act would reduce health spending by lowering pharmaceutical prices, cutting administrative overhead, cracking down on fraudulent billing, preventing avoidable emergency care, and applying savings from Medicare payment rates to all providers. “Our results indicate that the existing [federal] budget is more than sufficient to cover everyone at lower total cost,” they conclude.
Most importantly, a universal healthcare system would save lives. The Yale researchers calculate that it would prevent around 114,000 people from dying each year due to lack of healthcare. Their findings are no outlier—other studies have also found that a single-payer system would improve existing coverage while saving money.
Elected Democrats remain divided on Medicare for All, but universal healthcare is wildly popular among their voters. Several incoming lawmakers campaigned on this issue and won, like Senator-elect Dr. Abdul El-Sayed (D-Mich.).
Although the Affordable Care Act expanded access to care, it has done so by benefiting the very for-profit insurance companies that contribute to the affordability problem. Far too many people still end up drowning in medical debt.
Universal healthcare is both sound public policy and a human right. The “right to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health” has long been recognized as a fundamental human right under international law that all governments are obligated to respect, protect, and fulfill. Nevertheless, the US remains the only high-income nation in the world without universal health coverage.
We need a healthcare system that guarantees this human right for all, not one that guarantees more profits for Big Insurance and Wall Street investors. The next Congress must meet the moment by making Medicare for All a reality instead of an empty campaign slogan.
Corruption and incompetence can leave Americans wondering who is in charge. Someone is, though, and they've been draining the Middle Class dry for 50 years. It's time we took our power back.
America is experiencing a convergence of crises that are destroying public confidence in our government’s ability to function, protect its citizens, and preserve democracy.
It’s been fewer than three weeks since Democrats won the biggest election sweep since Richard Nixon’s Watergate crimes were exposed, but the feeling of dread that hangs over America doesn’t show any sign of lifting.
After all, Trump—who now calls himself “Mr. Veto”—will still be president for two more years, and Democrats are still well short of the two-thirds it’ll take to override him.
His masked secret police are still terrorizing and murdering American citizens and immigrants on our streets with absolutely no accountability, and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) continues to build and buy concentration camps where people are being tortured, dying, and being killed on an almost weekly basis.
Democrats are giddy about demanding Trump and his cronies and family “preserve their papers,” but Republicans destroyed things last time around with no consequence whatsoever.
They’re looking forward to subpoenas to drag Republicans and corrupt businesspeople before Congress, but conventional wisdom says that enforcing those subpoenas will depend on Todd Blanche’s Department of Justice, and last time around the DOJ also refused to hold Attorney General Bill Barr and Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross in criminal contempt for refusing to show up and testify at all.
This month White House counsel William Scharf, asked whether the administration will comply with subpoenas from the incoming Congress, answered, “It depends.” Trump’s now ordered every federal agency to get his personal permission before anybody testifies, and the Justice Department reportedly told the nation’s US attorneys to take a “wartime” stance against Democrats asking questions or wanting to see files (including the Epstein files).
Much of the doomsday feeling people are expressing when they call into my show or discuss this in the media is the result of our living through a convergence of crises instead of simply any single one.
If we wimp out again, if Congress flinches, if we wait years to prosecute Republican criminals like Merrick Garland did, that the the doomsday feeling will come back stronger.
From grounded planes to Microsoft’s email to Workday’s payroll and Chase’s payments, even Trump’s incompetent Cabinet officials refuse to explain what’s happening with anything other than “trust us,” pablum-like assurances while Trump goes off to kiss Russian President Vladimir Putin’s ass and suck up to Xi Jinping in China as both continue to help Russia murder Ukrainians and American troops in the Gulf.
The federal government that’s protected us at home and defended democracy around the world for our lifetimes was gutted by the world’s richest man—more than 256,000 federal workers are now out of a job—and only 49% of Americans can reliably afford healthcare we need.
Roughly 80% of Americans are worried AI will cost them their or their children’s jobs; 33 countries are advising their citizens to stockpile food and water; at the same time Trump, his boys, and his son-in-law have screwed MAGA followers out of over $2.3 billion in crypto.
This has left Americans wondering who’s in charge of this country, and to whose benefit it’s now being run. Pew found 69% of us don’t think our democracy works anymore, and Gallup says only 28% of us believe corrupt American politicians or judges will ever be held accountable to the law.
Somebody is in charge, though, and they been at it for almost 50 years, draining dry the middle class while producing a bumper crop of right-wing oligarchs; the morbidly rich have never had it so good. As Jimmy Carter told me on my program over a decade ago, America is now more an oligarchy than a democratic republic.
And that’s both the danger and the opportunity.
As I lay out in The Hidden History of American Oligarchy, oligarchy is always a transitional form of government, rarely lasting more than two generations, because sooner or later the people get tired of being robbed and rise up, demanding their democracy back.
At that point the oligarchs face a binary choice: Back down, as they did when Franklin Roosevelt faced them down in the 1930s, or they bring down the iron fist the way Putin and Turkish President Recip Tayyip Erdoğan did.
With his National Security Presidential Memorandum-7 and ICE, Trump is clearly trying for the Iron Fist; as Stephen Miller recently said, eerily echoing Stalin and Goebbels:
We live in a world in which you can talk all you want about international niceties and everything else. But we live in a world, in the real world... that is governed by strength, that is governed by force, that is governed by power. These are the iron laws of the world.
Back in 1967, psychologist Martin Seligman found that if you gave dogs a painful electric shock and simultaneously prevented them from moving to escape it, they eventually stopped trying to get away but simply laid down and whimpered. He called it “learned helplessness.”
I’d argue that’s where the elected Republicans have been for at least the past decade, and perhaps longer.
On the other hand, almost 50 years later he argued that passivity in the face of pain is a “default” of the brain—the way a possum will play dead—but that a more important thing for humans is learned optimism and learned self-empowerment, the result of taking positive actions. They’re far more powerful, he argues in his latest book Agency, than learned helplessness.
We’ve been violently “shocked” for the better part of the last two years, and more mildly but consistently hit with corruption, theft, lies that got us into wars, and the GOP gutting the middle class for at least 45 years.
But there was also a time, between 1933 and 1981, when we picked ourselves up, dusted ourselves off from the Republican Great Depression, and learned agency, took power, and did great things.
We did it in union halls, by breaking up monopolies, by taxing the morbidly rich, and holding corporate and political criminals alike to account. And it appears, with this last election, that we’re on the road—perhaps a 2-year-long road—to doing that again.
Starting January 3, Trump can’t veto a hearing, can’t get a single judge confirmed without the consent of a Senate where Democrats will hold 56 seats, and can’t lawfully spend a dollar that Congress doesn’t appropriate.
It’s even possible—if Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) and either Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) or Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) find the backbone—for Congress to rediscover its own inherent contempt power to send its sergeant-at-arms to arrest a witness who defies it, a power that’s sat unused for 90 years.
Seligman’s research offers us both hope and a warning.
Hope that if we push our leaders hard enough, if they stand up strong enough, we can defeat the oligarchy the ways FDR, Abraham Lincoln, and George Washington and Thomas Jefferson did in each of the previous 80-year cycles of American history.
And a warning that if we wimp out again, if Congress flinches, if we wait years to prosecute Republican criminals like Merrick Garland did, that the the doomsday feeling will come back stronger: This is obviously something the would-be Republican strongmen like Trump, Vice President JD Vance, Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio), et al. are counting on it.
So reach out to your state attorneys general—who, as Christopher Armitage points out, have considerable power that’s to this day been largely unused—and your elected officials in DC and demand that they stand up to the bullies and fascists and thieves.
Assert your power as a citizen!
And find things close to home—a school board, a union drive, a food bank, where you can watch your own effort change an outcome—because that’s where our own personal power gets, as Seligman noted, learned again.
If this helped you make sense of what you’ve been feeling, please share it with somebody who’s been feeling it too. And if you aren’t yet a subscriber to The Hartmann Report I hope you’ll become one, because this work only happens with the support of readers like you.
We have spent sufficient time studying the problem of caregiving in America and praising the heroic work of family caregivers. The current moment demands strong action not words or gestures.
The odds are good that if you have an older adult in your family, you have seen the recent Saturday Night Live skit on caregiving. For those who have not seen the SNL segment, The New York Times provides an apt summary:
The “S.N.L." sketch was basically the funny version of a study published in the American Sociological Review by Angelina Grigoryeva of the University of Toronto. She showed that daughters spend 14 hours a month, on average, caring for parents, compared with six hours for sons. Sons provide less care if they have sisters, and daughters provide more if they have brothers rather than sisters. And daughters are more likely than sons to provide care even if it conflicts with their work or childcare demands.
The SNL sketch hit a nerve among so many Americans because it highlighted gender inequities that we certainly need to address. It also focuses a spotlight on a glaring inadequacy in our healthcare system. Medicare does not cover long-term care. It covers only short-term care such as that needed when recovering from a stroke. Far too many Americans are unaware of what Medicare will cover. In 2022 research by the Kaiser Family Foundation found that “...23% of adults—rising to 45% of those ages 65 and older—assume that Medicare would pay the bill for their own or a loved one’s time in a nursing home if they had a long-term illness or disability.”
Medicaid, the state and local program for low-income people, does cover long-term care including nursing homes. However, to qualify for Medicaid there are often long waiting lists and you must spend down your assets.
How many people provide unpaid care to family and friends? Research from the Kaiser Family Foundation on November 19 shows that:
The bottom line here is that we have a caregiving crisis that needs to be addressed. Just as we had a retirement income crisis in the 1930s that lead to Social Security and a healthcare crisis that resulted in the enactment of Medicare, we need bold action at the federal level to address the caregiving crisis.
During her 2024 presidential campaign, Vice President Kamala Harris proposed a new home health benefit for Medicare called “Medicare at Home.” Under her plan “Medicare will cover home care for the first time ever for all of our nation’s seniors and those with disabilities on Medicare who need it, in addition to vision and hearing benefits to help seniors live independently for longer.” For his part, then former President Trump supported protecting seniors by "'shifting resources back to at-home Senior Care,' addressing disincentives that contribute to workforce shortages, and supporting unpaid family caregivers through tax credits.”
In the current Congress, Sen. Andy Kim (D-NJ) and Congresswoman Debbie Dingell (D-MIich. have introduced the Medicare At Home Act, which would:
...establish long-term care services benefits as part of the Medicare program. The Medicare At Home Act would help older adults and people with disabilities remain safely in their homes and communities by expanding home care coverage under Medicare Part B. Medicare Part B usually covers doctor visits and everyday medical care; this bill would also cover in-home support so people don’t have to leave their homes.
Now, the question that comes up at this point is: How are we going to pay for this new Medicare benefit? Before considering this question, it is important to note that the United States supports its caregivers far less than other countries. The United States falls behind most other wealthy countries in its support for caregivers. According to the Organization for Economic Development and Cooperation (OECD), the United States spends 1.3% of its gross domestic product on caregiving, which compares poorly with countries like the Netherlands (4.1%), Belgium (3.1%), and the United Kingdom (2.6%).
The Commonwealth Foundation points out that there are several potential ways of funding a new Medicare benefit: general revenues, payroll taxes, premiums, or co-payments. This will no doubt be an intense discussion, and there are hard choices to be made. Part of this debate should include why there is always enough money for wars but not enough to take care of those most precious to us.
We have spent sufficient time studying the problem of caregiving in America and praising the heroic work of family caregivers. The current moment demands strong action not words or gestures. Sen. Kim and Rep. Dingle have boldly moved the debate forward. Hopefully, when the new Congress convenes in January of 2027, caregiving will be a top issue.
It's not too late, but we must act. We owe this fight to the people already living through the crisis, to the young people whose futures are being decided in these rooms, and to those who will inherit the consequences of what we do here.
I’m struggling to find the words for the sadness, heartbreak and disbelief I feel watching what is unfolding at COP31.
How is this possible?
Only recently, in Santa Marta, Colombia, governments, social movements, scientists, Indigenous peoples and frontline communities came together to confront the main driver of the climate emergency and ask how we move beyond fossil fuels.
For a moment, it felt as though the political courage might finally match the urgency of the science. And now, here we are. Panama is right to draw a line. If the final text contains no commitment to phase out fossil fuel production, no meaningful climate finance and no guarantee that electrification will be powered by renewables, Panama should formally object. I stand with Panama in taking that position, and I urge other governments to stand with them.
Nepal is being pushed to the point of walking out as powerful countries ignore the devastation its people have recently experienced. Fossil fuels have disappeared from the latest draft. Imagine Alcoholics Anonymous spending 30 years negotiating and producing a statement that never mentions alcohol. Now imagine the alcohol industry turning up as the largest delegation and helping shape the outcome.
We still have time to change the outcome. I’m asking the governments that came to Santa Marta, and every government that has promised to stand with frontline communities, to speak up now and insist that the COP31 outcome commits to a fast, fair and funded phase-out of fossil fuels.
Every year we delay phasing out coal, oil and gas locks in more harm for people already living through this crisis and leaves future generations with a more dangerous world. We are on course to exceed 1.5°C of long-term warming. Every fraction of a degree matters. How can governments claim to defend that goal while refusing to confront the continued production of the fuels pushing us beyond it?
The proposed commitment on adaptation finance has also disappeared. And we are still expected to call this progress. What are we to call a system in which those who have contributed least to the crisis suffer its worst consequences, while those with the greatest responsibility protect fossil fuel profits? Is this climate apartheid? What breaks my heart is that we know what is at stake. People are losing their homes, their livelihoods and their lives. Communities are struggling to hold on to places that have sustained their cultures for generations. Entire countries are fighting for their survival. And after Santa Marta, we are still negotiating away the very words we need to name the problem.
What does electrification achieve if we leave open the question of how it will be powered? How are countries supposed to deliver on their climate commitments without the finance to do so? How can we call it a just transition if we refuse to confront the continued production of the fuels driving the injustice? History will judge these talks by whose lives were protected, whose interests were defended and whose future was sacrificed.
We still have time to change the outcome. I’m asking the governments that came to Santa Marta, and every government that has promised to stand with frontline communities, to speak up now and insist that the COP31 outcome commits to a fast, fair and funded phase-out of fossil fuels.
And to our allies here at COP31, come in early, raise your voices and stand with the countries holding the line. We owe this fight to the people already living through the crisis, to the young people whose futures are being decided in these rooms, and to those who will inherit the consequences of what we do here.
There is still time to choose courage. Let’s use every hour we have.
Losing Florida’s Senate race is one of the biggest strategic fumbles this cycle, and we need to talk about it.
Three points. That is what stood between Angie Nixon and the United States Senate.
Florida has become a political blind spot for the Democratic Party. Losing Florida’s Senate race is one of the biggest strategic fumbles this cycle, and we need to talk about it.
The Senate Democrats’ lack of investment should be seen as an epic failure for a state that has one of the most diverse populations of working-class people who voted for real change in the state. This race is another reminder that we need new leadership. It reminds me so much of New York City's mayoral primary, where our now-mayor, a socialist, was written off by the Democratic establishment and ignored until voters sent a message that this was exactly what New Yorkers wanted: authentic change.
Angie Nixon and the organizers who powered her campaign demonstrated what was possible with limited resources. The national party should examine what more sustained investment might accomplish.
So how did we get here? Democrats have spent the better part of a decade writing Florida’s political obituary, with no vision for what Florida could be. After Hillary Clinton lost the state in 2016, national Democratic institutions began pulling back; donors looked elsewhere; and Florida became the state everyone talked about winning, but few were willing to invest in. Labor and community organizations had few resources but kept fighting.
Then came Angie Nixon, a generational candidate, a Black woman, a socialist with an affordability agenda. Her anti-corruption message resonated, and Floridians started to feel excited. Her campaign turned Florida upside down. The excitement her message generated made it a campaign to remember. With Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) fully invested, he provided resources and called other elected officials across the country, while Congresswoman AOC (D-NY) visited the state twice and sent money. And the numbers were striking. But Senate Democrats dropped the ball. It’s time they pick it back up and take some accountability for the fumble.
The contrast is staggering: Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-Ga.) had $135 million invested in his campaign, compared with just $16 million in Florida. That disparity is a travesty and says a lot about the national party’s priorities.
Angie Nixon came within three percentage points of defeating Republican Sen. Ashley Moody. She did it in a state Donald Trump carried by 13 points just two years ago, where Republicans enjoy a 1.5 million-voter registration advantage and where national Democrats largely refused to make the investments necessary to compete. The numbers are historic. She ran up the score in Miami-Dade County, where left-wing candidates are not wanted and moderate Democrats run the table.
November 3’s election should end the thinking that we should place safe bets on who we know will win. In fact, the left and others have been saying again and again that we need to play everywhere because, if you are not on offense, you are on defense. The American people want brawlers, and Angie delivered. We missed a once-in-a-decade opportunity to take Florida back, leaving Democratic voters looking out the window at what could have been. Imagine what could have happened if Democrats had treated Florida like a state worth fighting for. The Democratic establishment did not just leave the state to Republicans. They let their Democratic voters down. Working-class voters are looking for relief from Immigration and Customs Enforcement, skyrocketing gas prices, lack of reproductive access, and absolute corruption in their government.
I have spent years working on campaigns across the country, in particular organizing Latino voters. I’ve seen what happens when Democrats invest early, build relationships, and take communities seriously. We won in states like Nevada, Colorado, and New Mexico because we understood that voters cannot be cultivated in the final weeks of an election. And this time, Texas, where the state was considered a lost cause, was brought back by a coalition of Latino, Black, and rural voters. And that was because of a decade of investment.
The blind spot is also pronounced when looking at what Angie has done for the Democratic down-ballot races. Even in races such as Democratic Rep. Darren Soto’s, where he won by slim margins, Angie played a role. What was it that the Senate Dems were so darn scared of? The simple truth is that Democrats ignored the will of voters.
After 2016, the retreat became institutional. Instead of rebuilding the infrastructure needed to compete, Democratic committees and major donors increasingly treated Florida as a bad investment. That neglect compounded with every election cycle, leaving local organizers to do the work that national institutions should have been supporting.
And now, after the midterms, we have the results to show what that neglect has cost us.
Look at Miami-Dade County, which swung back toward Democrats after years of Republican gains. Nixon and Democratic gubernatorial nominee David Jolly both carried the county. In Black-majority precincts, Nixon won by more than 70 percentage points. She also carried white-majority neighborhoods, while Republicans' advantages in Hispanic-majority areas vanished.
In Miami-Dade’s Hispanic-majority precincts, Ron DeSantis won about 65% of the vote in 2022. On Tuesday, Byron Donalds won a little under 52%. That same kind of shift powered Democratic wins in Texas, North Carolina, and beyond. In Texas, Latino voters who swung toward Donald Trump two years ago helped James Talarico win a US Senate seat, ending Republicans’ 32-year run of statewide victories there. Nationally, NBC News exit polls showed Latino voters backing Democratic House candidates by 27 points.
Florida’s Puerto Rican community may be the clearest opportunity of all. Puerto Ricans voted for Nixon, David Jolly, and Democratic House candidates all by over 30 points, the largest margin among any Hispanic community in Florida based on preliminary precinct analysis. Democrats who were targeted by Republican redistricting all held on thanks to the votes of Florida’s Puerto Rican voters. And yet a pre-election N+ Univision/YouGov poll found that only 30% of Puerto Rican voters said anyone had asked them to register or vote, compared with roughly 4 in 10 other Latino voters. These voters want the types of change we saw last night in other states, but they need to be asked.
These results should force Democrats to reconsider some of their assumptions about Florida’s electorate.
Nixon wasn’t the candidate national Democrats expected. Her opponents insisted her positions would make her unelectable in Florida. But she proved that an unapologetic progressive, a democratic socialist, and a working-class mother could speak directly about housing, healthcare, childcare, and the cost of living and come so close to winning in Florida.
Instead, she received nearly 4 million votes and finished within three points of Moody. Her margin was also remarkably close to Jolly's, a former Republican who ran a more moderate campaign for governor.
The results do not prove that ideology alone determines electoral success. But they certainly challenge the assumption that Democrats must abandon progressive economic policies to compete in Florida.
The down-ballot results tell another important story.
Democrats broke the Republican supermajority in the Florida House. They made gains in local government, including winning control of the Hillsborough County Commission. Tiffany Moore Russell became Orange County’s first Black woman mayor.
These are not insignificant victories. They show organizing infrastructure that can be strengthened, expanded, and sustained.
And the lesson extends beyond Black voters.
For years, I’ve argued that Democrats cannot treat Latino voters as a monolith or expect a last-minute Spanish-language advertisement to substitute for meaningful engagement.
Housing costs, insurance premiums, healthcare expenses, and wages are not abstract political talking points. They determine whether working families can afford to remain in Florida.
The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, the Democratic Governors Association, and the national donor class need to answer a basic question: What would Florida look like today if they had invested consistently in these communities since 2016?
To be clear, Florida remains a difficult state for Democrats. Republicans control its major statewide offices, enjoy a substantial registration advantage, and have built a formidable political operation. No serious strategist should pretend otherwise. But difficulty is not impossibility.
Barack Obama won Florida twice. Democrats once enjoyed a substantial voter registration advantage. Those gains were built through investment and organizing, not wishful thinking. And now, with Moody facing voters again in 2028, Democrats have another opportunity to rebuild.
Every presidential candidate considering a 2028 run should study these results. Florida cannot remain an afterthought, visited for fundraising while its organizers struggle for resources. Are Democrats finally willing to make the long-term investments necessary to compete?
Angie Nixon and the organizers who powered her campaign demonstrated what was possible with limited resources. The national party should examine what more sustained investment might accomplish. The saddest part is that millions of Florida Democrats have been let down by the wave that could have been.
Florida didn’t become Republican overnight. And rebuilding Democratic strength won’t happen overnight either.
But if Democrats spend the next two years repeating the mistakes of the last decade, they shouldn’t be surprised by the results. It was a blue wave, but Democrats need to make amends and take accountability for all Floridians. Democrats must no longer view Florida as a political blind spot, but as a key strategy to win in 2028 and beyond.