EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- One American Who Isn't For Sale
- Edward Snowden: Saving Us from the United Stasi of America
- Major Loss to Organic Farmers as Court Rules in Favor of Monsanto
- The Judicial Lynching of Bradley Manning
- Remembering Satyajit Ray’s Hirok Rajar Deshe: On Edward Snowden, Resistance and Inverted Totalitarianism
Popular content
Today's Top News
Pretending to be Civilized in an Epidemic of Institutional Sadism
From the you-can't-be-serious department: Savana Redding was a 13-year-old honors student at a small Arizona middle school. In math class one morning the principal ordered her to pack up and follow him to his office. The principal interrogated her about a planner Savana had lent a friend, and a few ibuprofin pills sitting on the principal's desk, which were found in the planner. Savana knew nothing about the pills.
The principal then ordered her to the nurse's office for a strip search. Over ibuprofin pills. Not that it would make a difference if she were carrying crack. She was 13. She was being ordered to strip. Her parents were never notified. Savana did not consent to the search but complied in humiliating details. She was forced, literally, to shake her bra and her underwear, exposing herself in front of the nurse and an assistant. Nothing was found. I don't know what's more perverse: The principal's zero-tolerance stupidity over ibuprofin pills, the degrading search, or the fact that nine U.S. Supreme Court justices will hear this case next month to decide what limits, if any, there should be on school authority.
But this isn't authority. It's criminal abuse -- of authority, of the child, of human dignity. How do we come to this? Stupid question, considering the accumulating record of a society where ideals of justice and humaneness mix with the basest controls in the name of discipline and order. They're close relatives, those school officials who order a 13 year old strip searched, to those who have children Tasered, or to police officers who now use that instrument of torture as a routine means of subjugation, or to prison guards who do the same with restraining chairs. When the barbaric becomes routine, it's called protocol. What should be denounced and forbidden is accepted and debated.
The distance has vanished from there to a government so willing to torture, and a public so willing to implicitly accept that dissolution of principles, if it's willing to debate it. "Why can't we send them to be tortured?" George W. Bush had wondered about terrorism suspects in the early days of his war, according to a new book by Patrick Tyler, The New York Times' chief diplomatic correspondent. "Stick something up their ass!" Bush got his wish in the by-now familiar litany of terrorist behavior in the name of fighting terrorism -- torture and rendition, secret prisons, Guantanamo, Abu Ghraib, the systematic policy of brutality approved from the top that muscled up the wars' enforcers.
That's all revolting enough. But it's all been offshore, an outsourcing of depravity over there so we wouldn't have to be depraved over here -- the unspoken parallel to Bush's dismal rationale of "fighting terrorists over there so we wouldn't have to fight them over here." That's assuming that depravity can be so neatly segregated so the rest of us can go about our civilized pretensions untroubled. But those excesses weren't exceptions. They were variations on everyday norms at home that made them possible.
Abu Ghraib was bad. Our domestic prison system is worse, from the unspoken torture of the solitary confinement of thousands (as The New Yorker's Atul Gawande argues in the current issue) to the stunning yet apathy inducing fact that 7.3 million Americans are in prison, on parole or under probation. It's a $47 billion-a-year industry, the opposite of "corrections," that exceeds China's entire military budget. Can that many Americans be so disproportionately more lawless than any other people on earth? On its face, the answer is no. Americans aren't. Their criminal justice system is -- the same system, unique in the world, that imprisons 13 year olds for life, carries out executions by conveyor belt (an average of 60 a year since 2000) and turns petty marijuana inhalers into felons swelling prison cells and budget deficits.
There is no off-shoring of these betrayals of civilized behavior, no way to segregate them from what we are as a culture and what we've made possible, abroad or in our own justice system and Taser-charged streets, and even our zero-tolerant schools, as Savana and many like her find out every day.
In "Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home," the crew of the Enterprise travels back from the 23rd century to 1986 America, either to save the planet or save the whales. There's a wonderful scene toward the end where Captain Kirk, Spock and Dr. McCoy are trying to save Chekov from the claws of 20th century health care. Dr. McCoy can't believe the hospital's wards of barbarism. To a woman on dialysis: "Dialysis? What is this, the dark ages? Here, swallow one of these." Chemotherapy? "Sounds like the (expletive) Spanish Inquisition." One of these days, I hope not so far as the 23rd century, we'll look back on this decade's epidemic of institutional sadism with as much horror as Dr. McCoy looked at 20th century medicine.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...



31 Comments so far
Show AllIf you want to know what I think, which maybe nobody does, but if you do, I think it all started when TOO many people thought themselves TOO self-important to work at anything that might get their hands dirty and their muscles sore. Thus, technical civilization and arrogance were born, and technical civilization and arrogance go hand-in-hand. And this is what-we-have-today in the Empire, that some erroneously still call America.
This hyper-technical civilization and arrogance will be our DOOM.
good article. most americans will probably not have to face such institutional abuse, but institutional indifference can be nightmarish as well. ("what? the city towed your car by mistake? too effin' bad.")
and we all just accept it. the docility of the average american in the face of the enormous crimes being committed and day to day humiliations and insecurities is really quite astounding.
our educational system is a marvel to behold. and, failing that, there is always prison. like that simpsons' episode where, to make up for the budget, the school rents out space to the local prison. school/prison? same thing.
school...prison...military....well said tristam.
I've always enjoyed your wisdom because you go right to the heart of the matter. Thank you for being there.
I just read this and I believe many here will enjoy this gem of truth:
http://www.rense.com/general85/forgetitjake.htm
Thanks for sharing ShadowDancer.
A particular civilization has a context, often created by the other civilizations around it.
Long gone are the days of hunting, fishing, and just pretty much camping out upon Creator's earth.
...
Long gone are the days of the Tribes & now the modern day Roman Empire is here.
...
Ah, that was then & this is now. Time sure flys when your having fun.
Sometimes, things don't change fast enough :-). You see, I am vegan - I do not hunt nor fish, etc., and I await the day that my brethren realize that they do not need to interfere in the lives of the individual members of other animal communities. We can let them be and live well too.
Wasn't it Gandhi who, when asked what he thought about Western civilization, replied, "I think it would be a good idea." ?
how about the five year old detained for hours for being on the no fly list
http://boingboing.net/2008/01/10/another-fiveyearold.html
when his mother hugged him because he was crying they strip searched them both for the second time because the toddler may have passed important security information during the hug
this is not funny
there are more than i million names on the no fly list and even the most uneducated paranoid sheeple living in his bomb shelter basement hoping the rapture comes this week - even nuts like that don't think a million names is right - but there you go
senator kennedy is on the list
as are may congressmen an senators
let's not forget the millions of people we have killed in this fictional, corporate media produced war on terror
talk about uncivilized - talk abut barbaric
keep in mind that homeland security was written prior to 9/11
what about the three trillion dollars that the pentagon had stolen - if you recall the psycho rumsfeld on 9/10/01 announced the pentagon was three trillion short on their accounting books
the next day 9/11 we have the tv show at the wtc and poof - we never hear about the three trillion again
man, those 19 saudis with their box cutters couldn't have attacked america at a better time
the air defense stands down, fake pilots do top gun flying, buildings turn into dust, the plane at the pentagon crams itself into a 20 hole before completely disintegrating
what an unbelievably lucky break for the bushco
what are the odds
back to sleep sheeple - we have american idol and dancing with the stars this week and i hear these episodes are laden with fun, excitement and some pretty darn good dancing
we know that obama is on the case with the support and love of both kissinger and brzezinski
have a good nap - don't forget to take your medications
I tremble every day sending my 12 y/o kid off to school because 'the authorities' truly are nitwits not to be trusted. We see that all over our society these days, don't we?
smipypr
Zero tolerance = innumerable tyrants
"Institutional Sadism" has operated in the USA since its inception--one need only look at the institutions of Slavery and Indian Removal. Added to those institutions was the concept of Total War, first tested on the inhabitants of the South by Sherman and now implemented by drone aircraft in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Becoming a civilized human means mastering one's Dark Side. Governments are mere reflections of the people running them, and the US government's barbaric behavior over many decades speaks volumes about the quality of the citizenry it employs.
. . . nine U.S. Supreme Court justices will hear this case next month to decide what limits, if any, there should be on school authority.
Dateline: The Supreme Court. In a separate opinion, Justice Antonin "Nino" Scalia said the school should have shot the student in question out of hand. "Ibuprofen is a gateway drug; the next step is heroin addiction", he wrote. Justice Clarence "Pubic Hair" Thomas said the student should not only have been shot but the corpse subsequently burned and hung from the chain link fence in front of the school.
Institutionalized sadism is common. Most people who have dealt with the legal system have an opinion on this issue. Please read what happened in Vermont - and things like this happen all the time.
http://www.pressaction.com/news/weblog/full_article/jackowski01252006/
There was indeed a reason why corporal punishment was banished from schools.
1st step is to admit that people who are sadist are wanting to be jail keepers.
In the last decade they have all come out of the closet and feeling free to practice S&M in USA. Plenty of career opportunity was presented by El Presidente and his cabal in the name of patriotism and protection. Fees paid for this service with our tax dollars.
Forgiveness and compassion is opposite of jail keepers. We have to choose.
toophat for you!
"In 'Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home,' the crew of the Enterprise travels back from the 23rd century to 1986 America, either to save the planet or save the whales. There's a wonderful scene toward the end where Captain Kirk, Spock and Dr. McCoy are trying to save Chekov from the claws of 20th century health care. Dr. McCoy can't believe the hospital's wards of barbarism. To a woman on dialysis: 'Dialysis? What is this, the dark ages? Here, swallow one of these.' Chemotherapy? 'Sounds like the (expletive) Spanish Inquisition.' One of these days, I hope not so far as the 23rd century, we'll look back on this decade's epidemic of institutional sadism with as much horror as Dr. McCoy looked at 20th century medicine."
LOL. I'm a only casual Trekkie, but I've always loved this movie and fondly remember those scenes with Bones in the hospital. He stole the movie. Then they're trying to run out of the hospital with Chekov and the formerly infirm little old lady on dialysis is celebrating her newfound health.
They wonder why people are afraid to go to the doctor or dentist, why animals are afraid of the vet.
I liked that movie, too. I believe one of the crew (Kirk?) also expressed surprised that we got out of the 20th Century. We did, but are we going to get out of the 21st Century?
We are a country of neighborhoods. And Arizona Sucks-It is marked by PERVASIVE bigotry, hatred and a mentality that idolizes guns, jails, locking people up, and John McCain if I recall. Go to prison for years for growing a little weed.
But a bored redneck can pull his pick-up into a gas station in Northern Arizona and fill up, buy a 12 gauge Remington pump & Ammo, a half-gallon of Jack Daniels & hit the road!
How many Arizona Rednecks does it take to eat coyote?
Two. One to get down on his knees and pig out, the other to watch for cars.
That the principal doing this to a 13 year old is enough to make my blood boil. The sad part in all of this is people keep saying "Ah, well torture cases don't matter. They do them there so they won't do them here." Yet, this article just proved the opposite. Oh, they'll torture innocent Iraqis over there alright but that doesn't stop domestic terrorism and abuse such as what the principal had done to the 13 year old. And the author makes an excellent point on outsourcing. In the 19th century, slave labor was so visible that it lead to the Civil War. Yet, today's slavery is not so obvious that most people will sit in ignorance about it unless their job is lost or is on the line. In fact, a coworker of mine who struggled to turn his 3-6 month contract positions into permanent jobs for two years found out that every time his job was outsourced for nothing. Even his best friends would laugh at him and say "Oh well, that's business. Sorry but in this world there are winners and there are losers. Maybe you're just not working hard enough." He was working very hard actually and I was in tears when he told me about how even his fiancee left him even as he was struggling to secure a job because she thought that she was doing great with her job for 4 years but that somehow he wasn't and she even mocked at his stressed out looks and told him "Sorry sweetie but nobody wants to marry a bald loser !" From childhood to adulthood, the system is so screwed up that the perpetrators get rewarded while even the hardest working victims get punished even when it wasn't their fault of their own. This is another reason that I fear that America is heading towards a greater depression because as history has shown, the Great Depression was about the only time people actually came together to help one another and all these individual weaknesses exploitations were minimized.
Your friend was very lucky to get jilted by a total asshole who maybe was good looking on the outside but a monster on the inside.
Don't worry about all the "losers and winners" meme that so many people spout. It's a cop out. They are scared shitless and don't have the integrity to admit it so they put on a cheap act. There are plenty of "real" people out there. If you are surrounded by B movie actors playing the "greed is IT" role, I suggest you find other friends because those "friends" you have are parasites that will suck the life out of you for money or power.
"Don't worry about all the "losers and winners" meme that so many people spout. It's a cop out. They are scared shitless and don't have the integrity to admit it so they put on a cheap act. There are plenty of "real" people out there."
I was always thinking along those lines somewhere but you framed it very well and with humour to put them to shame. I'll keep that quote in mind. Thank you. :)
"If you are surrounded by B movie actors playing the "greed is IT" role, I suggest you find other friends because those "friends" you have are parasites that will suck the life out of you for money or power."
That's exactly why I'd never concede into risking a bad marriage. In another post (see my responses to the article http://www.commondreams.org/view/2009/03/28-3), I discussed my almost conceding to being a slave wife and yes I'm well aware of parasites who pretend to be "friends" and I thank this site, Alternet, and the progressive/liberal sites for giving us the basic alerts in life about these things.
You are welcome and good for you. Things won't always be this bad. Good luck to you.
Good riddance to that fiancee. The only good thing about misfortune is that it shows you who your true friends are.
Joe
A society without any standard but the requirement to always obey authority figures is dysfunctional. Cognitive dissonance paralyzes social interaction and productive innovation. This benefits legacy institutions owned by very rich individuals that don't want any change in the status quo. Eventually even the rich get caught up in the maelstrom of social fiber destruction that comes about. Sharks in a feeding frenzy bite and kill each other by mistake. We are there now. The frenzy of greed breeds the worst reactions from those in power. All these labels describing the "isms" for all this destructive behavior are symptoms of major decay. The rich have no idea what they have unleashed. These stupid bastards really believed they could corral and coerce all the people all the time. It's the old pipe dream from the ivory towers. They never learn.
And another charming feature of "zero-tolerance" approaches-- which by definition are draconian, rigid, and authoritarian-- is that they undermine such courage, independence, and flexibility that an adminstrator might have in the first place.
That is, while a degree of sadism or lust for power may be an occupational hazard to which many school officials yield, there are also decent teachers and administrators who recognize and oppose the pettiness and general outrage of children being victimized by zero-tolerance administration.
But the administrator either goes along and takes the "easy out" of administering harsh sanctions because his or her "hands are tied" by rigid mandatory proscriptions, or expresses dissent that makes said administrator Intolerable to the system.
So, just as in our political system, incumbents are rewarded for fecklessness and conformity.
· Yr Obd't Servant
I am in strong agreement with Mr. Tristam. As he points out, our collective tolerance of torture has rippled throughout our culture. A recent example of how our putatively just criminal justice system has become corroded, is the case of those two juvenile court judges in, I think, Georgia. The gained control of the court budget, which paid for juvenile detention. Then they shut down the county-owned juvie detention center and began to funnel all juveniles with sentences to a privately-owned and run detention center that actually paid the judges for each child (juvenile offenders are children, let's keep this in mind) the judges sent to prison. (calling it a detention center makes it sound a little soft but it is a juvenile prison).
The juvenile court in this county quickly became known for imposing the strictest sentences possible on all juvenile offenders. The crooked judges had daily goals, making certain they filled their quota of incarcerated children so they would get their kickbacks.
Those judges are slime, yes. And each of them are individually culpable for what they did. But there is no question in my mind that these jduges were able to exist -- and persevere with their hideous crimes -- because our large culture has deteriorating values. These scumbag judges performed right in front of the justice community where they lived. Some juvenile advocates tried to challenge them but the judges controlled everything and shut every effort to contain them down.
This juvenile court judicial scandal/crime would not have been possible if we (all of us carry some of this burden) had not tolerated the blatant abuse of what used to be our values. Once our government started torturing, we were all infected.
Keep up the good work, Mr. Tristam.
The indicent you relate occurred here in Pennsylvania. The railroaded a massive number of kids this way, without attorneys in many cases even though the kids were definitely legally allowed one but told they weren't. The two main offencers, the two judges, got 7 year prison sentences. They should have gotten life. How many totally innocent people are in prison today, serving long sentences, because of other judges doing exactly the same kinds of things? Death would have been too good for those two assholes. The sent kids to jail for doing things as insignificant as mocking a school principal on a web page. So don't mock any local tin horn public official if you want to stay out of jail in AmeriKKKKKa today.
reading thru the comments made me wonder about pierre t's conclusion. interesting that the person 2ND most likely to cause your death, after yourself (thru "lifestyle" issues like smoking), is YOUR DOCTOR or HOSPITAL or other health care provider.
(at least per this article:http://www.counterpunch.com/goekler03242009.html)
more institutional neglect and indifference....
Coaches become principals and are in charge of the schools. The typical coach is gross and insensitive with narrow intellectual capacity, yet America loves it's coaches. Coaches have sex with students regularly so it should be no surprise that one was strip searched. Schools are made into little hells when coaches are placed in control. The culture of coach run schools are akin to little gestapos.
Torture does not commence in a vacuum. For it to become an organ of State policy, as it seems to have, people in government must first conceive of the idea - in other words to visualize it, or conceptualize the practice in other ways, before then giving the go ahead for torture to be carried out. This pre-supposes a sado-masochistic mindset. This mindset partly comes about through suppressed anger, but politically in the need to reinforce the top to bottom hierarchical system in its most potent manifestations. This psychology is easily recognizable from the Bush/Cheney/Blair triumvirate and the way they enforced motifs onto society whilst in power. Until the root cause of the need for the masses to vote into power individuals who will given them the satisfaction of seeing this kind of politico-psychological sado-masochism being played out in the national and international arena, the problem will not go away, or not entirely. First, each person who votes (or influenced the political system) must try to understand the 'other' and not live through fear and anger, in other words, to think and act responsibly - and thus stop empowering the 'crazies' to anarchically plunge the world into war, economic destruction, environmental catastrophe and the starvation of vast masses of humanity. Torture is the sharp end of a truly sick mindset, and it is this mindset which must be cured.
Good to see the "sadism" word proximately displayed here and in Chris Hedges' recent piece calling for a "moral bailout". If a critical mass can keep the sadomasochistic character dance in main focus the bars to the cage the collective is trapped in can further come into vision (egad! am I one of the bars?!); then of course the location of the lock can appear...allowing for formation of the key to begin...
As intimated by other commentators here the sadomasochistic relationship pervades all strata of human social structures, whether macro or micro - it's the true March of Madness, and breaking it's spell the real Big Dance. Hmm...maybe it's time to review how Joseph McCarthy was reined in - Good Night and Good Luck to All.
American schools are all surrounded by fences. The children are locked in for their "protection", thanks to insanely promiscuously gun laws by people who think that people without guns would be able to kill people as readily as a lunatic holding a couple of automatic pistols. The same firearm promiscuity, and 'zero tolerance' in drug laws, has put weapons & money in the hands of the powers now giving Gauleiter Napolitano all the moral indignation she needs to continue to fuel that problem.