EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- Corporate Win: Supreme Court Says Monsanto Has 'Control Over Product of Life'
- How the US Turned Three Pacifists into Violent Terrorists
- Cornel West: Obama 'Is a War Criminal'
- In 'March Toward Disaster,' World Hits 400 PPM Milestone
- Revealed: How US State Department 'Twists Arms' on Monsanto's Behalf
Popular content
Today's Top News
Three Strikes Against Apple
There's too much blood on its phones, laptops, and tablets.
In college, I considered my Apple laptop a faithful, effective, and occasionally even fun machine. A year past graduation, this constant companion to late nights spent studying, working, or wasting time has aged into a decrepit device. Like the old Windows hourglass, its colorful pinwheel cursor consistently heralds interminable delays.
Similarly, my prehistoric mobile phone frequently freezes, drops calls, or prematurely runs out of battery power. Even in those treasured moments when it operates at capacity, it lacks the touch screen, email, and Internet capabilities today's savvy consumers supposedly demand. By all indications, I'm ripe for an upgrade to a new MacBook, iPhone, or iPad.
Here's why I'm taking a pass.
Apple, like most other electronics companies, makes liberal use of an ore called columbite-tantalite — widely known as coltan — whose electrical retention properties improve the battery lives of electronic devices. While Australia is the world's largest coltan producer, suppliers for Apple and its competitors often prefer to buy their coltan at lower cost from mining operations in war-ravaged eastern Congo.
The money from these transactions rarely reaches the miners themselves. Rather, it's funneled to Rwandan- and Ugandan-backed rebel groups inside the Congo who control the mines and use the revenues to fund their operations in the world's deadliest conflict since World War II. Promises by the Congolese government to shutter such mines and by Apple to scrutinize its supply chains have rung ineffectual and hollow.
This "blood coltan" and other components make their way to China, where contractors assemble products for Apple and virtually every other major electronics company. Journalist and playwright Mike Daisey visited the Shenzhen, China base of operations for Foxconn, a Taiwanese manufacturing behemoth who reportedly assembles half of the world's electronics.
He reported interviewing workers who often labored for anywhere from 12 to 16 hours straight or longer, standing interminably and finding little compensation for the inevitable health problems and unpaid overtime that result from such treatment. He also met dozens of child laborers, who often lived with their coworkers in cramped company dormitories under constant surveillance for any hint of complaint or worker organization.
The facility made news last year for a ghastly streak of worker suicides. Today's Foxconn employees are mildly better compensated, but they must agree to sign "no-suicide" pacts with the company — although the complex now features a network of "suicide nets," just in case.
Finally, inside the United States, where Apple reaps the benefits of America's taxpayer-funded physical and legal infrastructure — and makes billions off U.S. consumers — the company has lent its support to the ironically named "Win America" campaign.
Supported by several other tax-dodging corporations, Apple is lobbying Congress to let the company repatriate and keep some $4 billion in profits currently stashed in offshore tax havens. This is money that would otherwise be owed to the U.S. government. At a moment of fiscal austerity, when Congress and state legislatures are gutting programs that assist our most vulnerable citizens, Apple — like all corporations and billionaires that have benefited handsomely from the U.S. system — should pay its fair share.
Industry analysts have estimated the total production costs for iPhones and iPads at a small fraction of the company's revenues, especially in light of those lucrative monthly contracts and endless "app" sales. Apple can hardly argue that such abusive practices are necessary to its bottom line. But even if they were, do you really want blood on your phone, laptop, or tablet?
Apple, of course, makes any number of innovative products. But being an innovator in technology shouldn't require being a reactionary on human rights — or being a shameless tax cheat. As an industry leader with ballooning profit margins, Apple can afford to get its coltan from Australia. It can shoulder the costs of a living wage and basic labor standards for its workers. And it can surely pay its taxes.
But for now, Apple has perpetuated the relentless violence in the Congo, abused hard-working and disenfranchised laborers in China, and, for good measure, sought to stiff the American taxpayers who have made it so wealthy.
Sorry, Apple. That's three strikes.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


24 Comments so far
Show AllHmmm . . . IBM's crimes are far worse. Apple is rising on my shit list "with a bullet." HP is on the Boycott Israel list.
So where do I get a computer? Is there a greener, more loving/caring option?
Good question. But your question has deeper meaning than just (green) product availability.
The issue of your question "So where do I get a computer" draws attention to the limits of "lifestyle activism." Your consumer choices can't buy your way out of this problem. It can't make you "pure."
The problem of the exploitation and violence related to the manufacture of all computers is inherent, not to computers, but to capitalism itself. The answer is not to become a Luddite. The answer is to end a system for which exploitation and violence is a NATURAL outcome of the drive to maximize profits and externalize costs.
Your question also points to the naivete of the article's assumed premise: that Apple - ever was - a "good" company, a good capitalist. There's no such thing. Apple may make a good product, but that is a different issue.
Good post Tom Larsen. If we had to boycott every product that depends on mistreatment of workers, including children, and anti-democratic practices, we would buy almost nothing. No clothes, no shoes, no food, no computers (as they all use coltan). Trapped in cities as most of us are, the best we can do with lifestyle activism is target the worst of the worst and make some energy saving choices such as to take public transportation where available. And keep using your old stuff as long as possible.
Right.
So, people should not think of themselves as superior to others, or be blaming people for, not driving a Prius, or not living off-the-grid, or not buying organic, or becoming a vegan etc. None of the aforementioned will change the way capital behaves; THAT, is what we should be organizing around, not whether you bike to work. Lifestyle activism is a form of liberalism: it doesn't challenge the system.
Nicely put. Short of global revolution against the capitalist system it's not sure what other solution there is to this. Glad to see a thread debunking the consumer-choice activism that one runs into a lot on this website.
Apple has been evil since they sanded IC numbers off the chips in the old Apple II so no one could service them. Microsoft has been evil since they stole the look and feel of Digital Research's CP/M operating system and sold it to IBM as DOS. Nothing about computers is very nice, but you can limit your damage by avoiding resource intensive portable devices and buying a STANDARD desktop machine made by a local system builder. For example, when its power supply dies, a new one costs around $20. The same thing, deliberately ordered non-standard by HP or Dell, et. al., can cost $200. If you need more software capability, there are open-source alternatives, and naturally you can always do the nasty and ignore the End User License Agreement of any software you might "acquire" by other means. Your system builder knows these things, and can help you. He needs to eat too, and lives in your town. He can do much more than Dell’s Indian call center. All of the corporations selling hardware and software are evil. ALL OF THEM. Your task is to minimize this. Try to keep some of the profit in your local economy. Try not to consume garbage (like laptops) that have a very short design life, unless you really, absolutely require them. Leave your animated postage stamp, disguised as a phone/pad/tablet in the store, and enjoy something real. I love computers. I also love cats. I really don’t need three hundred of either, thank you very much. MINIMIZE your footprint. I have never found a computer in a dumpster that was not repairable or at least partially useful in some way. Most work if simply plugged in. Americans have to be the stupidest and most wasteful creatures in the world. When there is no more resource to build toys, we won’t be in a strong position. Resource has to be used for survival, helping fellow symbiotic terrestrial organisms, and planning for the future, not pissed away for no reason. Information should not be sold, or used as a weapon.
What did Hp do?
They used to make really good test equipment and actually innovated. Now they are merely another name on a metal sticker selling mostly cheapened Foxconn stuff. Why bother? Electronics has always been a scam. The problem is now worse than I ever imagined in my wildest nightmare. Google "Madman Muntz" and picture the same horror on steroids. The cheap rubbish of the 1950's and 60's at least lasted a few years. Much of the electronic fecal slime made today has a lifetime of months, if it even works at all. You never see the waste that does not make it to the customer. Just say NO to crap you don't really need.
Simply deny the inital sale! Get one year old or so on Craigs List noone needs the newist and greatist, unless you need it to impress the ladies, or boss! The same x86 standard has been used for 30yrs is still the base of every computer sold today. So buying a yr old used one doesn't hurt and does deny the fatcats the sale! >^^<
Well... I think the guy that's selling the used one is doing so because he knows there is a market for his used one where he can recoup some of the value. If that Ipod Touch had 0 resale value, then he may not buy another one and stick with the one he already had. If that is the case, buying a used one is facilitating another sale, albeit indirectly.
I have not checked through the hardware producers, but those who decide not to purchase Apple and do not want to submit themselves to the problems attendant on Windows can find a simple, effective, and free-of-charge solution in Ubuntu Linux.
Almost all the software is either truly free in the GNU sense--free as in freedom--or at least open source, and one can find a program to do just about anything and do it well in Linux without paying money or even having to shop. That does not just mean not having to reach into one's wallet (though donations go to a good cause!), it means not having to mess with passwords and codes and long-distance tech support calls in order to use software that one has already paid cash for, or having to repurchase software to re-install it because one has been so improvident as to lose some slip of paper or CD cover.
I found the control interface immediately intuitive when I migrated from Windows several years ago; I believe Mac users would find it even more so, since both OS's are in one or another way UNIX-based.
I have very nearly zero virus and spyware-based problems. I do not mean that it does not exist or that the system is impenetrable; I just mean that it does not become so choked with commercial spyware as to become sluggish and unusable, as Windows products do even after one has invested in one to a dozen antivirus and anti-spyware programs.
The one time I did have a significant invasion (whether a human invader or a Trojan I never did determine to my satisfaction), I simply re-installed the operating system. The problem required no help from any experts and was done within a couple hours, and all I lost was the work I had not backed up.
Finally, those who do have a system with Windows can download a copy of Ubuntu and try running it from a CD or DVD drive to check it out and get familiar with it at no risk. Alternatively, one can even install it on one part of the hard drive and boot into either Linux or Windows at will.
Great info Peter...thanks. I would like to add that Apple has chosen to drop it`s Wikileaks application on it´s new iPhone´s and therefore is saying it does not support freedom of the press, true democracy or a transparent government. So now it is 4 strikes against Apple. I mourn the early Apple when Steve was a true inovator...now he has caved in and become a slave to the corporate run governments of the world.
go to the apple store and you see the automatons in their green shirts, khaki pants and brown shoes
with that mooney type look of ecclesiastical bliss in their eyes, looking off to nowhere
then they have the "geniuses" who earn a little above the minimum wage - you get a name instead of a raise. if these folks were truly geniuses then what the fuck are they doing working retail at the apple counter
their factories in china have suicide nets around them because the conditions are so shitty folks throw themselves off the roof in despair
apple's solution was to erect suicide nets rather than pay their workers and ease the 105 hour work weeks - cost effective
i'm a pc guy, always have been, 97% of the world is running windows
mac buyers pay twice as much for a computer that has so many hidden and ongoing charges that they wind up paying three times as much
suckers
deep in a trance they are
the ipod was a good product - the rest are expensive crap
fuck apple and steve jobs, nwo scum that he is...........
Great informative article!
Also, Apple has some sort of spyware in its product. Conversations heard perfectly from other parts of the house, even while it is asleep were picked up.
"Conversations heard perfectly from other parts of the house, even while it is asleep were picked up."
URL??
No URL. My husband was online talking to someone and as soon as the person stopped making noises, the computer turned up its own volume sensitivity automatically to where my husband could hear other people and conversations in other parts of the house crystal clear.
Anyone within 500ft of a Mac can be overheard.
No URL. My husband was online talking to someone and as soon as the person stopped making noises, the computer turned up its own volume sensitivity automatically to where my husband could hear other people and conversations in other parts of the house crystal clear.
Anyone within 500ft of a Mac can be overheard.
Why anyone would expect a major corporation to behave itself is beyond me.
It's long past time we killed the myth that money is anything but a cruel illusion, and that it is somehow necessary for innovation or to make society run.
Why can journalists never get technical or scientific issues right?
His remark: "widely known as coltan — whose electrical retention properties improve the battery lives of electronic devices." is, technically, gibberish.
Coltan is an ore of tantalum which is used in tantalum capacitors. Capacitors are the second-most common - and traditionally the bulkiest component in an electronic circuit. But Tantalum capacitors are well-suited for miniaturization, so their use becomes very important in pocket-sized or tablet-sized devices. Now, I know this - and I'm not an electrical engineer or technician either - so a journalist writing on technical matters can also.
>>Capacitors are the second-most common - and traditionally the bulkiest component in an electronic circuit.<<
Nope. The bulkiest components, traditionally speaking, would be transformers and vacuum tubes. In regard to modern electrical circuits you are probably correct.
Just a question... how come paragraphs are allowed on this thread and not on others?
I just made this a paragraph.
put this in the wrong place
Pay taxes? Are you kidding, they earn almost $21 a share, and they don't even pay a dividend!