Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Netanyahu Pounds War Drums
WASHINGTON - Less than a week after Republicans made major gains in the U.S. midterm elections, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has called on President Barack Obama to "create a credible threat of military action" against Iran.
Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks during a session of the Knesset, the Israeli parliament, in Jerusalem November 3, 2010. (REUTERS/Ammar Awad) Initial official reaction was negative, with Defense
Secretary Robert Gates insisting that Obama's preferred
strategy of enhanced multilateral sanctions and
negotiations, which may resume after a year's hiatus later
this month, was working better than expected.
"I disagree that only a credible military threat can get Iran to take the actions that it needs, to end its nuclear weapons program," Gates said when asked about Netanyahu's remarks during a visit in Australia.
"We are prepared to do what is necessary, but at this point,
we continue to believe that the political, economic approach
that we are taking is, in fact, having an impact in Iran."
According to diplomatic sources quoted in the Israeli and
U.S. press, Netanyahu's appeal came during a meeting with
Vice President Joseph Biden in New Orleans Sunday. It
suggests that his right-wing government and its allies here,
including hawkish Republicans who will take control of the
House of Representatives in January, are preparing to
escalate pressure on Obama to adopt a more confrontational
stance with Tehran.
Indeed, even as Netanyahu was telling Biden, according to
the anonymous sources, that "only a real military threat
against Iran can prevent the need to activate a real
military force," Republican Sen. Lindsay Graham, a leading
national-security spokesman for his party, told an
international conference in Halifax, Canada, that Obama
would help his own re-election chances in 2012 if he made
"abundantly clear that all options (to Iran) are on the
table" – a phrase that is associated with taking military
action.
And if Tehran actually developed a nuclear weapon, he said,
Obama should act "not to just neutralize their nuclear
program, …but to sink their navy, destroy their air force
and deliver a decisive blow to the Revolutionary Guard. In
other words, neuter that regime. Destroy their ability to
fight back."
The rhetorical escalation by both Netanyahu and his
supporters here comes amid diplomatic jockeying between Iran
and the so-called P5+1 – the five permanent members of the
U.N. Security Council and Germany –over the site and agenda
of a meeting that both sides have said they hope will take
place later this month.
The P5+1, which is represented by the European Union's
foreign policy chief, Catherine Ashton, have proposed a mid-
month meeting in Vienna. But Tehran Monday called for Turkey
to host the talks.
Along with Brazil, Turkey had secured Iran's agreement last
spring to a proposal, originally put forward as a
confidence-building measure by the P5+1 a year ago, to ship
a substantial amount of its growing stockpile of low-
enriched uranium (LEU) outside the country for enrichment to
the 20 percent level needed to fuel a nuclear plant in
Tehran (TRR) that produces medical isotopes.
The Turkey-Brazil deal, however, was summarily rejected by
the Obama administration and its European allies on the
grounds that Tehran had added significantly to its stockpile
in the previous six months.
In recent weeks, however, they have hinted they may go along
with a similar transfer scheme if Iran agrees to send a
larger proportion of its total stockpile out of the country,
stops enriching uranium to the higher level and agrees to
address the future of its nuclear program.
In another conciliatory gesture, the Obama administration
last week named Jundallah, a radical Sunni group that has
repeatedly attacked government security forces in
Baluchistan in recent years, a terrorist organization.
While Netanyahu and his supporters here are dismissing as
insufficient Obama's strategy of sanctions and talks, two
centrist think tanks Monday urged the administration to
place more emphasis on engaging the Islamic Republic.
Previewing a more-comprehensive report to be released Nov.
16, Barry Blechman and Daniel Brumberg of the non-partisan
Stimson Center urged Obama to offer Tehran a "set of robust
economic, political and strategic incentives that give
Iran's leaders reason to cooperate" as part of a
"recalibration" of U.S. strategy that would reduce its
reliance on "coercive measures".
Writing in USA Today, the two non-proliferation specialists
argued that Washington should explicitly recognize Iran's
right to enrich uranium under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation
Treaty – something that it has yet to do – and provide other
inducements, including proposing bilateral or multilateral
talks on security issues, notably Afghanistan and the drug
trade, and normalizing diplomatic exchanges, and offering
help in modernising Iran's energy industry.
In addition, a new paper released Monday by the bipartisan
Iran Task Force convened by the Atlantic Council on the
evolution of internal Iranian politics, particularly since
last year's disputed elections, called for Washington to
pursue "strategic patience" with Tehran "and avoid
overreactions that could set back Iran's political
development".
"Short-term prospects for U.S.-Iranian reconciliation and
for a resolution of the Iranian nuclear file are poor in
large part because of Iran's internal political crisis,"
according to the author, veteran Iran observer Barbara
Slavin. "In the longer term, however, history, demography,
and education favor liberalization and international
integration… The focus of U.S. policy should be to buy time
for this evolution to take place."
Whether these recommendations will be taken up in
preparation for the prospective talks remains to be seen,
but it seems increasingly clear that Netanyahu and his
supporters here feel emboldened by last week's election to
press Obama in the opposite direction.
Netanyahu's government had been relatively quiet on Iran
since last June when Obama succeeded in persuading the U.N.
Security Council to impose a new round of sanctions against
Iran for alleged nuclear transgressions. It even expressed
satisfaction with subsequent efforts to rally the European
Union, Japan, and South Korea among others behind much
tougher sanctions against companies doing business with
Tehran.
But, with sympathetic Republicans taking over the House of
Representatives, the Israeli government appears confident it
can press for more.
According to "diplomatic sources" quoted by the Jerusalem
Post, Netanyahu warned Biden that Iran "is attempting to
mislead the West, and there are worrying signs that the
international community is captivated by this mirage."
"The only time that Iran stopped its nuclear program was
in 2003, and that was when they believed that there was a
real chance of an American military strike against them," he
reportedly told Biden.
U.S. neo-conservatives and other hawks have been making much
the same argument for some time. In a speech to the
influential Council on Foreign Relations in late September,
Independent Democratic Sen. Joseph Lieberman, who is close
to Graham and former Republican presidential candidate Sen.
John McCain, called for Obama to "take steps that make clear
that if diplomatic and economic strategies continue to fail
to change Iran's nuclear policies, a military strike is not
just a remote possibility in the abstract, but a real and
credible alternative policy that we and our allies are ready
to exercise."
His remarks were praised by William Kristol, the editor of
the neo-conservative Weekly Standard and a top adviser to
Republican foreign-policy hawks, and the Wall Street
Journal's editorial page.
Such war talk was denounced as "dangerous" Monday by the
Atlantic Council's chairman, former Sen. Chuck Hagel, who
also co-chairs Obama's Intelligence Advisory Board, as well
as the Council's Iran task force. "If you're going to
threaten war on any kind of consistent basis, then you'd
better be prepared to follow through on that (threat)," he
said.
"The United States of America is currently in two of the
longest wars we've ever been in… at a very significant cost
to this country. …I'm not sure the people of the United
States want to do a third war," he said.
Jim Lobe's blog on U.S. foreign policy can be read at
http://www.lobelog.com.
- Posted in

93 Comments so far
Show AllLOVE the "sieg heil" salute in the photograph! Kinda says it all...
It's the Bellamy salute. Look it up.
Then how come they act like Nazis?
Oh that's right, it isn't really a holocaust if the Palestinians are the victims.
The wall behind him looks like the walls they built to keep the Palestinians out.
Does he want another Holocaust or is he just paranoid?
Threatening another country is, and should be, against international law and the UN Charter. Any person in government, any government, who does this is breaking international law, should be prosecuted and is a tyrant. The fact that it is many times us and our "allies" is depressing and telling.
What would the press reaction be here if a country, that was militarily stronger than Iran, talked so casually about threatening this country? What if, say, China was debating whether or not to bomb New York, to destroy our Navy, Air Force, etc and China had the history we do and had already done so to our neighbors? The imperialist mindset is morally indefensible. The only thing to do in this situation is to punch the bully in the mouth. Israel cannot be the bully it is without the US's support, the US cannot financially afford a war with Iran, has no moral or logical argument to justify a war with Iran. So act like fools and bring down at least three countries, if not the region.
By the way, if you want to know what a dirt bag Netanyahu is watch this video where he admits, brags, to people about "stopping" the Oslo Peace Process (and placing blame elsewhere in public ever since). He not only brags about stopping Oslo, he talks about how easy it is to manipulate the US. By that he means the idiots in the US government. He gives himself too much credit though, they delude themselves and need no help:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z6KLFrye9Xk&feature=related
Notice that VP Joe Biden has been very actively encouraging this with
numberous comments since he has taken office -- and again the other day!
Think something like Israel would be "justified" in striking Iran!!!
This is cover for what our right wing HAWKS/crazies want, of course.
Not that Netanyhu and right wing Israel wouldn't be willing!!
If you have the weapons .... hey, why not use them!!
Disgraceful!
"According to all myth, the female - not the male -- gives life"
Only, it isn't a "sieg heil" salute. Nutty uses his left hand, not right which is correct for any salute. He is obviously caught mid gesture waving hands around.
Also the nazi (sieg heil) salute was NOT based on the Bellamy Salute. Rather it came indirectly from a common historical source of the Roman Salute. The Nazis took it almost directly from the Italian Fascists who took it from a silent film by a guy named d'Annunzio who thought it was how the ancient Romans saluted which is not based in any historical fact other than a couple references in literature but not on any coin or statue.
Hitler and his crowd were fine with American money, but they weren't fans of really anything American. We weren't "pure" enough to be culturally interesting to Herr Hitler et al.
So Bellamy never heard about the Roman Salute?
anyway how do we know he is saluting?
Maybe Red Balllon knows he is trying to keep it down from the hecklers to his "lets get the USA to kill Iran" rant.
Thanks to JohnShade for clarifying the historical source.
I think Netty was just making an oratorial gesture.
I get so bored with the knee-jerk "just like the nazis" responses, as though there weren't other disgusting, murderous examples to reference. People don't seem to get as upset about Idi Amin, Rwanda, Mao, Kim Jong this'n'that, Stalin, a dozen tin pot dictators installed-inspired-funded by the US - genocide-by-proxy, etc etc., that, numerically, were even more devastating.
No defense of nazis from me - I'm a civilian survivor of a war-time bomb attack on a residential district. yay collateral damage.
I only wish people didn't make it so easy on themselves when they toss out these callow declarations: "just like the nazis" - no, just like Netanyahu. I'm surprised, even a little disappointed, that he and his goons aren't parading around in miltary uniforms complete with fake fruit salad, gold lanyards and epaulettes, shiny brass buttons, flat-top hats and sunglasses and shiny knee-high boots like every other fascist dictator.
Israel is not unique in its extremist-fascist tendencies, not even original, and likely won't be the last case ever to occur. It's just uniquely repulsive in its lack of creativity and imagination re justice and humanity.
How about Nixon's "two-arms extended wing-like with slanted peace signs" salute?
It just made him look really goofy.
oopsie
sheesh
Oh, one more small detail - a quick overview of government architectural style in the US should show you that the US also models itself on a romantic notion of the ancient Roman empire, and not just in matters of style. I never though that was a good sign.
Thanks for the excellent clairfication redballoon.
Yes, Governments always seem to build themselves up above the people protected by armies and look what we get.
Things are changin fast though.... hard to keep up.
The scary thing is as the USA goes broke it won't be the National Security State that will be unfunded.
It will be the Social Security state that will get the ax first.
Do ya get the picture?
yup
Wow. People took this dumb comment way too seriously!
Have you all seen the Boeing sponsored PSA's 'thanking military veterans' as we come up on Veteran's Day? God, it makes me sick. Thanks for getting your ass shot, your family forever messed up, so we can keep our military weapons divisions red hot and rolling, profits and bonuses at record levels. National budget deficits? Don't worry, be happy.
Chuck Hagel, like Colin Powell is starting sound better as a presidential candidate.
AD
Colin Powell for prez? You're kidding, right? Not another milquetoast, please!
I thought Powell was going to Hollywood after his Oscar winning performance at the UN.
We need to create an international force to invade and occupy Israel putting these war criminals on trial and begin liberating the Palestinian people.
Perhaps we should also think about putting the war criminal system out of business in the USA.
Seconded!
After all, USA - Israel's military supporter - has only half the world's weapons, 2/3 of weaponsales and 3/4 of R&D of weapons. If the rest of the world gangs up on them, the "international force" might stand a chance.
Thats why the war criminal moves freely around in America. Both countries share the same crimes!
Agreed, 100%. These murderous squatters are a strain on the US economy and this useless welfare state should be permanently removed immediately!
Funny that you say that cause Israel has called for the same thing...for the US!
Israeli lawmaker calls for arrest of US war criminals
http://www.israeltoday.co.il/default.aspx?tabid=178&nid=22112
I thought Iraq had the WMD's?
Here we go again!
Spin the FEAR, spin it GOOD.
Well Iraq had them, but in Bush's latest book he claims Sad daam had them all moved to Iran! LOL!
"[A] military strike is not just a remote possibility in the abstract, but a real and credible alternative policy that we and our allies are ready to exercise." --hold on one minute: "Who is 'we' white man?"
The same a-holes who were beating the war drums for Afghanistan and Iraq. Notice "we" don't hear much about North Korea since they actually got a bomb. War is all these people know and unfortunately, they like to include all of us people who would prefer peace and a little getting along in that "we".
This A'hole Netannyahu's country has several A'bombs!
several - snrrrt! Between 200 and 400.
Love the photo of Netanyahu's Nazi salute. Perfect.
He - and the U.S. MSM - needs to acknowledge that
1) Iran has no proven nuclear weapons program. This has been documented hundreds of times, and the IDEA of the U.N. has confirmed they have found no evidence of such a program.
2) Iran, as a signatory to the NPT, has the right, under the law, to develop nuclear power for energy-generation purposes. The nuclear reactors they are building are perfectly legal under the treaty and the law.
3) Iran has never - in its entire history - ever attacked or even threatened to attack, any other country. It is Iran that has been on the receiving end of multiple threats by other nations - America, Israel, Iraq.
4) The comments by Senator Lindsay Graham this weekend that the U.S. needs to invade Iran and blow them back to the stone age is a violation of the U.N. Charter, which states that threatening to invade another sovereign nation is illegal. The constant saber-rattling by the U.S. about attacking Iran also falls under this category. Hilary Clinton's direct threat to use nuclear weapons against Iran last year was a violation of the law, not to mention downright horrific.
It is the U.S., and its bitch, Israel, that need to be invaded, and no "credible threat" needs to be invented to do so, as both countries have proven time and time again they are both threats to international peace and security.
"When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag, carrying a cross."
Bellamy salute - look it up.
'Bellamy Salute.' I do hope that you're kidding. As if Netanyahu would even know what the 'Bellamy Salute' was. However, I'm certain that he knows what the Nazi salute is. Me thinks that you are trying to push a string here 'Redballon,' to those who clearly see your tactic. Try again.
"Bellamy salute - look it up."
That is all you have said so far, but what about the drums of war?
I looked up Bellamy salute and it looks like the Nazis and now Netanyahoo are into it.
http://rexcurry.net/pledge-utah.html
Hitler was inspired by the US right wing... that is where he got all that purity of race and religion crap and now Netanyahoo wants every resident of Israel to swear allegiance to the "Jewish State".
This is not right.
Unfortunately, one of the uglier side-effects of the discovery of evolution and genetics was the belief in eugenics, which engendered all kinds of abuses - in prisons, hospitals, mental wards, schools. It was a trend universal to the Western democracies and still survives in various degraded forms, such as the social Darwinism in the Anglo-capitalist countries. Americans habitually turn to genetic ecplanations for behaviours or tendencies.
It wasn't just the US right wing. Hitler had a lot of support from many sources that believed in racial superiority and the rightness of asserting it. It was a trend in sociological thinking shared by many entities. I don't believe it originated with the US right wing. In fact, a big portion of that racial superiority nonsense accompanies empire building - always, the invaders, the empire builders believe themselves to be more worthy, smarter, cleaner, stronger, superior, and they claim to have a deity-sanctioned mission to rule and educate the vanquished.
Of course, the US has been threatening Iran ever since its puppet, the Shah, was overthrown by the Islamist rebellion. It also actively encouraged Iraq's war against Iran, insofar as it provided Saddam Hussein with weapons during that time.
In 1953, however, the US, "a force for good in the world," went beyond merely issuing threats and enabling a war, as it did after 1979, but its CIA downright overthrew the democratically elected president of Iran.
Relations between Iran and the US have been marked by that criminal act ever since.
Demonstorm "Iran has never - in its entire history - ever attacked or even threatened to attack, any other country."
Here, too, a lack of historical knowledge is on display. ref. wikipedia: "The Persian Empire was the largest empire by geographical extent in ancient times; at the height of its power, the empire encompassed approximately 8 million km2.[1] The empire was forged by Cyrus the Great, and spanned three continents: Asia, Africa and Europe."
not in recent tiems, but certainly in ancient times. Why not, what the hey, everybody's doing it...
"It is noted ... for emancipation of slaves including the Jews from their Babylonian captivity."
So much for gratitude.
Tomayto tomahto. Y'oughta have put a time constraint on it. Never ever is a very loose frame.
While Iran occupies much of the same Geographical territory as Iran does today, the Anicent Persina Empire has little to do with Iran.
The Roman Empire is gone. The Carthagian Empire is gone. Libya has never attacked Italy.
Horrified:
Not true. Nadir Shah's sacking of Delhi (India) is well known in India.
Just a historical correction. And, for the record, screw that racist Netanyahoooooo.l
I am not talking about Persia. I'm talking about the sovereign nation of IRAN.
To you, they are the same, but they are not. That's like saying that every single horrible act committed by the Western Frankish Kingdom is attributable to modern-day France.
You need a serious history lesson, sir.
"When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the flag, carrying a cross."
I think we need to "create a credible threat of military action" against all those who voted for these Republican jingos.
From Democracy Now:
Netanyahu Speech Disrupted in New Orleans
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu spoke in New Orleans on Monday before the Jewish Federation General Assembly. His address was repeatedly interrupted by young Jewish activists from the Young Leadership Institute of Jewish Voice for Peace.
Benjamin Netanyahu: "I’m going to talk about delegitimizing Israel, but they really have the wrong address."
Activist: "The occupation delegitimizes Israel!"
Who the f*ck is Netanyahoo to tell us how to run our foreign policy? We'll bomb Iran when we're good and ready, and not a moment before!
Seriously though, that's not cool. One of these days we're going to tell Israel to go shove it... I can dream, right?
Hell one of these days....Yo Israel...shove it!
FYI
The "Nazi" salute you refer to all the time has its origin the good ol' USA. Yes, indeed. It was called the Bellamy salute and was customary with the Pledge of Allegiance (Francis Bellamy).
Google it for yourself.
So -y'all need to recognize its true origin.