Police Arrest Seven Protesters at Foreclosed Home
Minneapolis - Police arrested seven people today outside the foreclosed home of Rosemary Williams, a Minneapolis woman who has publicly refused to leave the property for months.
About a dozen Minneapolis police officers arrived at the south
Minneapolis home this afternoon, at the request of GMAC Mortgage, the
legal owner of the property. A private company boarded up the house
with bright metal sheeting, after officers allowed Williams and several
supporters to remove personal belongings.
The arrests occurred after protesters broke through plastic police tape roping off the property and sat down on the sidewalk. Police sprayed the group with pepper spray as they broke through the tape.
The protesters will likely be charged with misdemeanors for obstructing the legal process, police officials said.
Williams' lengthy fight to remain in her house has inspired several local homeowners to remain in their homes despite eviction orders. Three women facing foreclosure arrived at the property today to show their support.
"What good is this?" said Linda Nurenberg, a Robbinsdale woman who has refused to leave the foreclosed home her father built in 1944. "Another vacant house, and of course I'm scared I could be next."
Nurenberg has a motion pending to fight eviction from her home. She said she attended a prayer vigil with Williams last night, and characterized Williams' mood as upbeat, and grateful for community support.
About 50 supporters stayed at the property throughout the early evening, chanting, "Foreclose the banks, not people's homes. Let Rosemary stay."
Minneapolis police spokesperson Sgt. Jesse Garcia, who spent his morning at the funeral of slain North St. Paul police officer Richard Crittenden, said that the heavy metal materials used to board up the house were unusual. A vacant home across the street has been boarded up with simple wood slabs for months.
"They secured my house with military armament," Williams said.
Activists outside the house speculated that breaking through the metal barriers would be difficult, if not impossible. They declined to comment on whether more civil disobedience is planned.
Police officers plan to remain at the property at least overnight to prevent trespassing.
Williams has been fighting eviction for months. GMAC said in a statement that it has attempted to negotiate several arrangements that would have allowed Williams to remain in her home, but they all fell through.
Williams was ordered to leave her property on Aug. 7, when Hennepin County sheriff's deputies served the eviction notice and changed the locks on her house. But a group of her supporters broke the locks and have been occupying the home ever since, vowing to stay despite the order.
"We intend to protest this," said activist Mick Kelly this afternoon. "Our goal is to get justice for Rosemary, to allow Rosemary to stay in her home."
Williams accepted a $5,000 check from GMAC this afternoon, but has not yet decided whether to cash it. A GMAC spokesperson said the company provided the money to help Williams relocate to a new residence.
"Today's actions were very difficult, and a regrettable end to 18 months of seeking a solution with Ms. Williams, with local non-profits and with the mortgage investor to keep her in the home on Clinton Avenue," said GMAC officials in a statement. "Unfortunately, Ms. Williams was chronically unable to meet her payment commitments under the adjustable rate mortgage she originated with BNC Mortgage."
Williams, who recently started working as a home health care assistant, vowed to continue her fight to purchase the property. She also plans to hand out flyers protesting foreclosure at President Obama's rally in Minneapolis tomorrow.
But Friday night, Williams' concerns are more immediate. While she was trying to decide where to spend the night, she realized she left her antique sewing machine in the boarded up garage.
"Oh well, it happens," Williams said. "With everything that's been going on these last few months, you never know what to expect."
Twitter
StumbleUpon
Facebook
Delicious
Digg
Newsvine
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
48 Comments so far
Show AllCicero: "Freedom is participation in power."
GM, for whom the loan originator GMAC is a subsidiary, received two different government "bailouts" together totaling well over $50 Billion dollars in the last 18 months. GM, as part of this "restructuring" rip-off ordered the layoffs of thousands of more GM employees, deeply scaled back U.S. production (severely damaging U.S. auto parts manufacturers in the bargain) and severed relationships with hundreds of GM-associated dealerships (many operated for over 50 years) leading directly to their closure. The dealership closures affected small and medium-sized town economies across the country.
Meanwhile, in the Asia Times, GM announced new factories, new jobs, new model construction orders and parts manufacturing partnerships in CHINA with CHINESE workers working in CHINESE plants and CHINESE business partners. GM's U.S. manufacturing overhead costs thus substantially lowered by a sick, sorry, anti-patriotic combination of undeserved federal tax-payer money handouts and the jettisoning of more American workers, parts manufacturers and dealerships, GM is expecting to profit big time by importing cars from China back into the U.S. and ramping up sales of Chinese-made GM cars within China.
The reason our Dimocrats and Refreeperkins are solidly behind this elaborate GM betrayal of America is that it will ultimately boost the value of GM stock FOR THE INVESTOR CLASS as part of our "JOBLESS RECOVERY" FOR THE RICH--the only Amurkans who really matter to either political Party or our ruling oligarchs anymore. The Republicans are compounding the hypocrisy of the situation as usual by bashing Obama for "nationalizing" GM--when he really helped further globalize it--exactly as the Republicans would have done had they been in power when GM demanded the bailouts.
The fact that GM's loan subsidiary GMAC is neck deep in the foreclosure of American homes just adds that final ugly detail to the whole degenerate sordid picture of precisely what is morally, ethically and spiritually wrong with contemporary "Amurka," its misplaced national priorities and its perpetually deceived masses.
Oh, and one DUI shouldn't cost ANY American his or her home. By that leap of illogic
the much worse crimes of violence routinely perpetrated by Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, the authors of the torture memos, the individuals who tortured over 100 "detainees" to death in Afghanistan and elsewhere, and major pro athletes in the U.S. should've rendered them all homeless years ago. People who believe a single DUI offense warrants homelessness have been made imbeciles by bad propaganda and/or bad religion. They lack any sense of proportion with respect to the law and are warped to boot. Amurka's now thoroughly twisted regressive anti-kulture is cranking these cranks out by the tens of millions. Too bad we can't build any better high ticket items besides right-wing morons and weapons.
I am so glad team Bush and Obama used OUR taxpayer money to bail out GM AND GMAC (same company) and now I am an investor and free bank for one-in-the-same companies. It feels soo good to help out the rich....I never knew how exciting life could be living out of a 13 ft. camper having to leave my home to find a toilet and a shower each day and wash dishes on the street like the Chinese used to do prior to their capitalist venture with the United States in the late 90's.
I am so busy with figuring out how to get my daily needs met I don't have time to find a paid job...but since there are fewer jobs than there are unemployed workers what's the freakin point of looking? No....I will just keep on living like a third-world person and ponder how many more Americans have to join me in living like an animal before they are willing to join me in caravaning en-mass to DC to camp out in the offices of our corrupt govt. officials offices.
I'm still waiting.....
Portland OR
GMAC (the money/financing arm of General Motors), the same ones who screamed like a sacrificial virgin that they were 'too big to fail' and had to be saved at public expense are now employing the jackboot thugs to take what was never theirs to begin with.
Typical.
And to those posters who are blaming the victim, who has admitted to being an alcoholic (hence the DUI), did you ever think there just might, *might* be a reason WHY she turned to the bottle for solace?
Think on that, when it's your turn to watch the thugs throw your family out into the street this coming winter...
Walk in peace.
Well said.
Human compassion is in short supply in the USA.
So here's how the game goes for the average middle class or poor person in the United States. You're born into debt, even if the family has some wealth. To exist on the land means you must pay a high-priced home mortgage or pay rent. Consequently, every baby born is born in hock to the banks or some real estate concern, though you don't really know that yet.
To "own" your property, you have to pay off this indebtedness for the majority of your working adult life. You have to secure decent-paying work for years on end, which is a very iffy proposition. Even if you are able to pull this off, you may not own the house or condo by the time you die, or you'll be evicted.
You pay police salaries. The police, in this case, protect the property rights of the banks. You have no rights. Remember, unless you pay those who own the land, you're a criminal. Don't think of sleeping in a public park - the police are there to roust you too. Of course you paid tax monies that fund the park too.
You pay tax monies that allow real estate concerns to use the public roads and water systems to sell their overpriced houses that you have scrimp and save to afford, if that.
Your tax dollars are handed over to the banks that loaned the money used to pay the mortgages. These are the same banks that helped inflate the housing bubble in the first place. These corporations committed major fraud but they got bailed out by you on your dime. Don't even ask because there is no bailout for you.
So you pay into a system in which you're essentially a wage slave or an indentured servant - for life. Nothing has really changed since the founding fathers, a bunch of wealthy country bumpkin landholders, conspired to establish a government for us all, on their terms, on someone else's lands. I guess you could say the "frontier" is gone - that's changed. It was Native American land that was stolen.
Your tax dollars return very little to you. No housing. No healthcare. Although, in other developed countries, the state does provide those things using tax dollars - and those are comparable capitalist states too. But no, not here in the United States. Here you're "free" - free to starve or be thrown into prison should you trip up.
In America, you do get to fund pointless illegal wars. You do pay for the forces that would suppress an uprising of like-minded people who might reject this system as inherently unfair. You pay for things like Northcom, or even your friendly local police force. It's just public service.
You're told that you succeed or fail by you're own hard work. Meanwhile, 40 percent of the rich simply get rich by inheriting their wealth. The United States has the greatest wealth disparity between the haves and have-nots of any country on the globe, yet you're supposed to think that we live in a classless egalitarian society.
You have the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness - in the abstract. But no one said anything about economic security, which is a precondition for life under capitalism.
On top of it all, you've got the law that supports property rights over every other right. You're told that you're free, but you haven't really read the fine print if you believe that.
"Property is theft!" So said the famous 19th century French anarchist Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, and they are words of wisdom today. Property represents the chain of infamy that makes us all into slaves, except for those who have gamed the system. Please think about it, especially those in this thread who get all huffy about a woman getting evicted. What heartless barbarism of thought is cultivated here.
http://tiny.cc/ProudhonWhatIsProperty
-TIA
I agree. I'll add that the definition of the word "property" is thoroughly gamed to favor the rich when they try to take yours.
Have you noticed the difference in prison sentences between bank robberies and rape? That says it all unless the rape victim is rich.
The moment you are too poor to pay "protection money"(taxes) to the police, you become targeted by them as an enemy.
WHY is this woman in foreclosure? (Nowhere does the story answer this question.) If the bank did something wrong, then she is in the right. If she is the victim of circumstances, ie she lost a job, got sick, etc, then the bank ought to work with her.
On the other hand, if she refinanced ten times to buy new SUVs, then she can freeze to death on a park bench this winter, for all I care. If she bought with an Adjustable Rate mortgage in 2006, at the top of the market, and is now upside down, then my sympathy is very limited.
Someone below answered my question. She refinanced (WHY?) at an adjustable rate, and then got a DUI, which, since she worked with a commercial drivers license, meant unemployment. Sorry. No sympathy here.
Your "power slave" moniker is apt; you're a slave to pwoer. You are also very American in your hatred and callousness. The victim is always at fault, apparently. Some of you right-wingers (and you are a right-winger, whatever you may call yourself; your comments reveal it) will occasionally claim to feel some sympathy if a person experiences misfortune because of illness or injury, but not many. My extremely right-wing American father truly believed that people who got sick were at fault for getting sick, that it was a sign that they had not been responsible enough in taking care of themselves, so he didn't care if they were writhing in pain in the streets while being beaten by frat boys. "What does that have to do with me?!!" he'd bellow when I'd press him on it. You are just as bad, believing that people who don't do well within the arbitrary financial rules of this society deserve to suffer and die simply because they aren't prevailing. How very Ayn Rand of you - and I'm sure you don't consider that an insult, though it is. It's a shame that decent people tend not to be violent or organized, cuz I'd love organized efforts to drive people like you out of our communities.
Ironic that you would call "power slave" a slave to power. If people would take personal responsiblity for their actions they would not be a slave to power.
Attention Power_Slave
exactly what you are, a slave to the great lie
wake up
Police officers are doing nothing wrong here. I hope no one is suggesting they are.
This is due process, its the way the law works. If you can't pay for something you borrowed money to buy, you cannot keep it. Its what you agreed to for the privilage.
Providing a check for $5000 is certainly generous for someone that has absolutely no right to the property.
H8,
Are you even aware of how distorted contract law has become in this country? What the F is an "Adjustable Rate Mortgage"? How does such a machine get built?
Anytime you join a bank, pay for phone or internet service, get a credit card, etc etc etc etc etc, you sign a CONTRACT that allows the CORPORATION to change the TERMS of the contract but does NOT grant YOU the right.
Ooh, ooh, you broke the terms of your "contract" with the corporation!
i certainly hope no one here is SUGGESTING that the corporation is a LIAR and a CRIMINAL! We all must simply bow our heads and obey!
"The people have no bread? Let them eat cake!"
There's a hard rain gonna fall...
Again, WHAT A CROCK. The rip-off artists have YOU conned.
I'm not only suggesting that police are doing something wrong here, I'm declaring that police are doing something wrong here. They ought to refuse to participate in such things and really ought to defend the residents. There's no virtue in "just doing your job" if your job is morally wrong, and there's no virtue in obeying the law if the law is morally wrong, as it is here. Apparently, poor people are always at fault in your world. If you're not a Libertarian or Republican yet, perhaps you should consider becoming one.
Socialist has a point here Henry8: we have one set of rules that apply to the lower classes, and another to the the upper. If the bankers were treated similarly, the CEO's would be fired and bankers forced into bankruptcy and evicted. But noooo, we gave them trillions to cover their bad bets. What kind of society have we created that we've become so harsh and stingy with those in dire need, and reward others who have pushed millions into poverty through deception and usury, while they live like kings and queens. This imbalance cannot stand forever, and will eventually come crumbling down. Unfortunately, many, many will be caught beneath the rubble.
Realize, too, that one can be frugal and responsible and still get whacked. And the social safety net seems to be contracting as well.
Do you work for the banking insustry or something? Your callous disregard for the plight of others is astonishing.
Funny, the law does not work like that for the people who caused the crisis- the banksters. They were able to take our tax money after they went bankrupt after making risky bets. You seem to echo the talking points of Fox News.
Why do the rich get away with high crimes and the victims get screwed? Does that appeal to your sense of Justice?
Your self-centered, callous knee-jerk reactions need to be thoght through just a bit more. It appears that don't give a F#$% about anyone else but yourself, which is fine. You can go live up in Idaho by yourself.
Oh, the police were just following the orders; they serve the interests of the ruling class and no one else. It must be nice to wealthy, yet not nice to be callous and spiteful to other folks who are less fortunate. You like to kick people when they are down?
What does Keith Ellison, the pro-Israeli first Muslim in Congress Representitive to Rosemary Williams have to say about this? Same thing he said as member of the House Judiciary SubCommittee on the Constitution when presented the House Bill to Impeach Cheney and Bush - "SPEAKER PELOSI HAS TAKEN THE ISSUE OF OFF THE TABLE".
Call Rosemary Williams' Representative to Congress and tell him to put this EVICTION back on the table:
Keith Ellison, D-MN5 - 612-522-1212
We have become a nation of people that think they are entitled to keep something for which they have not paid. She has been living in that house for MONTHS for free and she is given a $5000.00 cash award to move??? How insulting to the responsible HOMEOWNERS who budget and meet their obligations every month.
It's brain washed foot kissers like you that have let or taken part in makin' usa the corp. hideout for the global gangster from around the globe. It's ok for us to let W go build a new house in texas after he and his boss Dick committed so many crimes they can't be listed, but get a dui on alcohol that some corporate pusher dealt you, and your a lazy deadbeat.
WHAT IS WRONG WITH THIS PICTURE!!!!
Yeah, the banks and the lenders did nothing wrong. Exploiting poor people and taking advantage of vulnerable people is the American way, right?. Why should we care about what happens to other people? I've go mine Jack, keep your hands off of my stack. Screw everyone else but ME!! It is all about ME!!
It is perfectly OK for the banksters to take taxpayer money and turn around and screw taxpayers with it right?
The victims are always to blame in immoral acts and criminal cases right?
So good for you, you have the financial wherewithal to have avoided any difficulty. Since you don't give a F#$%, why should anyone give a F about you?
We can bo back to Medieval times where it is everyone for themselves. You no care for me, I no care for you. We can devolve into a Hobbesian world, sound like fun?
Sad to say we still do live in a 'Hobbesian world.' The only difference now is that we're better at disguising it with euphemisms, flowery words, and especially the PRETENSE of caring. And generally when someone does something there's something in it for them--even if it be something abstract like a puffed up self-image. That's what narcissism is all about. With Obama, it's much more about his legacy (or IMAGINED legacy), than doing what is true and compassionate. Authentic integrity is very, very rare.
socialist: I agree with your post!
A couple of weeks ago, I went to see a film directed by Leslie Cockburn, and co-produced by Andrew Cockburn, American Casino. I was devastated by the stories that Ms. Cockburn cogently wove together to tell the story of Baltimore residents who have suffered through foreclosures over the past few years. In fact, everyone in the audience expressed their sadness and horror as they left the Film Forum, here in NYC. The director succeeded in putting human faces on the tragedy of the financial crisis exacerbated by the subprime mortgage fiasco, and backed up the stories with solid research. I can tell you that my eyes were brimming with tears.
In 2006, 61% of the mortgages should have been written as prime mortgages, and not subprime mortages. However, the adjustable interest rates were so much more profitable! Citizens were pushed into signing the loans -- the documents, themselves, as thick as a phone book. Lawyers in the film told Ms. Cockburn that they, themselves, didn't always understand the complicated language used in the loan documents. The film, too, will show you that it can happen to anyone.
Now, the banksters are, once again, rolling in money, and Wall Street is celebrating with "busniness as usual" -- on the taxpayer's dime. "We the People" have been screwed!
The lack of compassion and empathy, by some, for our fellow citizens who find themselves abandoned by the system roars in my head!
I, for one, do not want to live in a Hobbesian world!
Thanks Kay, however several posters here do not agree. They believe that the banksters are not the problem, the victims are the problem. I did not realize that CD attracted so many elitist right-wing capitalists.
"I did not realize that CD attracted so many elitist right-wing capitalists."
Many Democrats are just as right-wing as Republicans and Libertarians when it comes to issues like this. It's why I encompass much of the US political population when I use the term right-wing.
right vs left, rep vs dem, black vs white, old vs young, army vs navy, rich vs poor, progressive vs regressive. who's winning? the rich bastards and their profit sheet.
http://www.mnsun.com/articles/2009/08/23/news/ro20norenberg.txt
"But Norenberg lost her job as a school bus driver after getting a DWI in October 2007, she said."
"Norenberg refinanced her mortgage, first with a fixed-rate mortgage and then with an adjustable rate mortgage."
"The home went into pre-foreclosure in November 2007, and Norenberg applied for a loan remodification. In February 2009, Chase Bank told her the sale took place on Jan. 30, 2009. Chase bank has since sold the mortgage to Citibank"
She actually had more than a year to get her act together.
I'm not nitpicking but i would have some more empathy if the activists had picked someone who was actually screwed by the bank. Someone that got sick or lost their job due to no fault of their own.
the same people that own the bank, own the brain control mechanism that pushed the alcohol and the mortgage. msm and their sponsors.
You still miss the overall point. The big picture remains the same.
No I am not missing the point. I do not agree with the bank bailout either. This country is going down the drain fast and there's no way to stop it.
And not everyone who advocates personal responsability is a "right wing capitalist", whatever that means. The point I was trying to make is that they picked the wrong person to showcase, a school bus driver who gets a DUI and loses job and then whines that she cannot pay her mortgage thet she refi'd twice.
I bet I can go out there and find at least two families who are more deserving to be helped.
What a crock.
Sit in at the damned bank and force them to re-fi every ARM they ever wrote. Rip-off artists cannot hide.
I disagree. If you screw up, and she screwed up, (A bus driver KNOWS that a DUI means unemployment.) then take responsibility. Don't come whining to the rest of us.
Slave is the right name for you.
Oh I see, if the filthy rich banksters screw up, then reward them with taxpayer money and instead of firing them and prosecuting them for fraud, give them extra billions in bonuses on the taxpayer dime.
If you screw up, too f-in bad. If that appeals to your sense of justice, then I pity you.
Well put. Thanks. The plutocrats just keep dividing and conquering and the majority are too ignorant to even notice they are being screwed!
In the past, neighbors with shotguns would show up at the auctions - and make the winning bid of one dollar.
"Police officers plan to remain at the property at least overnight to prevent trespassing."
Is GMAC paying real estate taxes on this property to cover the cost for police protection or are the taxpayers dipping in to their pockets again for the benefit of corporate welfare projects?
If I were a taxpaying citizen of Minneapolis, I would want to know!
The state and its monopoly on violence and coercion exclusively serves the interests of the ruling class. The police are part of the guardian class who undermine their own class interests by serving the interests of the ruling elite. This is how capitalist elites can thrive and enjoy protection from the masses.
Have GMAC produce the mortgage certificate.
The ORIGINAL mortgage certificate with her signature on it obligating her to pay in the first place.
Bet they sold it!
That's what Marcy Kaptur recommends.
Joe
Exactly correct. And they must have it. And that means physically.
I forgot, isn't GMAC a subsidiary of General Motors? Send her some bailout money.
I imagine the morale of the workers at GMAC is really high now that they have accomplished evicting someone.
We have bad things happening to good people by people who probably want to be good. What to do?
Obama, we beseech you to hear our cries of distress.
I wouldn't hold your breath. Obama is a fink.
And when it is police officers whose houses are foreclosed on, what will they do then? That's coming soon.
Winter is also coming soon. Will banks be putting old poor people out onto the street as winter approaches?
I predict we will see more than one bank burn within the next year.
Police officers are not loosing their jobs.
they will be when the military takes over
Good point.