Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Time to Apologize for the West's Shameful Support of Dictatorship in Egypt
Tahrir Square, epicenter of the earthquake that ousted Egypt’s western-backed dictator, Husni Mubarak, is quiet - for the moment.
There are banner-wavers, speakers, and youngsters milling about. But the by now world-famous square has a forlorn, leftover look, with more street people than revolutionaries. Violence crackles like static electricity.
Heavily armed riot and security police and their armored vehicles are massed nearby. In the ancient Khan al-Khalili Bazaar, I saw vanloads of government thugs waiting to attack demonstrators. I was almost arrested when I started taking photos.
Demonstrators at Tahrir showed me cans of expended tear gas that caused some deaths and many casualties. Whether they were the usual anti-riot CS gas, or the six times stronger, carcinogenic CR that can kill or blind, I could not tell. But the canisters were marked, “Made in the USA” and everyone knew it.
While Hillary Clinton was gushing about democracy in Egypt, shipments of US made anti-riot gear, including truncheons, gas, and rubber bullets, are being airlifted in from the US. Clinton’s US State Department appears to be timidly backing Egypt’s revolution, but the real power in US foreign policy, the Pentagon, is standing firmly behind Egypt’s 500,000-man armed forces.
I just observed Egypt go to the polls in a series of complex parliamentary elections. The vote was remarkably clean and fair, a triumph for all Egyptians.
Two more regional polls are yet to be held, but the outcome is clear. The Muslim Brotherhood and its Islamic ally, Wasat, won over 40% of the vote. The Salafist al-Nur Party, which seeks a state run under Islamic law, won 24%. The secular Egyptian Bloc won only 13.4%.
All the preppy, upscale, youth armed with cell phones and Blackberries first seen in Tahrir that became the darlings of the western media vanished. Revolutions are made by political and economic issues, not social media.
Egyptians clearly want democracy and parliamentary government, as do people across the Arab world. But Egypt’s mighty military-security establishment and its western backers do not: they are fighting a bitter action to slow down real democracy and to safeguard their privileges and power.
Egypt’s military gets nearly $3 billion in US funds and arms each year, plus millions more in “black” money from CIA and the Pentagon – in addition to millions in economic aid. The US supplies all of the military’s key weapons systems and retains control of the spare parts keeping them operating. The most important US intelligence and security agencies maintain large stations in Cairo to protect the regime. Half of Egypt’s food imports are financed by the US.
Many of Egypt’s key generals “trained” at US military colleges and defense courses where they were vetted by CIA and DIA. As with Turkey’s large armed forces – at least until nine years ago – Egypt’s military was joined at the hip to the US defense establishment and arms industry. In exchange, Egypt agreed to become a tacit ally of Israel.
Given Egypt’s role as a virtual US protectorate, the flood of hypocrisy now issuing from Washington, London, Paris and Ottawa over their alleged support of Egyptian democracy is striking. For the past thirty years, these powers have ardently backed Egypt’s notably ruthless, brutal dictatorship whose security forces used torture, rape, and murder to terrorize its citizens.
While Egyptians want democracy, the military wants political figureheads and the right to intervene in politics to protect its interests aka “national security” – the same demands used for decades by the right-wing Turkish military to block democracy. Egypt’s generals insist there be no investigations of human rights abuses. Washington is trying to sustain the Egypt-Israel alliance that all Egyptians detest.
The military, its US backers, Israel, and some misinformed western media warn the Muslim Brotherhood will turn Egypt into another Iran. This is nonsense. The Brotherhood is conservatives, timid and focused on social issues. In Egypt’s political context, it is a moderate party.
Egyptians want jobs, housing, food, education and a rescue for the deeply ailing economy, not worldwide jihad.
If western powers fail to seize this historic opportunity and work with the Brotherhood’s moderates, they will end up with the scimitar-wavers.
The west can begin by apologizing for so long supporting Mubarak’s brutal dictatorship.
- Posted in


6 Comments so far
Show AllDictators in the third world nations and defacto dictators in many industrialized nations has been standard operating procedure for decades.
Watching unelected bankster dictators being installed in one European nation after another confirms that this model is expanding and not diminishing on a global scale.
The west can begin by apologizing for so long supporting Mubarak’s brutal dictatorship.
Same can be said for all of the dictators the west supported as long as they played by their rules.
there are no apologies that are going to cut it i am afraid eric
also, there are no apologies forthcoming
an empire means you don't have to say you are sorry
then, once started, where would we stop
clearly this writer knows what is going on in egypt and the region in general and i suppose his notion of an apology is a bit tongue in cheek
we no longer have democracy here in fortress amerika and we are not the ones who promote it around the world
now "controlled democracy" to replace controlled tyrants - that's another matter
you know the type of democracy where you got a couple of paid off and psychotic misanthropes in office who somehow never vote the wishes of the people (sound familiar) - that's what we sell - snake oil
with our fiat money system in way over its debt head war is the only answer for our controllers
war as a trans formative event
problem - reaction - solution
right now the world - with its occupy movements - is in the reaction phase, just as planned by the oligarchs
when they are ready, and after a war or two (more), they will bring in the solution - world government, world finance, world army
these days i see this tragic farce of politics playing out and i just wonder how stupid people are that they can't see this shit
having successfully gotten away with the 9/11 psyop these psychos who pull all the strings realized they can do pretty much whatever they want
now its all war - all the time, cheney's wet dream
eric only briefly mention israel who have been conducting assassinations and subterfuge all over the world, but especially in the mideast for 60 years. their role has been huge
i don't expect an apology from them either
Eric, just finished reading your "War At The Top Of The World"...we thank you for shedding light on this very volatile part of the world.
But Eric, did you say apologize? Hell, that straw could become the Holy Grail that mends the discord between camel and man!
It's been said, "the elephant doesn't like to be moved by ants under his feet which is why he never brings it up at the dinner table", but we keep trying I guess till we install instant replay in [the lived events] as they do in sports. Then we would all sing: WHAT A WONDERFUL WORLD THIS WOULD BE
And to your credit Eric, you would be receiving a medal of honor. Thanks Again!
What does "scimitar-wavers" mean? It's hard to tell what you're saying other than "you support the Brotherhood, or you support the 'scimitar-wavers'".