EMAIL SIGN UP!
Most Popular This Week
- The Bill of Rights Exists: An Open Letter to Dianne Feinstein
- Major Loss to Organic Farmers as Court Rules in Favor of Monsanto
- NSA Whistleblower Revealed: Q&A with Edward Snowden
- One American Who Isn't For Sale
- 'Reprehensible, Reckless, Illegal': Washington Officials Slam Heroic NSA Surveillance Leaker
Popular content
Today's Top News
Plan to Flood Fukushima Reactor Could Cause New Blast, Experts Warn
Plant operator Tepco reveals meltdown and breach of pressure vessel, with Greenpeace warning against pumping water in
Experts have warned of a potentially dangerous radiation leak if Japan proceeds with plans to flood a damaged reactor containment vessel at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant. The facility's operator has admitted uranium fuel rods in the No 1 reactor partially melted after being fully exposed because of the 11 March tsunami.
A worker inside the No 1 reactor building at Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant. Experts have warned of a potentially dangerous radiation leak if Japan proceeds with plans to flood a damaged reactor containment vessel at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant. (AP)
Tokyo Electric Power (Tepco) said water levels had fallen to at least one metre below four-metre-long fuel rods inside the reactor core and melted fuel had slumped to the bottom of the reactor's containment vessel.
The damage is more severe than Tepco had previously reported and is almost certain to frustrate its quest to bring the plant under control within six to nine months. Officials said the leaked fuel was being kept cool and there was no risk of an explosion of the kind that blew the roof off the reactor in March.
The discovery was made after engineers were able to enter the reactor building, where they adjusted water gauges, for the first time since the plant was crippled by the earthquake and tsunami.
Officials said initial findings indicated a large leak in the pressure vessel but temperatures remained well below dangerous levels.
"There must be a large leak," Junichi Matsumoto, a general manager at the utility, told reporters. "The fuel pellets likely melted and fell, and in the process may have damaged the pressure vessel itself and created a hole."
Nuclear safety official Takashi Sakurai said: "The situation in the core hasn't changed [since early in the crisis] and the fuel rods are being cooled by water continuously being injected into the core."
Japan's nuclear safety agency said it believed partially melted fuel had fallen to the bottom of the pressure vessel, which holds the reactor core together, and may have leaked into its concrete base, known as the dry well.
Greenpeace has urged Tepco to abandon plans to flood the container with water, given the likelihood that melted fuel has damaged it. Shaun Burnie, nuclear adviser to Greenpeace Germany, said: "Flooding a reactor that has fuel [that has fallen] through the pressure vessel is not a good idea."
Outlining a worst-case scenario, Burnie said very large amounts of cold water hitting the melted fuel could cause an explosion, trigger substantial damage to the reactor and create a "high risk of atmospheric release running for days, if not weeks." He added: "I think [the flooding option] will now be scrapped."
Greenpeace said problems could escalate rapidly if the fuel melted through the reactor vessel. "As the fuel rods were fully exposed and subsequently melted, it is highly likely that the core's integrity is compromised and that there is larger amount of melted fuel at the bottom of the reactor pressure vessel." John Large, an independent nuclear engineering consultant in London, said Tepco's plan to flood the reactor was riddled with "potential risks". It appeared not to have factored in the extent of damage to the fuel rods and the structural state of the containment vessel, including whether it was watertight. "It seems to be poorly thought through," he said, adding that the firm had not demonstrated that the strategy could work.
Matsumoto ruled out a possible explosion but said: "We have to revise the flooding method. We can't deny the possibility that a hole in the pressure vessel caused water to leak."
The use of water to keep the reactors cool has led to the build-up of about 70,000 tons of contaminated water at Fukushima Daiichi. Tepco is pumping the water into a nearby storage building while it sets up a decontamination system.
Cooling water has leaked from the cores of reactors 2 and 3. One other unit at Fukushima Daiichi did not contain fuel rods at the time of the earthquake, while another two have achieved "cold shutdown" – their cooling water is below boiling point.
The permanent or temporary shutdown of reactors at Fukushima Daiichi and other nuclear plants could leave only a third of Japan's 54 reactors in operation by the end of the month, NHK has reported.
The public broadcaster said the disaster had prompted the suspension of 14 reactors, while 19 others were offline for inspections. Two reactors at Hamaoka nuclear plant in central Japan are to be shut while a tsunami wall is built.
The prime minister, Naoto Kan, has ordered the temporary closure of Hamaoka, which sits on an active fault line, amid warnings that it could be crippled by another huge earthquake expected to hit the region in the next 30 years.
In all 35 reactors – or about two-thirds of Japan's total – will have been shut down by the end of May. Officials are hoping to achieve a 15% cut in energy use during the summer to avoid rolling blackouts.
The government has decided to use taxpayers' money to help Tepco compensate tens of thousands of people affected by the Fukushima accident. Total damages are expected to run into trillions of yen, equating to tens of billions of pounds.
Reports said the government would issue special-purpose bonds worth 5tn yen (£37bn), with other utilities asked to pay into a newly established fund. Tepco would be required to contribute annual premiums and allow monitoring of its management by a government-appointed commission.
Analysts said the scheme would ensure Tepco's status as a listed firm and prevent market instability, although there are fears that the costs will be passed on to consumers in the form of higher electricity bills.
"This scheme will help alleviate concerns of financial market turmoil because holders of Tokyo Electric shares and bonds will be protected," Yasuhide Yajima, a senior economist at the NLI Research Institute, told Reuters.
Comments
Note: Disqus 2012 is best viewed on an up to date browser. Click here for information. Instructions for how to sign up to comment can be viewed here. Our Comment Policy can be viewed here. Please follow the guidelines. Note to Readers: Spam Filter May Capture Legitimate Comments...


27 Comments so far
Show AllThe Devils bargain the Japs have made has come back to haunt them. They already lived on a country where the Mts., Volcanoes and earthquakes / tsunamis made it difficult for the pop. Now they realize adding in these dangerous overrated water boilers has made things even worse.
Same reactor design the US uses,,,How's the TVA doing with Noah's flood?
SEAGLASS
Japs, Dagos, Chinks, Niggers, Red-Necks, Frogs, Sand-Niggers are all racist remarks. Surely you know that.
Stop it!
Quit your fucking cursing.
Actually I didn't know that Japs was a racist remark. My assumption was that using Japs was no different than using Canucks, Brits, Turks, Poles, or Aussies and that it referred to the citizens of Japan regardless of race.
I also thought that Red-Necks referred to individuals with particular way of looking at the world that is not much in sync with progressive thinking and ideals.
>>"This scheme will help alleviate concerns of financial market turmoil because holders of Tokyo Electric shares and bonds will be protected," <<
Which of course is the most important factor to consider. Profits must be protected. People can die. So what? How do their deaths affect profits? Thats all that matters. Profits. Profits uber alles.
No one has died so far. The tsunami has killed 18,000
It's highly unlikely no one has died from radiation sickness already.
Too many first responders and too many rads released for that unlikely scenario. It's most likely that many have already died and many more will die over the next few months. It will cost tens of thousands of lives with just cancer deaths before it's over. Expect a whole lot of genetic mutations too.
And, of course, none of the ocean-dwelling beings and the non-ocean dwelling beings that eat those ocean-dwelling beings (i.e. birds) have died. And what about the land-dwelling beings (cows, pigs, etc) that have died?
Apparently, it's only important that 'no one' (i.e. human) has died.
What happened to caring about the least among us?
No one has died so far.
How do you know that to be true.
Let's assume you are correct.
What if a similar accident had occurred in France?
How many to the west of the accident would have died by now?
How many would be doomed to cancer and birth defects?
Don't say it couldn't happen in France.
Murphy's law rules.
Wait for an asteroid the size of a car to hit a multi-reactor French site.
Yes, the probability is remote.
Remote possibilities have a way of becoming actualities.
What if What if. What should we do, go back to living in caves?
WVK,
I found your ability to comment here as proof that you are human.
However, the content of your comments is proof that you are not humane.
While it is quite true that humans can, for various reasons ($,$ and $), deny that certain behavior and activities should not be curtailed because, even if someone HAS died from them in the past, no one has died from them in this instance, this assertion is empty of facts, figures, truth or empathy.
When X-rays were all the rage back in the early 1900s, the people were getting routinely roasted with radiation at doctor's offices (the effects on fetuses of pregnant women was particularly gruesome). The timing and dosage hadn't been fine tuned so lots of people eventually died. However, there were folks then (as you are doing now) asserting that "no one has died" so it's peachy fucking keen.
Radiation effects and mortality rates from external and internal dosages are well documented. To deny this is bullshit. Did you know Tepco is contracting with the Japanese mafia to pay "jumpers" to film inside the plants while they get lethal dosages? These people are mostly homeless or terminally ill patients that are promised a certain amount of compensation for their families if they will perform this service. Tepco is just trying to keep shareholder costs down, you see. It's capitalism in action. Tough shit for the homeless. Of course now you want proof, data, NRC reports and scientific, peer reviewed, government accepted statements that this horrendous practice is going on. And until you get that proof, NO ONE HAS DIED YET, RIGHT?
Thanks for your astute observations, and for properly framing the debate:
Either we let the nuke companies and governments build more of these dangerous machines and we live with the risks and consequences; OR, we go live in caves.
If you're a shill or a troll, you're doing a really bad job.
What if there was an 8.9 earthquake just east of the Fukushima plants and what if a huge resulting tsunami breached a seawall and inundated the plants and drowned the backup diesel generators and what if this caused a meltdown in at least one of the reactors and what if melting fuel in a storage pool went critical? Naahhhh... this scenario is just too far fetched -- nothing like this could ever happen.
What if a bunch of wackos flew airliners into the two tallest buildings in NYC?
What if record floods were to occur all up and down the Mississippi River valley?
It is just me with my raging hormones. Why are we all sitting here on our fat asses quietly waiting to be extinguished without as much as a peep or a by your leave? WTF? Where is the outrage? Why are we not screaming at the top of our lungs and breaking doors down? The Media is certainly quiet about this over here. I notify my friends of these events and the silence is deafening. Ya bunch of cowards‼‼‼
So… the human race slinks away into oblivion with out even a whimper… and thus taking the whole rest of the planet with it. I hope Mother Earth can forgive us and I hope she can survive the onslaught. I wonder what the next intelligent being she will pick to inhabit this bit of space will look like. Will it walk upright, will it have the gift of speech, will it build great cities…or will it just live in peace with its fellows.
It Will Go On
The red, setting sun, casts long shadows of the rocks and hills.
When the guns are silent and the napalm has burned out,
The desert still exists, silent save for the susurration of the sand
Blown by the winds, slowly covering the wounds of war.
Forgotten monuments again becoming homes and shelter.
Small creatures creep out in the gathering stillness
To carry on their own lives, eating and being eaten
In the long dance that predates man and will continue long after.
As the climates change, volcanos and tsunamis rend the land and shore,
With the melting of the ice the seas rise; temperate zones become steppes
Encased in permafrost. Man's vaunted civilization may crumble away.
Man, himself, may run crying into the limbo that holds the dinosaurs.
The desert, silent save for the susurration of the sand, will still exist.
The red, setting sun, will cast long shadows of the rocks and hills.
Small creatures will creep out in the gathering stillness
To carry on their own lives, eating and being eaten as they always have...
Steve Osborn
21 November 2005
Dogface, my experience precisely to the,, 'ragging hormones' & the 'deafening silence' of friends, to 'it is what it is', buck-up--------of course the same is true of my family when it comes to Israel/Palestinian issues----if we don't discuss it, it will simply take care of itself-------it is more then less isolating! I find myself more & more flummoxed to exasperation...
In part no one does anything because there is no environmental information anywhere. No reports on radiation levels. The EPA has abandoned any testing of rain, milk or fish since they have determined there is no danger. This lack of information increases our ignorance and insulates us from the critical feedback we need on the state of our environment that would propel people into the streets. And when they do give us any tidbit of environmental information it is often confusing. Like "70,000 tons of contaminated water". Who thinks of water in tons? How many gallons is that? There is an worldwide orchestrated attempt to conceal critical ecoinfo from the masses. Want financial information? It's everywhere all the time. Sports info? You can get stats down to the size of a player's shoe. Environmental information? Good luck.
Roughly, 60 million gallons, probably more... and the water added just makes it all worse.
Navy thinks of water in tonnes.
1 tonne (long ton) is 1 cubic meter or 1000 liters of water or 264.5 US gallons or 222 Imperial (UK) gallons or a little over 4 hogsheads (wine).
... damaged the pressure vessel itself and created a hole."
As in the China Syndrome?
First step.
In a "China Syndrome" meltdown, the glob of super-heating melted fuel melts through ALL containment and into the Earth, leading to steam explosions when it hits the water table, massive atmospheric release of multiple radioactive elements, ongoing direct contamination of the Earth and the water as the damned thing keeps melting and moving...
Wouldn't literally melt all the way to China, although from Japan the closest cognate name would be more like "America Syndrome."
America Syndrome!!
Much of the world, it seems, already suffers from America Syndrome.
What the Japanese government is doing with TEPCO's bills is what the U.S. Government will do in the future with a similar disaster's bills. You'll pay an extra trillion to keep some nuclear operator solvent and well-financed.
On the issue of human lives, a number of reports in Common Dreams and alternative media e-sources have identified over 1000 human corpses around the Fukushima plant which are too radioactive to cremate, bury in normal burial grounds or even be handled by civil burial. Some comments here assume no deaths from nuclear contamination. Ask where these bodies fit in? Other reports pointed out schools closing in Korea over 1000 kilometres directly to the east of Fukushima exceeding maximum suggested exposures. Prevailing wind blows in Japan, as here from west to east. Other reports have mentioned many workers exceeding maximum radiation doses. With radio-active isotope half-lives in the hundreds of thousands of years, nuclear is the extreme hazard / toxin / poison for planet earth's precious life.