Investigating the Mortgage Crisis
This investigation is much needed, and frankly, overdue, as the foreclosure crisis has now hit record levels.
The Committee has requested--and will subpoena if necessary--records from Wells Fargo, Bank of America (including Countrywide), JP Morgan Chase, Citigroup, Residential Capital (GMAC), and US Bank Home Mortgage. It is also issuing a subpoena for records on Countrywide Financial's VIP program.
While the media seems focused on the Countrywide VIP program and questions of whether Towns himself benefited from it (he has denied doing so but will forward the documents to the House Committee on Standards of Official Conduct), I think the far more significant development here is the breadth of information the Committee is demanding from Big Banking.
The records in question cover 2000 to 2008, and include: the number and types of mortgages issued (whether fixed rate, adjustable, subprime, etc.); number of foreclosures and on which types of mortgages for every month during that time period; any marketing strategies and target audiences for residential mortgages, home equity loans, or similar products; special benefits provided to officials with a regulatory relationship with the banks; any draft legislation pertaining to mortgage lending that was offered to legislators; and any coordinated campaigns with other banks to fight mortgage regulation.
The Nation's national affairs correspondent William Greider recently wrote of the financial crisis: "We may know the broad outlines, but the landscape remains littered with unanswered questions and informed suspicions about who did what to produce the breakdown. The relevant facts are still buried in the files of Wall Street firms and the regulatory agencies that utterly failed as watchdogs.... Asking deeper questions about the true sources of the calamity is a first step toward developing authentic answers to the nation's predicament."
Here's hoping the Towns' investigation helps bring responses, finally, towards some of those crucial authentic answers.

Twitter
StumbleUpon
Facebook
Delicious
Digg
Newsvine
Google
Yahoo
Technorati
47 Comments so far
Show AllDeceptive and preditory lending practices ,whood a thunk it? Blow a bubble they knew would bust, no can't be. peace
Good comments from CDers, but still we have enormous hypocrisy here. KVH calls for "investigations" of banking criminals, yet if there had been proper investigations of the source of her family wealth, namely her grandfather Jules Stein, would she be a publisher, a trust-fund heiress?
Oh, that's right. It doesn't matter. It never matters in America where you get your money. Wash your mob-associated money right, and your succeeding generations can intone as avatars of purity.
I am sounding a tired, churlish refrain. The New Ascetics never have to face their own corruptions, and keep lecturing us with the same, folk music level admonitions. Hedges, Nader, Kucinich, KVH, Jensen, McKibben - always on the moral purity spiritual crusade, never facing their own past duplicities, failures, incompetencies, futilities. Aren't others getting tired of these New Ascetic bylines?
KVH needs an urban plunge without her SUV, credit cards, designer clothing, or body guards. Maybe her perspective would transform while getting a whiff of urine filled alley ways where the homelesss sleep in most unbran centers; but then again, that would require breaking away from her inside-the-beltway tour, which includes white-tie dinners, sniffing the arse of the DNC and Obama, and playing the powerful women while sweeping crumbs off the table to the rest of us.
Since she is the product of corporate hegemony, did you expect anything less? She has to keep those interest payments on her trust fund flowing with the rest of the banksters.
Hedges, Mckibben, and Jensen walk their talk. Try investigating their lives. Nader has not owned a car any time in his life, although he does own a substantial share in a Fidelity fund; nevertheless, his entire life has been of service to humanity, when most were married to their wealth. No man's life is predicated on one single issue.
Good words, but in service to my own views, however radical they may be, I still lump these folks together as the New Ascetics. Nader has been tireless, often right, a lonely crusader - and yet nearly wholly ineffective.
What good are these self-styled martyrs and renouncers when their causes have become so thoroughly trashed, run over, reduced to the furthest margins? These modern fakirs do not live in a recognizable active culture, did not protest when they were getting these ridiculous degrees from Ivy League monstrosities, are not capable of taking on the modern American monoliths of religion and work - Hedges, McKibben, and Jensen are mobbed-up traditionalists. They pose no threat to the corporate supersystem, because they as solitary beings intone, inveigh, decry - advising us to go talk to a tree, never look at naked pictures, be nice by going to church and making investments in green money -laundering operations, sit around the table listening to tales of yore from dear old dead Dad. They make the act of being opposed to the corporate supersystem as exciting as sitting around listening to a zither.
Talk to people where they live! Have an original idea that incorporates futility! Stop the lecturing blather and mediocre autism. Shake a tailfeather. Stop being so damn boring.
or for example Ms. Pelosi regularly wearing a pearl necklace that cost well over the average American family's yearly wage. The old saying of "walk a mile in my shoes" no longer applies to the wealthy democrats.
And whatever happened to Obama's admonition that we needed to end "trickle down" economics only to bail out the banks w/ the amount of money that could have paid off EVERY MORTGAGE in America!
That would have been truly stimulating to the economy - and we have to admit that these people are intelligent - which leaves us with the conclusion that we're getting a big "F You" from the Obamacrats.
2 can play that game.......
And someone here tell me - are they trying to destroy the democratic party completely or do they really think we are that dumb?
The American "people" are COMATOSE and living in a state not unlike that of MATRIX . they are living largely based on "surrogate" reality.
they are "awake" within that Comatose state.
Teddy, I agree. What are we going to do about it?
I honestly don't know what can be done over-all. all I can see is what history has shown: eventually people revolt if they are pushed to the wall. but whatever americans do - that is their business - we've said that about criticising what the USA does in its imperialism :"it's the business of other people in their countries what kind of government they enable".
in this case - I can only think that americans have lost or never had the capacity of REAL story-telling - history and passing it on or engaging each other , therefore they have lost the capacity for civic mindedness and therefore real knowledge over their own reality and future.
perhaps americans ought to start behaving like they have SOME interest in politics and not JUST entertainment. but that's a tall order because that is like saying that americans have to wean themselves away from the very idea of their own reality:
Entertainment. and unlike most cultures, even the least advanced ones....whose "entertainment" through the ages have ALWAYS been forms of history and instruction on society...
americans' entertainment is designed as symbol and substitute FOR reality creating Myths that never WERE reality at all but created out of pure thin air.
this is unlike the Mythologies of Ancient Greece for instance...or their fables, where they were "teaching" tools about things in the real world:
for example:
The story of Midas and his golden touch : it is about Greed .
or the story of HOmer's Iliad - it is about greed also, betrayal, what personal desires can launch - wars.
but america's entertainment is not like that - it is designed to REMOVE people FROM reality and distract them from learning ABOUT reality by creating a mythical "america" which then replaces reality and then they form a new reality BASED on that Myth out of thin air:
thus "WARS of conquest" based on the MYTH of "Paul Bunyan" - conqueror ...etc.
but DEFINITELY americans, if they were to START somewhere - succeed or fail - ONE of the things they have to start from is to ENGAGE each other, personally, familially, workplace-wise, friendship circles wise , community, etc. etc. ABOUT TRUE history and encourage and enhance a CURIOUSITY about history in an honest way...a curiosity of INQUIRY taught as something that is more satisfying than mere
":entertainment" .
unfortunately - this is not the "culture" of america.
it is - i must say sadly - despite its wealth and power - a culture of unbelievable Shallowness.
I was told this by older people decades ago when i was growing up - and I didn't quite understand yet - but i have come to believe it more and more. it IS a Culture of Shallowness that wraps sentimental symbols around itself as a pretense of 'depth'.
and I believe this is because americans are not really taught or encouraged to be truly "inquiring minds"....inspite of the line , so american too, :
"inquiring minds want to know"...
ONE thing that i have not seen much of in america is this:
a PHILOSOPHICAL nature , a philosophical curiosity. and i have always been amazed at its almost complete absence.
where I come from, the philippines, even poor farmers , unschooled - can hold conversations with a deeply inquiring and philosophical , even intellectual nature.
but I have seldom , rarely, if ever - really come across it as a matter of course among americans.
maybe i have found the answer for myself - why i often find them ...even when I try as subtly as I can to elicit more engaged discussions ...sorry to say: boring.
I can't see any other way out of it.
how about manifest destiny as a ignored FACT about genocide based on the MYTH that it was God's will.
Sioux Rose
TEDDY: Wonderfully astute analysis. I think one almost has to be an outsider (born elsewhere, or well & wisely traveled) to really pierce the dense din of delusion that passes for info-tainment (and/or news) in the USA.
Thanks all.
SiouxRose..my feeling is that what might, might, only be a way of "seeing" that you point out in my observations from having come from "the outside" - regarding the USA - could be partly true -- but , i think, it is also because i come from a place where we don't and didn't have the kind of "prosperity" that americans have had in the modern world for so long among the present "modern nations" reality.
so - what I think is that it is likely far easier for someone like me 0r anyone from other countries that are poorer (which means the majority of countries) - to really see when the USA has fallen BELOW the levels of common prosperity that the world has known and even admired or envied as "outsiders" BECAUSE we have the MEASUREMENT from the standpoint of being much poorer.
in other words - i have a MEMORY of what POVERTY can be like when i see it contrasted against what americans have.
and THEN when I see that americans TODAY and over the past 3 decades have been falling behind - then - i RECOGNIZE things that i have seen ....
i see americans getting "POOR" closer and closer to what it is like for poor people in the other countries.
i begin to see that , where 2,000 to 4,000 PESOS in teh philippines for a monthly salary is common - and BARELY gets a single person through a month ...which is like 40 US dollars..and which - because of global "wage arbitration" and monetary policies - is forced on workers by the global system --
i see the correlation - where 2 thousand DOLLARs in the USA barely gets a single person in the usa anywhere.
and yet i remind myself :
where a person in the philippines will earn the equivalent of 40-80 US dollars PER month...and where an american will earn 2,000 US dollars per month...they are more or less COMPARABLE in abilities (if not in system exposure) as workers or professionals of whatever trades they have.
in other words -- i am always reminded :
"a person that earns in dollars 2,000 per month as a secretary in the usa is not necessarily a BETTER secretary or even more hardworking than someone in the philippines"...
and YET under global finance , dictated by the USA, the labor of the filipina ONLY amounts to 40 Dollars for the comparable labor.
but then - they are BOTH POOR in their respective countries...although the filipina is obviously many degrees poorer than an american COMPARATIVE to the countries.
i think this is partly why i might find it a bit easier than many americans to see BOTh the similarity of actual or "virtual" poverty for the filipino and the american in their respective countries - compared to those above them...as well as seeing that the filipina is STILL poorer than the american for doing the SAME work in the "global market place".
you see what I mean?
MICROSOFT has its BIGGEST "calling and technician center" in the Philippines - did you know? because the pay is cheap, they need the money and investments in a condition forced on them by the american-LED (i emphasise "LED" because the USA can NOT BE SOLELY the responsible one for it..not ALL evils are from the USA, is what I mean) -- and to filipinos - THAT is already a BIG "upward" improvement in their condition...
but to an american -- that is really low-wage.
even if that were - to a filipino - 4,000 PESOS a month
that only translates to 120 dollars or so .
so - how can the COUNTRY hope to emerge from being a "servant" to the USA? EVEN if individually some filipinos might enjoy a little bit of relief for a bit more earning from Microsoft which ALSO enjoys the Profits from giving low wages ?
so - when i see the same things happening in the USA TOWARDS americans -- i can easily see :
what is being or has been imposed on other countries by us corporations - they are NOW more widely imposed ON americans themselves...and this is NOT surprising to me - because from the distance of an outsider growing up - i already saw the disparity - that was so artificial and unjust between a "great rich country" the USA and the philippines or other poor countries..( and back home this was already a very conscious discussion among a highly political people , because WE KNOW what it's like to be under imperialist boots) -
and seeing it "from the inside" - affecting myself as a "member" of american society and therefore also FEELING the HURT of americans as if they were MY own people - i can not avoid seeing the essential TRUTH:
OF COURSE the american system WILL ALSO victimise its own people BECAUSE that IS the essence of the system - it is
as my cousin back home told me in a letter:
"SO - ted - long time since we talked - you're really in the BELLY OF THE BEAST, huh? "
that's why I always say :
"THE CHICKEN HAS COME HOME TO ROOST"...
or truly "what goes around , comes around".
it is SO sad, SiouxRose, everyone,
NONE of us - from whatever country - shouldn't have to bear these kinds of injustices.
we have loved ones, we have friends, we have people, there are children, old people, people not so strong...people with so little
and MOST OF US ARE working as hard as we can under the circumstances
while building up mountains of wealth - to be GATHERED by so few.
and HERE in the USA is the CENTRE of the entire structure of global exploitation. it is, in modern times - the FACTORY that produces THAT system. indeed it can be seen PRACTICED on americans themselves , EVEN IF americans have little idea of the REAL effects of that - MUCH WORSE in conditions OUTSIDE of teh USA. and if THEY REALLY had to live THAT way - they would LONG ago have dismantled their entire structure.
and this is what it means that the suffering of others - sooner or later AFFECTS everyone else.
We know the score. The mortgage crisis arose, the rich were further enriched, working people got billed, and people are still losing there homes because absolutely nothing of consequence was done to assist them. The rest is just info-snow. They are laughing at us.
The United States of America should be more truthfully called "The United Corporations of America" .
GwNorth,
You are correct. What are you (we) going to do about it. I hear the outrage in your comment. Are you not compelled to take action?
THE FOUNDATION of the Global Crisis that started in america is suppressed wages -
leading to the " debt " society
simple equation:
A) if one doesn't earn proper wages because of the capitalist dogma of race to the bottom
B) one is forced to BORROW in order to function within that society's "accepted" norms ......promoted as "Credit" -
C) THUS a so-called "credit" society - but the bottom line is : it is the height of Oxymoronic thinking since
DEBT is NOT credit..
DEBT is NOT wealth. it is MAKE BELIEVE wealth and eventually arrives at the BLACK HOLE of an economy.
People living in America better brace for the coming PRICE INFLATION that will be sudden and SEVERE and as an article says even "deadly"....
When a nation lives in a BALLOON of an economy a BUBBLE of an economy by forcing the rest of the world to Support that Bubble ....the time comes when NATIONALIST ECONOMIC interests FORCE other countries to begin to WITHDRAW that support ....
and when that support is withdrawn - even so gradually and "benignly" in perspective over time - that balloon is going to collapse.
AND THEN the REAL consequences of having "prospered" through a BUBBLE make believe prosperity will appear.
it is NOT YET here. bad as the times have become FOR the USA.
countries like Brazil, other south american nations, (note: BOLIVIA is the FASTEST GROWING economy since the last TWO YEARS in the southern hemisphere of the americas BEGINNING by Bolivia's refusing to pay the IMF and WORLD BANK what were PROVEN as usurious and ILLEGAL loan terms that enabled Bolivia to put DOMESTIC development at the fore)
ASEAN nations, China, etc...not only HAVE survived the devastation created by the USA -- europe continues to languish and looks to Asia to SAVE IT - but WILL continue to do so and even emerge quite unscathed ESPECIALLY and SO LONG as they RAISE their NATIONALIST and REGIONAL economic INTERESTS...and AWAY from "servicing" the American BUBBLE economy and allow the USA to collapse to its PROPER size....which is MANY TIMES SMALLER than
ADVERTISED.
Oct 30, 2009
Inflation by stealth
By John Browne
Over the past two years, the United States government and the Federal Reserve have dispersed trillions of public dollars, run up enormous deficits, and kept interest rates at zero. In just about any economic textbook, this combination of policies would be described as the perfect recipe for inflation.
Yet, with the exception of the usual increases in healthcare and education, prices by and large are not rising. Many have concluded that our economic leadership has simply outsmarted the textbooks.
The benign Consumer Price Index (CPI) figures are serving as a rallying point behind which the financial talking-heads are forming
a parade of optimism. The low CPI is their "proof" that inflation is not a pressing concern. This view is two dimensional.
Inflation is classically described simply as an increase in the money supply. Although these changes will impact price levels, it doesn't necessarily follow that prices will rise when inflation is high. Instead, inflation may merely result in stable prices at a time when prices would otherwise be falling.
In the popular mentality, however, inflation is simply defined as prices rising. After decades of steadily rising prices, people seem to have forgotten that prices sometimes fall. In light of the bursting of a number of record-breaking, government-fueled asset bubbles, prices should be declining across the board (as they did in the Great Depression). The fact that prices are stable, or have even rallied in some sectors, indicates that inflation is already spreading across the economy.
After falling to just 6,547 in the months after the crash, the Dow has rallied past the 10,000 mark. This should strike even novice investors as unjustified. Jobs are still being lost, a massive healthcare entitlement and carbon tax are winding through Congress, and no one with at least one foot in the real world has a palpable sense of imminent recovery. Corporate earnings have fallen far behind the rally in shares prices, stretching valuation multiples to pre-crash levels.
While not quite as frothy, home prices are now moving up for all the wrong reasons. The seminal Case-Shiller Index of home prices is now up for the fourth month in a row. The index's designer, Professor Robert Shiller, has stated recently that the current upward trajectory is unsustainable. In fact, the levels are still above the 50- and 100-year trend lines.
In the worst economic climate since the Great Depression, and after the largest housing bust on memory, single-family home prices should be falling well below the trend lines. But with a doubling of the monetary base and special interest programs like the homebuyers' tax credit, home prices have stabilized and even increased in some markets. That's the work of inflation.
With gross domestic product growth now returning to positive territory, many inflation hawks ask why inflation has yet to truly manifest. The explanation can be found in the difference between monetary base and money supply.
The latest US$1.9 trillion injection of government money was composed of some $900 billion of stimulus, of which only about 20% has been distributed. However, in its attempts to stabilize the financial system, the government has already spent some $1 trillion of Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) type funds.
The TARP money, financed by an increase in the monetary base, has been provided to the banks at zero cost. And for the first time, the Fed is paying interest on bank reserves. Therefore, the banks can lend money to the Fed and to the government via Treasury securities at an interest rate spread of some 3% to 4% without risk. Given these incentives, it makes no sense to lend to anybody else. So, despite a massive increase in the monetary base, credit remains tight and price levels flat.
However, if the Fed stops paying interest on bank reserves or otherwise "persuades" the banks to lend, the $1 trillion will be leveraged up by the banks and spewed out into the economy. Fractional reserve banking will transform a $1 trillion monetary base injection into a $9 trillion increase in money supply. When that happens, prices for everything will go through the roof.
So for now, inflation is like a ninja stalking our economy. It's lurking in the shadows but can't easily be seen. But once its strikes, it will be fast and deadly.
John Browne is senior market strategist, Euro Pacific Capital. Euro Pacific Capital commentary and market news is available at http://www.europac.net. It has a free on-line investment newsletter.
(Copyright 2009 Euro Pacific Capital.)
Inflation fears threaten US creditworthiness
Oct 27, '09
Scourge of commodity inflation returns
Sep 18, '09
In hindsight, that is an easy but condescending position for you to assume.
Beyond your exaggerated example, do not forget that many of the loans were obtained on the basis of Realtors and appraisers using very real and assuring market comps and double digit appreciation to justify the home values and the loans.
Also, for the mortgagees, there was little reason to believe their jobs and retirement funds were in jeopardy, that making the loan payments would be a problem, or that selling the home would become a difficulty. To the contrary, I know Realtors whom specifically told prospective homebuyers they could easily sell their home if things didn't work out, and at the time that seemed to make sense to everybody involved. I also know Realtors and mortgage brokers that told mortgagees they would be able to easily refinance when their ARMs kicked in, because of the expected appreciation of their property. Do you really think all of this would have happened if that wasn't actually the case - or is everyone just as stupid as you put it?
Realtors and appraisers helped create the prior artificial inflation of real estate that encouraged as much as 125% financing of real estate. Why doesn't anybody talk about that? And the banks mentioned in this article are hardly the only players involved. The whole thing was/is a cruel scam, and we need to focus on the people that perpetrated the scam instead of ridiculing the unwitting dreamers caught in the web of deception.
Re cosmobilly October 29th, 2009 9:05 pm
Thanks for your excellent response to Chomp, whose first (and usually only) impulse is to blame the victim.
In addition to the local, street-level corruption of realtors and appraisers, we have to consider the far larger problem of the fractional reserve banking system. Banks routinely lend out money they don't really have; a simple book entry with some zeroes after any random integer enables you to sign a mortgage, but you have to repay with actual cash or its tangible equivalent. This is obtained in the usual way, by exchanging irreplaceable hours of your life for currency.
That in a nutshell is what led to the financial meltdown: credit was created without any underlying asset, which multiplied throughout the economy like screaming feedback; but as in a childhood game, when the music stopped, not everyone had a place to land.
This, Chomp, was not "stupidity," but "cupidity" in its most arrogant, virulent form, as manifested by the gangster-politician-CEO axis of evil. Those who in their desperation believed the late-night infomercials which told them they could house-flip their way to a secure, even comfortable retirement, are more to be pitied than censured.
"Here's hoping the Towns' investigation helps bring responses, finally, towards some of those crucial authentic answers."
_____________________________________
Ah, Katrina, I know not why you haven't changed your name to "Pandora" by now.
I agree with the emergent consensus in the comments. Both the Tinkerbell named Hope and the "investigation" will tumble from the wheel of government like deflected mosquitoes into a roadside ditch, in accordance with our Unitary Executive's imperial dictum to "Move Forward".
It grieves me to be the one to break it to you, Pandora, but it's time you learned the truth, in the form of a bitter paraphrase of Emily Dickinson:
Hope is the thing with fetters.
· Yr Obd't Servant
Accountability is a top down institution and it has been that way for some time in the U.S..
Too big to be accountable! Too big to fail!
Corporate Communism! Someone else here termed it that, and it fits!
Re NMBill October 29th, 2009 1:28 pm
That's a vicious slur on communism. Jesus (the first communist---see "loaves and fishes") and I object.
Corporate feudalism is more like it. Or we could stick with the classic definition, as propounded by Benito Mussolini (who was in a position to know): fascism.
Correct.
People should be careful not to will-nilly use "communism" being applied to Corporations in the USA.
the USA is nothing but a Feudal Society "modern version" - it is a system of CASTES - of Rich and powerful "owners" (corporations, banks, US chamber of commerce, Banks, Pentagon, Surveillance, Security State industry, and the Families and investors and boards behind the mask of "corporation" etc)
...and glorified SLAVES and SERFS calling themselves "americans" who are taught from childhood to think that they own ANYTHING even if they are just ALLOWED to enjoy a little bit of Insular illusion of "participation" by working "hard"...
but in reality:
if one substituted the American Work Place and "homes" and communities with
rows and rows of tobacco, corn, sugar...and whatever .....you see nothing but millions of SLAVES whipped into working "shape" (education, religion, patriotism, traditions, blah, blah, blah) adn singing :
"America the land of the free"........
The current mortgage crisis actually began in early 2006 as median home prices hit their highs.
According to Case-Shiller, median home prices hit 140% of their year 2000 levels in early 2006. A $200,000 home bought in year 2000, reached $280,000 in value.
Home prices dropped 40% in 2006, back to their 2000 levels.
Any competent economist or banker might ask why?
Instead of taking defensive actions, more NINJA loans and more derivatives were pushed out. Credit card rates rose to more than 30%. Bankers kept adding profits to their bottom line and fuel to the economic fire.
Where were the regulators - where was MSM - where were the voices of common sense?
Since 2006, median home prices have dropped another 50%. Case-Shiller predicts another 10% - 15% drop. With a price drop of 50%, homes prices must rise 100% to return to year 2000 levels. A 60% drop requires a 150% increase.
Many people refinanced their mortgages to a level higher than 2000 prices. If home prices rise by 5% per year, it will take 20 - 30 years to get back to year 2000 levels.
Meanwhile, credit cards are being used to replace equity that no longer exists. What do banks do? Raise rates to more than 30%. the too big to fail - especially Bank of Amerika - are among the worst offenders.
..............
Someone needs to invstigate short selling of bank stock from 2006 to March of 2009. I'm sure more than one banker made a fortune shorting the market. They are not making a fortunes as bank stocks increase. Expect short-selling when trhe markets double dips.
...............
And meanwhile, Iceland is Bankrupt and had to close their three MacDonalds. You'd think that MacDonalds could make a deal for cod and keep the three shops open.
A victory for Icelandic nutrition.
Of course ICELAND is NOT just one of the TROPHY "privatization capitalism" examples of US led economics that collapsed:
IRELAND too, ALSO ESTONIA and LATVIA..the TROPHIES of the "triumph of capitalism"
NOW virtual BASKET CASES that ran to China or RUssia for LOANS to float themselves up....because the IMF that GAVE them their prescription medicine at the behst of the USA - wouldn't lend to them.........
Oh I am sure they will find a few sacrifical lambs as they did in the Savings and Loans Scandals.
These Sacrifices are seen as needed time to time by the power elite in order to protect the "integrity" of the system.
Nothing will really change.
In more primitive societies when the people were restless with "rebellion" the rulers learned that sacrificing some small few to the Gods in order to placate the masses ensured they would remain in power.
The Modern "rulers" have this perfected to an art form.
"The Modern "rulers" have this perfected to an art form."
The current ruling class are no better than previous ruling class. There reaches a point where a society enters an anger flashpoint, or critical mass if you will. When the peasants are starving and angry, no matter what sacrifices the elite make, and unless meaningful restitution is made, there is, and always has been blood to be paid. Let them eat cake (or sleep in the streets), and let the revolution begin.
Today's peasants are starving and angry but their anger is misdirected. See my response to Spiritgirl.
I for one am pushing for answers! Though I realize that many in America have been dumbed down and divided by "faux issues", I'm optimistic that this crises has touched enough "unconscious" Americans that they will wake up and realize that they too are being used to forward a Corporate agenda that goes against US all!
Just remember it was the anger and inequality of the masses that started the French revolution, it was the anger and inequality that forced the colonists to take action, and it will be the same anger and inequality that forces many on the right to wake up and see the mendacity and those that promote the ideology for the bs that it is!
This manipulation is much about the illusion of "belonging"(and thereby feeling superior). There seems to be an infinite supply of dolts who have no hope of bettering their economic status (in large part because our society in general does not educate our children in money matters at all) who are ripe for seduction by being made to feel that they are part of the "in crowd" by the regurgitators of wing nut crap (limburger- Beck et al). This lack of economic skills, combined with NO background at all (not even a concept of what is meant by, critical thinking).
Climb a few rungs on the economic ladder and find many who have immense, ill gotten, wealth. They inveitably desire social acceptance. (Perfect example: Joe Kennedy --father of the recent tragedy prone generation of Kennedys in government). Their acceptance became his.(Not to even mention the even more recent Bush crime family) Ergo - politicians in general go there from a background most often littered with moral terpitude. It is not a pretty picture.
Spiritgirl
I'm also focused on pushing for answers. I am angry at what I see and most alarming is that my fellow citizens are in a fog, yes "unconcious",distracted by the lack of real reporting in the media and the false contest between Republicans and Democrats, liberals and conservatives. They are responding with fear to the series of false crises created by the Corporatocracy. They can't see the forest from the trees. We don't have 2 party system, its a one party system.
So, in the spirit of pushing for answers, I see the first critical task is to wake up America by exposing what is really going on. I see a fantastic opportunity to do so by pushing our congress to pass HR 1207 and S604, a call for the full audit of the FED. Most of the electorate think the FED is a government entity, not the totally unchecked private enterprise that it is. Most people would assume that the FED is audited and when they discover there is not oversight on the 10s of trillions of our dollars manipulated by the FED, they will be angry. We can watch where the opposition to these bills is coming from because the corporate/banking elite will do everything they can to kill or water down these bills. Those that oppose these bills can be exposed for their true agendas and patrons. Perhaps this could be the mechanism to wake up Americans and begin to check the systematic dismantling of our liberty. So I am starting by contacting my rep and senators, urging others to do so as well - to compel our so called representatives to get behind this legislation. If I had independent wealth, I'd hire an army of investigators to track this legislation, and investigate the influences on anyone that oppose it and I'd publish the results exposing the corrupted. perhaps this will begin to wake up America - the first step to reversing the dangerous path we are on.
What do think Spiritgirl?
I'd like to think that the American people will wake up just like that but there will have to be a reverse conditioning strategy in the works. People are just as angry today as they were back during the French Revolution but their anger has been craftily misdirected by the ruling class. The question remains as to who will be able to correct the misdirection and how.
It will all be a whitewash, just like 911 was a whitewash.
As long as the have nots believe that they will someday become a member of the haves, they will tolerate all manner of greed and corruption. However when it becomes apparent that the haves are no longer accepting new members into their lair, the have nots, hopefully begin to stir from their coma.
"However when it becomes apparent that the haves are no longer accepting new members into their lair, the have nots, hopefully begin to stir from their coma."
The haves always find a way to throw a bone to the have nots to pretend "inclusion". The trick is to get the have nots to avoid falling for the bait and it can be a tough task.
Katrina chirps, "... I think the far more significant development here is the breadth of information the Committee is demanding from Big Banking. ...Here's hoping the Towns' investigation helps bring responses..."
- With words like these, KVH performs the function of Nation-style "liberals:" to encourage the naive fantasy that our government is capable of "reining in" the corporate oligarchy, as opposed to slavishly doing its bidding.
Let's be clear: in a capitalist society, the government is simply the political instrument of the ruling class. It may sometimes posture for PR purposes as an "investigator, watchdog or overseer." But at the end of the day, the government will do what's demanded by the ruling class it represents.
That's why we have only 2 parties, both of which "just happen to be" big-business parties; and why any alternative to this arrangement (for example, a party organized to represent the interests of working people) is outlawed.
"That's why we have only 2 parties, both of which "just happen to be" big-business parties; and why any alternative to this arrangement (for example, a party organized to represent the interests of working people) is outlawed."
They're not outlawed but they have to jump through more hoops and are marginalized by the duopoly to the point of being nearly nonexistent. The only way I see parties actually representing the working class winning is if more people open their hearts and minds to the issues and judge the candidates by what they really stand for and/or have supported and opposed in the past. It appears that getting the electorate to do that will be as easy as herding cats. Most who voted Democrat appear to be sticking to voting that way and ditto for the Republicans with most swing voters simply alternating between D and R with very few showing signs of going third party. It really stinks !
By the way, thank you for writing a perfect analysis on John Nichols back in August. I cannot stand it when the writers apologize for the Democrat Party without rhyme or reason.
The older I get, the more certain I become that the corporatocracy will not allow us to avoid complete impoverishment and/or enslavement through the use of any safe, clean, morally pure mechanism, such as voting in a third party. They will force us to do it the hard way, the messy, dangerous, morally questionable way, or not at all.
Some comments are so good one just has to say, yup!
Maybe this will amount to nothing, or maybe prosecutions will result. Either way, it's better to be talking openly about these matters than not.
At least some of the public seems to have arrived at that "teachable moment" so beloved of progressives.
Jethro Tullamore, I'm all for "teachable moments" but I question, as have those already commenting, on WHAT will be taught during this moment. Will we learn that, as there are banks "too big to fail," they are as well too big to be held accountable for their failures? Did anyone else notice the omission of Goldman Sachs from van den Heuvel's list of to-be-investigated firms? Was this an oversight or an indication that the biggest cheese of all in the rat's nest of Wall Street corruption is just too big (being that it owns the U.S. Treasury and a big slice of the presidency) to be held accountable? We've had plenty in the past of "investigations" in which those lower in hierarchies of power take the rap for malfeasances of those higher up the ladder, and it takes a persistent cuss like Senator Ervin or Howard Baker, to keep asking of the higher-ups: "what did they know and when did they know it?" I'm afraid we'll just learn all over what we already knew about the corruption in our political lives. But maybe I'm wrong and an Ervin or Baker or Sam Dash or Robert Welch will appear; and maybe, just to dream big, that a Bernstein or Woodward might come out of the "journalistic" woodwork.
Investigate away, but the guilty will be given a pass, and life will go on. That's the thing about the hegemony of big business in our country today. When they circumvent regulations, and lobby successfully to get rid of regulations, they do things that make big money at the top, pass the whole process down to investors and the public when the stuffing begins to spew out. These outrageous business practices are unsustainable, and would cause normal businesses to fail, which would point to the wrongness of such practices, and the consequences, providing lessons for all, but lobbying power trumps all, and life goes on, spiraling downwards. We prop up failure in this country nowadays, saying "too big to fail". We've thrown away common sense in favor of second chances with no strings attached.
I totally agree. The so-called "investigations" are pointless jokes. As long as those big cronies are being bailed out with our tax dollars and destructive policies rigged to safeguard them at our expense, no amount of investigating will change a thing. Congress looks more like a circus hall anyway that they'd might as well carry out their lame dumbshows on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart to lead them.
Obama and the best congress money can buy have made it clear that markets will continue to be allowed to self-regulate...its the American way.
Any token investigations they might initiate will simply be a waste of taxpayers' money.