Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Israeli Peace Activist Called ‘Cancerous Traitor’ for Asking Tough Questions
Israeli academic and activist Neve Gordon's recent Los Angeles Times article, in which he explained why he supports Palestinian calls for a boycott of his own country, has drawn furious fire against him from within Israel, apparently endangering his job. Here is a call from the Jewish Voice for Peace, to support his right to express his views.
Following the publication of Neve Gordon's article, there has been a vehement and aggressive attack against him in Israel that calls into serious question Israel's commitment to academic freedom and the democratic right to free speech.
We now believe that massive international pressure will be needed to keep him from being fired from his job.
Gordon is a political science professor at Ben Gurion University, Israel, and a long-time peace activist.
His endorsement of economic pressure offers what Naomi Klein termed "the most effective tools in the non-violent arsenal" to address the Israeli occupation.
And yet Professor Rivka Carmi, the president of Ben Gurion University, was quoted in the Jerusalem Post saying that the "university may no longer be interested in his services".
She said that "academics who feel this way about their country are welcome to search for a personal and professional home elsewhere".
Is Carmi really calling on Gordon to leave his country?
Several Knesset members from the right have called upon Carmi and the minister of education to sack Gordon, while Education Minister Gideon Sa'ar called the article "repugnant and deplorable".
In the thousands of talkbacks generated by articles in Israel, hundreds of angry readers have called Gordon a traitor, a virus and cancerous, and have threatened to expel him from Israel. Some have even called for his execution.
Unsurprisingly, Israeli rights-abusive policies, the occupation and how one might resolve the conflict are side-stepped and the central issue becomes how to do away with the messenger.
In Gordon's words: "From the responses to the article it seems most people don't have the courage to discuss the main issues.
Is Israel an apartheid state? How can the Israeli- Palestinian conflict be resolved? Is the settlement project good for Israel or will it cause the state's destruction?
It's easy to criticise me while evading the tough and important questions." The dismaying response to Gordon's article is but the latest manifestation of attempts to silence dissent within Israel.
In the past six months activists from New Profile, which describes itself as "a movement for the civilisation of Israeli society", have been arrested and investigated; Israeli human rights activist Ezra Nawi is in danger of going to jail for non-violently defending the destruction of a Palestinian home; and just last week the vice-prime minister called Peace Now, an Israeli pacifist organisation working for Palestinian self-determination, "a virus".
Are these the actions of a democracy? Boycotts, divestment and sanctions constitute a legitimate non-violent strategy with a history, most famously in South Africa. It deserves honest, thoughtful appraisal, such as Gordon offered in his recent article.
By supporting Gordon we are protecting the ability to talk openly about the Israeli occupation and about non-violent options to address it, including boycott, divestment and sanctions.

17 Comments so far
Show AllWhy do my comments supporting Neve Gordon and free speech get spamed and rejected?
I am quite surprised that no one has used the term 'rat' to describe the man. Or is that too close to the insults that Hitler used to hurl at Jewish intellectuals. I don't hold out any hope that the man wont be fired from a job in Israel, even if every country on earth argued for not firing him, he's still going to get sacked for speaking an unpopular truth. I hope that he's not killed by one of the nutty settlers.
On a lighter note, did Common Dreams add some sort of spell check? Or is that from an upgrade to my browser?
Looks like the peace movement is growing.
These attacks on free speech are the proof.
They snarl and hiss about the man's character, but they won't argue the subject. That's important!
Eeeeyukk! Repulsive.
Israel just gets uglier by the day. It's out of control.
Somebody's got to reign it in.
G-d gave the land to everybody, Bibi!
Ilan Pappe had to leave Israel for UK because life became very harsh for his children:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yhfEWqBvav0
He also felt that the total "irrelevance" of voices like his in the Stalinist Zionist society was also a factor in his decision to be an activist from abroad:
http://emma2.radio4all.net/pub/files/redeye@coopradio.org/91-1-20080411-Ilan_Pappe.mp3
"Verily I say unto you, No prophet is accepted in his own country."
If "prophet" can be broadly defined as "teller of inconvenient truths to Power", this is at least one verse from the Gospel that's as true today as it was when it was first recorded.
· Yr Obd't Servant
Sioux Rose
O.S. Timelessly true, but then the inviolate Truths never do go out of style. They do, however, remain inconvenient for those with agendas not quite intended for the Light.
Again, the Israeli government seems to be taking the worst abuses from the Nazi and Fascist governments that persecuted their ancestors and resurrecting them in their own country. I'm proud of all the Israeli Peace Activists who continue to work in an increasingly repressive atmosphere.
Wrote a comment to the Jerusalem Post for Prof.Carmi quoting a couple of Proverbs,that I dont remember,that fit her perfectly where I was concerned.Tony
I don't see what’s the problem. This is a perfect example of freedom of speech.
Prof. Neve Gordon exercised his freedom of speech, by calling to boycott his own country, Israel. This is perfectly legal according to the Israeli law. The fact is that nothing happened to him. He wasn't executed, arrested, nor did he lose his job at the University. (The Israeli law protects him.)
Some other people, (anonimous talkbacks in Israel) who don't like his ideas, and who enjoy the same freedom of speech rights as Prof. Gordon, called him a "Cancerous traitor." (They too didn’t break the Israeli law.)
Show me one more country in the Middle East which has similar level of freedom of speech as Israel does.
For example: Last month in Gaza, a cleric named Abdel-Latif Moussa, spoke against the Hamas. (His crime was: saying that Gaza is an Islamic emirate) For speaking his mind, he and 23 of his supporters were shot dead by the Hamas.
Can you even compare?
Hasn't lost his job yet. By the way, can Vanunu (however you spell the name) talk about how many nukes Israel has built?
Of course, Israelis have the right to speak their minds... But what of those people who live on land occupied by the Israelis? Do they get to live lives of peace if they're young, or are they spat upon and shot by the settlers?
Still, freedom of speech level in Israel is better than in any other country in the Middle East.
Unless you're a Palestinian, than that speech can get you shot. (by the army, the settlers, the average Israeli)
Israel has killed a lot more than 24.
Has Israel killed a lot more than 24 people because they spoke their mind?
When was that?
I never said Israel killed because they spoke their mind. But, Israel does kill for a lot of reasons, none of them legal.