Subscribe to Common Dreams News Updates
Most Popular This Week
Popular content
Today's Top News
Why Afghans Have No Hope in This Week's Vote
Like millions of Afghans, I have no hope in the results of this week’s election. In a country ruled by warlords, occupation forces, Taliban insurgency, drug money and guns, no one can expect a legitimate or fair vote.
Among the people on the street, a common sentiment is, ‘Everything has already been decided by the U.S. and NATO, and the real winner has already been picked by the White House and Pentagon.’ Although there are a total of 41 candidates running for president, the vast majority of them are well known faces responsible for the current disastrous situation in Afghanistan.
Hamid Karzai has cemented alliances with brutal warlords and fundamentalists in order to maintain his position. Although our Constitution forbids war criminals from running for office, he has named two notorious militia commanders as his vice-presidential running mates – Qasim Fahim, who was, at the time of the 2001 invasion, the warlord who headed up the Northern Alliance, and Karim Khalili. The election commission did not reject them or a number of others accused of many crimes, and so the list of candidates also includes former Russian puppets and a former Taliban commander.
Karzai has also continued to absolutely betray the women of Afghanistan. Even after massive international outcry and brave protesters taking to the streets of Kabul, Karzai has implemented the infamous law targeting Shia women. He had initially promised to review the most egregious clauses, but in the end it was passed with few amendments, leaving the barbaric anti-women statements untouched. As Human Rights Watch recently said, “Karzai has made an unthinkable deal to sell Afghan women out in return for the support of fundamentalists in the August 20 election.”
Deals have been made with countless fundamentalists in Karzai’s maneuvering to stay in power. For example, pro-Iranian extremist Haji Mohammad Mohaqiq, who has been accused of war crimes, has been promised five cabinet positions for his party, and so he has told the media he’s backing Karzai. A deal has even been done with the dreaded warlord Rashid Dostum – who has returned from exile in Turkey to campaign for Karzai – and many other such terrorists. Rather than democracy, what we have in Afghanistan today are back room deals amongst discredited warlords.
The two main contenders to Karzai’s continued rule, Ashraf Ghani Ahmadzai and Abdullah Abdullah, do not offer any change; both are former cabinet ministers in this discredited regime and neither has a real, broad footing amongst the people. Abdullah has run a high profile campaign, in part due to the backing and financial support he receives from Iran’s fundamentalist regime. Abdullah and some of the Northern Alliance commanders supporting him have threatened unrest if he loses the vote, raising fears of a return to the rampant violence and killing that marked the civil war years of 1992 to 1996. All of the major candidates’ speeches and policies are very similar. They make the same sweet-sounding promises, but we are not fooled. Afghans remember how Karzai abandoned his campaign pledges after winning the 2004 vote.
We Afghans know that this election will change nothing and it is only part of a show of democracy put on by and for the West, to legitimize its future puppet in Afghanistan. It seems we are doomed to see the continuation of this failed, mafia-like corrupt government for another term.
The people of Afghanistan are fed up with the rampant corruption of Karzai’s “narco-state” government – his own brother, Wali Karzai, has been linked to drug trafficking in Kandahar Province – and the escalating war waged by NATO. In May of this year, U.S. air strikes killed approximately 150 civilians in my native province, Farah. More than ever, Afghans are faced with powerful internal enemies – fundamentalist warlords and their Taliban brothers-in-creed – and the external enemies occupying the country.
Democracy will never come to Afghanistan through the barrel of a gun, or from the cluster bombs dropped by foreign forces. The struggle will be long and difficult, but the values of real democracy, human rights and women’s rights will only be won by the Afghan people themselves.
So do not be fooled by this façade of democracy. Your governments in the West that claim to be bringing democracy to Afghanistan ignore public opinion in their own countries, where growing numbers are against the war. President Obama in particular needs to understand that the change Afghans believe in does not include more troops and a ramped up war.
If the populations of Afghanistan and the NATO countries were able to vote on this military occupation it could not continue indefinitely, and peace would finally be within reach.
- Posted in


18 Comments so far
Show AllI hope Malalai Joya will stay safe and survive because we need her. She is brave and speaks the truth.
Your hope is my hope.
My wish is that the people understand that any vote while under occupation is a vote for the enemy then vote with their guns.
ditto
Assuming you are a US citizen, you shouldn't need her, rather the reality is that she needs YOU. It is only the US citizenry that can bring this madness to an end.
The system as presently constitutes was not design by warlords, thugs or Kazai etc. If it is not Kazai as President it is be another Kazai. This scheme was designed by the US and their European allies.
By being a member of a parliament etc they created the writer herself becomes an entangled stake holder in the imperial project, a sort of catch 22.
Lessons of the roles colonial missionaries played in foreign conquered and squandered lands should be a lesson to all astute observers.
At the end of the day people should be left alone to choose their own paths period. Otherwise, the devil shall always find work.
Which is worst--to be fooled by a candidate who pretends to be what you want him to be and when elected double-crosses you and breaks your heart--because nothing is going to change-except to get worst OR someone who you know is an enemy of your beliefs and you know what is going on like in this case and you know what to expect and know how to react to it right off? It's the gang of them we need to go after.
Great to hear from you again Malalai- on target as always. I thought about you this morning when I saw a headline in the paper "popular Uzbek backs Karzai" which was of course Dostum. what a surprise.
Stay safe dear truth teller.
I couldn't agree with you more. Ours didn't change anything either.
No country that's being militarily occupied can be said to have free elections. Our occupiers wear corporate logos instead of kaiki. The results are the same.
It's window dressing; an attempt to put a kinder face on the new Raj. It will surely prove to be as ineffective as the rest of America's misguided foreign policy.
Plutocratic thinking is at least 200 years behind the times and more than a little crazy.
My heart goes out to the women of Afghanistan who have been betrayed by the men there. It is outrageous. Men should stand up along with the women who are their sisters, daughters, mothers, and wives to fight the oppression that is returning like a nightmare to haunt that nation and the world.
Afghan men are too busy fighting invaders from the fake-democracy USA and dragging their women's burned and broken bodies out of their homes bombed by USAF, so they just don't have time for pseudo-progressive whining that also comes from the US.
The Afghans get to choose between Warlord Enabler A and Warlord Enabler B - again. Karzai is a dressed-up puppet and the others are the same, albeit less fashionably clad. And the people continue to bleed while being sucked dry by their own.
Democracy will never come to Afghanistan through the barrel of a gun, or from the cluster bombs dropped by foreign forces.
Neither Bollocks Obimbo nor the military killers who tell him what to do care about that, even though many of them know it to be true. The American Condor Legion is using Afghanistan as a testing ground for new weapons and tactics. Afghanistan will bleed until the American juggernaut chokes to death on its own stupidity and brutality.
The Afghans have virtually no hope for even a life at this rate let alone voting.
Gee, what a mothereffin similarity.
America. The US. The Yanquis are in control,
And homey, your vote is a joke.
The Afghans are just so much smarter than Americans. They get it. Their votes are tp.
Let the drones rock.
We in America do not have enough money to give top quality health care to all our citizens and yet we are wasting billions of tax dollars on this true "death panel" policy of wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Protesters of the health care plan are so worried about their children being burdened with trillions of dollars in debt due to the cost of insuring that their children will be able to afford health care if they get ill. But they do not care about the trillions of dollars our children will be burdened with due to what Malalai Joya called "wasting money and blood in Afghanistan". Thanks Malalai for speaking out in spite of the risks. Please be safe.
I am sure that the Canadian prime minster and our national broadcaster, the CBC, will do what they can to maintain the illusion that this Afghan election is fair and supported by the people. That's the least they can deliver, apparently, for 127 dead Canadians, thousands of dead Afghans and about $20 billion.
The CBC is usually a little bit more enlightened during the day time than in the evening.
They just interviewed Rangina Hamidi in Afghanistan who said the same things as Joya.
I am surprised to see Malalai Joya authoring neat English columns in a highly respected website like Common Dreams . Org. Wish she had delivered her message as neatly to the common Afghans in her home country too. Her vulgar ranting on national and private Afghan media (There are hundreds of them now, most of them critical of Karzai regime) has made her notoriously unpopular. "Warlords" don't like her, we understand. Why ordinary citizens frown at the mention of her name, I wonder.
When I read or hear her, I again wonder what her objective is: western media glamor or Afghan common good? If it was Afghan common good, she should have spoken to common Afghans in a respectable manner. Who in Afghanistan hasn't lost a loved one in the crisis there? All Afghans have suffered. People empathize better with those who are brave and "decent".
I have observed that the people whom she frequently aims at in her Liberally targeted English (language) media are those who fought against the ISI backed political factions prior to 9/11. To illustrate my point, just in this column alone, she accuses Dr. Abdullah, the main ocntender to Karzai, of being funded by "Iran" without offering any credible source yet discomfortingly avoids even mentioning the "name" of the Taliban commmander who also runs for Afghan presidency.
Sex sells, we have joked, in the media and liberals have chosen vulgarity to offer as a media commodity now. Afghan society does have plenty of decent and genuinely concerned Afghan female parliamentarians who spend ALL their time promoting the cause of Afghan women INSIDE Afghanistan. They don't travell expensively as Ms Joya does. Please help those. Enough of drama.